Steve Woolgar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Steve Woolgar has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Daniel Neyland
Goldsmiths, University of London
11 shared publications - Catelijne Coopmans
Department of Thematic Studies (Technology and Social Change), Linköping University, Sweden
2 shared publications Javier Lezaun
Institute for Science, Innovation and Society (InSIS), School of Anthropology and Museum Ethnography, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 shared publications- Koichi Mikami
Keio University Hiyoshi Campus
1 shared publication - Tanja Schneider
Technical University of Denmark
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in The American Sociologist
- Vol. 53 (2) , 176-187
The Value of Strident Agnosticism: Dorothy Pawluch and the Endurance of Ontological Gerrymandering
This paper reflects on the origins and subsequent reception of the paper “Ontological Gerrymandering: The anatomy of social problems explanations”, published in 1985. It describes the circumstances of my turning up at McGill University as a Visiting Professor in Sociology and meeting Dorothy, then a graduate student and the TA assigned to an undergraduate course on Social Problems which I was asked to teach. The paper reflects on the twin benefits: of an interloper, from Europe and from Science and Technology Studies (STS), entering the exotic and heady fray of North American social problems; and of Dorothy’s steady and resolute guidance in introducing me to a new field. The paper suggests some reasons for the endurance of the paper’s arguments, more than 35 years after its publication, drawing on some parallel developments in Social Problems and STS. It asks why has there been rather little mutual interaction between these disciplines, given their common concern with questions, among others, about values, effects and interventions in academic scholarship. The paper concludes that many more of us might have done well to pursue the path of strident agnosticism.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in The American Sociologist
- Vol. 53 (2) , 176-187
Open AccessThe Value of Strident Agnosticism: Dorothy Pawluch and the Endurance of Ontological Gerrymandering
This paper reflects on the origins and subsequent reception of the paper “Ontological Gerrymandering: The anatomy of social problems explanations”, published in 1985. It describes the circumstances of my turning up at McGill University as a Visiting Professor in Sociology and meeting Dorothy, then a graduate student and the TA assigned to an undergraduate course on Social Problems which I was asked to teach. The paper reflects on the twin benefits: of an interloper, from Europe and from Science and Technology Studies (STS), entering the exotic and heady fray of North American social problems; and of Dorothy’s steady and resolute guidance in introducing me to a new field. The paper suggests some reasons for the endurance of the paper’s arguments, more than 35 years after its publication, drawing on some parallel developments in Social Problems and STS. It asks why has there been rather little mutual interaction between these disciplines, given their common concern with questions, among others, about values, effects and interventions in academic scholarship. The paper concludes that many more of us might have done well to pursue the path of strident agnosticism.
- Open Access
- 12 July 2018
- Published by Society for Social Studies of Science (4S) in Engaging Science, Technology, and Society
- Vol. 4, 303-319
STS as a Program of Ontological Disobedience: Koichi Mikami Talks with Steve Woolgar
Is science and technology studies (STS) a luxury that our society cannot afford anymore? In this interview, Koichi Mikami tries to learn lessons from Steve Woolgar’s distinguished career on how the kind of sensibilities treasured within the field of STS and the type of critical engagement that its researchers aspire to might be best exercised in a changing landscape of higher education and academic research. Woolgar explains how he, at some key moments in his career, managed to create “a room” for reflexive thought and critical engagement in domains that could otherwise have been dominated by simple deterministic discourses. He explains that the questions of how and to whom you sell your criticism deserve as much attention as what your criticism is. A reflection by Koichi Mikami follows the interview.
- 12 July 2018
- Published by Society for Social Studies of Science (4S) in Engaging Science, Technology, and Society
- Vol. 4, 303-319
Open AccessSTS as a Program of Ontological Disobedience: Koichi Mikami Talks with Steve Woolgar
Is science and technology studies (STS) a luxury that our society cannot afford anymore? In this interview, Koichi Mikami tries to learn lessons from Steve Woolgar’s distinguished career on how the kind of sensibilities treasured within the field of STS and the type of critical engagement that its researchers aspire to might be best exercised in a changing landscape of higher education and academic research. Woolgar explains how he, at some key moments in his career, managed to create “a room” for reflexive thought and critical engagement in domains that could otherwise have been dominated by simple deterministic discourses. He explains that the questions of how and to whom you sell your criticism deserve as much attention as what your criticism is. A reflection by Koichi Mikami follows the interview.
- 18 November 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in BioSocieties
- Vol. 10 (4) , 389-399
Neuroscience beyond the laboratory: Neuro knowledges, technologies and markets
- 18 November 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in BioSocieties
- Vol. 10 (4) , 389-399
Neuroscience beyond the laboratory: Neuro knowledges, technologies and markets
- 25 May 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Studies of Science
- Vol. 45 (3) , 462-467
Missing the (question) mark? What is a turn to ontology?
Our introductory essay in this journal’s 2013 Special Issue on the ‘turn to ontology’ examined the shift from epistemology to ontology in science and technology studies and explored the implications of the notion of enactment. Three responses to that Special Issue argue that (1) there is no fundamental qualitative difference between the ontological turn and social constructivism, (2) we need to be wary of overly generic use of the term ‘ontology’ and (3) the language of ‘turns’ imposes constraints on the richness and diversity of science and technology studies. In this brief reply, we show how each of those critiques varies in its commitment to circumspection about making objective determinations of reality and to resisting reification. We illustrate our point by considering overlapping discussions in anthropology. This brings out the crucial difference between the science and technology studies slogan ‘it could be otherwise’ and the multinaturalist motto ‘it actually is otherwise’.
- 25 May 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Studies of Science
- Vol. 45 (3) , 462-467
Missing the (question) mark? What is a turn to ontology?
Our introductory essay in this journal’s 2013 Special Issue on the ‘turn to ontology’ examined the shift from epistemology to ontology in science and technology studies and explored the implications of the notion of enactment. Three responses to that Special Issue argue that (1) there is no fundamental qualitative difference between the ontological turn and social constructivism, (2) we need to be wary of overly generic use of the term ‘ontology’ and (3) the language of ‘turns’ imposes constraints on the richness and diversity of science and technology studies. In this brief reply, we show how each of those critiques varies in its commitment to circumspection about making objective determinations of reality and to resisting reification. We illustrate our point by considering overlapping discussions in anthropology. This brings out the crucial difference between the science and technology studies slogan ‘it could be otherwise’ and the multinaturalist motto ‘it actually is otherwise’.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 248-266
Conclusions
Chapter 10 opens up space for considering mundane governance as involved in constituting matter, both in the evidential sense of bringing matter into being and in the sense of constituting what ought to matter, why, how, assessed by what means, using what kind of process, and so on. In this sense, the bin bag of Chapter 2 can be wrong through its particular passage of relations of ontological constitution, evidential, and moral ordering, accountability relations, their consequence, output and disruption. The argument about bin bags and other matters focuses on the mundane—in the twin sense of being every day and becoming of the world—and governance in respect to accountabilities and ontologies. The chapter explores partial aspects of the narratives of mundane governance offered in preceding chapters. It concludes with an analysis of the continual changes that are a central characteristic of mundane governance by looking to the future.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 248-266
Conclusions
Chapter 10 opens up space for considering mundane governance as involved in constituting matter, both in the evidential sense of bringing matter into being and in the sense of constituting what ought to matter, why, how, assessed by what means, using what kind of process, and so on. In this sense, the bin bag of Chapter 2 can be wrong through its particular passage of relations of ontological constitution, evidential, and moral ordering, accountability relations, their consequence, output and disruption. The argument about bin bags and other matters focuses on the mundane—in the twin sense of being every day and becoming of the world—and governance in respect to accountabilities and ontologies. The chapter explores partial aspects of the narratives of mundane governance offered in preceding chapters. It concludes with an analysis of the continual changes that are a central characteristic of mundane governance by looking to the future.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 220-247
Disruption
Chapter 9 considers ways in which relations of governance are disrupted, breached, and repaired. In particular, it looks again at water bottles and attempts to carry liquids through security, traffic management and the breakdown of traffic lights, and parking and manoeuvres to challenge the status of parking tickets that have been issued. This analysis draws attention to ways in which ontological constitution of the evidential and moral is not static, but can be open to ongoing challenge and restatement. It also suggests that ‘rules’ of governance are often not available for deeper interrogation as representative of a governance rationale (even among those who form part of governance set-ups, such as airport security) beyond restatement of rules. The chapter argues that repairs to governance relations are instructive for drawing attention to ongoing changes in governance. Finally, it suggests that breaches in governance relations are a normal, everyday feature of governance action.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 220-247
Disruption
Chapter 9 considers ways in which relations of governance are disrupted, breached, and repaired. In particular, it looks again at water bottles and attempts to carry liquids through security, traffic management and the breakdown of traffic lights, and parking and manoeuvres to challenge the status of parking tickets that have been issued. This analysis draws attention to ways in which ontological constitution of the evidential and moral is not static, but can be open to ongoing challenge and restatement. It also suggests that ‘rules’ of governance are often not available for deeper interrogation as representative of a governance rationale (even among those who form part of governance set-ups, such as airport security) beyond restatement of rules. The chapter argues that repairs to governance relations are instructive for drawing attention to ongoing changes in governance. Finally, it suggests that breaches in governance relations are a normal, everyday feature of governance action.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 194-219
Mundane terror
Chapter 8 engages with things that have—via particular passages through, and questions posed of, accountability relations—become ontologically insecure. It focuses on water bottles and letter bombs as focal points for elaborating such insecurity. Water bottles are the latest candidate object of insecurity in airport governance and accountability relations that seek to constitute objects and their people as security ready. Letter bombs are a means through which businesses can take on responsibility for the management of terror. And yet objects and their passengers continually prove themselves to be security unready and the ‘letter’ ‘bombs’ and MI5’s instructions for handling such prove impossible to operationalize. Indeed it can be argued that actions to govern the insecure into being secure, constitute a broader, deeper, and more pervasive ontological insecurity than the insecure objects initially permit.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 194-219
Mundane terror
Chapter 8 engages with things that have—via particular passages through, and questions posed of, accountability relations—become ontologically insecure. It focuses on water bottles and letter bombs as focal points for elaborating such insecurity. Water bottles are the latest candidate object of insecurity in airport governance and accountability relations that seek to constitute objects and their people as security ready. Letter bombs are a means through which businesses can take on responsibility for the management of terror. And yet objects and their passengers continually prove themselves to be security unready and the ‘letter’ ‘bombs’ and MI5’s instructions for handling such prove impossible to operationalize. Indeed it can be argued that actions to govern the insecure into being secure, constitute a broader, deeper, and more pervasive ontological insecurity than the insecure objects initially permit.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 166-193
Spaces of governance
Chapter 7 considers the spaces of airports as locales through which governance is accomplished. It draws together material from a guided tour of the airport terminal conducted by managers of that terminal with a series of ethnographies completed by passengers seeking to catch planes. Accountability relations in the space of the airport are almost limitless in number and combination. The constitution of accountability relations, audiences, expectations, outcomes, and consequences for action are an ongoing feature of the airport and the terminal managers’ jobs. In place of any counter expectations that the airport terminal space accomplishes governable and orderly transit of passengers or that passengers accomplish an orderly transit through the space by drawing on the airport’s wayfinding systems, the chapter uncovers a series of actions that accomplish more or less orderly spaces, transits, passengers, wayfinding systems, managers of terminals, and airport processes.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 166-193
Spaces of governance
Chapter 7 considers the spaces of airports as locales through which governance is accomplished. It draws together material from a guided tour of the airport terminal conducted by managers of that terminal with a series of ethnographies completed by passengers seeking to catch planes. Accountability relations in the space of the airport are almost limitless in number and combination. The constitution of accountability relations, audiences, expectations, outcomes, and consequences for action are an ongoing feature of the airport and the terminal managers’ jobs. In place of any counter expectations that the airport terminal space accomplishes governable and orderly transit of passengers or that passengers accomplish an orderly transit through the space by drawing on the airport’s wayfinding systems, the chapter uncovers a series of actions that accomplish more or less orderly spaces, transits, passengers, wayfinding systems, managers of terminals, and airport processes.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 135-165
Compliance
Chapter 6 uses traffic management materials to investigate whether mundane governance works. Although it briefly considers ways that resources are constituted as evidential–moral–actionable to assess the extent to which governance works (e.g. by establishing league tables of the best and worst performing speed cameras), it is more compelling to investigate means by which governance subjects are compliant with governance. Research involved going out with drivers and studying ways in which they accomplish driving. Through navigating a plethora of cameras, lines, signs, lanes, other road users, invocations of past histories, what they had been told by friends, what they had seen on TV or read in newspapers, drivers actively constitute a sense of their driving, the objects and subjects of driving, and roads along which they drive. Compliant driving involves constituting rules to which they are being compliant along with assessment (of sorts) of the extent of their compliance.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 135-165
Compliance
Chapter 6 uses traffic management materials to investigate whether mundane governance works. Although it briefly considers ways that resources are constituted as evidential–moral–actionable to assess the extent to which governance works (e.g. by establishing league tables of the best and worst performing speed cameras), it is more compelling to investigate means by which governance subjects are compliant with governance. Research involved going out with drivers and studying ways in which they accomplish driving. Through navigating a plethora of cameras, lines, signs, lanes, other road users, invocations of past histories, what they had been told by friends, what they had seen on TV or read in newspapers, drivers actively constitute a sense of their driving, the objects and subjects of driving, and roads along which they drive. Compliant driving involves constituting rules to which they are being compliant along with assessment (of sorts) of the extent of their compliance.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 107-134
Structures of governance
Chapter 5 examines the relationships between the authorities of governance, in particular, the governance system through which regional safety camera partnerships has been established across the UK, under the management of a national programme board, operated by the Department for Transport. In place of the messiness of Chapters 3 and 4, this example appears to provide an encompassing governance structure. However, on close engagement with the partnerships and those responsible for managing the programme board, it turns out that this governance structure does not straightforwardly pre-exist actions of governance. Despite a notionally standardized set of national guidelines, decisions are made and changed, and varied between partnerships. Structures and rules of governance are themselves subject to messy, ongoing ontological constitution.
- 28 November 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 107-134
Structures of governance
Chapter 5 examines the relationships between the authorities of governance, in particular, the governance system through which regional safety camera partnerships has been established across the UK, under the management of a national programme board, operated by the Department for Transport. In place of the messiness of Chapters 3 and 4, this example appears to provide an encompassing governance structure. However, on close engagement with the partnerships and those responsible for managing the programme board, it turns out that this governance structure does not straightforwardly pre-exist actions of governance. Despite a notionally standardized set of national guidelines, decisions are made and changed, and varied between partnerships. Structures and rules of governance are themselves subject to messy, ongoing ontological constitution.