TWThomas P. Weil

Thomas P. Weil

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Thomas P. Weil has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The Canadian healthcare system: It needs enhancement

    by Thomas P Weil

    Although Canadian healthcare is commonly referred to as a single-payer system providing universal coverage for only hospital and physician benefits, it is argued herein that their plan actually functions as a multi-payer model; and, it provides a far lesser breadth of coverage than available among most western European countries. Of concern is that in addition to their mandated plan, only 60% of their residents are covered by private insurance for pharmaceuticals, dental care, and eye services most often paid for as a fringe benefit by their employers. In addition, based on their medical loss ratios (74% for group coverage; 38% for individual insurance), these investor-owned, private insurance plans cannot be considered as an effective approach to protect the public against these medical expenditures. An obvious solution is to mandate these benefits as enhancements to the Canada Health Act of 1985, but this alternative is currently thought to be unrealistic for both political and economic reasons. Major issues now facing the Canadian healthcare system, in terms of its routine delivery of patient care, are not the single- versus multi-payer question or the inefficiencies of their supplementary insurance, but (a) the extended patient waits for non-emergent surgical services; (b) the lack of appropriate fiscal incentives when reimbursing their hospitals; and (c) their resident physicians currently completing approved programs in general surgery and the surgical sub-specialties frequently being unable to secure appropriate medical staff appointments. Maybe the Canadian healthcare system, although providing universal hospital and physician services, is not as idyllic as perceived by many throughout the world.


  • What can the Canadians and Americans learn from each other's health care systems?

    by Thomas P. Weil

    Summary: Numerous papers have been written comparing the Canadian and US healthcare systems, and a number of health policy experts have recommended that the Americans implement their single‐payer system to save 12–20% of its healthcare expenditures. This paper is different in that it assumes that neither country will undertake a significant philosophic or structural change in their healthcare system, but there are lessons to be learned that are inherent in one that could be a major breakthrough for the other. Following the model in Canada and in Western Europe, the USA could implement universal health insurance so that the 32.0 million (2015) Americans still uninsured would have at least minimal coverage when incurring medical expenditures. Also, the USA could use smart cards to evaluate eligibility and to process health insurance claims; these changes resulting in an estimated 15% reduction in US health expenditures without adversely effecting access or quality of care. Such a strategy would result in the eventual loss of 2.5 million white‐collar jobs at hospitals, physician offices and insurance companies, a long‐term economic gain.Only a few would agree with the statement that Canada already functions with a multi‐payer reimbursement system as evidenced by (1) a federal‐provincial, tax‐supported plan, administered by each of the provinces, providing universal coverage for hospital and physician services and (2) roughly 60% of its residents receiving employer‐paid health insurance benefits, underwritten primarily by investor‐owned plans, that are less than effective to reimburse for pharmaceuticals, dental and other healthcare services.What could be learned from the USA and particularly from Western European countries is possibly implementing an approach, whereby at least upper‐income Canadians could opt out of their federal‐provincial plan and purchase private insurance coverage — being eligible for far more comprehensive “private” benefits for hospital, physician, pharmaceutical, dental and other healthcare services. Aside from generating billions of additional needed revenues from the private sector, it could (1) help eliminate long waits for non‐emergent physicians' care by appointing newly minted specialists to their medical staffs; (2) offer prompt admissions for elective cases to “private” wings of hospitals; (3) increase available funding for what is currently an undercapitalized system; (4) enhance the system's sluggish operations; and (5) encourage more competition among various providers. Although such a two‐tier approach, such as available in the USA and elsewhere, is politically dead on arrival in Canada today, private insurance being already legal and commonly available there. Interestingly, this recommended solution is utilized in most western European countries where there is a higher percentage than in Canada of public (versus private) funding of their total health expenditures.Because of various vested interests, attempts to implement any of the aforementioned proposals will undoubtedly result in considerable political rancor. There is greater likelihood, however, that the Canadians because their need to be more effective and efficient in their delivery of care, and their overall long‐term fiscal outlook will agree to the further privatization of their healthcare system before the Americans will mandate universal access, use the smart card to process insurance eligibility and claims or will impose price controls on high‐tech services and on pharmaceuticals. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.


  • Leadership in academic health centers in the US: A review of the role and some recommendations

    by Thomas P Weil

    The leadership of the US's most complex academic health centers (AHCs)/medical centers requires individuals who possess a high level of clinical, organizational, managerial, and interpersonal skills. This paper first outlines the major attributes desired in a dean/vice president of health affairs before then summarizing the educational opportunities now generally available to train for such leadership and management roles. For the most part, the masters in health administration (MHA), the traditional MBA, and the numerous alternatives primarily available at universities are considered far too general and too lacking in emotional intelligence tutoring to be particularly relevant for those who aspire to these most senior leadership positions. More appropriate educational options for these roles are discussed: (a) the in-house leadership and management programs now underway at some AHCs for those selected early on in their career for future executive-type roles as well as for those who are appointed later on to a chair, directorship or similar position; and (b) a more controversial approach of potentially establishing at one or a few universities, a mid-career, professional program (a maximum of 12 months and therefore, being completed in less time than an MBA) leading to a masters degree in academic health center administration (MHCA) for those who aspire to fill a senior AHC leadership position. The proposed curriculum as outlined herein might be along the lines of some carefully designed masters level on-line, self-teaching modules for the more technical subjects, yet vigorously emphasizing integrate-type courses focused on enhancing personal and professional team building and leadership skills.


  • Health management education in Europe and in the United States: A comparative review and analysis

    by Thomas P Weil

    In Europe and in the United States, health management education and the role of health managers are patterned and consistent with how the country’s healthcare system is organized, managed, and financed. In the United States, the fee-for-service, entrepreneurial dominated approach, resulting in health being one of the few remaining growth industries, has created a huge demand for additional health management education programs and managers. Therefore, universities finding themselves in an economic slump are attracted to establish health services administration programs (a North American term) since they require limited capital, continue to attract enrollment, and contribute to the “social good.” In contrast, the European countries’ healthcare systems provide universal access to care and strict, governmental fiscal control on healthcare expenditures. As a result, the American masters-level health manager model has not thrived there—although not willingly conceded is the fact that in Europe physicians continue to dominate the management ranks. After outlining a number of the current problems facing US health management education, this article focuses on: (1) a projected shuttering of the weaker American health management programs and the market for health managers being overly saturated (such as for lawyers now), because the US gross domestic product expenditures for health will decrease over the next two decades from the current level of 17.6% to be somewhat comparable to the 11.5% in Canada, France, and Germany; and (2) a projected increase in the enrollment among European health management programs for several reasons: (a) a huge spike in the demand for additional clinically oriented, health managers who can trade off concerns of cost versus quality; and (b) the constraints of most countries’ statutory health insurance plans will become increasingly more evident so that privatization of healthcare services will become an option for those with above average incomes and, thereby, generate a demand for newly minted health managers similar to the US masters-level graduate.


    • 23 July 2013
      • Vol. 28  (6) , 373-7

    Commentary: something has to give. the question is, what?

    by Thomas P Weil

    A large facet joint cyst, the size of a walnut, at L5-S1 resulted in an "emergency" laminectomy at Asheville, North Carolina's Mission Hospitals on this 79-year-old active equestrian and retired healthcare consultant, who more than a half-century earlier was formally trained in hospital administration and medical economics. While as an inpatient, he reflected broadly about today's healthcare expenditures, utilization, and quality, and speculated on possible future remedies.

    • 4 April 2013
      • Vol. 28  (4) , 254-6

    Hospital reimbursement incentives: is there a more effective option?--Part II.

    by Thomas P Weil

    As discussed in Part I of this article, hospital executives in Canada, Germany, and the United States manage their facilities' resources to maximize the incentives inherent in their respective reimbursement system and thereby increase their bottom line. It was also discussed that an additional supply of available hospitals, physicians, and other services will generate increased utilization. Part II discusses how the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 will eventually fail since it neither controls prices nor utilization (e.g., imaging, procedures, ambulatory surgery, discretionary spending). This article concludes with the discussion of the German multipayer approach with universal access and global budgets that might well be a model for U.S. healthcare in the future. Although the German healthcare system has a number of shortfalls, its paradigm could offer the most appropriate compromise when selecting the economic incentives to reduce the percentage of the U.S. gross domestic product expenditure for healthcare from 17.4% to roughly 12.0%.

    • 5 February 2013
      • Vol. 28  (3) , 164-8

    Hospital reimbursement incentives: is there a more effective option?--Part I.

    by Thomas P Weil

    Based on the fiscal incentives inherent in a nation's hospital reimbursement methodology, it is highly predictable how the nation's healthcare executives will manage their organization's resources. The hospital data presented herein suggest that prospective reimbursement such as with DRGs in Germany and the United States encourages preadmission testing, more ambulatory care procedures, shorter average lengths of stay, and a greater number of employee hours per discharge. Payment on the basis of total patient days, such as in Canada, results in more acute care beds and more total days per 1000 persons, longer average lengths of stay, and less intensive use of personnel. But even when nations provide universal access, for various reasons those with mental illness and those who are indigent, poorly educated, and nonwhite use less healthcare services.

    • 28 August 2012
      • Vol. 28  (1) , 47-50

    Difficulties in consummating a meaningful hospital-physician collaboration.

    by Thomas P Weil

    Although there is a vast literature concerning the virtues of hospital-physician collaborative efforts, their actual performance to date in the United States according to rigorous research studies is far less than impressive. Hospitals are usually the party most interested in initiating such alignments, but physicians, as they respond to a patient's clinical needs, control almost all healthcare expenditures. Discussions between the parties have the potential of creating serious conflicts, primarily because of the lack of trust between physicians and hospital executives. The most frequent issues that arise are those relating to the sharing of ambulatory care revenues and who will be responsible for various clinical operations.


    • 19 May 2012
      • Vol. 27  (5) , 263-7

    Why are ACOs doomed for failure?

    by Thomas P Weil

    Among the more ambitious parts of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (2010) is the formation of Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) that offer fiscal rewards when well-organized, integrated hospital-physician groups can improve quality of care and reduce the cost of Medicare expenditures. After studying the conceptual and operational issues, it is concluded herein that ACOs are in the long-haul doomed for failure since: 1) most hospitals and physicians have major difficulties in consummating tightly coordinated collaborative efforts; 2) providers historically have had a dismal track record in reducing cost, because of existing fee-for-service incentives; and 3) existing regulations do not provide sufficient fiscal rewards to assume the cost of starting an ACO and its possible operational risks.