Ian Hughes
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Ian Hughes has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Rick Budd
Ludlow Street Healthcare, Llanbedr Court, Newport, Wales, UK
2 shared publicationsDarren James
Psychology and Counselling Directorate, Whitchurch Hospital, Cardiff, Wales, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 2 September 2009
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
- Vol. 16 (6) , 510-522
The Dodo Bird Verdict—controversial, inevitable and important: a commentary on 30 years of meta‐analyses
In this article, the assertion that different psychological therapies are of broadly similar efficacy—often called the ‘Dodo Bird Verdict’—is contrasted with the alternative view that there are specific therapies that are more effective than others for particular diagnoses. We note that, despite thirty years of meta‐analytic reviews tending to support the finding of therapy equivalence, this view is still controversial and has not been accepted by many within the psychological therapy community; we explore this from a theory of science perspective. It is further argued that the equivalence of ostensibly different therapies is an inevitable consequence of the methodology that has dominated this field of investigation; namely, randomised controlled trials [RCTs]. The implicit assumptions of RCTs are analysed and it is argued that what we know about psychological therapy indicates that it is not appropriate to treat ‘type of therapy’ and ‘diagnosis’ as if they were independent variables in an experimental design. It is noted that one logical consequence of this is that we would not expect RCTs to be capable of isolating effects that are specific to ‘type of therapy’ and ‘diagnosis’. Rather, RCTs would only be expected to be capable of identifying the non‐specific effects of covariates, such as those of therapist allegiance. It is further suggested that those non‐specific effects that have been identified via meta‐analysis are not trivial findings, but rather characterise important features of psychological therapy. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 2 September 2009
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
- Vol. 16 (6) , 510-522
The Dodo Bird Verdict—controversial, inevitable and important: a commentary on 30 years of meta‐analyses
In this article, the assertion that different psychological therapies are of broadly similar efficacy—often called the ‘Dodo Bird Verdict’—is contrasted with the alternative view that there are specific therapies that are more effective than others for particular diagnoses. We note that, despite thirty years of meta‐analytic reviews tending to support the finding of therapy equivalence, this view is still controversial and has not been accepted by many within the psychological therapy community; we explore this from a theory of science perspective. It is further argued that the equivalence of ostensibly different therapies is an inevitable consequence of the methodology that has dominated this field of investigation; namely, randomised controlled trials [RCTs]. The implicit assumptions of RCTs are analysed and it is argued that what we know about psychological therapy indicates that it is not appropriate to treat ‘type of therapy’ and ‘diagnosis’ as if they were independent variables in an experimental design. It is noted that one logical consequence of this is that we would not expect RCTs to be capable of isolating effects that are specific to ‘type of therapy’ and ‘diagnosis’. Rather, RCTs would only be expected to be capable of identifying the non‐specific effects of covariates, such as those of therapist allegiance. It is further suggested that those non‐specific effects that have been identified via meta‐analysis are not trivial findings, but rather characterise important features of psychological therapy. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
- Vol. 15 (1) , 28-37
Patients' explanations for depression: a factor analytic study
Objectives: Previous questionnaire studies have attempted to explore the factor structure of lay beliefs about the causes of depression. These studies have tended to either fail to sample the full range of possible causal explanations or extract too many factors, thereby producing complex solutions. The main objective of the present study was to obtain a more complete and robust factor structure of lay theories of depression while more adequately sampling from the full range of hypothesized causes of depression. A second objective of the study was to explore the relationship between respondents' explanations for depression and their perceptions of the helpfulness of different treatments received. Method and design: A 77‐item questionnaire comprising possible reasons for ‘why a person might get depressed’ was mailed out to members of a large self‐help organization. Also included was a short questionnaire inviting respondents to note treatments received and their perceptions of the helpfulness of these treatments. Data from the 77‐item questionnaire were subjected to a principal components analysis. Results: The reasons rated as most important causes of depression related to recent bereavement, imbalance in brain chemistry and having suffered sexual assault/abuse. The data were best described by a two‐factor solution, with the first factor clearly representing stress and the second factor depressogenic beliefs, the latter corresponding to a cognitive–behavioural formulation of depression aetiology. The two scales thus derived did not, however, correspond substantially with rated helpfulness for different treatments received. Conclusions: The factor structure obtained was in contrast to more complex models from previous studies, comprising two factors. It is likely to be more robust and meaningful. It accords with previous research on lay theories of depression, which highlight ‘stress’ as a key cause for depression. Possible limitations in the study are discussed, and it is suggested that using the questionnaire with more recently depressed people might yield clearer findings in relation to perceptions of treatment helpfulness. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
- Vol. 15 (1) , 28-37
Patients' explanations for depression: a factor analytic study
Objectives: Previous questionnaire studies have attempted to explore the factor structure of lay beliefs about the causes of depression. These studies have tended to either fail to sample the full range of possible causal explanations or extract too many factors, thereby producing complex solutions. The main objective of the present study was to obtain a more complete and robust factor structure of lay theories of depression while more adequately sampling from the full range of hypothesized causes of depression. A second objective of the study was to explore the relationship between respondents' explanations for depression and their perceptions of the helpfulness of different treatments received. Method and design: A 77‐item questionnaire comprising possible reasons for ‘why a person might get depressed’ was mailed out to members of a large self‐help organization. Also included was a short questionnaire inviting respondents to note treatments received and their perceptions of the helpfulness of these treatments. Data from the 77‐item questionnaire were subjected to a principal components analysis. Results: The reasons rated as most important causes of depression related to recent bereavement, imbalance in brain chemistry and having suffered sexual assault/abuse. The data were best described by a two‐factor solution, with the first factor clearly representing stress and the second factor depressogenic beliefs, the latter corresponding to a cognitive–behavioural formulation of depression aetiology. The two scales thus derived did not, however, correspond substantially with rated helpfulness for different treatments received. Conclusions: The factor structure obtained was in contrast to more complex models from previous studies, comprising two factors. It is likely to be more robust and meaningful. It accords with previous research on lay theories of depression, which highlight ‘stress’ as a key cause for depression. Possible limitations in the study are discussed, and it is suggested that using the questionnaire with more recently depressed people might yield clearer findings in relation to perceptions of treatment helpfulness. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.