James Downe
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
James Downe has a total of 55 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Steve Martin
Cardiff Business School, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
18 shared publicationsRhys Andrews
Cardiff Business Sch, Publ Management, Cardiff, S Glam, Wales
6 shared publicationsRichard Cowell
Cardiff University United Kingdom
6 shared publications- Tom Entwistle
Cardiff Business School, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
5 shared publications - Valeria Guarneros-Meza
De Montfort University
5 shared publications Clive Grace
Steve Martin, James Downe and Clive Grace are in Cardiff Business School Cardiff University UK
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 35
Evaluating the impact of knowledge brokering practices: Learning from embedded impact research at the Wales Centre for Public Policy
The emergence and proliferation of knowledge brokering organisations (KBOs) as a mechanism for bridging the gap between research and policy has led to a range of studies analysing various aspects of their form and activity. However, methodological, conceptual, and practical challenges have until recently prohibited evaluation of the impact of KBOs. This has led to calls for studies to examine the multifaceted impact of KBOs, and for organisations themselves to take an active role in planning for and capturing their own impact. This paper contributes towards this agenda by describing and reflecting on the work of a KBO—the Wales Centre for Public Policy—to plan for and evaluate the impact of its knowledge brokering activities through the introduction of an Embedded Impact Researcher (EIR). A description of the EIR role is provided, followed by three reflections and recommendations from its implementation for similar organisations looking to capture their own impact. First, we argue for the development of better models of the knowledge brokering process. Second, the potential for ‘mechanistic’ thinking to aid the process of impact planning is explored. Third, the nature of, and tensions associated with, ‘embedded’ research are discussed. It is anticipated that by sharing these experiences, researchers and practitioners may identify transferable elements that may inform their own work.
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 35
Open AccessEvaluating the impact of knowledge brokering practices: Learning from embedded impact research at the Wales Centre for Public Policy
The emergence and proliferation of knowledge brokering organisations (KBOs) as a mechanism for bridging the gap between research and policy has led to a range of studies analysing various aspects of their form and activity. However, methodological, conceptual, and practical challenges have until recently prohibited evaluation of the impact of KBOs. This has led to calls for studies to examine the multifaceted impact of KBOs, and for organisations themselves to take an active role in planning for and capturing their own impact. This paper contributes towards this agenda by describing and reflecting on the work of a KBO—the Wales Centre for Public Policy—to plan for and evaluate the impact of its knowledge brokering activities through the introduction of an Embedded Impact Researcher (EIR). A description of the EIR role is provided, followed by three reflections and recommendations from its implementation for similar organisations looking to capture their own impact. First, we argue for the development of better models of the knowledge brokering process. Second, the potential for ‘mechanistic’ thinking to aid the process of impact planning is explored. Third, the nature of, and tensions associated with, ‘embedded’ research are discussed. It is anticipated that by sharing these experiences, researchers and practitioners may identify transferable elements that may inform their own work.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 34
Understanding the impact of knowledge brokering organizations: the case of the UK What Works Centres
An increasingly common response to the challenge of facilitating engagement between research and policy is to establish knowledge brokering organizations (KBOs). These perform important evidence mobilization functions, but the precise nature and extent of their impacts on policy and practice remains underexplored. This is partly because it is difficult to attribute specific impacts to intermediary actors within the wider networks in which they operate. There is therefore a pressing need to improve understanding of the impacts of KBOs and how they can be assessed. This paper addresses this through a qualitative study of the ways in which a network of What Works Centres (WWCs) are engaging with these challenges in the UK. Our research questions are (1) How do WWCs aim to contribute to policy and/or practice across different contexts? (2) How do they relate these potential contributions to the ways in which they define, track, and demonstrate their impact? We contribute to the literature on KBOs by showing that WWCs seek to influence policy and practice not just by facilitating access to evidence, but also by developing close relationships with decision-makers and building capacity to act upon knowledge within professional and place-based systems. The findings also highlight that the WWCs are in the process of developing approaches to plan for and evaluate these impacts that reflect their complex and uncertain nature. The paper concludes by discussing the possible use of evaluation frameworks that focus on demonstrating the contributions KBOs make to the processes through which impact occurs.
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 34
Open AccessUnderstanding the impact of knowledge brokering organizations: the case of the UK What Works Centres
An increasingly common response to the challenge of facilitating engagement between research and policy is to establish knowledge brokering organizations (KBOs). These perform important evidence mobilization functions, but the precise nature and extent of their impacts on policy and practice remains underexplored. This is partly because it is difficult to attribute specific impacts to intermediary actors within the wider networks in which they operate. There is therefore a pressing need to improve understanding of the impacts of KBOs and how they can be assessed. This paper addresses this through a qualitative study of the ways in which a network of What Works Centres (WWCs) are engaging with these challenges in the UK. Our research questions are (1) How do WWCs aim to contribute to policy and/or practice across different contexts? (2) How do they relate these potential contributions to the ways in which they define, track, and demonstrate their impact? We contribute to the literature on KBOs by showing that WWCs seek to influence policy and practice not just by facilitating access to evidence, but also by developing close relationships with decision-makers and building capacity to act upon knowledge within professional and place-based systems. The findings also highlight that the WWCs are in the process of developing approaches to plan for and evaluate these impacts that reflect their complex and uncertain nature. The paper concludes by discussing the possible use of evaluation frameworks that focus on demonstrating the contributions KBOs make to the processes through which impact occurs.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 239-258
Do policy actors have different views of what constitutes evidence in policymaking?
The role played by evidence in policymaking is hotly disputed and there is no agreement over how evidence is defined. This article examines whether policy actors have different views of what counts as evidence and which factors influence these perceptions (for example, professional background, length of service, organisation setting, cultures of evidence)? In addressing this question, we contribute to the growing research focus on the context of evidence use. Q methodology – a mixed method approach to study people’s attitudes towards a topic – is used in interviewing 67 policy actors and comparing two countries, Scotland and Wales, to find out whether there are different cultures of evidence. In both countries, we identified four distinct profiles of attitudes towards evidence: the evidence-based policymaking (EBPM) Idealist, the Pragmatist, the Inclusive, and the Political. Our research highlights important differences between the two contexts, with a greater leaning towards EBPM views of evidence in Wales, and more pragmatism in defining evidence in Scotland. We illustrate how different cultures of evidence coexist in a same context and highlight their similarities and differences. We also contribute to the understanding of the value of Q methodology research by showing that it can be used to compare two datasets collected in different countries.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 239-258
Do policy actors have different views of what constitutes evidence in policymaking?
The role played by evidence in policymaking is hotly disputed and there is no agreement over how evidence is defined. This article examines whether policy actors have different views of what counts as evidence and which factors influence these perceptions (for example, professional background, length of service, organisation setting, cultures of evidence)? In addressing this question, we contribute to the growing research focus on the context of evidence use. Q methodology – a mixed method approach to study people’s attitudes towards a topic – is used in interviewing 67 policy actors and comparing two countries, Scotland and Wales, to find out whether there are different cultures of evidence. In both countries, we identified four distinct profiles of attitudes towards evidence: the evidence-based policymaking (EBPM) Idealist, the Pragmatist, the Inclusive, and the Political. Our research highlights important differences between the two contexts, with a greater leaning towards EBPM views of evidence in Wales, and more pragmatism in defining evidence in Scotland. We illustrate how different cultures of evidence coexist in a same context and highlight their similarities and differences. We also contribute to the understanding of the value of Q methodology research by showing that it can be used to compare two datasets collected in different countries.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 51 (4) , 628-646
Externalising policy advice within subnational governments
The concept of policy advisory systems (PAS) has been applied almost exclusively at national level. This article demonstrates that it can also be employed to analyse the development and dynamics of policy advice in a subnational government. Our empirical study of the externalisation of policy advice by the Welsh Government shows that it has been shaped by distinctive historical, institutional and political factors, and its impacts are different to those reported by studies of out-sourcing national policy advice. In our case study, external policy advice was seen as complementing rather than competing with the civil service. Instead of deinstitutionalising policy advice – that is, dislocating it from the usual sites where knowledge for policy is produced – new formal routes have been established for external sources of expertise to influence policy decisions. Contrary to the findings of some previous studies, externalising policy advice has not been a centralising force. Nor has it fundamentally challenged existing assumptions and values or increased politicisation of the policy process. These findings demonstrate that the PAS concept is useful across a range of settings, not just at national level. We show that applying it to a broader range of contexts, including subnational polities, can challenge, strengthen and expand existing theories of policy advice and policymaking.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 51 (4) , 628-646
Externalising policy advice within subnational governments
The concept of policy advisory systems (PAS) has been applied almost exclusively at national level. This article demonstrates that it can also be employed to analyse the development and dynamics of policy advice in a subnational government. Our empirical study of the externalisation of policy advice by the Welsh Government shows that it has been shaped by distinctive historical, institutional and political factors, and its impacts are different to those reported by studies of out-sourcing national policy advice. In our case study, external policy advice was seen as complementing rather than competing with the civil service. Instead of deinstitutionalising policy advice – that is, dislocating it from the usual sites where knowledge for policy is produced – new formal routes have been established for external sources of expertise to influence policy decisions. Contrary to the findings of some previous studies, externalising policy advice has not been a centralising force. Nor has it fundamentally challenged existing assumptions and values or increased politicisation of the policy process. These findings demonstrate that the PAS concept is useful across a range of settings, not just at national level. We show that applying it to a broader range of contexts, including subnational polities, can challenge, strengthen and expand existing theories of policy advice and policymaking.
- 28 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 41 (3-4) , 265-286
Deconstructing complexity: A comparative study of government collaboration in national digital platforms and smart city networks in Europe
This research deconstructs complexity as a key challenge of intergovernmental digitalisation projects. While much of the literature acknowledges that the fundamental restructuring coupled with technical capacity that these joint projects require leads to increased complexity, little is known about how different types of complexity interact within the collaborative process. Using established concepts of substantive, strategic, and institutional complexity, we apply complexity theory in collaborative digital environments. To do so, eight digital projects are analysed that differ by state structure and government level. Using a cross-case design with 50 semi-structured expert interviews, we find that each digitalisation project exhibits all types of complexity and that these complexities overlap. However, clear differences emerge between national and local level projects, suggesting that complexity in digitalisation processes presents different challenges for collaborative digitalisation projects across contexts.
- 28 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 41 (3-4) , 265-286
Deconstructing complexity: A comparative study of government collaboration in national digital platforms and smart city networks in Europe
This research deconstructs complexity as a key challenge of intergovernmental digitalisation projects. While much of the literature acknowledges that the fundamental restructuring coupled with technical capacity that these joint projects require leads to increased complexity, little is known about how different types of complexity interact within the collaborative process. Using established concepts of substantive, strategic, and institutional complexity, we apply complexity theory in collaborative digital environments. To do so, eight digital projects are analysed that differ by state structure and government level. Using a cross-case design with 50 semi-structured expert interviews, we find that each digitalisation project exhibits all types of complexity and that these complexities overlap. However, clear differences emerge between national and local level projects, suggesting that complexity in digitalisation processes presents different challenges for collaborative digitalisation projects across contexts.
- Open Access
- 2 November 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Local Government Studies
- Vol. 48 (5) , 929-950
The local government response to austerity in a small devolved country: the case of Wales
The 2008 Global Financial Crisis and subsequent austerity drive across Europe and North America has been particularly felt at a local government level. Wales presents a valuable case study through which to explore the impact of austerity on local government: it is a small country with a devolved government that is philosophically opposed to austerity, yet where cuts to local government have been drastic. Drawing on interviews with Welsh councils and key stakeholders, this paper explores three approaches councils have taken to managing austerity – efficiency, investment, and retrenchment – and finds that councils were already at a financial ‘tipping point’ before the pandemic. This paper concludes by considering the lessons that could be applied to the new challenge of recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic.
- 2 November 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Local Government Studies
- Vol. 48 (5) , 929-950
Open AccessThe local government response to austerity in a small devolved country: the case of Wales
The 2008 Global Financial Crisis and subsequent austerity drive across Europe and North America has been particularly felt at a local government level. Wales presents a valuable case study through which to explore the impact of austerity on local government: it is a small country with a devolved government that is philosophically opposed to austerity, yet where cuts to local government have been drastic. Drawing on interviews with Welsh councils and key stakeholders, this paper explores three approaches councils have taken to managing austerity – efficiency, investment, and retrenchment – and finds that councils were already at a financial ‘tipping point’ before the pandemic. This paper concludes by considering the lessons that could be applied to the new challenge of recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 81 (4) , 625-637
The Motivations for the Adoption of Management Innovation by Local Governments and its Performance Effects
This article analyses the economic, political, and institutional antecedents and performance effects of the adoption of shared Senior Management Teams (SMTs)—a management innovation (MI) that occurs when a team of senior managers oversees two or more public organizations. Findings from statistical analysis of 201 English local governments and interviews with organizational leaders reveal that shared SMTs are adopted to develop organizational capacity in resource‐challenged, politically risk‐averse governments, and in response to coercive and mimetic institutional pressures. Importantly, sharing SMTs may reduce rather than enhance efficiency and effectiveness due to redundancy costs and the political transaction costs associated with diverting resources away from a high‐performing partner to support their lower‐performing counterpart.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 81 (4) , 625-637
Open AccessThe Motivations for the Adoption of Management Innovation by Local Governments and its Performance Effects
This article analyses the economic, political, and institutional antecedents and performance effects of the adoption of shared Senior Management Teams (SMTs)—a management innovation (MI) that occurs when a team of senior managers oversees two or more public organizations. Findings from statistical analysis of 201 English local governments and interviews with organizational leaders reveal that shared SMTs are adopted to develop organizational capacity in resource‐challenged, politically risk‐averse governments, and in response to coercive and mimetic institutional pressures. Importantly, sharing SMTs may reduce rather than enhance efficiency and effectiveness due to redundancy costs and the political transaction costs associated with diverting resources away from a high‐performing partner to support their lower‐performing counterpart.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2020
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 48 (2) , 335-353
Does knowledge brokering facilitate evidence-based policy? A review of existing knowledge and an agenda for future research
The claim that evidence-based policy (EBP) produces better outcomes has gained increasing support over the last three decades. Knowledge brokering (KB) is seen as a way to achieve improved policymaking and governments worldwide are investing significant resources in KB initiatives. It is therefore important to understand the range of these activities and to investigate whether and how they facilitate EBP. This article critically reviews the extant literature on KB. It identifies six important limitations: the existence of multiple definitions of KB; a lack of theory-based empirical analysis; a neglect of knowledge brokering organisations; insufficient research on KB in social policy; limited analysis of impact and effectiveness; and a lack of attention to the role played by politics. The paper proposes an agenda for future research that bridges disciplinary boundaries in order to address these gaps and contribute new insights into the politics of evidence use.
- 1 April 2020
- Published by Bristol University Press in Policy & Politics
- Vol. 48 (2) , 335-353
Open AccessDoes knowledge brokering facilitate evidence-based policy? A review of existing knowledge and an agenda for future research
The claim that evidence-based policy (EBP) produces better outcomes has gained increasing support over the last three decades. Knowledge brokering (KB) is seen as a way to achieve improved policymaking and governments worldwide are investing significant resources in KB initiatives. It is therefore important to understand the range of these activities and to investigate whether and how they facilitate EBP. This article critically reviews the extant literature on KB. It identifies six important limitations: the existence of multiple definitions of KB; a lack of theory-based empirical analysis; a neglect of knowledge brokering organisations; insufficient research on KB in social policy; limited analysis of impact and effectiveness; and a lack of attention to the role played by politics. The paper proposes an agenda for future research that bridges disciplinary boundaries in order to address these gaps and contribute new insights into the politics of evidence use.
- 31 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Public Management Review
- Vol. 23 (3) , 376-396
Organizational identity threats and aspirations in reputation management
Reputational threats are key to understanding public services’ behaviour. Previous research has viewed external performance assessments as an unwelcome imposition on public managers and a threat to organizational identity. Analysing the adoption of a self-imposed process of peer-led assessment by public managers in UK local government we show how the absence of performance assessment was seen as a reputational threat. Engaging proactively with the new voluntary assessments becomes an essential tool for active reputation management. We find that reputation does not only shape the responses to external performance assessment but the external performance assessment itself.
- 31 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Public Management Review
- Vol. 23 (3) , 376-396
Organizational identity threats and aspirations in reputation management
Reputational threats are key to understanding public services’ behaviour. Previous research has viewed external performance assessments as an unwelcome imposition on public managers and a threat to organizational identity. Analysing the adoption of a self-imposed process of peer-led assessment by public managers in UK local government we show how the absence of performance assessment was seen as a reputational threat. Engaging proactively with the new voluntary assessments becomes an essential tool for active reputation management. We find that reputation does not only shape the responses to external performance assessment but the external performance assessment itself.
- 16 January 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Public Money & Management
- Vol. 38 (2) , 131-138
Does austerity drive public service innovation? Evidence from shared senior management teams in local government
Shared senior management teams are a recent and radical response to financial austerity. They aim to improve the efficiency of public services without the disruption, controversy and transaction costs associated with full-blown organizational mergers. This paper assesses the adoption of this management innovation by English district councils, identifies enablers and barriers to its effective implementation, offers a preliminary assessment of its impacts, and draws out practical lessons for policy-makers.
- 16 January 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Public Money & Management
- Vol. 38 (2) , 131-138
Does austerity drive public service innovation? Evidence from shared senior management teams in local government
Shared senior management teams are a recent and radical response to financial austerity. They aim to improve the efficiency of public services without the disruption, controversy and transaction costs associated with full-blown organizational mergers. This paper assesses the adoption of this management innovation by English district councils, identifies enablers and barriers to its effective implementation, offers a preliminary assessment of its impacts, and draws out practical lessons for policy-makers.