John S. L. McCombie
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
John S. L. McCombie has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jesus Felipe
Asian Development Bank, Manila, Philippines
3 shared publications- Jesus Felipe
Asian Development Bank
2 shared publications Mark Roberts
2 shared publications- Aashish Mehta
University of California Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, USA
1 shared publication - Alvaro Angeriz
School of Business and Management, Queen Mary, University of London, Mile End Road, London E1 4NS, UK
1 shared publication - Amy Glasmeier
Department of Geography, The Pennsylvania State University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 11 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-4
Thirlwall, Anthony P (1941–2023)
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Evolutionary Economics
- Vol. 35 (2) , 247-280
Is anything left of the debate about the sources of growth in East Asia 30 years later? A critical survey
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Evolutionary Economics
- Vol. 35 (2) , 247-280
Is anything left of the debate about the sources of growth in East Asia 30 years later? A critical survey
- 27 July 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing in Review of Keynesian Economics
- Vol. 11 (3) , 400-415
Why the conventional test of Thirlwall’s law is still not a ‘near-tautology’: a rejoinder to Professor Blecker
Blecker (2021) repeats an argument, first put forward by McCombie (1981) (but later repudiated by him) and also summarised by Blecker (2016, 2021) that the traditional test of Thirlwall’s law is merely estimating what Blecker terms a ‘near-tautology’ or ‘near-identity’. This is based on an analysis concerning the arithmetical calculation of the import and export income elasticities of demand, and the circumstances under which these will equal their statistical estimates. The arithmetically calculated income elasticities are the growth of imports divided by the growth of domestic income and the growth of exports divided by the growth of world income, respectively. Blecker’s argument is that if the statistical estimates of the two income elasticities of demand equal their respective arithmetically calculated values, and are used in the testing of the law, this represents a near-tautology. This rejoinder demonstrates that Blecker’s argument concerning the near-tautology is a misinterpretation of the nature of the traditional testing of Thirlwall’s law. It is shown that Blecker and Ibarra’s (2013) alternative model, which is used to test the balance-of-payments constrained model for Mexico and which it is claimed avoids the putative near-tautology problem, is itself problematic. As such, it does not represent an improvement over the traditional model of Thirlwall’s law, but, ironically, may give approximately the same empirical result.
- 27 July 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing in Review of Keynesian Economics
- Vol. 11 (3) , 400-415
Why the conventional test of Thirlwall’s law is still not a ‘near-tautology’: a rejoinder to Professor Blecker
Blecker (2021) repeats an argument, first put forward by McCombie (1981) (but later repudiated by him) and also summarised by Blecker (2016, 2021) that the traditional test of Thirlwall’s law is merely estimating what Blecker terms a ‘near-tautology’ or ‘near-identity’. This is based on an analysis concerning the arithmetical calculation of the import and export income elasticities of demand, and the circumstances under which these will equal their statistical estimates. The arithmetically calculated income elasticities are the growth of imports divided by the growth of domestic income and the growth of exports divided by the growth of world income, respectively. Blecker’s argument is that if the statistical estimates of the two income elasticities of demand equal their respective arithmetically calculated values, and are used in the testing of the law, this represents a near-tautology. This rejoinder demonstrates that Blecker’s argument concerning the near-tautology is a misinterpretation of the nature of the traditional testing of Thirlwall’s law. It is shown that Blecker and Ibarra’s (2013) alternative model, which is used to test the balance-of-payments constrained model for Mexico and which it is claimed avoids the putative near-tautology problem, is itself problematic. As such, it does not represent an improvement over the traditional model of Thirlwall’s law, but, ironically, may give approximately the same empirical result.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2019
- Published by Asian Development Bank
The Illusions of Calculating Total Factor Productivity and Testing Growth Models_From Cobb–Douglas to Solow and Romer
This paper shows why aggregate production functions seem to work empirically.
- 1 October 2019
- Published by Asian Development Bank
Open AccessThe Illusions of Calculating Total Factor Productivity and Testing Growth Models_From Cobb–Douglas to Solow and Romer
This paper shows why aggregate production functions seem to work empirically.
- 6 September 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 131-172
Why the Subprime Financial Crash Should Have Been Prevented and Implications for Current Macroeconomic and Regulatory Policy
- 6 September 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 131-172
Why the Subprime Financial Crash Should Have Been Prevented and Implications for Current Macroeconomic and Regulatory Policy
- Open Access
- 22 November 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Papers in Regional Science
- Vol. 97 (1) , 133-150
Brexit and its possible implications for the UK economy and its regions: A post‐Keynesian perspective
- 22 November 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Papers in Regional Science
- Vol. 97 (1) , 133-150
Open AccessBrexit and its possible implications for the UK economy and its regions: A post‐Keynesian perspective
- Open Access
- 4 July 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Review of Applied Economics
- Vol. 32 (4) , 450-471
Productivity growth of the cities of Jiangsu province, China: a Kaldorian approach
This paper considers the determinants of economic growth of the cities of Jiangsu province, China, adopting a Kaldorian approach. It is found that there is a close correlation between the growth of non-industry and industry (Kaldor’s first law) that provides indirect evidence for the export-base theory. The paper discusses two competing explanations of the foundations of the Verdoorn law (Kaldor’s second law), which, in its simplest form, is the relationship between industrial productivity and output growth. It also considers the static–dynamic Verdoorn law paradox. This arises from the fact that estimating the Verdoorn law in log-levels often gives statistically insignificant estimates of the Verdoorn coefficient while the use of growth rates gives significant values of around one half. The results show that this does not occur when data for the cities are used. A plausible explanation for the paradox is that it results from spatial aggregation bias. It is also found that inter-province urban productivity disparities first increase, but subsequently decrease over the period considered.
- 4 July 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Review of Applied Economics
- Vol. 32 (4) , 450-471
Open AccessProductivity growth of the cities of Jiangsu province, China: a Kaldorian approach
This paper considers the determinants of economic growth of the cities of Jiangsu province, China, adopting a Kaldorian approach. It is found that there is a close correlation between the growth of non-industry and industry (Kaldor’s first law) that provides indirect evidence for the export-base theory. The paper discusses two competing explanations of the foundations of the Verdoorn law (Kaldor’s second law), which, in its simplest form, is the relationship between industrial productivity and output growth. It also considers the static–dynamic Verdoorn law paradox. This arises from the fact that estimating the Verdoorn law in log-levels often gives statistically insignificant estimates of the Verdoorn coefficient while the use of growth rates gives significant values of around one half. The results show that this does not occur when data for the cities are used. A plausible explanation for the paradox is that it results from spatial aggregation bias. It is also found that inter-province urban productivity disparities first increase, but subsequently decrease over the period considered.
- 8 May 2017
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Economic Studies
- Vol. 44 (2) , 226-244
A reconciliation proposal of demand-driven growth models in open economies
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the literature on demand-driven Keynesian growth in open economies by developing a formal model that combines Dixon and Thirlwall’s (1975) export-led growth model and Thirlwall’s (1979) balance-of-payments constrained growth model into a more general specification. Then, based on the model developed in this paper, the authors analyse more broadly some important issues concerning the net impact of currency depreciation on the short-run growth. Design/methodology/approach: The authors build upon Dixon and Thirlwall’s (1975) export-led growth model and Thirlwall’s (1979) balance-of-payments constrained growth model in order to develop the theoretical framework. The authors also run numerical simulations to illustrate the net impact of devaluation on the short-run growth rate in different scenarios. Findings: The authors demonstrate that the net impact of currency devaluation on growth can go either way, depending on some structural conditions such as the average share of imported intermediate inputs in prime costs of domestic firms and the institutional capacity of trade unions to set nominal wages through the bargaining process. The model also shows that the effectiveness of a competitive real exchange rate to promote growth is higher in countries where the share of labour in domestic income is also higher. Research limitations/implications: This paper provides a coherent formal starting-point for further theoretical developments on the interrelatedness between currency devaluation, income distribution and growth. These findings provide empirically testable hypothesis for future research. Originality/value: The present study proposes an alternative formal solution for the theoretical problem of imposing a balance-of-payments constraint on the process of cumulative causation often incorporated in Kaldorian growth models. In terms of policy, the framework sheds further light on the relevance of income distribution and the labour market institutional framework for the dynamics of the exchange rate pass-through mechanism and allows us to map out related conditions under which currency devaluation can promote growth.
- 8 May 2017
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Economic Studies
- Vol. 44 (2) , 226-244
A reconciliation proposal of demand-driven growth models in open economies
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the literature on demand-driven Keynesian growth in open economies by developing a formal model that combines Dixon and Thirlwall’s (1975) export-led growth model and Thirlwall’s (1979) balance-of-payments constrained growth model into a more general specification. Then, based on the model developed in this paper, the authors analyse more broadly some important issues concerning the net impact of currency depreciation on the short-run growth. Design/methodology/approach: The authors build upon Dixon and Thirlwall’s (1975) export-led growth model and Thirlwall’s (1979) balance-of-payments constrained growth model in order to develop the theoretical framework. The authors also run numerical simulations to illustrate the net impact of devaluation on the short-run growth rate in different scenarios. Findings: The authors demonstrate that the net impact of currency devaluation on growth can go either way, depending on some structural conditions such as the average share of imported intermediate inputs in prime costs of domestic firms and the institutional capacity of trade unions to set nominal wages through the bargaining process. The model also shows that the effectiveness of a competitive real exchange rate to promote growth is higher in countries where the share of labour in domestic income is also higher. Research limitations/implications: This paper provides a coherent formal starting-point for further theoretical developments on the interrelatedness between currency devaluation, income distribution and growth. These findings provide empirically testable hypothesis for future research. Originality/value: The present study proposes an alternative formal solution for the theoretical problem of imposing a balance-of-payments constraint on the process of cumulative causation often incorporated in Kaldorian growth models. In terms of policy, the framework sheds further light on the relevance of income distribution and the labour market institutional framework for the dynamics of the exchange rate pass-through mechanism and allows us to map out related conditions under which currency devaluation can promote growth.
- 20 January 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Radical Political Economics
- Vol. 47 (2) , 274-291
Can the Marginal Productivity Theory of Distribution be Tested?
This paper shows why attempts to test the neoclassical aggregate marginal productivity theory of distribution are inherently flawed. The use of constant-price value data and an underlying accounting identity mean that the close correspondence often found between the “output elasticities” of a putative aggregate production function and the relevant factor shares is a mere statistical artefact. Likewise, the results of estimating neoclassical labor demand functions must, for the same reason, always give spurious results.
- 20 January 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Radical Political Economics
- Vol. 47 (2) , 274-291
Can the Marginal Productivity Theory of Distribution be Tested?
This paper shows why attempts to test the neoclassical aggregate marginal productivity theory of distribution are inherently flawed. The use of constant-price value data and an underlying accounting identity mean that the close correspondence often found between the “output elasticities” of a putative aggregate production function and the relevant factor shares is a mere statistical artefact. Likewise, the results of estimating neoclassical labor demand functions must, for the same reason, always give spurious results.
- 2 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Review of Political Economy
- Vol. 26 (1) , 60-84
The Aggregate Production Function: ‘Not Even Wrong’
The foundations of the aggregate production function were long ago thrown into doubt by problems of aggregation and the Cambridge capital theory controversies. Yet the aggregate production function, whether in the familiar form of the Cobb-Douglas, the CES, or the translog, continues to be widely used in both theoretical and applied analysis. The reason for its continued use rests on the instrumental position that ‘it works’. The aggregate production function sometimes yields good statistical fits with plausible estimates of the coefficients. However, for some time, it has been realised that the existence of an underlying accounting identity can explain the regression results, even if the aggregate production function does not exist. This argument has been widely ignored. This paper, drawing on a rhetorical approach, assesses why this is the case. It shows that the few criticisms that have been made of the critique involve fundamental misunderstandings that represent a failure of the economic method.
- 2 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Review of Political Economy
- Vol. 26 (1) , 60-84
The Aggregate Production Function: ‘Not Even Wrong’
The foundations of the aggregate production function were long ago thrown into doubt by problems of aggregation and the Cambridge capital theory controversies. Yet the aggregate production function, whether in the familiar form of the Cobb-Douglas, the CES, or the translog, continues to be widely used in both theoretical and applied analysis. The reason for its continued use rests on the instrumental position that ‘it works’. The aggregate production function sometimes yields good statistical fits with plausible estimates of the coefficients. However, for some time, it has been realised that the existence of an underlying accounting identity can explain the regression results, even if the aggregate production function does not exist. This argument has been widely ignored. This paper, drawing on a rhetorical approach, assesses why this is the case. It shows that the few criticisms that have been made of the critique involve fundamental misunderstandings that represent a failure of the economic method.