George Szmukler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
George Szmukler has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
John Dawson
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 30 September 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (10) , 647-650
“Personality disorder” and capacity to make treatment decisions
Whether treatment decision-making capacity can be meaningfully applied to patients with a diagnosis of “personality disorder” is examined. Patients presenting to a psychiatric emergency clinic with threats of self-harm are considered, two having been assessed and reviewed in detail. It was found that capacity can be meaningfully assessed in such patients, although the process is more complex than in patients with diagnoses of a more conventional kind. The process of assessing capacity in such patients is very time-consuming and may become, in itself, a therapeutic intervention.
- 30 September 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (10) , 647-650
“Personality disorder” and capacity to make treatment decisions
Whether treatment decision-making capacity can be meaningfully applied to patients with a diagnosis of “personality disorder” is examined. Patients presenting to a psychiatric emergency clinic with threats of self-harm are considered, two having been assessed and reviewed in detail. It was found that capacity can be meaningfully assessed in such patients, although the process is more complex than in patients with diagnoses of a more conventional kind. The process of assessing capacity in such patients is very time-consuming and may become, in itself, a therapeutic intervention.
- 30 March 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (4) , 224-228
Financial incentives for patients in the treatment of psychosis
Poor medication adherence in patients with a psychosis is associated with relapse. It has been proposed that outcomes might be improved by using financial incentives for treatment adherence (FITA). However, a strong moral intuition against this practice has been found. This paper examines the ethics of FITA.Three arguments are presented, which if accepted would severely restrict or even prohibit the practice. These are based on (1) “incommensurable values”, where FITA denigrates an aspect of “respect for the person”, (2) “exploitation”, where unfair advantage is taken of the patient, and (3) “fairness”, where it is difficult to draw a line between those who should and should not be offered payment. A number of practical impediments are also considered.
- 30 March 2009
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 35 (4) , 224-228
Financial incentives for patients in the treatment of psychosis
Poor medication adherence in patients with a psychosis is associated with relapse. It has been proposed that outcomes might be improved by using financial incentives for treatment adherence (FITA). However, a strong moral intuition against this practice has been found. This paper examines the ethics of FITA.Three arguments are presented, which if accepted would severely restrict or even prohibit the practice. These are based on (1) “incommensurable values”, where FITA denigrates an aspect of “respect for the person”, (2) “exploitation”, where unfair advantage is taken of the patient, and (3) “fairness”, where it is difficult to draw a line between those who should and should not be offered payment. A number of practical impediments are also considered.
- 1 January 2006
- Vol. 34 (3) , 398-401
Commentary: toward resolving some dilemmas concerning psychiatric advance directives.
Dilemmas about when psychiatric advance directives (PADs) should be overridden are complicated by conflicting legal frameworks that may nonetheless operate concurrently-a legal scheme based on decision-making capacity (or competency) set against a legal scheme based on civil commitment, in which the latter may "trump" the former. A single statute in which the strengths of both schemes are "fused" may be possible. There is evidence that the promise of PADs in enhancing patients' control over their treatment can be achieved without legislation for PADs and where civil commitment is given legal precedence. An example is the "joint crisis plan" in which, through a negotiation facilitated by an independent third party, a joint agreement is reached between patient and service provider about what treatment should be given when, as a result of a relapse of mental illness, the patient loses the ability to make treatment decisions. This clinical instrument may significantly reduce later involuntary treatment.
- 1 January 2006
- Vol. 34 (3) , 398-401
Commentary: toward resolving some dilemmas concerning psychiatric advance directives.
Dilemmas about when psychiatric advance directives (PADs) should be overridden are complicated by conflicting legal frameworks that may nonetheless operate concurrently-a legal scheme based on decision-making capacity (or competency) set against a legal scheme based on civil commitment, in which the latter may "trump" the former. A single statute in which the strengths of both schemes are "fused" may be possible. There is evidence that the promise of PADs in enhancing patients' control over their treatment can be achieved without legislation for PADs and where civil commitment is given legal precedence. An example is the "joint crisis plan" in which, through a negotiation facilitated by an independent third party, a joint agreement is reached between patient and service provider about what treatment should be given when, as a result of a relapse of mental illness, the patient loses the ability to make treatment decisions. This clinical instrument may significantly reduce later involuntary treatment.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2005
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in Psychiatric Bulletin
- Vol. 29 (12) , 447-448
The ground is in great shape, but can we field a kitted-out team? Commentary on … Mental health research system in England
Chilvers & Clark make it clear that research and development (R&D) in the National Health Service (NHS) is now a managed process. There is a coherent strategy and much thought has been given to the use of resources. I welcome this development and the ‘Health Research System’ that forms its framework.
- 1 December 2005
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in Psychiatric Bulletin
- Vol. 29 (12) , 447-448
Open AccessThe ground is in great shape, but can we field a kitted-out team? Commentary on … Mental health research system in England
Chilvers & Clark make it clear that research and development (R&D) in the National Health Service (NHS) is now a managed process. There is a coherent strategy and much thought has been given to the use of resources. I welcome this development and the ‘Health Research System’ that forms its framework.