Michael Reynolds
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Michael Reynolds has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Chryssa Themelis
Norwegian University of Science and Technology
1 shared publication - Gale Parchoma
Department of Educational Research, Lancaster University
1 shared publication - Linda Perriton
Stirling Management School, University of Stirling, Stirling, UK
1 shared publication - Madeleine Sclater
University of Glasgow
1 shared publication - Sue Tickner
University of Glasgow
1 shared publication - Vivien Hodgson
Lancaster University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 3 September 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 49 (5) , 521-536
Critical Management Education in challenging times
In this article, we review the aims of the Critical Management Education project against the background of changes in the student population and increasing institutional pressures to protect sources of income. We revisit the foundations of the critical project in the contributions of radical – including critical management – educators, examine recent changes in the management education context and review the ways our theory and practice have responded and should respond to these changes. We call for the Critical Management Education community to review the basis of its critical work with students if the ‘classroom’ is to remain an important site for criticality.
- 3 September 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 49 (5) , 521-536
Critical Management Education in challenging times
In this article, we review the aims of the Critical Management Education project against the background of changes in the student population and increasing institutional pressures to protect sources of income. We revisit the foundations of the critical project in the contributions of radical – including critical management – educators, examine recent changes in the management education context and review the ways our theory and practice have responded and should respond to these changes. We call for the Critical Management Education community to review the basis of its critical work with students if the ‘classroom’ is to remain an important site for criticality.
- 21 March 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Action Learning: Research and Practice
- Vol. 8 (1) , 5-13
Reflective practice: origins and interpretations
The idea of reflection is central to the theory and practice of learning – especially learning which is grounded in past or current experience. This paper proposes a working definition of reflection and reviews its origins and recent developments. The author also provides an account of ‘critical reflection’, including its rationale and characteristics, and argues for its particular suitability in the practice of action learning.
- 21 March 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Action Learning: Research and Practice
- Vol. 8 (1) , 5-13
Reflective practice: origins and interpretations
The idea of reflection is central to the theory and practice of learning – especially learning which is grounded in past or current experience. This paper proposes a working definition of reflection and reviews its origins and recent developments. The author also provides an account of ‘critical reflection’, including its rationale and characteristics, and argues for its particular suitability in the practice of action learning.
- Open Access
- 3 May 2010
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 7, 593-601
Symposium 1: Learning, Teaching and Assessment in Networked Learning
The focus of our paper is on Theme 2 of the Networked Learning Manifesto which focused on Learning Teaching and Assessment and stated as follows: Networked e-learning as envisaged in this manifesto requires models of learning that are based on participation and not ones that are based on transmission. This requires as much emphasis on learning processes and learning to learn as on subject knowledge. Educational values which contribute to quality in learning and teaching environments are those that seek to encourage dialogue, exchange of ideas, intrinsic approaches to study and engagement. It is this that we need to support through networked e-learning. Networked e-learning provides the opportunity for developing innovative assessment practices in which teachers and learners collaborate in the assessment process. Networked e-learning is not a depersonalising experience. The careful integration of course design and innovative assessment can create as intimate an educational experience as a face-to-face encounter. In this paper we look at these statements in more detail in terms of what the ideas behind each of them were and the meaning and relevance of some of the key ideas to the current theory and practice of networked learning. Our approach is to review current thinking sufficiently to highlight issues which the manifesto raises and in addition, to examine these issues from the perspective of an empirical research study of networked learning practice. We have summarised key issues in the final section of the paper as questions which we hope might provide criteria for evaluating how the principles incorporated in the manifesto are reflected in current networked learning theory and in practice. The questions we suggest are: What values and beliefs underlie practice? Are claims to democratic pedagogy justified? What interpretations of ‘community’ are found in use? Do they take account of the social and political processes involved? As tutors, what ideas do we draw on to help make sense of these processes? Do Networked Learning practices support critical reflection and the co-construction of knowledge? Do assessment procedures reflect the same values as are embodied in other aspects of the pedagogy? If there are differences, are they at least acknowledged? Do our pedagogies support space and time for trust and confidence to develop?
- 3 May 2010
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 7, 593-601
Open AccessSymposium 1: Learning, Teaching and Assessment in Networked Learning
The focus of our paper is on Theme 2 of the Networked Learning Manifesto which focused on Learning Teaching and Assessment and stated as follows: Networked e-learning as envisaged in this manifesto requires models of learning that are based on participation and not ones that are based on transmission. This requires as much emphasis on learning processes and learning to learn as on subject knowledge. Educational values which contribute to quality in learning and teaching environments are those that seek to encourage dialogue, exchange of ideas, intrinsic approaches to study and engagement. It is this that we need to support through networked e-learning. Networked e-learning provides the opportunity for developing innovative assessment practices in which teachers and learners collaborate in the assessment process. Networked e-learning is not a depersonalising experience. The careful integration of course design and innovative assessment can create as intimate an educational experience as a face-to-face encounter. In this paper we look at these statements in more detail in terms of what the ideas behind each of them were and the meaning and relevance of some of the key ideas to the current theory and practice of networked learning. Our approach is to review current thinking sufficiently to highlight issues which the manifesto raises and in addition, to examine these issues from the perspective of an empirical research study of networked learning practice. We have summarised key issues in the final section of the paper as questions which we hope might provide criteria for evaluating how the principles incorporated in the manifesto are reflected in current networked learning theory and in practice. The questions we suggest are: What values and beliefs underlie practice? Are claims to democratic pedagogy justified? What interpretations of ‘community’ are found in use? Do they take account of the social and political processes involved? As tutors, what ideas do we draw on to help make sense of these processes? Do Networked Learning practices support critical reflection and the co-construction of knowledge? Do assessment procedures reflect the same values as are embodied in other aspects of the pedagogy? If there are differences, are they at least acknowledged? Do our pedagogies support space and time for trust and confidence to develop?
- Open Access
- 3 May 2010
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 7, 925-931
Symposium 5: Athenian Democracy & Networked Learning Communities
The Athenian democracy is worthy of study if for no other reason than that it was inspiration for many academic fields. This project highlights some institutions and policies of the Athenian democracy, during its flowering in the fifth and fourth centuries BC, in order to interpret them for the benefits of networked learning communities. Concepts such as ephebes and the power of reward can be applied to both the ancient and digital era, without implying an exact parallel. New members (ephebes) need training to create their e-portfolios, acquire digital literacy and epistemic fluency to be eligible to contribute to and benefit from community management. Discussion forums could be an arena for dialogue and information exchange. Allocating labor, e-community managers could fulfill the potential of technology-enhanced learning and tutors would able to select and distribute resources that could be useful and applicable. Praxis and democratic ideals are mirrored in the framework of an economy of knowledge. Epistemologically speaking, an economy of knowledge can be seen as a theory for acquiring the full benefits and costs of coming to know and use knowledge. This theory of knowledge could be a core concept in network learning. This theory does not presume full knowledge, but it does presume democratic social construction of knowledge. On ontological grounds, subjectivity implies that there are always some alternative constructions available to choose from in dealing with the world. The reliability of democracy increases as different points of views transformed into a socially ‘agreed’ way of interaction and participation. The dark side of democracy more closely related to NL communities could shade mainly the ideas of irrational decision, monoculture (single, homogeneous culture without diversity) and demagogy. To illuminate dark corners of democratic e-communities, a form of ‘aristocratic democracy’ is used as a metaphor for the social regime. The term, aristocracy, in the Greek sense of the word, means that the best rules in every domain. To top it all, cultural pluralism could light democratic e-communities, with creativity or conflict that can promote critical thinking and dialogue.Praxis and further research are required to test the validity of the theory presented.
- 3 May 2010
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 7, 925-931
Open AccessSymposium 5: Athenian Democracy & Networked Learning Communities
The Athenian democracy is worthy of study if for no other reason than that it was inspiration for many academic fields. This project highlights some institutions and policies of the Athenian democracy, during its flowering in the fifth and fourth centuries BC, in order to interpret them for the benefits of networked learning communities. Concepts such as ephebes and the power of reward can be applied to both the ancient and digital era, without implying an exact parallel. New members (ephebes) need training to create their e-portfolios, acquire digital literacy and epistemic fluency to be eligible to contribute to and benefit from community management. Discussion forums could be an arena for dialogue and information exchange. Allocating labor, e-community managers could fulfill the potential of technology-enhanced learning and tutors would able to select and distribute resources that could be useful and applicable. Praxis and democratic ideals are mirrored in the framework of an economy of knowledge. Epistemologically speaking, an economy of knowledge can be seen as a theory for acquiring the full benefits and costs of coming to know and use knowledge. This theory of knowledge could be a core concept in network learning. This theory does not presume full knowledge, but it does presume democratic social construction of knowledge. On ontological grounds, subjectivity implies that there are always some alternative constructions available to choose from in dealing with the world. The reliability of democracy increases as different points of views transformed into a socially ‘agreed’ way of interaction and participation. The dark side of democracy more closely related to NL communities could shade mainly the ideas of irrational decision, monoculture (single, homogeneous culture without diversity) and demagogy. To illuminate dark corners of democratic e-communities, a form of ‘aristocratic democracy’ is used as a metaphor for the social regime. The term, aristocracy, in the Greek sense of the word, means that the best rules in every domain. To top it all, cultural pluralism could light democratic e-communities, with creativity or conflict that can promote critical thinking and dialogue.Praxis and further research are required to test the validity of the theory presented.
- 27 August 2009
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 40 (4) , 387-392
Wild Frontiers—Reflections on Experiential Learning
Experiential learning is currently prominent in management—including ‘critical’ management, pedagogy. This article reflects on the contribution of experiential learning to management education and on the resistance it has sometimes evoked, both from academics and managers. On the basis of these observations I suggest that the significance of experiential learning is not only as an alternative way of learning but in the social and political values that it brings to both educational and organizational contexts. In view of recent post-heroic developments in conceptions of leadership, I speculate that there could be currently a better match between experiential learning approaches and organizational practice than had previously been the case.
- 27 August 2009
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 40 (4) , 387-392
Wild Frontiers—Reflections on Experiential Learning
Experiential learning is currently prominent in management—including ‘critical’ management, pedagogy. This article reflects on the contribution of experiential learning to management education and on the resistance it has sometimes evoked, both from academics and managers. On the basis of these observations I suggest that the significance of experiential learning is not only as an alternative way of learning but in the social and political values that it brings to both educational and organizational contexts. In view of recent post-heroic developments in conceptions of leadership, I speculate that there could be currently a better match between experiential learning approaches and organizational practice than had previously been the case.
- Open Access
- 5 May 2008
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 6, 727-735
Symposium 4: Perspectives on the International student experience: a review
There is currently considerable interest in understanding international students’ experience of higher education in English speaking settings and the increase in numbers of students visiting the UK for undergraduate and postgraduate education has made tutors more aware of the problems they and their students encounter – from dealing with language to adjusting to different educational and social customs. A particular aspect of this interest is the interconnection between the international classroom and the application of participative methods in that the increased interaction such methods involve make difference of any kind more significant. This interconnection between difference – whether of gender, nationality, culture – and participative educational methodology - is equally important for us to understand in the context of Networked Learning, especially when it draws on pedagogical traditions with an emphasis on learning as ‘collaborative’, ‘cooperative’, or invokes the concept of ‘community’. The application of these methods usually involves a less directive role for the tutor and a more involving experience for the student. As a consequence, there will be a greater range of possibilities for cultural differences to play a part. However there is a further link. Our ingenuity in designing participative approaches in higher education – including those involving international student groups - may have outrun our understanding of the social and cultural complexities which characterise them. The aim of this paper is to review attempts to research tutors’ and students’ experiences of multinational programmes in order to identify the perspectives which would seem to offer most to those of us who work with international groups of students – including in a networked learning environment. So for example, some authors take a psychological position as a way of understanding students’ responses of frustration, confusion and anxiety when faced with unfamiliar pedagogical approaches or focus on purely educational aspects such as student performance, language difficulties or the impact of stereotypes. Other authors emphasise the interconnectedness of psychological phenomena with social and cultural contexts and important differences - whether as regards gender, religion or politics or place even more emphasis on students’ experience as constructed from social and cultural differences, and of understanding classroom experience as society in microcosm. In an approach that is similar to the one taken in this paper, Archer and Francis have proposed a framework which acknowledges the different perspectives used in addressing the multi-national classroom and argued that these do not simply represent different but equally acceptable alternatives, but that differences are significant in that they predispose educationalists to quite different responses, socially and politically. Archer and Francis propose distinct discourses which can be seen as responses to diversity: for example a compensatory response – as when implicitly positioning students as needing help to conform to the ‘home’ behaviour norms; or multicultural – as when celebrating or subjugating cultural differences in the interests of establishing a collaborative learning environment. The central theme of this paper will be to establish not simply the range of perspectives employed, but to examine whether some are more appropriate in informing our understanding of working with multinational student groups, particularly in a learning environment informed by cooperative principles. As a corollary the paper will consider whether some approaches are – at least if used exclusively – inappropriate, in that they view complex social events through a psychologistic lens.
- 5 May 2008
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 6, 727-735
Open AccessSymposium 4: Perspectives on the International student experience: a review
There is currently considerable interest in understanding international students’ experience of higher education in English speaking settings and the increase in numbers of students visiting the UK for undergraduate and postgraduate education has made tutors more aware of the problems they and their students encounter – from dealing with language to adjusting to different educational and social customs. A particular aspect of this interest is the interconnection between the international classroom and the application of participative methods in that the increased interaction such methods involve make difference of any kind more significant. This interconnection between difference – whether of gender, nationality, culture – and participative educational methodology - is equally important for us to understand in the context of Networked Learning, especially when it draws on pedagogical traditions with an emphasis on learning as ‘collaborative’, ‘cooperative’, or invokes the concept of ‘community’. The application of these methods usually involves a less directive role for the tutor and a more involving experience for the student. As a consequence, there will be a greater range of possibilities for cultural differences to play a part. However there is a further link. Our ingenuity in designing participative approaches in higher education – including those involving international student groups - may have outrun our understanding of the social and cultural complexities which characterise them. The aim of this paper is to review attempts to research tutors’ and students’ experiences of multinational programmes in order to identify the perspectives which would seem to offer most to those of us who work with international groups of students – including in a networked learning environment. So for example, some authors take a psychological position as a way of understanding students’ responses of frustration, confusion and anxiety when faced with unfamiliar pedagogical approaches or focus on purely educational aspects such as student performance, language difficulties or the impact of stereotypes. Other authors emphasise the interconnectedness of psychological phenomena with social and cultural contexts and important differences - whether as regards gender, religion or politics or place even more emphasis on students’ experience as constructed from social and cultural differences, and of understanding classroom experience as society in microcosm. In an approach that is similar to the one taken in this paper, Archer and Francis have proposed a framework which acknowledges the different perspectives used in addressing the multi-national classroom and argued that these do not simply represent different but equally acceptable alternatives, but that differences are significant in that they predispose educationalists to quite different responses, socially and politically. Archer and Francis propose distinct discourses which can be seen as responses to diversity: for example a compensatory response – as when implicitly positioning students as needing help to conform to the ‘home’ behaviour norms; or multicultural – as when celebrating or subjugating cultural differences in the interests of establishing a collaborative learning environment. The central theme of this paper will be to establish not simply the range of perspectives employed, but to examine whether some are more appropriate in informing our understanding of working with multinational student groups, particularly in a learning environment informed by cooperative principles. As a corollary the paper will consider whether some approaches are – at least if used exclusively – inappropriate, in that they view complex social events through a psychologistic lens.
- Open Access
- 5 April 2004
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 4, 254-260
Symposium 10: A Critique of Participative Discourses Adopted in Networked Learning
The predominant discourse of e-learning is frequently focused on the adoption of participative learning approaches involving co-operation, collaboration and peer assessment incorporating implied principles of democracy and ‘community’. There are tensions in the practical application of these features, particularly in relation to working with ‘difference' when comparing the underlying course philosophy with student experience of such courses. There is an implicit assumption that being participative means sharing control but what, in practice, does this entail for the students? Different interpretations of participative approaches will be identified (pedagogical, ideological or both) and an illustrative case discussed in which the principle of participation was applied to the design and assessment of assignments.
- 5 April 2004
- Published by Aalborg University in Networked Learning Conference
- Vol. 4, 254-260
Open AccessSymposium 10: A Critique of Participative Discourses Adopted in Networked Learning
The predominant discourse of e-learning is frequently focused on the adoption of participative learning approaches involving co-operation, collaboration and peer assessment incorporating implied principles of democracy and ‘community’. There are tensions in the practical application of these features, particularly in relation to working with ‘difference' when comparing the underlying course philosophy with student experience of such courses. There is an implicit assumption that being participative means sharing control but what, in practice, does this entail for the students? Different interpretations of participative approaches will be identified (pedagogical, ideological or both) and an illustrative case discussed in which the principle of participation was applied to the design and assessment of assignments.
- 1 March 2000
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 31 (1) , 67-81
Bright Lights and the Pastoral Idyll
The idea of community underlies much of the more participative, if not experiential, approaches to management education and development. More recently the idea has entered the conceptual vocabulary of the `learning organization'. The appeal of community lies in its implied promise of solidarity, belonging, and a sense of personal significance. But these promises can mask darker tendencies towards coercion and the assimilation of differences. This article offers a critique of the notion of community. It proposes an alternative basis for a management pedagogy in which differences are the grounds for debate, dispute and understanding, rather than the reason for assimilation or exclusion.
- 1 March 2000
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 31 (1) , 67-81
Bright Lights and the Pastoral Idyll
The idea of community underlies much of the more participative, if not experiential, approaches to management education and development. More recently the idea has entered the conceptual vocabulary of the `learning organization'. The appeal of community lies in its implied promise of solidarity, belonging, and a sense of personal significance. But these promises can mask darker tendencies towards coercion and the assimilation of differences. This article offers a critique of the notion of community. It proposes an alternative basis for a management pedagogy in which differences are the grounds for debate, dispute and understanding, rather than the reason for assimilation or exclusion.
- 1 June 1998
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 29 (2) , 183-200
Reflection and Critical Reflection in Management Learning
There is growing interest in Management Learning literature in a more critical perspective than has usually been the case in either management education or management development. This article contrasts the concept of critical reflection-drawing on the work of critical theorists in adult education-with the more familiar concept of `reflection'. In proposing how the principles of critical reflection might be applied to management education practice, the distinction is made between educational content (the curriculum) and educational process (methods and structures), drawing attention to the need to consider both in the development of a `critical' management pedagogy.
- 1 June 1998
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 29 (2) , 183-200
Reflection and Critical Reflection in Management Learning
There is growing interest in Management Learning literature in a more critical perspective than has usually been the case in either management education or management development. This article contrasts the concept of critical reflection-drawing on the work of critical theorists in adult education-with the more familiar concept of `reflection'. In proposing how the principles of critical reflection might be applied to management education practice, the distinction is made between educational content (the curriculum) and educational process (methods and structures), drawing attention to the need to consider both in the development of a `critical' management pedagogy.
- 1 June 1997
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 28 (2) , 115-133
Learning Styles: A Critique
The concept of `learning style' is virtually taken for granted in management development, in spite of considerable doubts about its validity from within cognitive psychology and education. The first part of this paper summarizes research that is critical of `learning styles', particularly in the form which predominates within management development and introduces the alternative concept of learning strategy, which is rarely encountered in this field. The second part of the paper develops a critique of learning style theory from a critical education perspective, raising even more significant concerns that in decontextualizing learning the concept of style may provide a discriminatory basis for dealing with difference in gender or race.
- 1 June 1997
- Published by SAGE Publications in Management Learning
- Vol. 28 (2) , 115-133
Learning Styles: A Critique
The concept of `learning style' is virtually taken for granted in management development, in spite of considerable doubts about its validity from within cognitive psychology and education. The first part of this paper summarizes research that is critical of `learning styles', particularly in the form which predominates within management development and introduces the alternative concept of learning strategy, which is rarely encountered in this field. The second part of the paper develops a critique of learning style theory from a critical education perspective, raising even more significant concerns that in decontextualizing learning the concept of style may provide a discriminatory basis for dealing with difference in gender or race.