MCMichael Calnan

Michael Calnan

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Michael Calnan has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The fall of work stress and the rise of wellbeing

    by David Wainwright, Michael Calnan


  • The fall of work stress and the rise of wellbeing

    by David Wainwright, Michael Calnan

    This chapter seeks to deconstruct the notion of stress. The discourse of work stress is collapsing under the weight of its own conceptual and methodological contradictions, only to be replaced by a new discourse of wellbeing. Much of the work-stress literature adopts a positivist epidemiological standpoint that sees stress as a response to ‘objective’ job characteristics, such as demands, control or support. As such, it fails to recognise the multi-factorial nature of mental health or the role of subjective appraisal in mediating the stress response, and is therefore unable to explain why individuals in objectively similar jobs report radically different levels of stress, or why the stress epidemic emerged at a time when work was arguably substantially less demanding than in earlier times. Interventions based on the work-stress model have spectacularly failed to reduce the incidence of work stress or the number of working days lost because of it, despite a major campaign by the HSE since 2001. Various attempts to overcome the limitations of the work-stress concept by empirical innovation have not proven successful.


  • What the doctor ordered: the Audit Commission's case study of general practice fundholders

    by David Wainwright, Michael Calnan

    General Practitioner (GP) fundholding originated in the belief that a quasi-market mechanism would lead to the more efficient and effective use of health care resources. The model was implemented and abandoned without formal recourse to evaluation or the evidence base. This chapter elucidates what can be learned from the past by taking the fundholding initiative of the 1990s as a case study. The Audit Commission's report emerged as the most extensive and systematic attempt to appraise the model. The authors have also broadened the case study to include evidence from other studies and consideration of the impact this evidence has had on policy.


  • Retracted

    Illness action rediscovered: a case study of upper limb pain

    by M. Calnan, D. Wainwright, C. O’neill, A. Winterbottom, C. Watkins

    Theoretical frameworks provide generalised accounts of illness action although empirical studies of the process are still in short supply. This study of upper limb pain provided a case study of illness action; as it is a common condition, there is uncertainty about its treatment and management, orthodox and non-orthodox care are seen as legitimate sources of help and it is linked with a range of causes. Face-to-face informal interviews were carried out with 47 informants with upper limb pain and their practitioners (n=19). The data were analysed in two different ways. The general stages of the illness action process were identified through a descriptive analysis of the upper limb pain sufferers' accounts and the policies and practices reported by their practitioners. Then, case studies were constructed to depict individual pathways through healthcare and consequences for sufferers. The illness action process was characterised by the normalisation and accommodation of pain informed by a discourse that predominantly invoked ageing and the wear and tear of the body. Practitioners also preferred to adopt a biomechanical approach and were reluctant to attribute psychosocial labels. The case studies illustrated the divergent, negotiated and opportunistic nature of the process and showed that the use of both orthodox and non-orthodox care formed only part of strategies used to manage upper limb pain. Sufferers evaluated the care they received in terms of pain alleviation, and were resigned to searching for the best way of living with their pain


  • Researching trust relations in health care

    by Michael Calnan, Rosemary Rowe

    Purpose – The aim of this paper is to provide a rationale for examining trust in health care. Design/methodology/approach – Conducts a review of the literature of trust relations in health care that highlighted that most empirical research has addressed threats to patient-provider relationships and trust in health care systems from the patient's perspective, but studies in the organisational literature suggests that trust relations in the workforce, between providers and between providers and managers, may also influence patient-provider relationships and levels of trust. Findings – Suggests that trust is not primarily dispositional or an individual attribute or psychological state, but is constructed from a set of inter-personal behaviors or from a shared identity. These behaviors are underpinned by sets of institutional rules, laws and customs. Research limitations/implications – This introductory paper has presented some evidence from an international, comparative study but there is the need for further, more detailed investigation into why trust relations may vary in different health care systems. Originality/value – This introductory paper provides a rationale for examining trust in health care and a context for the different elements of trust.


  • Trust relations in health care: an agenda for future research

    by Michael Calnan, Rosemary Rowe, Vikki Entwistle

    Purpose – The aim of this paper is to draw together suggestions for future research from the papers and from the discussion that took place at the workshop. Design/methodology/approach – The suggestions are summarised under four broad themes. Findings – At an international workshop on trust organised by the UK MRC Health Services Research Collaboration there was broad agreement that trust was still a salient issue in diverse health care contexts. The workshop proceedings identified a number of important questions for empirical research and several key conceptual, theoretical and methodological questions relating to trust that need to be addressed in support of or alongside this. The collection of papers in this volume starts to address some of these questions. Originality/value – Considers trust relations in health care from patient, clinical, organisational and policy perspectives.


  • Trust relations in health care: developing a theoretical framework for the “new” NHS

    by Rosemary Rowe, Michael Calnan

    Purpose: This paper seeks to address how and why trust relations in the NHS may be changing and presents a theoretical framework for exploring them in future empirical research.Design/methodology/approach: This paper provides a conceptual analysis. It proposes that public and patient trust in health care in the UK appears to be shaped by a variety of factors. From a macro perspective, any changes in levels of public trust in health care institutions appear to derive partly from top‐down policy initiatives that have altered the way in which health services are organised and partly from broader social and cultural processes. A variety of policy initiatives, including the introduction of clinical governance and the resulting use of performance management to scrutinise and change clinical activity, increasing patient choice and involvement in decision‐making regarding their care, are examined for how they have changed the context for trust relations within the NHS.Findings: It is argued that these policy initiatives have produced a new context for trust relations within the NHS, shifting the inter‐dependence and distribution of power between patients, clinicians, and mangers and changing their vulnerability to each other and to health care institutions. The paper presents a theoretical framework based on current policy discourses which illustrates how new forms of trust relations may be emerging in this new context of health care delivery, reflecting a change in motivations for trust from affect based to cognition based trust as patients, clinicians and managers become more active partners in trust relations. The framework suggests that trust relations in all three types of relationship in the “new” modernised NHS might, in general, be particularly characterised by an emphasis on communication, providing information and the use of “evidence” to support decisions in a reciprocal, negotiated alliance.Originality/value: The paper examines the drivers for change in trust in health care relations in the UK and develops a theoretical framework for the emergence of new trust relations that can be subsequently explored through empirical research.


  • Dignity under Threat? A Study of the Experiences of Older People in the United Kingdom

    by Michael Calnan, David Badcott, Gillian Woolhead

    Theoretical accounts have offered a general understanding of the social significance and importance of dignity and suggest that older age may threaten dignity by structuring and limiting the opportunities for participation and/or social recognition. Micro-sociological research has shown how older people negotiate their identity, in the face of its erosion by the aging body and disability and the domination of health and social care workers. These theoretical approaches inform the study presented here, which explores the meaning and experience of dignity for older people in their daily lives. Older people's accounts were elicited through a series of focus groups with participants living in England and Wales. Participants were selected according to predefined criteria to represent a range of different socioeconomic and ethnic backgrounds, levels of fitness, and home circumstances. Personal identity and autonomy were the aspects of dignity most meaningful to the participants, and discussions tended to focus mainly on when personal identity and autonomy were threatened or violated in the context of the provision of health and social care. The authors discuss the extent to which older people's discourse on dignity resonates with the theoretical discourse.