Helen Malson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Helen Malson has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Irmgard Tischner
Department of Social Sciences University of the West of England Bristol UK
3 shared publicationsGail Anderson
Department of Adolescent Medicine, Westmead Hospital, Westmead, Australia
2 shared publicationsMichael Kohn
Department of Adolescent Medicine, Westmead Hospital, Westmead, Australia
2 shared publicationsSimon Clarke
Department of Adolescent Medicine, Westmead Hospital, Westmead, Australia
2 shared publicationsAli Borden
1 shared publication- Annadís Greta Rúdólfsdóttir
University of Iceland, Iceland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 52-81
A Genealogy of ‘Anorexia Nervosa’
While the name of the symbolic female disorder may change from one historical period to the next, the gender asymmetry of the representational tradition remains constant.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 52-81
A Genealogy of ‘Anorexia Nervosa’
While the name of the symbolic female disorder may change from one historical period to the next, the gender asymmetry of the representational tradition remains constant.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-38
Theorizing Women
I have argued that if we are to understand the problem of ‘anorexia’ better we need to engage more thoroughly with its socio-cultural and gender-specific dimensions. We must question the medical model of anorexia and the empiricist or positivistic assumptions concerning the nature and status of ‘anorexia’ that underlie many current perspectives and work instead from a perspective which situates anorexia within its socio-cultural context and which provides a more thorough theorization of gender. In this chapter I aim to provide such a perspective by drawing on psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theory. However, my aim is not to provide an exposition of psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theories in their entirety; such a project lies well beyond the scope of this book. I intend, rather, to discuss those aspects of psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theory which I think are particularly useful and inspirational in attempting to understand the experiences of the social subject and, more specifically, the distress that many girls and women in this society experience around eating and not eating, around losing and gaining weight, being fat or thin, around being a woman and around being ‘anorexic’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-38
Theorizing Women
I have argued that if we are to understand the problem of ‘anorexia’ better we need to engage more thoroughly with its socio-cultural and gender-specific dimensions. We must question the medical model of anorexia and the empiricist or positivistic assumptions concerning the nature and status of ‘anorexia’ that underlie many current perspectives and work instead from a perspective which situates anorexia within its socio-cultural context and which provides a more thorough theorization of gender. In this chapter I aim to provide such a perspective by drawing on psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theory. However, my aim is not to provide an exposition of psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theories in their entirety; such a project lies well beyond the scope of this book. I intend, rather, to discuss those aspects of psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theory which I think are particularly useful and inspirational in attempting to understand the experiences of the social subject and, more specifically, the distress that many girls and women in this society experience around eating and not eating, around losing and gaining weight, being fat or thin, around being a woman and around being ‘anorexic’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 39-50
Discourse, Feminism, Research and the Production of Truth
In Chapter 1 I discussed psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theories and explored how these theories undermine our commonsense and mainstream psychological notions of gender, identity and embodiment. In providing a radically anti-essentialist account of subjectivity, gender and embodiment, I argued that a feminist post-structuralist perspective, informed by Lacanian theory, provides a useful and inspirational theoretical space within which to question critically the status of our current knowledges of ‘anorexia’ and in which we can re-examine the problem of ‘anorexia’ in its socio-historically specific and genderspecific discursive contexts. A feminist post-structuralist perspective, I have argued, enables us to transgress the individual-society dichotomy and to engage more thoroughly with a concept of ‘anorexia’ as a socio-culturally constituted phenomenon, manifested in individual women. It enables us to locate women’s and girls’ experiences and distress around food and eating and around gender, subjectivity and embodiment within those discourses that constitute and regulate our lives in late twentieth-century Western society. It also enables us to explore the gendered dimensions of these discourses, allowing us to engage with the socio-political dimensions of our own and/or others’ subjectivities. By unravelling some of those discourses that converge upon the female body and on the ‘anorexic’ body We can explore how the ‘micro-physics of power’ that functions in discourse operates upon the anorexic body.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 39-50
Discourse, Feminism, Research and the Production of Truth
In Chapter 1 I discussed psychoanalytic and post-structuralist theories and explored how these theories undermine our commonsense and mainstream psychological notions of gender, identity and embodiment. In providing a radically anti-essentialist account of subjectivity, gender and embodiment, I argued that a feminist post-structuralist perspective, informed by Lacanian theory, provides a useful and inspirational theoretical space within which to question critically the status of our current knowledges of ‘anorexia’ and in which we can re-examine the problem of ‘anorexia’ in its socio-historically specific and genderspecific discursive contexts. A feminist post-structuralist perspective, I have argued, enables us to transgress the individual-society dichotomy and to engage more thoroughly with a concept of ‘anorexia’ as a socio-culturally constituted phenomenon, manifested in individual women. It enables us to locate women’s and girls’ experiences and distress around food and eating and around gender, subjectivity and embodiment within those discourses that constitute and regulate our lives in late twentieth-century Western society. It also enables us to explore the gendered dimensions of these discourses, allowing us to engage with the socio-political dimensions of our own and/or others’ subjectivities. By unravelling some of those discourses that converge upon the female body and on the ‘anorexic’ body We can explore how the ‘micro-physics of power’ that functions in discourse operates upon the anorexic body.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 165-193
Discursive Self-Production and Self-Destruction
As we have seen, a variety of different discourses converge upon the thin/anorexic body, constituting that body in numerous often conflicting ways so that it signifies a multiplicity of diverse subjectivities. The discursive productions of ‘anorexia’ are inextricably tied up with the discursive productions of identity and the problematics of feminine subjectivity (see Chapter 7). From this perspective ‘anorexia’ can be read as a form of self-production. The material and discursive production of the female body as an ‘anorexic’ body simultaneously produces a range of particular subjectivities for the thin or ‘anorexic’ woman. And, indeed, ‘anorexia’ may be explicitly construed as a means of producing identity (see Chapter 7): self-starvation may be explicitly constituted as a form of self-production. Yet such ‘anorexic’ practices are also quite clearly associated with profound psychological distress and are in themselves damaging and self-destructive. ‘Anorexia’ can thus be understood as a material and discursive process of producing an identity for oneself and simultaneously of destroying oneself both literally and metaphorically. And it is this tension, this paradoxical construction of ‘anorexia’ as both self-producing and self-annihilating, that I shall explore in this chapter.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 165-193
Discursive Self-Production and Self-Destruction
As we have seen, a variety of different discourses converge upon the thin/anorexic body, constituting that body in numerous often conflicting ways so that it signifies a multiplicity of diverse subjectivities. The discursive productions of ‘anorexia’ are inextricably tied up with the discursive productions of identity and the problematics of feminine subjectivity (see Chapter 7). From this perspective ‘anorexia’ can be read as a form of self-production. The material and discursive production of the female body as an ‘anorexic’ body simultaneously produces a range of particular subjectivities for the thin or ‘anorexic’ woman. And, indeed, ‘anorexia’ may be explicitly construed as a means of producing identity (see Chapter 7): self-starvation may be explicitly constituted as a form of self-production. Yet such ‘anorexic’ practices are also quite clearly associated with profound psychological distress and are in themselves damaging and self-destructive. ‘Anorexia’ can thus be understood as a material and discursive process of producing an identity for oneself and simultaneously of destroying oneself both literally and metaphorically. And it is this tension, this paradoxical construction of ‘anorexia’ as both self-producing and self-annihilating, that I shall explore in this chapter.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 82-106
Discoursing Anorexias in the Late Twentieth Century
In Chapter 3 I examined how ‘anorexia nervosa’ first came to emerge as an object of nineteenth-century medical discourse, exploring how, with the rise of science over theology, women’s self-starvation was gradually taken into the remit of medical rather than ecclesiastical authority (see also Brumberg, 1986). As the medical profession established itself as a source of secular authority, so it also developed an increasing array of knowledges and technologies by which it classified, explained, treated and regulated the population. And, with the concomitant rise of the bourgeois family, sexuality and gender featured as prominent targets of medical discipline (Foucault, 1979) such that ‘woman’, particularly white middle-class woman, was repeatedly constituted as a pathological category (Showalter, 1985). During the nineteenth century, explanations for women’s supposed pathological nature were shifting, however, and ‘anorexia nervosa’ emerged as a distinct disease entity at precisely this juncture in time. The discourse on hysteria was detaching itself from its classical origins so that women’s nerves replaced their wombs in accounts of female pathology. At the same time the equally culturally entrenched discourse on hypochondria was also changing. Whilst retaining its historical reference to the stomach as a nervous organ, hypochondria increasingly referred to general ‘nervousness’ and to ‘malades imaginaires’. And ‘anorexia’, I argued, emerged at the interface of these two converging discourses. It was constituted as a disease entity in which ‘hysteria’ and ‘hypochondria’ became merged and in which pathologized femininity could be rearticulated as nervous rather than classically hysterical.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 82-106
Discoursing Anorexias in the Late Twentieth Century
In Chapter 3 I examined how ‘anorexia nervosa’ first came to emerge as an object of nineteenth-century medical discourse, exploring how, with the rise of science over theology, women’s self-starvation was gradually taken into the remit of medical rather than ecclesiastical authority (see also Brumberg, 1986). As the medical profession established itself as a source of secular authority, so it also developed an increasing array of knowledges and technologies by which it classified, explained, treated and regulated the population. And, with the concomitant rise of the bourgeois family, sexuality and gender featured as prominent targets of medical discipline (Foucault, 1979) such that ‘woman’, particularly white middle-class woman, was repeatedly constituted as a pathological category (Showalter, 1985). During the nineteenth century, explanations for women’s supposed pathological nature were shifting, however, and ‘anorexia nervosa’ emerged as a distinct disease entity at precisely this juncture in time. The discourse on hysteria was detaching itself from its classical origins so that women’s nerves replaced their wombs in accounts of female pathology. At the same time the equally culturally entrenched discourse on hypochondria was also changing. Whilst retaining its historical reference to the stomach as a nervous organ, hypochondria increasingly referred to general ‘nervousness’ and to ‘malades imaginaires’. And ‘anorexia’, I argued, emerged at the interface of these two converging discourses. It was constituted as a disease entity in which ‘hysteria’ and ‘hypochondria’ became merged and in which pathologized femininity could be rearticulated as nervous rather than classically hysterical.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 194-199
Conclusions
‘Anorexia nervosa’ seems to crystallize many contemporary complex sociocultural concerns and conflicts surrounding gender, subjectivity and embodiment. It is expressive of societal preoccupations as well as personal distress. It is saying something about what it means to be a woman in late twentieth-century Western society. But what is ‘anorexia nervosa’? Most people are now familiar with what are now regarded as the central characteristics of ‘anorexia’ and will often see it as, in some way, a feminine disorder: ‘anorexia’ is something that afflicts today’s young women. As a diagnostic category, ‘anorexia’ has existed since the late nineteenth century and yet it also seems to be a peculiarly modern ‘disorder’. Whilst interpretations of epidemiological data are always contentious (see Brumberg, 1986) it does seem that increasing numbers of girls and women are being diagnosed as anorexic. And ‘disordered’ eating is clearly an important, troubling, aspect of many womens’ lives (Bruch, 1978) and appears to be affecting ever younger girls (Hill and Robinson, 1991). Compared with many other ‘disorders’, ‘anorexia’ also has a high profile both in the media and in academic and clinical literature, suggesting a cultural fascination with all things ‘anorexic’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 194-199
Conclusions
‘Anorexia nervosa’ seems to crystallize many contemporary complex sociocultural concerns and conflicts surrounding gender, subjectivity and embodiment. It is expressive of societal preoccupations as well as personal distress. It is saying something about what it means to be a woman in late twentieth-century Western society. But what is ‘anorexia nervosa’? Most people are now familiar with what are now regarded as the central characteristics of ‘anorexia’ and will often see it as, in some way, a feminine disorder: ‘anorexia’ is something that afflicts today’s young women. As a diagnostic category, ‘anorexia’ has existed since the late nineteenth century and yet it also seems to be a peculiarly modern ‘disorder’. Whilst interpretations of epidemiological data are always contentious (see Brumberg, 1986) it does seem that increasing numbers of girls and women are being diagnosed as anorexic. And ‘disordered’ eating is clearly an important, troubling, aspect of many womens’ lives (Bruch, 1978) and appears to be affecting ever younger girls (Hill and Robinson, 1991). Compared with many other ‘disorders’, ‘anorexia’ also has a high profile both in the media and in academic and clinical literature, suggesting a cultural fascination with all things ‘anorexic’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 148-164
Anorexia and the Discursive Production of the Self
In the preceding two chapters I have drawn on a series of interviews with women diagnosed or self-diagnosed as ‘anorexic’ in order to explore some of the discourses and discursive resources deployed in the constructions of ‘anorexia’, ‘femininity’ and ‘the body’. I have aimed to demonstrate that both within and across the women’s accounts there is a variety of entangled discourses which produce these discursive objects in multiple, often conflicting ways. That is, the meanings of these objects differ between discourses and, whilst some constructions are mutually consolidating, others are conflictual. The thin/anorexic body may, for example, be construed as heterosexually attractive, as a signifier of a patriarchally defined romantic femininity. And this signification is consolidated by other constructions of the thin body as small, childlike and ill. However, this same body may also be construed as androgynous or boyishly thin. It may signify a resistance to or rejection of ‘traditional femininity’, and it may be produced as a controlled body, signifying a powerful and disembodied subjectivity. The thin body thus sustains a multiplicity of meanings and may signify a variety of (often conflicting) subjectivities. The discursive and physical management of the thin/anorexic body and the discursive struggle over its meanings can thus be understood as a management of identity. The production and maintenance of the thin/anorexic body through dieting, self-starvation and/or purging can be viewed as facilitating interpellation in certain subject positions and as resistance to others.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 148-164
Anorexia and the Discursive Production of the Self
In the preceding two chapters I have drawn on a series of interviews with women diagnosed or self-diagnosed as ‘anorexic’ in order to explore some of the discourses and discursive resources deployed in the constructions of ‘anorexia’, ‘femininity’ and ‘the body’. I have aimed to demonstrate that both within and across the women’s accounts there is a variety of entangled discourses which produce these discursive objects in multiple, often conflicting ways. That is, the meanings of these objects differ between discourses and, whilst some constructions are mutually consolidating, others are conflictual. The thin/anorexic body may, for example, be construed as heterosexually attractive, as a signifier of a patriarchally defined romantic femininity. And this signification is consolidated by other constructions of the thin body as small, childlike and ill. However, this same body may also be construed as androgynous or boyishly thin. It may signify a resistance to or rejection of ‘traditional femininity’, and it may be produced as a controlled body, signifying a powerful and disembodied subjectivity. The thin body thus sustains a multiplicity of meanings and may signify a variety of (often conflicting) subjectivities. The discursive and physical management of the thin/anorexic body and the discursive struggle over its meanings can thus be understood as a management of identity. The production and maintenance of the thin/anorexic body through dieting, self-starvation and/or purging can be viewed as facilitating interpellation in certain subject positions and as resistance to others.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
The Thin Woman
The First Edition of The Thin Woman, first published in 1998, provides an in-depth discussion of anorexia nervosa from a critical feminist social psychological standpoint. In the original text, the author argues that the notion of 'anorexia' as a medical condition limits our understanding of anorexia and the extent to which we can explore it as a socially and discursively produced problem. The book now has a new introduction that discusses some of the major cultural and academic developments that have occurred since its first publication. In considering our changing cultural landscapes, the introduction goes on to discuss the so-called ‘obesity crisis’; the emergence of post-feminism; the massive global expansion of digital and social media and, most recently, the Covid-19 pandemic. Turning to academic developments, it focuses on the increasing recognition of intersectional feminism and reflects on how intersectional perspectives are now beginning to shape critical feminist research and theory in this field. The new introduction also highlights the significant growth in the last 25 years of critical feminist research on eating disorders, which has brought with it a greater awareness of intersectional theory and a more inclusive agenda; an expansion of research foci; a diversification of methodologies and the emergence of more egalitarian models of research in which those with lived experience of eating disorders are becoming valued research team members who help to shape research aims, designs and processes. Based on original research using historical and contemporary literature on anorexia nervosa and a series of interviews with women who identified as ‘anorexic’, this book offers critical insights into this problem. It is an invaluable read for anyone interested in eating disorders and gender, developments in feminist post-structuralist theory and discourse analytic research in psychology.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
The Thin Woman
The First Edition of The Thin Woman, first published in 1998, provides an in-depth discussion of anorexia nervosa from a critical feminist social psychological standpoint. In the original text, the author argues that the notion of 'anorexia' as a medical condition limits our understanding of anorexia and the extent to which we can explore it as a socially and discursively produced problem. The book now has a new introduction that discusses some of the major cultural and academic developments that have occurred since its first publication. In considering our changing cultural landscapes, the introduction goes on to discuss the so-called ‘obesity crisis’; the emergence of post-feminism; the massive global expansion of digital and social media and, most recently, the Covid-19 pandemic. Turning to academic developments, it focuses on the increasing recognition of intersectional feminism and reflects on how intersectional perspectives are now beginning to shape critical feminist research and theory in this field. The new introduction also highlights the significant growth in the last 25 years of critical feminist research on eating disorders, which has brought with it a greater awareness of intersectional theory and a more inclusive agenda; an expansion of research foci; a diversification of methodologies and the emergence of more egalitarian models of research in which those with lived experience of eating disorders are becoming valued research team members who help to shape research aims, designs and processes. Based on original research using historical and contemporary literature on anorexia nervosa and a series of interviews with women who identified as ‘anorexic’, this book offers critical insights into this problem. It is an invaluable read for anyone interested in eating disorders and gender, developments in feminist post-structuralist theory and discourse analytic research in psychology.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-12
Classic Edition Introduction
The ‘turn to discourse’ – heralded in psychology by Henriques et al.’s (1984) Changing the Subject, Potter and Wetherell’s (1987) Discourse and Social Psychology, Parker’s (1989) The Crisis in Modern Social Psychology, and How to End It and Burman and Parker’s (1993) Discourse Analytic Research – came rather later to psychology than it did to other social sciences. So when The Thin Woman was first published in 1998, 25 years ago, critical and critical feminist perspectives were still considered quite new and unusual in psychology and still heavily resisted by much of the mainstream. The Thin Woman thus represented a radical departure from existing psychological theory and research into eating disorders which, with few exceptions, had been (and continues overwhelmingly to be) positivist or post-positivist in outlook, based on quantitative research and premised on a quasi-medical, individualising and pathologising model of eating disorders as clinical entities that are viewed as categorically distinct from the allegedly healthy norms exhibited by those without a diagnosis. In contrast, drawing on Foucauldian, Lacanian and feminist psychoanalytic theory, The Thin Woman theorised eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa, as an amalgam of discursively constituted and regulated categories of embodied subjectivities and practices that rearticulate, rather than deviate from, a range of culturally dominant, mainstream ideas, norms and values, particularly around gender, bodies and ‘the individual’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-12
Classic Edition Introduction
The ‘turn to discourse’ – heralded in psychology by Henriques et al.’s (1984) Changing the Subject, Potter and Wetherell’s (1987) Discourse and Social Psychology, Parker’s (1989) The Crisis in Modern Social Psychology, and How to End It and Burman and Parker’s (1993) Discourse Analytic Research – came rather later to psychology than it did to other social sciences. So when The Thin Woman was first published in 1998, 25 years ago, critical and critical feminist perspectives were still considered quite new and unusual in psychology and still heavily resisted by much of the mainstream. The Thin Woman thus represented a radical departure from existing psychological theory and research into eating disorders which, with few exceptions, had been (and continues overwhelmingly to be) positivist or post-positivist in outlook, based on quantitative research and premised on a quasi-medical, individualising and pathologising model of eating disorders as clinical entities that are viewed as categorically distinct from the allegedly healthy norms exhibited by those without a diagnosis. In contrast, drawing on Foucauldian, Lacanian and feminist psychoanalytic theory, The Thin Woman theorised eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa, as an amalgam of discursively constituted and regulated categories of embodied subjectivities and practices that rearticulate, rather than deviate from, a range of culturally dominant, mainstream ideas, norms and values, particularly around gender, bodies and ‘the individual’.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 127-147
Subjectivity, Embodiment and Gender in a Discourse of Cartesian Dualism
In the previous chapter I discussed how the thin or anorexic body may be differently gendered by the different discourses in which it is constituted. One of the discourses that I identified in this analysis was a discourse of Cartesian dualism, which produces the body as uncontrolled and threatening and alien to the disembodied subject position of mind/self. This chapter continues with this theme of mind-body dualism, exploring how issues of control, subjectivity, embodiment and gender are discursively constituted within this Cartesian dualist discourse (see also Malson and Ussher, 1996b; Malson, forthcoming).
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 127-147
Subjectivity, Embodiment and Gender in a Discourse of Cartesian Dualism
In the previous chapter I discussed how the thin or anorexic body may be differently gendered by the different discourses in which it is constituted. One of the discourses that I identified in this analysis was a discourse of Cartesian dualism, which produces the body as uncontrolled and threatening and alien to the disembodied subject position of mind/self. This chapter continues with this theme of mind-body dualism, exploring how issues of control, subjectivity, embodiment and gender are discursively constituted within this Cartesian dualist discourse (see also Malson and Ussher, 1996b; Malson, forthcoming).