Ann Bradshaw
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Ann Bradshaw has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Clair Merriman
1 shared publicationLynda Price
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 8 June 2015
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 23 (1) , 78-85
An analysis of England's nursing policy on compassion and the 6Cs: the hidden presence of M. Simone Roach's model of caring
In 2012, chief nursing officers (CNO) in England published a policy on compassion in response to serious criticisms of patients’ care. Because their objective is fundamentally to shape nursing, this study argues, following Popper, that the policy should be analysed. An appraisal tool, developed from Popper, Gadamer, Jauss and Thiselton, is the framework for this analysis. The CNO policy document identified six values and behaviours, termed ‘6Cs’, required by all nurses, midwives and care staff. The document contains no data, references or acknowledgements, but is similar to the 6Cs defined by the Canadian nursing nun, Sister M. Simone Roach, in her theory of caring published 30 years earlier. Roach considered caring and the components of it, including compassion, to be moral virtues, an inner motivation to care. This study suggests that without explicit reference to Roach's ideas, and her underlying theoretical base, the CNO requirement has the effect of turning virtues into commodities and a form of external control, described by Ritzer as a McDonaldized dehumanization. This study, which has international relevance beyond England and the UK, suggests that the CNO revise their policy by acknowledging Roach's 6Cs and openly discuss the implications of her work for their policy.
- 8 June 2015
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 23 (1) , 78-85
An analysis of England's nursing policy on compassion and the 6Cs: the hidden presence of M. Simone Roach's model of caring
In 2012, chief nursing officers (CNO) in England published a policy on compassion in response to serious criticisms of patients’ care. Because their objective is fundamentally to shape nursing, this study argues, following Popper, that the policy should be analysed. An appraisal tool, developed from Popper, Gadamer, Jauss and Thiselton, is the framework for this analysis. The CNO policy document identified six values and behaviours, termed ‘6Cs’, required by all nurses, midwives and care staff. The document contains no data, references or acknowledgements, but is similar to the 6Cs defined by the Canadian nursing nun, Sister M. Simone Roach, in her theory of caring published 30 years earlier. Roach considered caring and the components of it, including compassion, to be moral virtues, an inner motivation to care. This study suggests that without explicit reference to Roach's ideas, and her underlying theoretical base, the CNO requirement has the effect of turning virtues into commodities and a form of external control, described by Ritzer as a McDonaldized dehumanization. This study, which has international relevance beyond England and the UK, suggests that the CNO revise their policy by acknowledging Roach's 6Cs and openly discuss the implications of her work for their policy.
- 23 June 2014
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 22 (1) , 74-83
Shaping the future of nursing: developing an appraisal framework for public engagement with nursing policy reports
It is accepted that research should be systematically examined to judge its trustworthiness and value in a particular context. No such appraisal is required of reports published by organizations that have possibly even greater influence on policy that affects the public. This paper explores a philosophical framework for appraising reports. It gives the reasons why informed engagement is important, drawing on Popper's concept of the open society, and it suggests a method for appraisal. Gadamer's concept of the two horizons and Jauss's reception theory offer a methodological framework to enable the individual citizen, whether professional or lay, to engage in debate about policy that affects him or her. By way of a worked example, the framework is applied to two international reports on nursing. Conclusions suggest that nursing policy should be subjected to robust interrogatory appraisal by both profession and public for a democratic debate and creative discourse. Although this analysis is related to international nursing policy, it has a wider relevance and application beyond nursing.
- 23 June 2014
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 22 (1) , 74-83
Shaping the future of nursing: developing an appraisal framework for public engagement with nursing policy reports
It is accepted that research should be systematically examined to judge its trustworthiness and value in a particular context. No such appraisal is required of reports published by organizations that have possibly even greater influence on policy that affects the public. This paper explores a philosophical framework for appraising reports. It gives the reasons why informed engagement is important, drawing on Popper's concept of the open society, and it suggests a method for appraisal. Gadamer's concept of the two horizons and Jauss's reception theory offer a methodological framework to enable the individual citizen, whether professional or lay, to engage in debate about policy that affects him or her. By way of a worked example, the framework is applied to two international reports on nursing. Conclusions suggest that nursing policy should be subjected to robust interrogatory appraisal by both profession and public for a democratic debate and creative discourse. Although this analysis is related to international nursing policy, it has a wider relevance and application beyond nursing.
- 19 May 2013
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 70 (1) , 60-67
Listening to the patient's self‐reported testimony: the authentic hermeneutical witness to the compassionate nurse?
Aim: This paper considers whether the patient's self‐reported testimony of nursing care provides an authentic basis for nursing knowledge. An international nursing and philosophical literature gives international relevance.Background: United Kingdom reports detail patients' complaints about nursing care. Many are personal self‐reported testimonies published in the media, but discounted by the nursing profession.Design: Discussion paper.Data Sources: Data sources 1873–2012 include policy documents, nursing studies involving grounded theory, phenomenology and narrative inquiry, nursing textbooks 1882–1971 and the interpretive paradigms of Glaser and Strauss, Heidegger, Ricoeur and Gadamer.Discussion: Nursing researchers use qualitative methodologies to understand the patient's experience of nursing. Three exemplars reveal epistemological and ontological problems. Epistemologically, researchers are controlling data, their selection and interpretation. Ontologically, the researcher's present horizon dominates because no consideration is given to the historical horizon and context where the tradition of nursing developed and defined the nurse. Arguably, patients' expectations of compassionate nurses bear witness to this past horizon.Implications for Nursing: Patients' self‐reported testimonies should be taken seriously as an evidence base for understanding and improving nursing care. Nursing researchers using qualitative methods should be transparent about their pre‐judgements. Connections with the past horizon of nursing history should be made to cast light on the present horizon.Conclusion: Patients' self‐reported testimonies are more congruent with methods of narrative inquiry than data solicited and filtered by the interviewer's undeclared pre‐judgement. They bear witness to the horizon of the past and the meaning and purpose of nursing, its values and ethos.
- 19 May 2013
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 70 (1) , 60-67
Listening to the patient's self‐reported testimony: the authentic hermeneutical witness to the compassionate nurse?
Aim: This paper considers whether the patient's self‐reported testimony of nursing care provides an authentic basis for nursing knowledge. An international nursing and philosophical literature gives international relevance.Background: United Kingdom reports detail patients' complaints about nursing care. Many are personal self‐reported testimonies published in the media, but discounted by the nursing profession.Design: Discussion paper.Data Sources: Data sources 1873–2012 include policy documents, nursing studies involving grounded theory, phenomenology and narrative inquiry, nursing textbooks 1882–1971 and the interpretive paradigms of Glaser and Strauss, Heidegger, Ricoeur and Gadamer.Discussion: Nursing researchers use qualitative methodologies to understand the patient's experience of nursing. Three exemplars reveal epistemological and ontological problems. Epistemologically, researchers are controlling data, their selection and interpretation. Ontologically, the researcher's present horizon dominates because no consideration is given to the historical horizon and context where the tradition of nursing developed and defined the nurse. Arguably, patients' expectations of compassionate nurses bear witness to this past horizon.Implications for Nursing: Patients' self‐reported testimonies should be taken seriously as an evidence base for understanding and improving nursing care. Nursing researchers using qualitative methods should be transparent about their pre‐judgements. Connections with the past horizon of nursing history should be made to cast light on the present horizon.Conclusion: Patients' self‐reported testimonies are more congruent with methods of narrative inquiry than data solicited and filtered by the interviewer's undeclared pre‐judgement. They bear witness to the horizon of the past and the meaning and purpose of nursing, its values and ethos.
- 1 November 2011
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 20 (1) , 82-92
Gadamer’s two horizons: listening to the voices in nursing history
Brian Abel-Smith's A History of the Nursing Profession published in 1960 marked a new critical approach to interpreting British nursing history in the light of modern culture. This approach was taken forward by most nursing history writers. In addition, some British nursing history writers, notably Monica Baly, Celia Davies and Anne Marie Rafferty, as well as Abel-Smith himself, have influenced the direction of British nursing policy. This study argues that the current method of interpreting nursing history, through the revisionist lens of what Patricia D'Antonio calls 'the mighty triumvirate of race, class and gender', makes a crucial omission. According to Hans-Georg Gadamer, the hermeneutical philosopher, historical interpretation should be a mutual dialogue of the 'then' and the 'now'. But in modern nursing history writing the present horizon dominates. In order to allow the past horizon to speak to the present, this study examines the textbooks of British nursing matrons and tutors 1873-1971. These primary sources show that nurses were taught to develop Christian virtues in order to become good nurses. This study suggests that understanding and engaging with these voices, and allowing them to speak to the present, is relevant for current British nursing as well as for nursing worldwide.
- 1 November 2011
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Inquiry
- Vol. 20 (1) , 82-92
Gadamer’s two horizons: listening to the voices in nursing history
Brian Abel-Smith's A History of the Nursing Profession published in 1960 marked a new critical approach to interpreting British nursing history in the light of modern culture. This approach was taken forward by most nursing history writers. In addition, some British nursing history writers, notably Monica Baly, Celia Davies and Anne Marie Rafferty, as well as Abel-Smith himself, have influenced the direction of British nursing policy. This study argues that the current method of interpreting nursing history, through the revisionist lens of what Patricia D'Antonio calls 'the mighty triumvirate of race, class and gender', makes a crucial omission. According to Hans-Georg Gadamer, the hermeneutical philosopher, historical interpretation should be a mutual dialogue of the 'then' and the 'now'. But in modern nursing history writing the present horizon dominates. In order to allow the past horizon to speak to the present, this study examines the textbooks of British nursing matrons and tutors 1873-1971. These primary sources show that nurses were taught to develop Christian virtues in order to become good nurses. This study suggests that understanding and engaging with these voices, and allowing them to speak to the present, is relevant for current British nursing as well as for nursing worldwide.
- 12 June 2011
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 20 (13-14) , 1797-1800
Editorial: The future of clinical nursing: meeting the needs of patients for compassionate and skilled nurses?
- 12 June 2011
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 20 (13-14) , 1797-1800
Editorial: The future of clinical nursing: meeting the needs of patients for compassionate and skilled nurses?
- 17 November 2010
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 19 (23-24) , 3459-3467
An historical perspective on the treatment of vocation in the Briggs Report (1972)
To examine the vocational ideal in the Briggs Report (Briggs 1972), its evidence, context and interpretation. As recently argued in Journal of Clinical Nursing, twentieth century reports have misrepresented nursing. This paper considers this argument in relation to the Briggs Report and its understanding of vocation. Sources consulted: nursing periodicals 1960-1975, nursing textbooks 1937-1971, the Briggs Report, research studies on nursing 1961-1971, secondary works on nursing history. Included are three newly discovered major primary sources. An historiographical analysis of archival sources which interrogates primary and secondary evidence to make transparent interconnection, coherence, consistency and reliability. Despite evidence from its own commissioned data that vocation was an important motivating factor, the Briggs Report recommended a new nursing model. The concept of vocation in nursing has been commonly interpreted as a cultural tool hindering the subsequent development of nursing. This approach has been a driver for policy decisions in nursing. Despite its own evidence, the Briggs Committee recommended far reaching changes, accepted by government and implemented over the following decade as Project 2000. The concept of vocation warrants further scholarship. Whether the historical ideal of vocation remains important, negatively or positively, to the attitudes, values and motivations of the clinical nurse and the quality of patient care, is a relevant and significant issue for contemporary UK and international nursing practice and policy.
- 17 November 2010
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 19 (23-24) , 3459-3467
An historical perspective on the treatment of vocation in the Briggs Report (1972)
To examine the vocational ideal in the Briggs Report (Briggs 1972), its evidence, context and interpretation. As recently argued in Journal of Clinical Nursing, twentieth century reports have misrepresented nursing. This paper considers this argument in relation to the Briggs Report and its understanding of vocation. Sources consulted: nursing periodicals 1960-1975, nursing textbooks 1937-1971, the Briggs Report, research studies on nursing 1961-1971, secondary works on nursing history. Included are three newly discovered major primary sources. An historiographical analysis of archival sources which interrogates primary and secondary evidence to make transparent interconnection, coherence, consistency and reliability. Despite evidence from its own commissioned data that vocation was an important motivating factor, the Briggs Report recommended a new nursing model. The concept of vocation in nursing has been commonly interpreted as a cultural tool hindering the subsequent development of nursing. This approach has been a driver for policy decisions in nursing. Despite its own evidence, the Briggs Committee recommended far reaching changes, accepted by government and implemented over the following decade as Project 2000. The concept of vocation warrants further scholarship. Whether the historical ideal of vocation remains important, negatively or positively, to the attitudes, values and motivations of the clinical nurse and the quality of patient care, is a relevant and significant issue for contemporary UK and international nursing practice and policy.
- 22 October 2010
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 19 (23-24) , 3555-3563
Is the ward sister role still relevant to the quality of patient care? A critical examination of the ward sister role past and present
To examine the UK ward sister role in contemporary and historical context. The ward sister role once key to nursing is now confused. A critical examination of the changing role of the ward sister. Sources consulted: nursing textbooks 1877-1971, nursing and medical periodicals 1912-2010, official government reports 1947-2010, research studies on nursing 1960-2010, secondary works on nursing history. An historiographical analysis of archival sources which interrogates primary and secondary evidence to make transparent interconnection, coherence, consistency and reliability. As a consequence of professional, educational and managerial changes, the traditional authority of the ward sister for nursing standards, ward services and ward facilities is diminished. Ward sisters are primarily motivated by nursing rather than managerial values. Hence, there is disparity in the title 'ward sister' espoused by ward sisters and the public and the title 'ward manager' espoused by non-nursing managers. This is not just terminology, but concerns the kind of values enshrined by the term and entrusted to the role. Until the late 1970s, the ward sister was key to maintaining standards of care. She was the trustee of a tradition and transmitted its values. Subsequent organisational and professional changes have diminished the authority of the role. History may suggest the need to examine and strengthen the ward sister role in the light of its original orientation. The ward sister role could have a fundamental effect on the quality of patient care if it were to regain its former scope and authority.
- 22 October 2010
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 19 (23-24) , 3555-3563
Is the ward sister role still relevant to the quality of patient care? A critical examination of the ward sister role past and present
To examine the UK ward sister role in contemporary and historical context. The ward sister role once key to nursing is now confused. A critical examination of the changing role of the ward sister. Sources consulted: nursing textbooks 1877-1971, nursing and medical periodicals 1912-2010, official government reports 1947-2010, research studies on nursing 1960-2010, secondary works on nursing history. An historiographical analysis of archival sources which interrogates primary and secondary evidence to make transparent interconnection, coherence, consistency and reliability. As a consequence of professional, educational and managerial changes, the traditional authority of the ward sister for nursing standards, ward services and ward facilities is diminished. Ward sisters are primarily motivated by nursing rather than managerial values. Hence, there is disparity in the title 'ward sister' espoused by ward sisters and the public and the title 'ward manager' espoused by non-nursing managers. This is not just terminology, but concerns the kind of values enshrined by the term and entrusted to the role. Until the late 1970s, the ward sister was key to maintaining standards of care. She was the trustee of a tradition and transmitted its values. Subsequent organisational and professional changes have diminished the authority of the role. History may suggest the need to examine and strengthen the ward sister role in the light of its original orientation. The ward sister role could have a fundamental effect on the quality of patient care if it were to regain its former scope and authority.
- 30 July 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (8) , 465-468
Measuring nursing care and compassion: the McDonaldised nurse?
In June 2008 the UK government, supported by the Royal College of Nursing, stated that nursing care would be measured for compassion. This paper considers the implications of this statement by critically examining the relationship of compassion to care from a variety of perspectives. It is argued that the current market-driven approaches to healthcare involve redefining care as a pale imitation, even parody, of the traditional approach of the nurse as “my brother’s keeper”. Attempts to measure such parody can only measure artificial techniques and give rise to a McDonald’s-type nursing care rather than heartfelt care. The arguments of this paper, although applied to nursing, also apply to medicine and healthcare generally.
- 30 July 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (8) , 465-468
Measuring nursing care and compassion: the McDonaldised nurse?
In June 2008 the UK government, supported by the Royal College of Nursing, stated that nursing care would be measured for compassion. This paper considers the implications of this statement by critically examining the relationship of compassion to care from a variety of perspectives. It is argued that the current market-driven approaches to healthcare involve redefining care as a pale imitation, even parody, of the traditional approach of the nurse as “my brother’s keeper”. Attempts to measure such parody can only measure artificial techniques and give rise to a McDonald’s-type nursing care rather than heartfelt care. The arguments of this paper, although applied to nursing, also apply to medicine and healthcare generally.
- 14 April 2008
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 17 (10) , 1263-1269
Nursing competence 10 years on: fit for practice and purpose yet?
Aims and objectives. This paper examines how nurses are prepared to be clinically competent and safe at registration, so that they are fit for practice and purpose. It follows up two papers on competence published in 1997 and 1998 and investigates subsequent developments.Background. In 1979, major changes in nursing affected nurse education and preparation for competence. In the following two decades, it became clear that nurses lacked clinical skills. This paper examines subsequent changes and asks the question whether this crucial shortcoming has now been remedied. This paper considers the background and context of change in nursing and nurse education in the 1980s. It looks at the new ideology, to prepare the ‘knowledgeable doer’ and examines the consequences of the change on nursing competency from the 1990s to the present day.Methods. This is a position paper. Professional policy documents from the English National Board for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting, United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting and Nursing and Midwifery Council, government reports and legislation on nursing and relevant nursing literature are examined and critically analysed and conclusions drawn.Conclusions. From 1923–1977, mandatory nursing syllabuses set by the General Nursing Council of England and Wales required the registered nurse to have acquired certain specific clinical skills. These were rigorously tested to an explicit standard set by the General Nursing Council before a nurse was awarded state registration. Twenty‐five years later, the loss of this system for ensuring this competence and the implications of this loss, have been widely recognised. As a result, many nurse training institutions have introduced clinical skills laboratories, simulation of practice and the Objective Structured Clinical Examination. However, to the authors’ surprise and contrary to their initial expectations, the Nursing and Midwifery Council has not made these systems uniform or mandatory and so still has no way of ensuring all nurse training is producing safe nurses in the United Kingdom. The authors conclude that the untested educational ideology that brought root and branch change to nurse training in 1983 and which failed to produce nurses ‘fit for practice and purpose’ may still prevail.Relevance to clinical practice. The present paper demonstrates that United Kingdom nurse training still has no uniform and mandatory system in place to ensure, as far as is possible, that all registered nurses are clinically competent and safe to practice.
- 14 April 2008
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 17 (10) , 1263-1269
Nursing competence 10 years on: fit for practice and purpose yet?
Aims and objectives. This paper examines how nurses are prepared to be clinically competent and safe at registration, so that they are fit for practice and purpose. It follows up two papers on competence published in 1997 and 1998 and investigates subsequent developments.Background. In 1979, major changes in nursing affected nurse education and preparation for competence. In the following two decades, it became clear that nurses lacked clinical skills. This paper examines subsequent changes and asks the question whether this crucial shortcoming has now been remedied. This paper considers the background and context of change in nursing and nurse education in the 1980s. It looks at the new ideology, to prepare the ‘knowledgeable doer’ and examines the consequences of the change on nursing competency from the 1990s to the present day.Methods. This is a position paper. Professional policy documents from the English National Board for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting, United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting and Nursing and Midwifery Council, government reports and legislation on nursing and relevant nursing literature are examined and critically analysed and conclusions drawn.Conclusions. From 1923–1977, mandatory nursing syllabuses set by the General Nursing Council of England and Wales required the registered nurse to have acquired certain specific clinical skills. These were rigorously tested to an explicit standard set by the General Nursing Council before a nurse was awarded state registration. Twenty‐five years later, the loss of this system for ensuring this competence and the implications of this loss, have been widely recognised. As a result, many nurse training institutions have introduced clinical skills laboratories, simulation of practice and the Objective Structured Clinical Examination. However, to the authors’ surprise and contrary to their initial expectations, the Nursing and Midwifery Council has not made these systems uniform or mandatory and so still has no way of ensuring all nurse training is producing safe nurses in the United Kingdom. The authors conclude that the untested educational ideology that brought root and branch change to nurse training in 1983 and which failed to produce nurses ‘fit for practice and purpose’ may still prevail.Relevance to clinical practice. The present paper demonstrates that United Kingdom nurse training still has no uniform and mandatory system in place to ensure, as far as is possible, that all registered nurses are clinically competent and safe to practice.
- 20 December 2006
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 16 (1) , 98-103
Rectal suppository insertion: the reliability of the evidence as a basis for nursing practice
This paper considers the correct method for inserting a rectal suppository, both as a medication and also to achieve bowel evacuation. The aim is to find out whether the correct method is blunt end or pointed end foremost. It follows from a question raised by a third year student nurse. In the classroom, she had been taught that the correct method for the administration of a suppository for systemic absorption was to insert it blunt end foremost into the rectum. However, if the suppository was to be used for evacuant purposes, it should be given pointed end foremost. In clinical practice, however, she was told the suppository should always be inserted pointed end foremost in all cases, whatever the purpose. This article seeks to clarify the dilemma by examining the sources of evidence underpinning different methods for inserting a rectal suppository. Hence, the literature on the insertion of rectal suppositories was gathered as systematically as possible from medical journals and textbooks, nursing journals and textbooks and manufacturers' information to patients. Having gathered the literature, this was examined, appraised and critically analysed for rigour, coherence and reliability. The review of the literature appears to show that evidence adduced for inserting the suppository blunt end foremost derives from one study published in the Lancet in 1991, which challenged 'commonsense'. There did not appear to be other, more recent research. On the other hand, manufacturers' information to patients states generally that the suppository should be inserted pointed end foremost. This has direct relevance for the administration of suppositories and also raises questions as to how research may become integrated into healthcare practice without adequate justification. An article published in the Lancet in 1991 has had a fundamental effect on nursing practice, but has not been subject to scrutiny. The advice given in this Lancet article differs from that currently given by most manufacturers of suppositories, which involves the terms of their product licence. Hence, there is a potential for problems with legal liability should an untoward event arise. Inserting rectal suppositories, whether as a medication or to achieve bowel evacuation, is a very common healthcare practice. Currently, there is inconsistency and discrepancy in the correct method for this procedure in both nursing education and practice. This paper examines the reliability of existing evidence and shows the need for further work in order to provide a reliable evidence base for this commonplace clinical procedure.
- 20 December 2006
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 16 (1) , 98-103
Rectal suppository insertion: the reliability of the evidence as a basis for nursing practice
This paper considers the correct method for inserting a rectal suppository, both as a medication and also to achieve bowel evacuation. The aim is to find out whether the correct method is blunt end or pointed end foremost. It follows from a question raised by a third year student nurse. In the classroom, she had been taught that the correct method for the administration of a suppository for systemic absorption was to insert it blunt end foremost into the rectum. However, if the suppository was to be used for evacuant purposes, it should be given pointed end foremost. In clinical practice, however, she was told the suppository should always be inserted pointed end foremost in all cases, whatever the purpose. This article seeks to clarify the dilemma by examining the sources of evidence underpinning different methods for inserting a rectal suppository. Hence, the literature on the insertion of rectal suppositories was gathered as systematically as possible from medical journals and textbooks, nursing journals and textbooks and manufacturers' information to patients. Having gathered the literature, this was examined, appraised and critically analysed for rigour, coherence and reliability. The review of the literature appears to show that evidence adduced for inserting the suppository blunt end foremost derives from one study published in the Lancet in 1991, which challenged 'commonsense'. There did not appear to be other, more recent research. On the other hand, manufacturers' information to patients states generally that the suppository should be inserted pointed end foremost. This has direct relevance for the administration of suppositories and also raises questions as to how research may become integrated into healthcare practice without adequate justification. An article published in the Lancet in 1991 has had a fundamental effect on nursing practice, but has not been subject to scrutiny. The advice given in this Lancet article differs from that currently given by most manufacturers of suppositories, which involves the terms of their product licence. Hence, there is a potential for problems with legal liability should an untoward event arise. Inserting rectal suppositories, whether as a medication or to achieve bowel evacuation, is a very common healthcare practice. Currently, there is inconsistency and discrepancy in the correct method for this procedure in both nursing education and practice. This paper examines the reliability of existing evidence and shows the need for further work in order to provide a reliable evidence base for this commonplace clinical procedure.