Penelope M. Mullen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Latest Publications
- 1 November 2004
- Published by SAGE Publications in Health Services Management Research
- Vol. 17 (4) , 217-228
Using performance indicators to improve performance
The recent introduction of performance assessment within the UK NHS, incorporating numerous performance indicators (PIs) and league tables, has led to health care organisations facing large numbers of targets and a star rating system with associated rewards and penalties. However, there is considerable evidence that using PIs for judgement rather than learning provides perverse incentives and can prove counterproductive. Drawing on earlier PI systems which, supplemented by expert systems, were designed to promote learning and exploration particularly by encouraging analysis of interactions between different indicators, a series of 'mini case studies' is presented. These reveal interesting relationships and suggest explanations for variations in performance, areas worth exploring further and possible approaches to improving performance - approaches not apparent from individual indicators and league tables. It is concluded that presentation of PIs in a format that encourages exploration and analysis could greatly enhance the potential of the current PIs to improve NHS performance.
- 1 November 2004
- Published by SAGE Publications in Health Services Management Research
- Vol. 17 (4) , 217-228
Using performance indicators to improve performance
The recent introduction of performance assessment within the UK NHS, incorporating numerous performance indicators (PIs) and league tables, has led to health care organisations facing large numbers of targets and a star rating system with associated rewards and penalties. However, there is considerable evidence that using PIs for judgement rather than learning provides perverse incentives and can prove counterproductive. Drawing on earlier PI systems which, supplemented by expert systems, were designed to promote learning and exploration particularly by encouraging analysis of interactions between different indicators, a series of 'mini case studies' is presented. These reveal interesting relationships and suggest explanations for variations in performance, areas worth exploring further and possible approaches to improving performance - approaches not apparent from individual indicators and league tables. It is concluded that presentation of PIs in a format that encourages exploration and analysis could greatly enhance the potential of the current PIs to improve NHS performance.
- 1 February 2004
- Published by SAGE Publications in Health Services Management Research
- Vol. 17 (1) , 47-58
Quantifying priorities in healthcare: transparency or illusion?
Explicit priority setting in healthcare, which often involves multiple criteria and value judgements, has come to prominence in a number of different healthcare systems over the past decade. Drawing on the results of a survey of priority setting in practice in the UK National Health Service, this paper analyses issues associated with quantification in priority setting, focusing on techniques for eliciting and aggregating values, the criteria and form of models used and their application in priority setting. The findings reveal a clear focus on equity, a strong concern to demonstrate openness, consistency and transparency in priority setting-leading to greater use of explicit multi-criteria models-and a notable focus on the quality of 'evidence'. However, reported difficulties in weighting over-long lists of non-commensurate and overlapping criteria, the inclusion of inappropriate criteria, and attributes of the form of models employed, lead to the conclusion that the implications of the methods are not always appreciated, the resulting priority 'scores' sometimes misunderstood and, in some cases, the concern for transparency and explicitness appears to outweigh concern for methodological understanding-leading to an illusion of transparency.
- 1 February 2004
- Published by SAGE Publications in Health Services Management Research
- Vol. 17 (1) , 47-58
Quantifying priorities in healthcare: transparency or illusion?
Explicit priority setting in healthcare, which often involves multiple criteria and value judgements, has come to prominence in a number of different healthcare systems over the past decade. Drawing on the results of a survey of priority setting in practice in the UK National Health Service, this paper analyses issues associated with quantification in priority setting, focusing on techniques for eliciting and aggregating values, the criteria and form of models used and their application in priority setting. The findings reveal a clear focus on equity, a strong concern to demonstrate openness, consistency and transparency in priority setting-leading to greater use of explicit multi-criteria models-and a notable focus on the quality of 'evidence'. However, reported difficulties in weighting over-long lists of non-commensurate and overlapping criteria, the inclusion of inappropriate criteria, and attributes of the form of models employed, lead to the conclusion that the implications of the methods are not always appreciated, the resulting priority 'scores' sometimes misunderstood and, in some cases, the concern for transparency and explicitness appears to outweigh concern for methodological understanding-leading to an illusion of transparency.
- 25 December 1999
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 2 (4) , 222-234
Public involvement in health care priority setting: an overview of methods for eliciting values
There is increasing interest, in the UK and elsewhere, in involving the public in health care priority setting. At the same time, however, there is evidence of lack of clarity about the objectives of some priority setting projects and also about the role of public involvement. Further, some projects display an apparent ignorance of both long‐standing theoretical literature and practical experience of methodologies for eliciting values in health care and related fields. After a brief examination of the context of health care priority setting and public involvement, this paper describes a range of different approaches to eliciting values. These approaches are critically examined on a number of dimensions including the type of choice allowed to respondents and the implications of aggregation of values across individuals. Factors which affect the appropriateness of the different techniques to specific applications are discussed. A check‐list of questions to be asked when selecting techniques is presented.
- 25 December 1999
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 2 (4) , 222-234
Public involvement in health care priority setting: an overview of methods for eliciting values
There is increasing interest, in the UK and elsewhere, in involving the public in health care priority setting. At the same time, however, there is evidence of lack of clarity about the objectives of some priority setting projects and also about the role of public involvement. Further, some projects display an apparent ignorance of both long‐standing theoretical literature and practical experience of methodologies for eliciting values in health care and related fields. After a brief examination of the context of health care priority setting and public involvement, this paper describes a range of different approaches to eliciting values. These approaches are critically examined on a number of dimensions including the type of choice allowed to respondents and the implications of aggregation of values across individuals. Factors which affect the appropriateness of the different techniques to specific applications are discussed. A check‐list of questions to be asked when selecting techniques is presented.