John H. Goldthorpe
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
John H. Goldthorpe has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Erzsebet Bukodi
Department of Social Policy and Intervention Nuffield College University of Oxford Oxford UK
4 shared publications - Robert Erikson
Swedish Institute for Social Research, Stockholm University, SE 10691, Stockholm, Sweden
4 shared publications Erzsébet Bukodi
Department of Social Policy and Intervention Nuffield College University of Oxford Oxford UK
3 shared publicationsInga Steinberg
Department of Social Policy and Intervention Nuffield College University of Oxford Oxford UK
2 shared publications- Barbara Maughan
King's College London
1 shared publication - Emily T Murray
MRC Unit for Lifelong Health and Ageing, University College and Royal Free Medical School, 33 Bedford Place, London WC1B 5JU, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie
- Vol. 78 (3) , 1-23
Description, Causal Explanation, and Policy Intervention in Sociology
I seek to restate and to develop a position I have previously taken up on the relation between description and causal explanation in sociology, in part by reference to an ongoing controversy on this matter in British sociology. I start out from the basic distinction between the causes of effects and the effects of causes, and from a more instructive controversy on the issues that arise that has occurred in epidemiology. Drawing on this, I emphasise three points: first, the importance of good description in sociology in its own right but also in establishing the social phenomena that call for explanation; second, the need for causal explanations to be given in terms of social processes or mechanisms, specified in terms of individual action and interaction which are capable of generating the explananda ; and third, the necessity of moving on from description to explanation in this way if sociology is to take up the actually increasing scope that exists for it to contribute to effective social policy and also to an understanding of the possible limits of such policy.
- 23 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie
- Vol. 78 (3) , 1-23
Open AccessDescription, Causal Explanation, and Policy Intervention in Sociology
I seek to restate and to develop a position I have previously taken up on the relation between description and causal explanation in sociology, in part by reference to an ongoing controversy on this matter in British sociology. I start out from the basic distinction between the causes of effects and the effects of causes, and from a more instructive controversy on the issues that arise that has occurred in epidemiology. Drawing on this, I emphasise three points: first, the importance of good description in sociology in its own right but also in establishing the social phenomena that call for explanation; second, the need for causal explanations to be given in terms of social processes or mechanisms, specified in terms of individual action and interaction which are capable of generating the explananda ; and third, the necessity of moving on from description to explanation in this way if sociology is to take up the actually increasing scope that exists for it to contribute to effective social policy and also to an understanding of the possible limits of such policy.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 76 (2) , 201-225
Variation in the social composition of the UK academic elite: The underlay of the two—or three—cultures?
In this paper, we complement a previous study of the UK natural science elite, as represented by Fellows of the Royal Society, with a comparable study of the humanities and social sciences elites, as represented by Fellows of the British Academy. We seek to establish how far similarities and differences exist in the social composition of these three academic elites and in the routes that their members have followed into elite positions. We are also concerned with the consequences of the humanities and social sciences elites being brought together in the British Academy, in contrast with the situation in most other countries where elite natural and social scientists are located in the same academy. We pursue these issues in the context of C. P. Snow's discussion of the social underlay of the cultural disjunction that he saw between the natural sciences and the humanities, while also considering how the social sciences fit in. We find that there is support for Snow's position at the time of his writing. However, a notable development in more recent years is that the growing social sciences elite is moving in its social composition away from the humanities elite and closer to the natural science elite. This is primarily due to changes in the social origins and education of Fellows in those sections of the British Academy that are on the borderline between the social and the natural sciences. A widening difference thus arises with Fellows in the humanities sections most representative of Snow's ‘traditional culture’.
- 22 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 76 (2) , 201-225
Open AccessVariation in the social composition of the UK academic elite: The underlay of the two—or three—cultures?
In this paper, we complement a previous study of the UK natural science elite, as represented by Fellows of the Royal Society, with a comparable study of the humanities and social sciences elites, as represented by Fellows of the British Academy. We seek to establish how far similarities and differences exist in the social composition of these three academic elites and in the routes that their members have followed into elite positions. We are also concerned with the consequences of the humanities and social sciences elites being brought together in the British Academy, in contrast with the situation in most other countries where elite natural and social scientists are located in the same academy. We pursue these issues in the context of C. P. Snow's discussion of the social underlay of the cultural disjunction that he saw between the natural sciences and the humanities, while also considering how the social sciences fit in. We find that there is support for Snow's position at the time of his writing. However, a notable development in more recent years is that the growing social sciences elite is moving in its social composition away from the humanities elite and closer to the natural science elite. This is primarily due to changes in the social origins and education of Fellows in those sections of the British Academy that are on the borderline between the social and the natural sciences. A widening difference thus arises with Fellows in the humanities sections most representative of Snow's ‘traditional culture’.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Politics
- p. 1-30
The changing class and educational composition of the UK political elite since 1945: implications for representation
Debates over the changing nature of the UK political elite have focused on questions of representation and the extent of class convergence between the leaderships of the Conservative and Labour parties. We present a new comprehensive survey of the class and educational composition of the membership of Conservative and Labour cabinets and shadow cabinets since 1945. Some convergence in the class composition of the leaderships is apparent, but intra-class differences in terms of sector and occupation point to persisting differences in adult experience in profit-making versus public/third sector organisations and in technical versus sociocultural professions. Educationally, there is a decline in the Conservative leadership in the numbers coming from elite private schools but not from private schools in general, and attendance at elite universities remains more common on the Conservative side. Changes in the class origins and previous employment of the Conservative leadership do not suggest any weakening in the party’s capacity to represent business interests. In contrast, while there has been no decline in the proportion of the Labour leadership from working-class origins, there has been an almost complete disappearance of those with adult experience of working-class life.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Politics
- p. 1-30
Open AccessThe changing class and educational composition of the UK political elite since 1945: implications for representation
Debates over the changing nature of the UK political elite have focused on questions of representation and the extent of class convergence between the leaderships of the Conservative and Labour parties. We present a new comprehensive survey of the class and educational composition of the membership of Conservative and Labour cabinets and shadow cabinets since 1945. Some convergence in the class composition of the leaderships is apparent, but intra-class differences in terms of sector and occupation point to persisting differences in adult experience in profit-making versus public/third sector organisations and in technical versus sociocultural professions. Educationally, there is a decline in the Conservative leadership in the numbers coming from elite private schools but not from private schools in general, and attendance at elite universities remains more common on the Conservative side. Changes in the class origins and previous employment of the Conservative leadership do not suggest any weakening in the party’s capacity to represent business interests. In contrast, while there has been no decline in the proportion of the Labour leadership from working-class origins, there has been an almost complete disappearance of those with adult experience of working-class life.
- Open Access
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Centro de Investigaciones Sociologicas in Reis: Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológicas
- No. 137,p. 43-58
De vuelta a clase y el estatus: Por qué debe reivindicarse una perspectiva sociológica de la desigualdad social
Las cuestiones relativas a la desigualdad social han adquirido recientementeuna nueva centralidad política en muchas sociedades occidentales. Sinembargo, las aproximaciones a la desigualdad social que han realizado lossociólogos han sido ignoradas, especialmente en el trabajo de economistasy epidemiólogos. Los principales rasgos del enfoque sociológico sonel énfasis en la desigualdad entendida en un sentido relacional más quesimplemente atributivo y la distinción entre la clase social y el estatus socialcomo dos formas cualitativamente diferentes de estratifi cación. Se presentandos casos para ilustrar las limitaciones y los peligros que resultan deignorar el trabajo empírico y conceptual de los sociólogos: el estudio de loseconomistas sobre la movilidad social intergeneracional y el estudio de losepidemiólogos acerca de las consecuencias de la desigualdad social parala salud y otros problemas sociales relacionados.
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Centro de Investigaciones Sociologicas in Reis: Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológicas
- No. 137,p. 43-58
Open AccessDe vuelta a clase y el estatus: Por qué debe reivindicarse una perspectiva sociológica de la desigualdad social
Las cuestiones relativas a la desigualdad social han adquirido recientementeuna nueva centralidad política en muchas sociedades occidentales. Sinembargo, las aproximaciones a la desigualdad social que han realizado lossociólogos han sido ignoradas, especialmente en el trabajo de economistasy epidemiólogos. Los principales rasgos del enfoque sociológico sonel énfasis en la desigualdad entendida en un sentido relacional más quesimplemente atributivo y la distinción entre la clase social y el estatus socialcomo dos formas cualitativamente diferentes de estratifi cación. Se presentandos casos para ilustrar las limitaciones y los peligros que resultan deignorar el trabajo empírico y conceptual de los sociólogos: el estudio de loseconomistas sobre la movilidad social intergeneracional y el estudio de losepidemiólogos acerca de las consecuencias de la desigualdad social parala salud y otros problemas sociales relacionados.
- Open Access
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 74 (4) , 547-565
Continuing complexity: The university careers of a scientific elite in relation to their class origins and schooling
We report on continuing research on the UK scientific elite, intended to illustrate a proposed new approach to elite studies and based on a prosopography of Fellows of the Royal Society born from 1900. We extend analyses previously reported of Fellows' social origins and secondary schooling to take in their university careers as under‐ and postgraduates. The composite term ‘Oxbridge’, as often applied in elite studies, is called into question, as members of the scientific elite prove to have been recruited more from Cambridge than from Oxford. Particular interest then attaches to the relation between Fellows' social origins and schooling and their attendance at Cambridge. Among Fellows whose university careers were made at Cambridge, those of more advantaged class origins and those with private schooling are over‐represented, although in this, as in various other respects, including Fellows' field of study, family influences persist independently of schooling. One suggestive interaction effect exists in that being privately educated increases the probability of having been at Cambridge more for Fellows from managerial than from professional families. Private schooling leading on to both undergraduate and postgraduate study at Cambridge can be identified as the educational ‘royal road’ into the scientific elite; and Fellows coming from higher professional and managerial families alike have the highest probability of having entered the elite in this way. But the most common route turns out in fact to be via state schooling and attendance at universities outside of ‘the golden triangle’ of Cambridge, Oxford and London; and this route is far more likely to have been followed by Fellows of all other class origins than higher professional. The relation between the degree of social skew in the recruitment of an elite and the degree of social homogeneity among its members can be more complex than has often been supposed.
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 74 (4) , 547-565
Open AccessContinuing complexity: The university careers of a scientific elite in relation to their class origins and schooling
We report on continuing research on the UK scientific elite, intended to illustrate a proposed new approach to elite studies and based on a prosopography of Fellows of the Royal Society born from 1900. We extend analyses previously reported of Fellows' social origins and secondary schooling to take in their university careers as under‐ and postgraduates. The composite term ‘Oxbridge’, as often applied in elite studies, is called into question, as members of the scientific elite prove to have been recruited more from Cambridge than from Oxford. Particular interest then attaches to the relation between Fellows' social origins and schooling and their attendance at Cambridge. Among Fellows whose university careers were made at Cambridge, those of more advantaged class origins and those with private schooling are over‐represented, although in this, as in various other respects, including Fellows' field of study, family influences persist independently of schooling. One suggestive interaction effect exists in that being privately educated increases the probability of having been at Cambridge more for Fellows from managerial than from professional families. Private schooling leading on to both undergraduate and postgraduate study at Cambridge can be identified as the educational ‘royal road’ into the scientific elite; and Fellows coming from higher professional and managerial families alike have the highest probability of having entered the elite in this way. But the most common route turns out in fact to be via state schooling and attendance at universities outside of ‘the golden triangle’ of Cambridge, Oxford and London; and this route is far more likely to have been followed by Fellows of all other class origins than higher professional. The relation between the degree of social skew in the recruitment of an elite and the degree of social homogeneity among its members can be more complex than has often been supposed.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 73 (3) , 484-504
The social origins and schooling of a scientific elite: Fellows of the Royal Society born from 1900
We present an analysis of the social composition of the UK scientific elite, as represented by Fellows of the Royal Society, in terms of Fellows' social class origins and type of secondary schooling. From various sources, we have assembled data for 1691 Fellows, representing 80% of our target population of all Fellows born from 1900 onwards whose scientific careers were spent predominantly in the UK. We find that while these elite scientists come largely from more advantaged class backgrounds, it is professional rather than business or managerial families that are the main source of their recruitment—and, increasingly, such families where a parent is in a STEM occupation. Recruitment from working‐class families has declined and for most recent birth cohorts almost ceased. The scientific elite is thus now more homogeneous as regards the social origins of its members than it was in the second half of the twentieth century. At the same time, little change is evident in the secondary schooling of Fellows. In all birth cohorts, between two‐fifths and a half of all—and over two‐thirds of those from more advantaged class backgrounds—were privately educated, although the proportion attending Clarendon schools would seem low compared with that in other elites. A further finding of interest is that some variation in Fellows' class origins and type of schooling exists across different research fields.
- 12 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 73 (3) , 484-504
Open AccessThe social origins and schooling of a scientific elite: Fellows of the Royal Society born from 1900
We present an analysis of the social composition of the UK scientific elite, as represented by Fellows of the Royal Society, in terms of Fellows' social class origins and type of secondary schooling. From various sources, we have assembled data for 1691 Fellows, representing 80% of our target population of all Fellows born from 1900 onwards whose scientific careers were spent predominantly in the UK. We find that while these elite scientists come largely from more advantaged class backgrounds, it is professional rather than business or managerial families that are the main source of their recruitment—and, increasingly, such families where a parent is in a STEM occupation. Recruitment from working‐class families has declined and for most recent birth cohorts almost ceased. The scientific elite is thus now more homogeneous as regards the social origins of its members than it was in the second half of the twentieth century. At the same time, little change is evident in the secondary schooling of Fellows. In all birth cohorts, between two‐fifths and a half of all—and over two‐thirds of those from more advantaged class backgrounds—were privately educated, although the proportion attending Clarendon schools would seem low compared with that in other elites. A further finding of interest is that some variation in Fellows' class origins and type of schooling exists across different research fields.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Twentieth Century British History
- Vol. 33 (3) , 451-459
Historians’ Uses of Archived Material from Sociological Research: A Response to the Commentaries on My Paper
- 30 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Twentieth Century British History
- Vol. 33 (3) , 451-459
Open AccessHistorians’ Uses of Archived Material from Sociological Research: A Response to the Commentaries on My Paper
- Open Access
- 30 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Twentieth Century British History
- Vol. 33 (3) , 394-411
Historians’ Uses of Archived Material from Sociological Research: Some Observations with Reference to the Affluent Worker Study
Of late, historians of twentieth-century Britain have made increasing use of archived material from sociological research. Such use is examined in the case of the Affluent Worker study. It is argued that established historiographical practice needs to be maintained, and careful consideration given to the provenance and purposes of the documentary material that is drawn upon—with close reference to the context, objectives, and design of the original research. So far as the Affluent Worker study is concerned, such a consideration has not always been adequate, and with untoward consequences. Further, where, as with the Affluent Worker study, the original research was of a survey-based, quantitative kind, serious methodological differences regarding data analysis can arise. These become most apparent where the re-use of the relics of such research is aimed at qualifying the conclusions of its authors or at critically ‘deconstructing’ the research processes in which they were involved.
- 30 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Twentieth Century British History
- Vol. 33 (3) , 394-411
Open AccessHistorians’ Uses of Archived Material from Sociological Research: Some Observations with Reference to the Affluent Worker Study
Of late, historians of twentieth-century Britain have made increasing use of archived material from sociological research. Such use is examined in the case of the Affluent Worker study. It is argued that established historiographical practice needs to be maintained, and careful consideration given to the provenance and purposes of the documentary material that is drawn upon—with close reference to the context, objectives, and design of the original research. So far as the Affluent Worker study is concerned, such a consideration has not always been adequate, and with untoward consequences. Further, where, as with the Affluent Worker study, the original research was of a survey-based, quantitative kind, serious methodological differences regarding data analysis can arise. These become most apparent where the re-use of the relics of such research is aimed at qualifying the conclusions of its authors or at critically ‘deconstructing’ the research processes in which they were involved.
- Open Access
- 3 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (3) , 627-650
Primary and secondary effects of social origins on educational attainment: New findings for England
We aim to bring together two current strands of research into inequalities in individuals’ educational attainment that are associated with their social origins: that concerned with the “primary” and “secondary” effects of social origins in creating inequalities, and that concerned with the relation between these inequalities and different components of social origins, taken to represent different forms of parental resources. Our main findings are the following. The secondary effects of social origins—their effects via the educational choices that young people make given their prior academic performance—are clearly operative across five key educational transitions within the English educational system. More specifically, we estimate that 35% of the total effect of social origins is secondary in the earliest transition that we consider, and from 15% to 20% in the subsequent four. Furthermore, mediation analyses reveal that secondary effects are most strongly associated with parental education and then, to a lesser degree with parental status, while little association exists with parental class and none at all with parental income. Primary effects are also at all transitions most strongly associated with parental education and status but in this case both parental class and parental income do retain some importance. We suggest an explanation for our empirical findings as resulting largely from the concern of highly educated, professional parents, and their children to avoid the occurrence of downward intergenerational mobility, especially in terms of education and status.
- 3 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (3) , 627-650
Open AccessPrimary and secondary effects of social origins on educational attainment: New findings for England
We aim to bring together two current strands of research into inequalities in individuals’ educational attainment that are associated with their social origins: that concerned with the “primary” and “secondary” effects of social origins in creating inequalities, and that concerned with the relation between these inequalities and different components of social origins, taken to represent different forms of parental resources. Our main findings are the following. The secondary effects of social origins—their effects via the educational choices that young people make given their prior academic performance—are clearly operative across five key educational transitions within the English educational system. More specifically, we estimate that 35% of the total effect of social origins is secondary in the earliest transition that we consider, and from 15% to 20% in the subsequent four. Furthermore, mediation analyses reveal that secondary effects are most strongly associated with parental education and then, to a lesser degree with parental status, while little association exists with parental class and none at all with parental income. Primary effects are also at all transitions most strongly associated with parental education and status but in this case both parental class and parental income do retain some importance. We suggest an explanation for our empirical findings as resulting largely from the concern of highly educated, professional parents, and their children to avoid the occurrence of downward intergenerational mobility, especially in terms of education and status.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (2) , 239-251
Class and status in interwar England: Current issues in the light of a historical case
There has been much recent discussion concerning the conceptual and empirical viability and value of the distinction between social class and social status, and in particular as implemented in the work of Chan and Goldthorpe. The present paper addresses certain of the issues that arise on the basis of a historical case, that of class and status in interwar England, with reference to housing, sports club membership, and dress. It seeks to show that, contrary to what has been claimed by various authors, the distinction can be effectively made and is indeed necessary to an understanding of these features of the social history of the period; that it is differential association that has to be seen as constitutive of status stratification, rather than differences in lifestyle; and that increased status striving, anxieties, and segregation, with adverse psychological consequences, can result from a narrowing as well as from a widening of class inequalities.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (2) , 239-251
Open AccessClass and status in interwar England: Current issues in the light of a historical case
There has been much recent discussion concerning the conceptual and empirical viability and value of the distinction between social class and social status, and in particular as implemented in the work of Chan and Goldthorpe. The present paper addresses certain of the issues that arise on the basis of a historical case, that of class and status in interwar England, with reference to housing, sports club membership, and dress. It seeks to show that, contrary to what has been claimed by various authors, the distinction can be effectively made and is indeed necessary to an understanding of these features of the social history of the period; that it is differential association that has to be seen as constitutive of status stratification, rather than differences in lifestyle; and that increased status striving, anxieties, and segregation, with adverse psychological consequences, can result from a narrowing as well as from a widening of class inequalities.