KKKim A. Kastens

Kim A. Kastens

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Kim A. Kastens has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • What kinds of questions do students ask while exploring data visualizations?

    by Kim A. Kastens, Melissa Zrada, Margie Turrin

    Question-asking is a necessary step towards formulating hypotheses, making decisions, and solving problems, and is Practice #1 in the Next Generation Science Standards. To improve question-asking, educators and researchers need a way to categorize and evaluate students’ questions, so as to judge whether an intervention has been effective. We collected a corpus of questions generated by undergraduates as they explored data pertaining to sea level and climate. To capture a broad range of questions, we recruited participants from all majors and multiple institutions, used different prompts to elicit questions, showed both physical- and social-science data, and presented the data both on paper and interactively. We developed a taxonomy of question types informed by geoscientific habits of mind and designed to be applicable across a wide range of data types. We assigned Bloom’s cognitive levels to each question type, and developed a quality metric for question sets. There were wide individual differences in both quality and quantity of questions, plus some systematic differences by experimental condition. Prompting to ask as many questions as possible elicited more high level questions overall, but prompting to write questions you would like to ask the scientist elicited important questions about how the data were collected. Encouragingly, over 70% of participants generated at least one question at the highest Bloom’s level. Implications for instruction include that assigned question-asking can be an opportunity to engage all students in question asking, and that students can ask good questions about complex data before the data are explained to them.


  • Open Access

    An Evolutionary Leap in How We Teach Geosciences

    by Kristen St. John, Kelsey Bitting, Cinzia Cervato, Kim A. Kastens, R. Heather Macdonald, John McDaris, Karen S. McNeal, Heather Petcovic, Eric Pyle, Eric Riggs, et al.

    New research into the ways that students learn and apply their knowledge is changing teaching methods and undergraduate geoscience course content.


  • Using Systems Thinking in the Design, Implementation, and Evaluation of Complex Educational Innovations, With Examples From the InTeGrate Project

    by Kim A. Kastens, Cathryn A. Manduca

    Many geoscience education initiatives now involve cross-departmental or multi-institutional programs. However, the geoscientists who lead such programs typically have little experience or training in program design, leadership, or evaluation. In this commentary, we make the case that geoscientists taking on these ambitious leadership roles can draw on a set of understandings and skills that they already have: the tools and habits of mind of systems thinking. Using examples from the InTeGrate program, we suggest ways to envision, shape, and monitor an educational intervention by thinking of oneself as building and improving a complex system with constituent subsystems. Suggestions for the design phase include the following: Decide on an essential suite of subsystems and plan for them to interact in mutually beneficial ways. Consider using a set of semi-autonomous parallel subsystems that will allow for replication with adaptation as experience accrues. Plan for nonlinear causality chains in which ...


  • Open Access

    What Geoscience Experts And Novices Look At, And What They See, When Viewing Data Visualizations

    by Kim A. Kastens, Thomas F. Shipley, Alexander P. Boone, Frances Straccia

    This study examines how geoscience experts and novices make meaning from an iconic type of data visualization: shaded relief images of bathymetry and topography. Participants examined, described, and interpreted a global image, two high-resolution seafloor images, and 2 high-resolution continental images, while having their gaze direction eye-tracked and their utterances and gestures videoed. In addition, experts were asked about how they would coach an undergraduate intern on how to interpret this data. Not unexpectedly, all experts were more skillful than any of the novices at describing and explaining what they were seeing. However, the novices showed a wide range of performance. Along the continuum from weakest novice to strongest expert, proficiency developed in the following order: making qualitative observations of salient features, making simple interpretations, making quantitative observations. The eye-tracking analysis examined how the experts and novices invested 20 seconds of unguided exploration, after the image came into view but before the researcher began to ask questions. On the cartographic elements of the images, experts and novices allocated their exploration time differently: experts invested proportionately more fixations on the latitude and longitude axes, while students paid more attention to the color bar. In contrast, within the parts of the image showing the actual geomorphological data, experts and novices on average allocated their attention similarly, attending preferentially to the geologically significant landforms. Combining their spoken responses with their eye-tracking behavior, we conclude that the experts and novices are looking in the same places but “seeing” different things.


  • Open Access

    Student interpretation of a global elevation map: What it is, how it was made, and what it is useful for

    by Sandra Swenson, Kim Kastens

    Visual representations of scientific data make these data accessible and enable students to examine the evidence used to build scientific arguments and test theories, even when the underlying data set is large or complicated. It is becoming more common in science education to use data visualizations based on data that students did not collect themselves. Teachers and instructional designers need to understand how students perceive and interpret such visualizations. This research examined the nature of students' interpretations about a colored, shaded-relief global digital elevation map useful for reasoning about a wide range of Earth processes. One hundred and ninety-six middle and high school students wrote answers to three open-ended questions while viewing the map projected on an overhead screen: “What do you think this is?” “How do you think this was made?” and “What do you think this is useful for?” Nearly half the students surveyed made no mention of topography/bathymetry or an equivalent concept. Twenty percent of the students misinterpreted the map to contain information other than elevation, including inappropriate interpretations such as water, temperature, and weather. Over half of the students did not describe any aspect of data acquisition as a component of the data map creation. In describing the utility of the map, students focused on information-retrieval tasks rather than on making inferences about Earth processes. Based on our findings about geoscience data visualization, we suggest strategies that may be beneficial in designing curriculum for teaching and learning with data maps.


  • Commentary: Object and Spatial Visualization in Geosciences

    by Kim Kastens

    Cognitive science research shows that the brain has two systems for processing visual information, one specialized for spatial information such as position, orientation, and trajectory, and the other specialized for information used to identify objects, such as color, shape and texture. Some individuals seem to be more facile with the spatial visualization system, while others favor the object visualization system. This commentary hypothesizes that geosciences draw heavily on both systems, in contrast to other studied professions whose practitioners tend to be strong at spatial visualization (e.g. physics), or object visualization (e.g. visual arts). Candidate object visualization tasks in geosciences include identifying rocks, minerals and fossils, and interpreting remote sensing images. Candidate spatial visualization tasks include envisioning the folding and faulting of sedimentary strata, and envisioning a 3-D volume from 2-D data. In general education, geoscience activities rich in object-visualizati...


  • How Students and Field Geologists Reason in Integrating Spatial Observations from Outcrops to Visualize a 3‐D Geological Structure

    by Kim A. Kastens, Shruti Agrawal, Lynn S. Liben

    Geologists and undergraduate students observed eight artificial “rock outcrops” in a realistically scaled field area, and then tried to envision a geological structure that might plausibly be formed by the layered rocks in the set of outcrops. Students were videotaped as they selected which of fourteen 3‐D models they thought best represented the geological structure and then explained their choice. The focus of this paper is on how students reasoned from observations to inferences. Students used observations of outcrops’ location, steepness (dip), orientation (strike), stratigraphy, and placement relative to topography to infer whether the structure was convex or concave, deep or shallow, symmetrical or asymmetrical, open or closed, and elongate or circular. On average, science majors produced more than twice as many evidence‐supported claims than did non‐science majors. Science majors produced more valid lines of reasoning than did non‐science majors, and students who selected a correct model produced more valid lines of reasoning than students who selected an erroneous model. Apparent challenges included identifying appropriate observational evidence, combining multiple lines of reasoning, and understanding the scale relationship between candidate models and the full‐scale structure.