PTPhilip Tipping

Philip Tipping

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Philip Tipping has a total of 67 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Biological control agents experience biotic resistance, but not apparent competition in a complex community assemblage

    by Melissa Smith, Ellen C. Lake, Carey R. Minteer, Alissa Berro, Karen E. Rice-David, Robert Kula, Michael W. Gates, Robert L. Kresslein, Philip Tipping

    Pre-release safety testing for biological control agents focuses on preventing direct non-target negative impacts, but unanticipated indirect effects within the community are possible, though difficult to anticipate. For example, apparent competition may occur when enemies that utilize native hosts spillover onto the novel biological control agents and then spill back over onto native hosts, causing population decline in both hosts and other potential effects throughout the trophic levels.,Lygodium microphyllum, Old World climbing fern, invades upland and mesic communities throughout peninsular Florida. We utilized Neomusotima conspurcatalis, the biological control agent for L. microphyllum, which had accumulated nine parasitoid species since its release (egg, larval, and pupal) to survey for apparent competition. We constructed blocks of native host plants (Acer rubrum, Myrica cerifera, and Taxodium distichum) within invaded and uninvaded habitats. Native Lepidoptera and N. conspurcatalis (eggs, larvae, and pupae) were collected at nine sampling points over thirteen months and reared until 1) adult emergence, 2) death, or 3) parasitoid emergence.,Only Mesochorus apantalis, a hyperparasitoid was recovered from native specimens and N. conspurcatalis. Parasitism rates were significantly higher in sites without L. microphyllum. Sites with L. microphyllum had significantly higher diversity in the parasitoid taxa, but not in the lepidopteran taxa.,While native parasitoids will likely continue to accumulate on N. conspurcatalis, our data indicate that they do not form a significant resource for parasitoids that negatively spill back onto native lepidopteran taxa. However, parasitism may present a barrier to effective management using N. conspurcatalis.

  • Open Access

    The impact of biocontrol agents on different chemotypes of Melaleuca quinquenervia, an invasive tree in south Florida

    by Blake Mackenzie Blaskowski, Peter Stiling, Philip Tipping, Melissa Martin, Lyn Gettys, Gregory S. Wheeler, Melissa Smith

    Across its natural and invaded range, Melaleuca quinquenervia, an invasive tree from Australia and Papua New Guinea, produces oils correspondent to two distinct chemotypes, based on production of essential oils. In Australia and Papua New Guinea, the two chemotypes separate geographically: Chemotype 1 occurs north of 25ºS and both chemotypes occur south of 25ºS. In south Florida, M. quinquenervia also occurs in two different habitats, dry and sandy soils in the west and wetter organic soils in the east. We investigated the effects of two biological control agents, the leaf feeding melaleuca snout weevil (Oxyops vitiosa), and the sap-sucking psyllid (Boreioglycaspis melaleucae) on both chemotypes in both types of habitats. We designed a common garden experiment to investigate the effects of herbivory and irrigation on M. quinquenervia growth with no difference in biological control agent abundance between chemotypes. The E-nerolidol chemotype (chemotype 1) grew significantly faster than the viridiflorol chemotype (chemotype 2), regardless of herbivory exposure. Seed production in plants exposed to herbivory was reduced by more than 99% compared to plants with limited herbivory, regardless of chemotype. The final height of insecticide-treated plants was over double that of unsprayed plants and the final trunk biomass was five times greater. However, in our experiments the effects of insecticide on final plant height, final trunk biomass and final branch biomass were greater for viridiflorol than E-nerolidol, suggesting biological control may have a greater impact on viridiflorol trees. Increased irrigation did not affect herbivore numbers but did significantly increase final tree height and final branch weight, and for height this increase was greater for viridiflorol. While our research suggests biological control agents are effective against both chemotypes, they also show that impacts are affected by both chemotype and environment.

  • Open Access

    The influence of two wildfires and biological control agents on the population dynamics of Melaleuca quinquenervia in a seasonally inundated wetland

    by Philip W. Tipping, Melissa R. Martin, Jeremiah R. Foley, Ryan M. Pierce, Lyn A. Gettys

    The potential of Melaleuca quinquenervia (Cav.) S.T. Blake to re-invade cleared areas was evaluated over a 13 y period that included two wildfires and the introduction of biological control agents. The first wildfire occurred in 1998 and was followed by a mean of 591.5 recruited seedlings m-2. Recruits from that fire were cleared seven years later in July 2005 for a second experiment to evaluate seedling recruitment into cleared areas. Seed rain, seedling recruitment and mortality, and sapling growth rates were measured in four plots located around individual large reproductive trees. A second natural wildfire in 2007 burned through those plots leading to increases in seed rain followed by a pulse in recruitment of 21.04 seedlings m-2, 96.5% fewer than after the 1998 fire. Recruits in half of the plots around each tree were then treated with regular applications of an insecticide to restrict herbivory by biological control agents, while herbivory was not restricted in the other half. There was no difference in seedling mortality between treatments 1083 days post fire (2007) with 96.6% seedling mortality in the unrestricted herbivory treatment and 89.4% mortality in the restricted herbivory treatment. Recruits subjected to the restricted herbivory treatment grew taller than those in the unrestricted herbivory treatment, 101.3 cm vs. 37.4 cm. Many of the recruits were attacked by the biological control agents that slowed their growth. Although solitary M. quinquenervia trees retain some capacity to re-invade areas under specific circumstances, there was a downward trend in their overall invasiveness at this site with progressively smaller recruitment cohorts due to biological control agents. Land managers should prioritize removing large reproductive trees over treating recently recruited populations which can be left for many years to the biological control agents to suppress before any additional treatment would be needed.


  • OUP accepted manuscript

    by Philip W Tipping, Melissa R Martin, Min B Rayamajhi, Paul D Pratt, Lyn A Gettys

    A 6-year time-series study in the Western Everglades region of Florida, United States examined the influence of woody debris from two tree species on invertebrate richness, abundance, and diversity, as well as tree debris mass loss, fragmentation, and residence time. Samples of decomposing fine woody debris and coarse woody debris (CWD) from non-native Melaleuca quinquenervia (Cav.) Blake and native Pinus elliottii Englem trees were removed from a field site every six months and processed to capture data on biotic and abiotic variables. Invertebrates found within debris were identified to family. A total of 61,985 individual invertebrates from three classes, 17 orders, and 95 families were identified from all debris. Although both tree species supported similar richness and diversity of invertebrates, abundance was greater in P. elliottii CWD compared with M. quinquenervia. Mass loss and fragmentation of debris were more rapid in M. quinquenervia fine woody debris with no differences between species for CWD. Although M. quinquenervia CWD supported fewer invertebrates than P. elliottii, overall the exotic tree provided a similar resource during the decomposition phase as the native P. elliottii suggesting that, unlike when it is alive, its decomposing presence had a minimal impact on invertebrate food webs. Land managers should consider specific intervals between herbicide applications and controlled burns to decrease the magnitude of fires in areas where a significant portion of the fuel load consists of dead M. quinquenervia, knowing that the decomposing trees are providing significant resources for invertebrate communities in the meantime.

  • Open Access

    Allometric equations for the invasive vine air potato (Dioscorea bulbifera) in its exotic range in Florida

    by Min B. Rayamajhi, Eric Rohrig, Philip W. Tipping, Paul D. Pratt, Jorge G. Leidi

    Non-destructive means for estimating Dioscorea bulbifera biomass will help gauge its management efficacy over time. Herein, we developed allometric equations to estimate total and fractional biomass components, and densities of aerial bulbils and underground tubers of field grown Dioscorea bulbifera in Florida. We selected four naturally infested sites representing its southern, central, and northern distribution in Florida and measured three independent variables (vine densities, stem diameters, and top heights) of 84 (21 site-1) discrete D. bulbifera patches during late October-early December of 2012. We destructively harvested D. bulbifera biomass, sorted by tubers, stems, leaves and bulbils, counted units of bulbils and underground tubers (dependent variables) and dried to a constant weight. Mean percentages of tuber, stem, leaf, and bulbil fractions in total biomass were 42.0, 15.6, 26.0 and 16.4, respectively. We developed parameterized multiplicative prediction models and regression equations for each dependent variable. Slopes of relationships among independent and dependent variables varied by biomass and density (bulbil and tuber) of plant components. Multiplied values of independent variables: all three for total, tuber, stem and leaf biomass; two (vine-base diameter*patch height) for bulbil biomass; and two (vine density*patch height) for bulbil density; and only one (stem density) for tuber-density provided best (R2 based) prediction values. These models will provide non-destructive methods for estimating biomass components and density of vegetative propagules of naturally growing D. bulbifera. Models are critical for understanding the performance of D. bulbifera in its exotic range, estimating biomass to project control costs, and comparing biomass components and bulbil/tuber densities during pre- and post-management periods to gauge control efficacy.


  • Open Access

    Persistence of Biological Control Agents in Waterhyacinth Following Herbicide Application

    by Ashley B. C. Goode, Philip W. Tipping, Lyn A. Gettys, Brittany K. Knowles, Ryann J. Valmonte, Eileen Pokorny

    Waterhyacinth (Pontederia [Eichhornia] crassipes) (Martius) Solms Laubach (Pontederiaceae) is an invasive, floating plant that causes environmental and economic damage outside its native range (Center 1987). The infestation in Florida began in the late 1800s, and it still requires diligent management to prevent it from overtaking waterways. In 2017, nearly half of the water bodies in Florida had P. crassipes populations, resulting in almost 25,000 acres (10,117.1 ha) being treated with herbicides (FFWCC 2017). Herbicides remain the principal management tactic (Schmitz et al. 1993; Gettys et al. 2014a, b) despite the establishment of 4 biological control agents (Perkins 1973; Center & Durden 1981; Center 1994; Center et al. 2002; Tipping et al. 2011, 2014b).


  • Classical biological control and apparent competition: Evaluating a waterhyacinth invaded community module

    by Philip W. Tipping, Melissa C. Smith, Ellen C. Lake, Carey R. Minteer, Ashley B. C. Goode, Jeremiah R. Foley, Lyn A. Gettys

    The scope and complexity of interactions within community food webs necessitates their simplification to a community module scale for conducting empirical studies. An outdoor mesocosm study in the USA quantified the strengths of direct and indirect interactions between two herbivore congeners that fed on two aquatic plant species while sharing a parasitoid. Kalopolynema ema (Hymenoptera: Mymaridae) is a stenophagous native egg parasitoid that attacks the hemipteran species in this study, Megamelus davisi (Hemiptera: Delphacidae), a native herbivore that feeds on the native aquatic species Nuphar advena, and the introduced biological control agent Megamelus scutellaris (Hemiptera: Delphacidae) that feeds on the non‐native aquatic species waterhyacinth, Pontederia crassipes. The presence of M. scutellaris did not significantly increase parasitism of M. davisi indicating that apparent competition was not a factor in this community module. There was no evidence of any trophic cascades caused by these interactions based on the relative growth rates of biomass and leaf area for both plant species. Synthesis and applications. The relative strengths of community interactions varied with herbivore densities suggesting that should negative indirect effects with biological control agents occur they would likely be transient and closely linked to population dynamics as influenced by abiotic factors like temperature. Despite identifying potential negative interactions using path analysis, we saw no apparent competition following the insertion of a weed biological control agent into a community that contains an ecological analog. In this example, the primary negative interaction was biotic resistance to Megamelus scutellaris from attack by Kalopolynema ema. Adopting weed management tactics that emphasize efficacy, sustainability and environmental benevolence argue for the use of classical biological control when appropriate.


  • Small-scale dispersal of a biological control agent – Implications for more effective releases

    by Ashley B.C. Goode, Carey R. Minteer, Philip W. Tipping, Brittany K. Knowles, Ryann J. Valmonte, Jeremiah R. Foley, Lyn A. Gettys


  • Assessing the risk of Eccritotarsus eichhorniae to pickerelweed, Pontederia cordata in North America

    by Philip W. Tipping, Jeremiah R. Foley, Lyn A. Gettys, Carey A. Minteer

    The mirid Eccritotarsus eichhorniae is a newly described species with potential as a biological control agent for water hyacinth, Eichhornia crassipes, in North America. A series of quarantine-based studies quantified E. eichhorniae usage of Pontederia cordata with no-choice, adult choice, nymph choice, multi-generation, and impact tests. Although greater numbers of E. eichhorniae adults developed on E. crassipes in two separate no-choice trials, some E. eichhorniae were able to complete development on P. cordata in both trials. Adults showed a clear oviposition preference for E. crassipes and F1 progeny reduced the mean relative growth rate of E. crassipes but not P. cordata. Naïve nymphs were more likely to leave P. cordata for E. crassipes but not all nymphs left P. cordata when given a choice. Both multi-generation trials showed a rapid increase in the density of adults and nymphs on E. crassipes over four to five generations while population densities on P. cordata did not change, indicating that this insect can maintain populations on this plant. The modest damage inflicted by a sibling species on E. crassipes, coupled with the ability of E. eichhorniae to persist on P. cordata, may pose an interpretation challenge to U.S. regulatory agencies concerned with non-target impacts by biological control agents. Another option for the continuing efforts to increase the biological control of E. crassipes is to prioritise the evaluation of other potential agents like Taosa longula Remes Lenicov (Homoptera: Dictopharidae) or Thrypticus truncatus Bickel and Hernández (Diptera: Dolichopodidae) over E. eichhorniae.