Gerlese S. Akerlind
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Gerlese S. Akerlind has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Suet Voon Yu
Australian National University, Australia
2 shared publications Kathleen M. Quinlan
1 shared publication- Kathleen M. Quinlan
Centre for the Study of Higher Education, University of Kent
1 shared publication Lynn McAlpine
Oxford Learning Institute, University of Oxford, Littlegate House, 16/17 St Ebbe's Street, Oxford OX1 1PT, UK
1 shared publication- Lynn McAlpine
University of Oxford
1 shared publication Sarah Jenkins
The Australian National University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in International Medical Education
- Vol. 4 (4) , 46
How Different Understandings of the Nature of Medical Practice Can Limit Future Development as a Medical Practitioner
Previous research has shown that medical practitioners’ conceptions of their profession play a significant role in their practice. This study extends that research by investigating ways in which different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ may act to expand or limit the potential for future development as a doctor. Based on previous research that identified different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ and ‘developing as a doctor’, a chi-square test of association between the two sets of conceptions was undertaken and a statistically significant association found. More and less complex conceptions of being a doctor were associated with more and less complex conceptions of developing as a doctor, respectively. This raises the likelihood that conceptions of being a doctor that develop early in one’s career may act to limit the potential for future development. Consequently, the paper recommends that different conceptions of medical practice be addressed as part of medical education. To help with this, the paper describes an innovative educational design based on the ‘variation theory of learning’ proposed within a phenomenographic epistemology. The educational design is specifically intended to help trainees become aware of elements of practice and development that they have not previously discerned.
- 8 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in International Medical Education
- Vol. 4 (4) , 46
Open AccessHow Different Understandings of the Nature of Medical Practice Can Limit Future Development as a Medical Practitioner
Previous research has shown that medical practitioners’ conceptions of their profession play a significant role in their practice. This study extends that research by investigating ways in which different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ may act to expand or limit the potential for future development as a doctor. Based on previous research that identified different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ and ‘developing as a doctor’, a chi-square test of association between the two sets of conceptions was undertaken and a statistically significant association found. More and less complex conceptions of being a doctor were associated with more and less complex conceptions of developing as a doctor, respectively. This raises the likelihood that conceptions of being a doctor that develop early in one’s career may act to limit the potential for future development. Consequently, the paper recommends that different conceptions of medical practice be addressed as part of medical education. To help with this, the paper describes an innovative educational design based on the ‘variation theory of learning’ proposed within a phenomenographic epistemology. The educational design is specifically intended to help trainees become aware of elements of practice and development that they have not previously discerned.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
How Different Understandings of the Nature of Medical Practice Can Limit Future Development as a Medical Practitioner
Previous research has shown that medical practitioners’ conceptions of their profession play a significant role in their practice. This study extends that research by investigating ways in which different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ may act to expand or limit the potential for future development as a doctor. Based on previous research that identified different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ and ‘developing as a doctor’, a chi-square test of association between the two sets of conceptions was undertaken and a statistically significant association found. More and less complex conceptions of being a doctor were associated with more and less complex conceptions of developing as a doctor, respectively. This raises the likelihood that conceptions of being a doctor that develop early in one’s career may act to limit the potential for future development. Consequently, the paper recommends that different conceptions of medical practice be addressed as part of medical education. To help with this, the paper describes an innovative educational design based on the ‘variation theory of learning’ proposed within a phenomenographic epistemology. The educational design is specifically intended to help trainees become aware of elements of practice and development that they have not previously discerned.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessHow Different Understandings of the Nature of Medical Practice Can Limit Future Development as a Medical Practitioner
Previous research has shown that medical practitioners’ conceptions of their profession play a significant role in their practice. This study extends that research by investigating ways in which different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ may act to expand or limit the potential for future development as a doctor. Based on previous research that identified different conceptions of ‘being a doctor’ and ‘developing as a doctor’, a chi-square test of association between the two sets of conceptions was undertaken and a statistically significant association found. More and less complex conceptions of being a doctor were associated with more and less complex conceptions of developing as a doctor, respectively. This raises the likelihood that conceptions of being a doctor that develop early in one’s career may act to limit the potential for future development. Consequently, the paper recommends that different conceptions of medical practice be addressed as part of medical education. To help with this, the paper describes an innovative educational design based on the ‘variation theory of learning’ proposed within a phenomenographic epistemology. The educational design is specifically intended to help trainees become aware of elements of practice and development that they have not previously discerned.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 15-34
2. Developments in phenomenography over time
In Chapter 2, I describe how phenomenography has changed and developed over time, grouping developments into four key stages: (1) commencement of phenomenography; (2) clarification of methods; (3) theoretical developments in phenomenography; and (4) phenomenographic practice in the 21st century. In order to make the implications of the changes more meaningful, I present concrete examples in the chapter of different kinds of research questions and outcomes expected at different stages. In introducing terms like 21st-century phenomenography, I want to be clear though that early approaches to phenomenographic research are still recognisably and acceptably phenomenographic; it is just that more sophisticated ways of conducting phenomenographic research are now encouraged.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 15-34
Open Access2. Developments in phenomenography over time
In Chapter 2, I describe how phenomenography has changed and developed over time, grouping developments into four key stages: (1) commencement of phenomenography; (2) clarification of methods; (3) theoretical developments in phenomenography; and (4) phenomenographic practice in the 21st century. In order to make the implications of the changes more meaningful, I present concrete examples in the chapter of different kinds of research questions and outcomes expected at different stages. In introducing terms like 21st-century phenomenography, I want to be clear though that early approaches to phenomenographic research are still recognisably and acceptably phenomenographic; it is just that more sophisticated ways of conducting phenomenographic research are now encouraged.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
Preface
We publish high-quality, open access academic research in the Humanities and Social Sciences. Read all our books for free online.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
Open AccessPreface
We publish high-quality, open access academic research in the Humanities and Social Sciences. Read all our books for free online.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 51-70
4. Variation in understandings of structural relationships in phenomenography
The notion of ‘structure’ and ‘structural relationships’ in phenomenography is perhaps the most distinctive and educationally useful part of the methodology. But it is also the most difficult and commonly misunderstood part. In order to clarify what we need to notice about the phenomenographic notion of structure and structural relationships to develop a sophisticated understanding of it, the phenomenographic study of phenomenography initially described in Chapter 3 continues in this chapter. In Chapter 4, I describe five qualitatively different ways of understanding structural relationships in phenomenography, and discuss associated implications for phenomenographic research practice and outcomes.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 51-70
Open Access4. Variation in understandings of structural relationships in phenomenography
The notion of ‘structure’ and ‘structural relationships’ in phenomenography is perhaps the most distinctive and educationally useful part of the methodology. But it is also the most difficult and commonly misunderstood part. In order to clarify what we need to notice about the phenomenographic notion of structure and structural relationships to develop a sophisticated understanding of it, the phenomenographic study of phenomenography initially described in Chapter 3 continues in this chapter. In Chapter 4, I describe five qualitatively different ways of understanding structural relationships in phenomenography, and discuss associated implications for phenomenographic research practice and outcomes.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 71-90
5. Epistemological assumptions in phenomenography
As described in Chapter 2, phenomenography developed from a research approach that was based on a common object of study in the 1980s, to a research approach with an accompanying set of accepted methods in the 1990s, to a research methodology with associated ontological and epistemological assumptions in the 2000s. This last development was initiated by the publication of Marton and Booth’s (1997) book, Learning and Awareness, in particular. This means that, from the 2000s, anyone who attempts to undertake phenomenographic research simply by applying a set of accepted methods, without an accompanying understanding of the theoretical assumptions underpinning those methods, will be short-changing their research. Chapter 5 describes the key epistemological assumptions put forward in Learning and Awareness, and clarifies how they relate to the methods adopted in phenomenography.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 71-90
Open Access5. Epistemological assumptions in phenomenography
As described in Chapter 2, phenomenography developed from a research approach that was based on a common object of study in the 1980s, to a research approach with an accompanying set of accepted methods in the 1990s, to a research methodology with associated ontological and epistemological assumptions in the 2000s. This last development was initiated by the publication of Marton and Booth’s (1997) book, Learning and Awareness, in particular. This means that, from the 2000s, anyone who attempts to undertake phenomenographic research simply by applying a set of accepted methods, without an accompanying understanding of the theoretical assumptions underpinning those methods, will be short-changing their research. Chapter 5 describes the key epistemological assumptions put forward in Learning and Awareness, and clarifies how they relate to the methods adopted in phenomenography.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 91-132
6. Study design, data gathering and the phenomenographic interview
Interviews are the traditional source of empirical data for phenomenographic research. But the phenomenographic interview is quite distinctive in nature. Phenomenographic interviews have a particular focus on working from concrete examples of participants’ interactions with the phenomenon under investigation, and seeking in-depth reflections from participants on why they interacted with the phenomenon in those particular ways. Participants are not expected to be able to describe their experience of a phenomenon directly, but to demonstrate that experience indirectly, through the ways in which they interact with the phenomenon. This chapter explains the design and conduct of interviews, illustrating the key principles with extended concrete examples from my own and others’ research. Although the focus of the chapter is on interviews, key principles for other forms of phenomenographic data gathering are also clarified.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 91-132
Open Access6. Study design, data gathering and the phenomenographic interview
Interviews are the traditional source of empirical data for phenomenographic research. But the phenomenographic interview is quite distinctive in nature. Phenomenographic interviews have a particular focus on working from concrete examples of participants’ interactions with the phenomenon under investigation, and seeking in-depth reflections from participants on why they interacted with the phenomenon in those particular ways. Participants are not expected to be able to describe their experience of a phenomenon directly, but to demonstrate that experience indirectly, through the ways in which they interact with the phenomenon. This chapter explains the design and conduct of interviews, illustrating the key principles with extended concrete examples from my own and others’ research. Although the focus of the chapter is on interviews, key principles for other forms of phenomenographic data gathering are also clarified.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 249-262
10. Phenomenography and collective awareness
Phenomenography initially commenced as a distinctive research approach based on two primary goals: to improve our understanding of learning from the students’ perspective; and to describe humanity’s collective awareness of different phenomena in the world. To date, the majority of phenomenographic research has focused on the former, educational goal. This means that the potential of research based on the second goal, investigating collective understanding of socially significant phenomena, has been underdeveloped. This forms the focus of this final chapter in the book. I start by unpacking the ongoing interest in collective awareness throughout the history of phenomenography, with examples of where phenomenographic research has been used outside of education. To help envisage the ways in which phenomenographic research might integrate with other social science research, I also outline phenomenography’s implicit position on the socially-mediated nature of human experience, and present a number of examples of studies that have integrated phenomenographic research with social and practice theories. The chapter is forward looking, with the aim of encouraging future research into collective awareness of phenomena within specific socially, culturally and historically situated groups, using phenomenographic methods.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 249-262
Open Access10. Phenomenography and collective awareness
Phenomenography initially commenced as a distinctive research approach based on two primary goals: to improve our understanding of learning from the students’ perspective; and to describe humanity’s collective awareness of different phenomena in the world. To date, the majority of phenomenographic research has focused on the former, educational goal. This means that the potential of research based on the second goal, investigating collective understanding of socially significant phenomena, has been underdeveloped. This forms the focus of this final chapter in the book. I start by unpacking the ongoing interest in collective awareness throughout the history of phenomenography, with examples of where phenomenographic research has been used outside of education. To help envisage the ways in which phenomenographic research might integrate with other social science research, I also outline phenomenography’s implicit position on the socially-mediated nature of human experience, and present a number of examples of studies that have integrated phenomenographic research with social and practice theories. The chapter is forward looking, with the aim of encouraging future research into collective awareness of phenomena within specific socially, culturally and historically situated groups, using phenomenographic methods.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 211-248
9. Phenomenography and variation theory
The epistemological assumptions outlined in Learning and Awareness also led to a theory of learning, called ‘variation theory’. This has been of great value to educational research and development, and has led to its own strand of applied research and practice based on pedagogical applications of variation theory in the classroom and in teacher education and development. Whilst variation theory research is often not strictly phenomenographic, they may be usefully applied together and complement each other in numerous ways. This chapter describes how the variation theory tradition developed during the 2000s, and outlines its ongoing relationship with phenomenography.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 211-248
Open Access9. Phenomenography and variation theory
The epistemological assumptions outlined in Learning and Awareness also led to a theory of learning, called ‘variation theory’. This has been of great value to educational research and development, and has led to its own strand of applied research and practice based on pedagogical applications of variation theory in the classroom and in teacher education and development. Whilst variation theory research is often not strictly phenomenographic, they may be usefully applied together and complement each other in numerous ways. This chapter describes how the variation theory tradition developed during the 2000s, and outlines its ongoing relationship with phenomenography.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 183-210
8. Adding further structure to the outcome space
A key indicator of phenomenography in the 21st century is the constitution of ‘dimensions of variation’ and associated ‘critical aspects’ in experience of phenomena. However, two ways of identifying and describing dimensions and critical aspects have emerged in the literature. In the traditional approach, dimensions of variation (and thus critical aspects) are constituted independently of each other. In the alternative approach, dimensions of variation (and thus critical aspects) are constituted in a structurally related way along common themes of meaning, called ‘themes of expanding awareness’. This adds additional structural complexity to the constitution of critical aspects of phenomena. This chapter clarifies the difference between the two approaches, provides concrete illustrations of the research outcomes that result from the two approaches, and discusses the different insights that each approach provides to our understanding of critical aspects of human experience.
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 183-210
Open Access8. Adding further structure to the outcome space
A key indicator of phenomenography in the 21st century is the constitution of ‘dimensions of variation’ and associated ‘critical aspects’ in experience of phenomena. However, two ways of identifying and describing dimensions and critical aspects have emerged in the literature. In the traditional approach, dimensions of variation (and thus critical aspects) are constituted independently of each other. In the alternative approach, dimensions of variation (and thus critical aspects) are constituted in a structurally related way along common themes of meaning, called ‘themes of expanding awareness’. This adds additional structural complexity to the constitution of critical aspects of phenomena. This chapter clarifies the difference between the two approaches, provides concrete illustrations of the research outcomes that result from the two approaches, and discusses the different insights that each approach provides to our understanding of critical aspects of human experience.