Didier Maillat
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Didier Maillat has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Steve Oswald
University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
4 shared publications - Cecilia Serra
Universite de Geneve , Switzerland
1 shared publication Kira Boulat
Department of English, Université de Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
1 shared publication- Kira Boulat
University of Fribourg
1 shared publication - Louis de Saussure
University of Neuchâtel
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 3 January 2024
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company
- p. 62-84
Manipulation in exceptional times
This chapter offers a cognitively-grounded account of manipulative strategies speakers may use to challenge and discredit scientific discourse in times of crisis, in which the perceived reliability of scientific communication is vulnerable. Specifically, we explore how such an overwhelming context is ideally suited for manipulative attempts to spread misinformation. We illustrate our account by analysing two strategies: one by which political authorities attempted to discredit scientific expertise, and one by which minority experts tried to weaken mainstream scientific expertise. In so doing, we provide a principled account of the way manipulation targeting expert voices in public discourse can affect an audience’s epistemic vigilance mechanisms, while offering insights into the role overwhelming contexts can play in bringing about these manipulative effects.
- 3 January 2024
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company
- p. 62-84
Manipulation in exceptional times
This chapter offers a cognitively-grounded account of manipulative strategies speakers may use to challenge and discredit scientific discourse in times of crisis, in which the perceived reliability of scientific communication is vulnerable. Specifically, we explore how such an overwhelming context is ideally suited for manipulative attempts to spread misinformation. We illustrate our account by analysing two strategies: one by which political authorities attempted to discredit scientific expertise, and one by which minority experts tried to weaken mainstream scientific expertise. In so doing, we provide a principled account of the way manipulation targeting expert voices in public discourse can affect an audience’s epistemic vigilance mechanisms, while offering insights into the role overwhelming contexts can play in bringing about these manipulative effects.
- 27 July 2023
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Pragmatics
- Vol. 33 (3) , 460-485
On the manifestness of assumptions
Right from the outset, relevance theory (Sperber and Wilson 1986/1995) tried to define interpretation as a process of context elaboration. Interpretation is seen as a path of least effort leading to the selection of a set of most accessible assumptions. One of the central aspects of this context elaboration process lies in the fact that contextual assumptions are not randomly scattered in the hearer’s cognitive environment. Instead, relevance theory claims that there are some organising principles ordering contextual assumptions and determining which will be accessed first and, therefore, which will be retained as part of the optimally relevant interpretation. The main organising principle is captured by the notion of manifestness, which combines two distinct properties of contextual assumptions: their accessibility and their strength in the cognitive environment. Sperber and Wilson (1986/1995) define them as a function of the processing history of an assumption for the former and the confidence with which an assumption is held for the latter. In this paper, I will explore the explanatory potential of manifestness by putting the notions of strength and accessibility to work on two current trends in pragmatic research, namely commitment (Ifantidou 2001; Boulat and Maillat 2017, 2023; Mazzarella et al. 2018; Bonalumi et al. 2020) and emotion (Moeschler 2009; Dezecache et al. 2013, 2015; Wharton and Strey 2019; Wilson and Carston 2019; Saussure and Wharton 2020; Wharton et al. 2021). My goal will be to show how these two dimensions of manifestness, as they were developed in the very early days of RT, can provide us with new theoretical insights in the study of human communication. In this paper, I will argue that, beyond their usefulness in providing a guiding principle for the comprehension procedure, the strength and accessibility of contextual assumptions can also advantageously shed light on other phenomena like commitment and emotions.
- 27 July 2023
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Pragmatics
- Vol. 33 (3) , 460-485
On the manifestness of assumptions
Right from the outset, relevance theory (Sperber and Wilson 1986/1995) tried to define interpretation as a process of context elaboration. Interpretation is seen as a path of least effort leading to the selection of a set of most accessible assumptions. One of the central aspects of this context elaboration process lies in the fact that contextual assumptions are not randomly scattered in the hearer’s cognitive environment. Instead, relevance theory claims that there are some organising principles ordering contextual assumptions and determining which will be accessed first and, therefore, which will be retained as part of the optimally relevant interpretation. The main organising principle is captured by the notion of manifestness, which combines two distinct properties of contextual assumptions: their accessibility and their strength in the cognitive environment. Sperber and Wilson (1986/1995) define them as a function of the processing history of an assumption for the former and the confidence with which an assumption is held for the latter. In this paper, I will explore the explanatory potential of manifestness by putting the notions of strength and accessibility to work on two current trends in pragmatic research, namely commitment (Ifantidou 2001; Boulat and Maillat 2017, 2023; Mazzarella et al. 2018; Bonalumi et al. 2020) and emotion (Moeschler 2009; Dezecache et al. 2013, 2015; Wharton and Strey 2019; Wilson and Carston 2019; Saussure and Wharton 2020; Wharton et al. 2021). My goal will be to show how these two dimensions of manifestness, as they were developed in the very early days of RT, can provide us with new theoretical insights in the study of human communication. In this paper, I will argue that, beyond their usefulness in providing a guiding principle for the comprehension procedure, the strength and accessibility of contextual assumptions can also advantageously shed light on other phenomena like commitment and emotions.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Communication
- Vol. 8, 1176845
Strength is relevant: experimental evidence of strength as a marker of commitment
When relevance theory tried to express the underlying processes involved during interpretation, Sperber and Wilson posited a process of context elaboration in which interpretation is seen as a path of least effort leading to the selection of a set of most salient contextual assumptions and implications. In this view, contextual assumptions are not randomly scattered in the hearer's cognitive environment during this context elaboration process. Instead, Relevance Theory claims that there are some organizing principles ordering contextual assumptions and determining which assumptions will be more likely to be accessed first in the process. The focus of this paper is on one such organizing principle captured by the notion of strength. Sperber and Wilson define it as the degree of confidence with which an assumption is held. While this notion has been posited right from the early days of Relevance theory, it has been left relatively untouched in relevance-theoretic accounts. In this paper, we will assess the explanatory potential of the notion of strength by linking it to the much-debated range of phenomena understood as related to commitment, i.e., the degree of speaker involvement in the truth of their utterance. Our goal will be to argue for a theoretical account of strength, in which strength is regarded as a cognitive marker of commitment, and more generally of the epistemic value of an utterance. In order to support this claim, we will present a series of original experimental designs in which we manipulated the level of speaker commitment in the information conveyed by their utterance. We predicted, on the basis of the theoretical model put forward, that such a manipulation would impact the level of strength. This cognitive effect, it is claimed, can in turn be measured through a recall task. We present results which support this model and discuss its implications.
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Communication
- Vol. 8, 1176845
Open AccessStrength is relevant: experimental evidence of strength as a marker of commitment
When relevance theory tried to express the underlying processes involved during interpretation, Sperber and Wilson posited a process of context elaboration in which interpretation is seen as a path of least effort leading to the selection of a set of most salient contextual assumptions and implications. In this view, contextual assumptions are not randomly scattered in the hearer's cognitive environment during this context elaboration process. Instead, Relevance Theory claims that there are some organizing principles ordering contextual assumptions and determining which assumptions will be more likely to be accessed first in the process. The focus of this paper is on one such organizing principle captured by the notion of strength. Sperber and Wilson define it as the degree of confidence with which an assumption is held. While this notion has been posited right from the early days of Relevance theory, it has been left relatively untouched in relevance-theoretic accounts. In this paper, we will assess the explanatory potential of the notion of strength by linking it to the much-debated range of phenomena understood as related to commitment, i.e., the degree of speaker involvement in the truth of their utterance. Our goal will be to argue for a theoretical account of strength, in which strength is regarded as a cognitive marker of commitment, and more generally of the epistemic value of an utterance. In order to support this claim, we will present a series of original experimental designs in which we manipulated the level of speaker commitment in the information conveyed by their utterance. We predicted, on the basis of the theoretical model put forward, that such a manipulation would impact the level of strength. This cognitive effect, it is claimed, can in turn be measured through a recall task. We present results which support this model and discuss its implications.
- Open Access
- 19 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Pragmatics
- Vol. 205, 157-168
Getting your inferences in order: Limiting variability in pragmatic inferences
- 19 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Pragmatics
- Vol. 205, 157-168
Open AccessGetting your inferences in order: Limiting variability in pragmatic inferences
- 4 May 2020
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Journal of Argumentation in Context
- Vol. 9 (1) , 124-147
The Argument and the Honey Pot
This paper proposes to harness the linguistic theory that looks at the construction of meaning in context – i.e., pragmatics – to investigate the contextual effects bearing on the interpretation of arguments in manipulative seduction contexts. Adopting a cognitively grounded relevance-theoretic approach, I will show that deceptive seduction is used primarily to strengthen the hearer’s perception of the seducer, thereby strengthening the standpoints and arguments s/he puts forward. In that sense, it will be argued, seductive moves function like contextual constraints on the interpretative processes. Exploring further the cognitive grounding of human interpretative processes, I will claim that many seductive manipulations rely on the halo effect – the cognitive bias whereby a positive trait (e.g., attractiveness) tends to spill over other personality traits (e.g., competence) – to create a contextual environment that will boost argument evaluation.
- 4 May 2020
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Journal of Argumentation in Context
- Vol. 9 (1) , 124-147
The Argument and the Honey Pot
This paper proposes to harness the linguistic theory that looks at the construction of meaning in context – i.e., pragmatics – to investigate the contextual effects bearing on the interpretation of arguments in manipulative seduction contexts. Adopting a cognitively grounded relevance-theoretic approach, I will show that deceptive seduction is used primarily to strengthen the hearer’s perception of the seducer, thereby strengthening the standpoints and arguments s/he puts forward. In that sense, it will be argued, seductive moves function like contextual constraints on the interpretative processes. Exploring further the cognitive grounding of human interpretative processes, I will claim that many seductive manipulations rely on the halo effect – the cognitive bias whereby a positive trait (e.g., attractiveness) tends to spill over other personality traits (e.g., competence) – to create a contextual environment that will boost argument evaluation.
- 21 March 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 261-279
She Said You Said I Saw It with My Own Eyes: A Pragmatic Account of Commitment
- 21 March 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 261-279
She Said You Said I Saw It with My Own Eyes: A Pragmatic Account of Commitment
- Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- Published by OpenEdition in E-rea
- Vol. 15.1 (15.1)
Les manipulations du discours de séduction : éclairage pragmatique
Le discours manipulatoire peut se décrire comme une stratégie visant à faire dérailler les processus interprétatifs. Au moyen de la théorie pragmatique de la Contrainte de Sélection de Contexte, on explique comment un locuteur-manipulateur peut infléchir à son avantage les mécanismes d'interprétation du destinataire. Cet article montre ainsi que certaines stratégies manipulatoires exploitent la séduction pour mettre en place des contraintes fortes à même de piéger l'interprétation du destinataire. L'explication proposée met notamment en jeu certains phénomènes de biais cognitifs bien connus de la littérature en psychologie cognitive pour expliquer les effets recherchés par les stratégies de séduction.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by OpenEdition in E-rea
- Vol. 15.1 (15.1)
Open AccessLes manipulations du discours de séduction : éclairage pragmatique
Le discours manipulatoire peut se décrire comme une stratégie visant à faire dérailler les processus interprétatifs. Au moyen de la théorie pragmatique de la Contrainte de Sélection de Contexte, on explique comment un locuteur-manipulateur peut infléchir à son avantage les mécanismes d'interprétation du destinataire. Cet article montre ainsi que certaines stratégies manipulatoires exploitent la séduction pour mettre en place des contraintes fortes à même de piéger l'interprétation du destinataire. L'explication proposée met notamment en jeu certains phénomènes de biais cognitifs bien connus de la littérature en psychologie cognitive pour expliquer les effets recherchés par les stratégies de séduction.
- 23 October 2016
- Published by Wiley
- p. 1-9
Relevance Theory
- 7 March 2016
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH
- p. 509-534
25. Deceptive and uncooperative verbal communication
- 7 March 2016
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH
- p. 509-534
25. Deceptive and uncooperative verbal communication
- 1 December 2013
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Pragmatics
- Vol. 59, 137-140
Biases and constraints in communication: Argumentation, persuasion and manipulation
- 1 December 2013
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Pragmatics
- Vol. 59, 137-140
Biases and constraints in communication: Argumentation, persuasion and manipulation