PMPaul McElhany

Paul McElhany

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Paul McElhany has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Reply on RC1

    by Paul McElhany, Mattias Cape, Giulia Faucher, Christina Frieder, Lenaïg G. Hemery, Debora Iglesias-Rodriguez, Christopher S. Murray, Wesley Noble

    Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) encompasses a variety of approaches to actively remove CO2 from the atmosphere, which, given current and projected emissions, is necessary to keep global average temperature increases to less than 2 °C. In addition to the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere, mCDR projects would have effects on the marine environment, including changes in ocean carbonate chemistry. These changes in carbonate chemistry can affect marine organisms through multiple physiological pathways. Although research on the effects of ocean acidification over the last fifteen years has advanced understanding of the effects of low pH/high CO2 conditions on marine organisms, much less is known about organismal response to the high pH/low CO2 or high alkalinity conditions that can be generated by some mCDR methods. We created a database of available information on marine species response to the carbonate chemistry conditions that can be generated by mCDR with a focus on identifying carbonate chemistry thresholds at which biological responses occur. The database contains 310 studies, from which we estimated 276 thresholds. In addition to all mCDR studies available to date, we reviewed studies not explicitly designed to address mCDR. These studies used natural and artificially manipulated variations in carbonate chemistry, including increasing pH and alkalinity, to explore basic physiological and biological responses as well as approaches to mitigate ocean acidification. In analyzing the database, we considered a variety of biological responses, both positive and negative, and considered sensitivity by taxa, exposure duration, treatment method and other factors. Using practical definitions of a threshold, including one based on the treatment level leading to the first statistically significant biological response, we describe the distribution of pH and alkalinity threshold values. The data reveal a high tolerance for high pH (>12) and high alkalinity for some species responses under some experimental conditions, but negative response to experimental conditions only slightly above ambient (pH 8.3) for other species responses. A positive effect of pH above ambient levels was observed in six cases, just 3 % of the total. We summarize results by presenting the distributions of threshold estimates collected from individual studies. The uncertainty and variation in organismal response represents a challenge for the development of management guidelines for the developing mCDR industry. Building on our review of existing studies, we suggest several paths forward for improved biological threshold estimates for mCDR-relevant carbonate chemistry conditions.

  • Open Access

    Reply on RC2

    by Paul McElhany, Mattias Cape, Giulia Faucher, Christina Frieder, Lenaïg G. Hemery, Debora Iglesias-Rodriguez, Christopher S. Murray, Wesley Noble

    Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) encompasses a variety of approaches to actively remove CO2 from the atmosphere, which, given current and projected emissions, is necessary to keep global average temperature increases to less than 2 °C. In addition to the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere, mCDR projects would have effects on the marine environment, including changes in ocean carbonate chemistry. These changes in carbonate chemistry can affect marine organisms through multiple physiological pathways. Although research on the effects of ocean acidification over the last fifteen years has advanced understanding of the effects of low pH/high CO2 conditions on marine organisms, much less is known about organismal response to the high pH/low CO2 or high alkalinity conditions that can be generated by some mCDR methods. We created a database of available information on marine species response to the carbonate chemistry conditions that can be generated by mCDR with a focus on identifying carbonate chemistry thresholds at which biological responses occur. The database contains 310 studies, from which we estimated 276 thresholds. In addition to all mCDR studies available to date, we reviewed studies not explicitly designed to address mCDR. These studies used natural and artificially manipulated variations in carbonate chemistry, including increasing pH and alkalinity, to explore basic physiological and biological responses as well as approaches to mitigate ocean acidification. In analyzing the database, we considered a variety of biological responses, both positive and negative, and considered sensitivity by taxa, exposure duration, treatment method and other factors. Using practical definitions of a threshold, including one based on the treatment level leading to the first statistically significant biological response, we describe the distribution of pH and alkalinity threshold values. The data reveal a high tolerance for high pH (>12) and high alkalinity for some species responses under some experimental conditions, but negative response to experimental conditions only slightly above ambient (pH 8.3) for other species responses. A positive effect of pH above ambient levels was observed in six cases, just 3 % of the total. We summarize results by presenting the distributions of threshold estimates collected from individual studies. The uncertainty and variation in organismal response represents a challenge for the development of management guidelines for the developing mCDR industry. Building on our review of existing studies, we suggest several paths forward for improved biological threshold estimates for mCDR-relevant carbonate chemistry conditions.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2026-1597

    by Paul McElhany, Mattias Cape, Giulia Faucher, Christina Frieder, Lenaïg G. Hemery, Debora Iglesias-Rodriguez, Christopher S. Murray, Wesley Noble

    Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) encompasses a variety of approaches to actively remove CO2 from the atmosphere, which, given current and projected emissions, is necessary to keep global average temperature increases to less than 2 °C. In addition to the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere, mCDR projects would have effects on the marine environment, including changes in ocean carbonate chemistry. These changes in carbonate chemistry can affect marine organisms through multiple physiological pathways. Although research on the effects of ocean acidification over the last fifteen years has advanced understanding of the effects of low pH/high CO2 conditions on marine organisms, much less is known about organismal response to the high pH/low CO2 or high alkalinity conditions that can be generated by some mCDR methods. We created a database of available information on marine species response to the carbonate chemistry conditions that can be generated by mCDR with a focus on identifying carbonate chemistry thresholds at which biological responses occur. The database contains 310 studies, from which we estimated 276 thresholds. In addition to all mCDR studies available to date, we reviewed studies not explicitly designed to address mCDR. These studies used natural and artificially manipulated variations in carbonate chemistry, including increasing pH and alkalinity, to explore basic physiological and biological responses as well as approaches to mitigate ocean acidification. In analyzing the database, we considered a variety of biological responses, both positive and negative, and considered sensitivity by taxa, exposure duration, treatment method and other factors. Using practical definitions of a threshold, including one based on the treatment level leading to the first statistically significant biological response, we describe the distribution of pH and alkalinity threshold values. The data reveal a high tolerance for high pH (>12) and high alkalinity for some species responses under some experimental conditions, but negative response to experimental conditions only slightly above ambient (pH 8.3) for other species responses. A positive effect of pH above ambient levels was observed in six cases, just 3 % of the total. We summarize results by presenting the distributions of threshold estimates collected from individual studies. The uncertainty and variation in organismal response represents a challenge for the development of management guidelines for the developing mCDR industry. Building on our review of existing studies, we suggest several paths forward for improved biological threshold estimates for mCDR-relevant carbonate chemistry conditions.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2026-1597

    by Paul McElhany, Mattias Cape, Giulia Faucher, Christina Frieder, Lenaïg G. Hemery, Debora Iglesias-Rodriguez, Christopher S. Murray, Wesley Noble

    Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) encompasses a variety of approaches to actively remove CO2 from the atmosphere, which, given current and projected emissions, is necessary to keep global average temperature increases to less than 2 °C. In addition to the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere, mCDR projects would have effects on the marine environment, including changes in ocean carbonate chemistry. These changes in carbonate chemistry can affect marine organisms through multiple physiological pathways. Although research on the effects of ocean acidification over the last fifteen years has advanced understanding of the effects of low pH/high CO2 conditions on marine organisms, much less is known about organismal response to the high pH/low CO2 or high alkalinity conditions that can be generated by some mCDR methods. We created a database of available information on marine species response to the carbonate chemistry conditions that can be generated by mCDR with a focus on identifying carbonate chemistry thresholds at which biological responses occur. The database contains 310 studies, from which we estimated 276 thresholds. In addition to all mCDR studies available to date, we reviewed studies not explicitly designed to address mCDR. These studies used natural and artificially manipulated variations in carbonate chemistry, including increasing pH and alkalinity, to explore basic physiological and biological responses as well as approaches to mitigate ocean acidification. In analyzing the database, we considered a variety of biological responses, both positive and negative, and considered sensitivity by taxa, exposure duration, treatment method and other factors. Using practical definitions of a threshold, including one based on the treatment level leading to the first statistically significant biological response, we describe the distribution of pH and alkalinity threshold values. The data reveal a high tolerance for high pH (>12) and high alkalinity for some species responses under some experimental conditions, but negative response to experimental conditions only slightly above ambient (pH 8.3) for other species responses. A positive effect of pH above ambient levels was observed in six cases, just 3 % of the total. We summarize results by presenting the distributions of threshold estimates collected from individual studies. The uncertainty and variation in organismal response represents a challenge for the development of management guidelines for the developing mCDR industry. Building on our review of existing studies, we suggest several paths forward for improved biological threshold estimates for mCDR-relevant carbonate chemistry conditions.

  • Open Access

    Biological thresholds for marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR): the effect of changes in carbonate chemistry

    by Paul McElhany, Mattias Cape, Giulia Faucher, Christina Frieder, Lenaïg G. Hemery, Debora Iglesias-Rodriguez, Christopher S. Murray, Wesley Noble

    Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) encompasses a variety of approaches to actively remove CO2 from the atmosphere, which, given current and projected emissions, is necessary to keep global average temperature increases to less than 2 °C. In addition to the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere, mCDR projects would have effects on the marine environment, including changes in ocean carbonate chemistry. These changes in carbonate chemistry can affect marine organisms through multiple physiological pathways. Although research on the effects of ocean acidification over the last fifteen years has advanced understanding of the effects of low pH/high CO2 conditions on marine organisms, much less is known about organismal response to the high pH/low CO2 or high alkalinity conditions that can be generated by some mCDR methods. We created a database of available information on marine species response to the carbonate chemistry conditions that can be generated by mCDR with a focus on identifying carbonate chemistry thresholds at which biological responses occur. The database contains 310 studies, from which we estimated 276 thresholds. In addition to all mCDR studies available to date, we reviewed studies not explicitly designed to address mCDR. These studies used natural and artificially manipulated variations in carbonate chemistry, including increasing pH and alkalinity, to explore basic physiological and biological responses as well as approaches to mitigate ocean acidification. In analyzing the database, we considered a variety of biological responses, both positive and negative, and considered sensitivity by taxa, exposure duration, treatment method and other factors. Using practical definitions of a threshold, including one based on the treatment level leading to the first statistically significant biological response, we describe the distribution of pH and alkalinity threshold values. The data reveal a high tolerance for high pH (>12) and high alkalinity for some species responses under some experimental conditions, but negative response to experimental conditions only slightly above ambient (pH 8.3) for other species responses. A positive effect of pH above ambient levels was observed in six cases, just 3 % of the total. We summarize results by presenting the distributions of threshold estimates collected from individual studies. The uncertainty and variation in organismal response represents a challenge for the development of management guidelines for the developing mCDR industry. Building on our review of existing studies, we suggest several paths forward for improved biological threshold estimates for mCDR-relevant carbonate chemistry conditions.


  • Open Access

    Ocean acidification thresholds for decapods are unresolved

    by Paul McElhany, D. Shallin Busch

    A published analysis of ocean acidification thresholds for decapod crustaceans highlights data showing the negative effects of low pH on many species. However, the methods used in the paper have substantial flaws that call into question the proposed thresholds. The quantitative metrics calculated for the meta-analysis are uninformative with respect to pH sensitivity, which raises concerns about the validity of the thresholds developed by the expert opinion process. We recommend against using the published thresholds and for a reanalysis of the data to identify new thresholds.


  • Open Access

    Uncovering mechanisms of global ocean change effects on the Dungeness crab ( Cancer magister ) through metabolomics analysis

    by Shelly A. Trigg, Paul McElhany, Michael Maher, Danielle Perez, D. Shallin Busch, Krista M. Nichols

    The Dungeness crab is an economically and ecologically important species distributed along the North American Pacific coast. To predict how Dungeness crab may physiologically respond to future global ocean change on a molecular level, we performed untargeted metabolomic approaches on individual Dungeness crab juveniles reared in treatments that mimicked current and projected future pH and dissolved oxygen conditions. We found 94 metabolites and 127 lipids responded in a condition-specific manner, with a greater number of known compounds more strongly responding to low oxygen than low pH exposure. Pathway analysis of these compounds revealed that juveniles may respond to low oxygen through evolutionarily conserved processes including downregulating glutathione biosynthesis and upregulating glycogen storage, and may respond to low pH by increasing ATP production. Most interestingly, we found that the response of juveniles to combined low pH and low oxygen exposure was most similar to the low oxygen exposure response, indicating low oxygen may drive the physiology of juvenile crabs more than pH. Our study elucidates metabolic dynamics that expand our overall understanding of how the species might respond to future ocean conditions and provides a comprehensive dataset that could be used in future ocean acidification response studies.

  • Open Access

    Using mineralogy and higher-level taxonomy as indicators of species sensitivity to pH: A case-study of Puget Sound

    by Shallin Busch, Paul McElhany

    Information on ecosystem sensitivity to global change can help guide management decisions. Here, we characterize the sensitivity of the Puget Sound ecosystem to ocean acidification by estimating, at a number of taxonomic levels, the direct sensitivity of its species. We compare sensitivity estimates based on species mineralogy and on published literature from laboratory experiments and field studies. We generated information on the former by building a database of species in Puget Sound with mineralogy estimates for all CaCO3-forming species. For the latter, we relied on a recently developed database and meta-analysis on temperate species responses to increased CO2. In general, species sensitivity estimates based on the published literature suggest that calcifying species are more sensitive to increased CO2 than non-calcifying species. However, this generalization is incomplete, as non-calcifying species also show direct sensitivity to high CO2 conditions. We did not find a strong link between mineral solubility and the sensitivity of species survival to changes in carbonate chemistry, suggesting that, at coarse scales, mineralogy plays a lesser role to other physiological sensitivities. Summarizing species sensitivity at the family level resulted in higher sensitivity scalar scores than at the class level, suggesting that grouping results at the class level may overestimate species sensitivity. This result raises caution about the use of broad generalizations on species response to ocean acidification, particularly when developing summary information for specific locations. While we have much to learn about species response to ocean acidification and how to generalize ecosystem response, this study on Puget Sound suggests that detailed information on species performance under elevated carbon dioxide conditions, summarized at the lowest taxonomic level possible, is more valuable than information on species mineralogy.


  • Open Access

    CO2 sensitivity experiments are not sufficient to show an effect of ocean acidification

    by Paul McElhany

    The ocean acidification (OA) literature is replete with laboratory studies that report species sensitivity to seawater carbonate chemistry in experimental treatments as an “effect of OA”. I argue that this is unintentionally misleading, since these studies do not actually demonstrate an effect of OA but rather show sensitivity to CO2. Documenting an effect of OA involves showing a change in a species (e.g. population abundance or distribution) as a consequence of anthropogenic changes in marine carbonate chemistry. To date, there have been no unambiguous demonstrations of a population level effect of anthropogenic OA, as that term is defined by the IPCC.


  • Appropriate pCO2 treatments in ocean acidification experiments

    by Paul McElhany, D. Shallin Busch