Frances Hines
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Frances Hines has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gillian Bristow
School of Geography and Planning, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
2 shared publications - Steve Martin
Cardiff University
2 shared publications - Tom Entwistle
Cardiff Business School, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
2 shared publications Otilia Marin
1 shared publication- Sophie Donaldson
School of City and Regional Planning, Cardiff University, Glamorgan Building, King Edward V Avenue, Cardiff, CF10 3WA, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 17 December 2008
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 32 (4) , 903-921
New Spaces for Inclusion? Lessons from the ‘Three‐Thirds’ Partnerships in Wales
Multi‐sector partnership working has become an increasingly important mode of governance across many Western European countries. It is seen as a means of overcoming social divisions, promoting more inclusive policymaking, and transforming governance systems. Partnership is perceived to be a more flexible form of governance, capable of resolving some of the complex policy and legitimation problems associated with more traditional statist approaches, and thus preferable for the delivery of public policy and services. However, as previous research has shown, there is an emerging ‘partnership crisis’ with partnerships often failing to be sufficiently inclusive of representative interests, leading to a lack of legitimacy, equity and effectiveness. This article explores the unique approach to addressing the lack of balanced and effective representation in partnerships developed by the Welsh Assembly Government. The Assembly has adopted a formal approach to structuring key partnerships on the basis of strict equality of representation across the public, private and voluntary sectors — the so‐called ‘three‐thirds principle’. This approach is conceptualized as a form of metagovernance whereby formal influence over partnership structures is being used in an effort to create institutional spaces for inclusion. The analysis indicates that while such network design does achieve improvement in partnership legitimacy, on its own it does not increase partnership effectiveness which remains constrained by the prevailing emphasis upon narrow, managerialist implementation agendas.Résumé: Le partenariat plurisectoriel est devenu un mode de gouvernance de plus en plus important dans de nombreux pays d'Europe de l'Ouest. Il apparaît comme un moyen de surmonter les divisions sociales, de favoriser une élaboration plus diversifiée des politiques et de transformer les systèmes de gouvernance. Le partenariat est perçu comme une forme plus souple de gouvernance, capable de résoudre certains des problèmes complexes de politique publique et de légitimité associés à des approches étatistes plus traditionnelles, donc préférable pour la mise en place des politiques et des services publics. Pourtant, une étude antérieure l'a montré, il se dessine une ‘crise du partenariat’, ce fonctionnement ne parvenant souvent pas à intégrer suffisamment les groupes d'intérêt représentatifs et conduisant à un défaut de légitimité, d'équité et d'efficacité. L'article étudie l'approche unique du gouvernement gallois pour traiter l'absence d'équilibre représentatif et d'efficacité dans les partenariats. Une démarche officielle a été adoptée pour structurer les partenariats‐clés sur la base d'une stricte égalité représentative entre les secteurs public, privé et associatifs, selon le principe dit des ‘trois tiers’. Le concept est une forme de méta‐gouvernance par laquelle une influence s'exerce formellement sur les structures de partenariat afin de créer des espaces institutionnalisés permettant l'inclusion. L'analyse indique que, si ce concept en réseau réussit bien à améliorer la légitimité des partenariats, à lui seul il n'accroît pas leur efficacité, laquelle reste dépendante de la prépondérance courante de programmes de mise en oeuvre limités et ‘managérialistes’.
- 17 December 2008
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 32 (4) , 903-921
New Spaces for Inclusion? Lessons from the ‘Three‐Thirds’ Partnerships in Wales
Multi‐sector partnership working has become an increasingly important mode of governance across many Western European countries. It is seen as a means of overcoming social divisions, promoting more inclusive policymaking, and transforming governance systems. Partnership is perceived to be a more flexible form of governance, capable of resolving some of the complex policy and legitimation problems associated with more traditional statist approaches, and thus preferable for the delivery of public policy and services. However, as previous research has shown, there is an emerging ‘partnership crisis’ with partnerships often failing to be sufficiently inclusive of representative interests, leading to a lack of legitimacy, equity and effectiveness. This article explores the unique approach to addressing the lack of balanced and effective representation in partnerships developed by the Welsh Assembly Government. The Assembly has adopted a formal approach to structuring key partnerships on the basis of strict equality of representation across the public, private and voluntary sectors — the so‐called ‘three‐thirds principle’. This approach is conceptualized as a form of metagovernance whereby formal influence over partnership structures is being used in an effort to create institutional spaces for inclusion. The analysis indicates that while such network design does achieve improvement in partnership legitimacy, on its own it does not increase partnership effectiveness which remains constrained by the prevailing emphasis upon narrow, managerialist implementation agendas.Résumé: Le partenariat plurisectoriel est devenu un mode de gouvernance de plus en plus important dans de nombreux pays d'Europe de l'Ouest. Il apparaît comme un moyen de surmonter les divisions sociales, de favoriser une élaboration plus diversifiée des politiques et de transformer les systèmes de gouvernance. Le partenariat est perçu comme une forme plus souple de gouvernance, capable de résoudre certains des problèmes complexes de politique publique et de légitimité associés à des approches étatistes plus traditionnelles, donc préférable pour la mise en place des politiques et des services publics. Pourtant, une étude antérieure l'a montré, il se dessine une ‘crise du partenariat’, ce fonctionnement ne parvenant souvent pas à intégrer suffisamment les groupes d'intérêt représentatifs et conduisant à un défaut de légitimité, d'équité et d'efficacité. L'article étudie l'approche unique du gouvernement gallois pour traiter l'absence d'équilibre représentatif et d'efficacité dans les partenariats. Une démarche officielle a été adoptée pour structurer les partenariats‐clés sur la base d'une stricte égalité représentative entre les secteurs public, privé et associatifs, selon le principe dit des ‘trois tiers’. Le concept est une forme de méta‐gouvernance par laquelle une influence s'exerce formellement sur les structures de partenariat afin de créer des espaces institutionnalisés permettant l'inclusion. L'analyse indique que, si ce concept en réseau réussit bien à améliorer la légitimité des partenariats, à lui seul il n'accroît pas leur efficacité, laquelle reste dépendante de la prépondérance courante de programmes de mise en oeuvre limités et ‘managérialistes’.
- 5 June 2007
- Published by Wiley in Business Strategy and the Environment
- Vol. 16 (5) , 319-321
Editorial
- 5 June 2007
- Published by Wiley in Business Strategy and the Environment
- Vol. 16 (5) , 319-321
Editorial
- 1 January 2007
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 44 (1) , 63-79
The Dysfunctions of Markets, Hierarchies and Networks in the Meta-governance of Partnership
Governments increasingly see partnerships as their delivery instrument of choice. There is disagreement, however, about how the proliferation of these institutions should be understood. One interpretation sees ungovernability, instability and unaccountability in the fragmented institutions of local governance. Another maintains that the new approaches to co-ordination have allowed for the reassertion of hierarchical control. On the basis of a theoretical exposition of the logic of co-ordination and a study of 10 partnerships in Wales, this paper presents evidence which suggests that partnerships suffer principally from the dysfunctional effects of hierarchical and market co-ordination.
- 1 January 2007
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 44 (1) , 63-79
The Dysfunctions of Markets, Hierarchies and Networks in the Meta-governance of Partnership
Governments increasingly see partnerships as their delivery instrument of choice. There is disagreement, however, about how the proliferation of these institutions should be understood. One interpretation sees ungovernability, instability and unaccountability in the fragmented institutions of local governance. Another maintains that the new approaches to co-ordination have allowed for the reassertion of hierarchical control. On the basis of a theoretical exposition of the logic of co-ordination and a study of 10 partnerships in Wales, this paper presents evidence which suggests that partnerships suffer principally from the dysfunctional effects of hierarchical and market co-ordination.
- 13 July 2004
- Published by Wiley in Business Strategy and the Environment
- Vol. 13 (4) , 201-208
Building innovations for sustainability: 11th international conference of the Greening of Industry Network
- 13 July 2004
- Published by Wiley in Business Strategy and the Environment
- Vol. 13 (4) , 201-208
Building innovations for sustainability: 11th international conference of the Greening of Industry Network