Nick Black
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Nick Black has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Catherine Pope
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 shared publications Joanne Griffiths
Health Services Research Unit, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT
2 shared publicationsAnn Bowling
Health Services Research Unit, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT
1 shared publicationCaroline Goldfrad
Intensive Care National Audit and Research Centre, London WC1H 9HR, bDepartment of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, University of Birmingham, Birmingham B15 2TH, cDepartment of Public Health and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT
1 shared publicationDuncan Neuhauser
Epidemiology & Biostatistics Department, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA
1 shared publicationFiona Godlee
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 July 2006
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 11 (3) , 180-183D
Books that have changed health services and health care policy
- 1 July 2006
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 11 (3) , 180-183D
Books that have changed health services and health care policy
Use of consensus development to establish national research priorities in critical care
Objectives: To test the feasibility of using a nominal group technique to establish clinical and health services research priorities in critical care and to test the representativeness of the group's views. Design: Generation of topics by means of a national survey; a nominal group technique to establish the level of consensus; a survey to test the representativeness of the results. Setting: United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland. Subjects: Nominal group composed of 10 doctors (8 consultants, 2 trainees) and 2 nurses. Main outcome measure: Level of support (median) and level of agreement (mean absolute deviation from the median) derived from a 9 point Likert scale. Results: Of the 325 intensive care units approached, 187 (58%) responded, providing about 1000 suggestions for research. Of the 106 most frequently suggested topics considered by the nominal group, 37 attracted strong support, 48 moderate support and 21 weak support. There was more agreement after the group had met—overall mean of the mean absolute deviations from the median fell from 1.41 to 1.26. The group's views represented the views of the wider community of critical care staff (r=0.73, PConclusions: A nominal group technique is feasible and reliable for determining research priorities among clinicians. This approach is more democratic and transparent than the traditional methods used by research funding bodies. The results suggest that clinicians perceive research into the best ways of delivering and organising services as a high priority.
Use of consensus development to establish national research priorities in critical care
Objectives: To test the feasibility of using a nominal group technique to establish clinical and health services research priorities in critical care and to test the representativeness of the group's views. Design: Generation of topics by means of a national survey; a nominal group technique to establish the level of consensus; a survey to test the representativeness of the results. Setting: United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland. Subjects: Nominal group composed of 10 doctors (8 consultants, 2 trainees) and 2 nurses. Main outcome measure: Level of support (median) and level of agreement (mean absolute deviation from the median) derived from a 9 point Likert scale. Results: Of the 325 intensive care units approached, 187 (58%) responded, providing about 1000 suggestions for research. Of the 106 most frequently suggested topics considered by the nominal group, 37 attracted strong support, 48 moderate support and 21 weak support. There was more agreement after the group had met—overall mean of the mean absolute deviations from the median fell from 1.41 to 1.26. The group's views represented the views of the wider community of critical care staff (r=0.73, PConclusions: A nominal group technique is feasible and reliable for determining research priorities among clinicians. This approach is more democratic and transparent than the traditional methods used by research funding bodies. The results suggest that clinicians perceive research into the best ways of delivering and organising services as a high priority.
- Open Access
- 15 July 1998
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA
- Vol. 280 (3) , 231-233
What Makes a Good Reviewer and a Good Review for a General Medical Journal?
Context.—Selecting peer reviewers who will provide high-quality reviews is a central task of editors of biomedical journals.Objectives.—To determine the characteristics of reviewers for a general medical journal who produce high-quality reviews and to describe the characteristics of a good review, particularly in terms of the time spent reviewing and turnaround time.Design, Setting, and Participants.—Surveys of reviewers of the 420 manuscripts submitted to BMJ between January and June 1997.Main Outcome Measures.—Review quality was assessed independently by 2 editors and by the corresponding author using a newly developed 7-item review quality instrument.Results.—Of the 420 manuscripts, 345 (82%) had 2 reviews completed, for a total of 690 reviews. Authors' assessments of review quality were available for 507 reviews. The characteristics of reviewers had little association with the quality of the reviews they produced (explaining only 8% of the variation), regardless of whether editors or authors defined the quality of the review. In a logistic regression analysis, the only significant factor associated with higher-quality ratings by both editors and authors was reviewers trained in epidemiology or statistics. Younger age also was an independent predictor for editors' quality assessments, while reviews performed by reviewers who were members of an editorial board were rated of poorer quality by authors. Review quality increased with time spent on a review, up to 3 hours but not beyond.Conclusions.—The characteristics of reviewers we studied did not identify those who performed high-quality reviews. Reviewers might be advised that spending longer than 3 hours on a review on average did not appear to increase review quality as rated by editors and authors.
- 15 July 1998
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA
- Vol. 280 (3) , 231-233
Open AccessWhat Makes a Good Reviewer and a Good Review for a General Medical Journal?
Context.—Selecting peer reviewers who will provide high-quality reviews is a central task of editors of biomedical journals.Objectives.—To determine the characteristics of reviewers for a general medical journal who produce high-quality reviews and to describe the characteristics of a good review, particularly in terms of the time spent reviewing and turnaround time.Design, Setting, and Participants.—Surveys of reviewers of the 420 manuscripts submitted to BMJ between January and June 1997.Main Outcome Measures.—Review quality was assessed independently by 2 editors and by the corresponding author using a newly developed 7-item review quality instrument.Results.—Of the 420 manuscripts, 345 (82%) had 2 reviews completed, for a total of 690 reviews. Authors' assessments of review quality were available for 507 reviews. The characteristics of reviewers had little association with the quality of the reviews they produced (explaining only 8% of the variation), regardless of whether editors or authors defined the quality of the review. In a logistic regression analysis, the only significant factor associated with higher-quality ratings by both editors and authors was reviewers trained in epidemiology or statistics. Younger age also was an independent predictor for editors' quality assessments, while reviews performed by reviewers who were members of an editorial board were rated of poorer quality by authors. Review quality increased with time spent on a review, up to 3 hours but not beyond.Conclusions.—The characteristics of reviewers we studied did not identify those who performed high-quality reviews. Reviewers might be advised that spending longer than 3 hours on a review on average did not appear to increase review quality as rated by editors and authors.
- Open Access
- 1 April 1998
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal for Quality in Health Care
- Vol. 10 (2) , 113-123
Does comorbidity affect the outcome of surgery? Total hip replacement in the UK and Japan
Objectives. To assess the impact of comorbidity on the outcome of surgery in the UK and in Japan; to determine the predictive ability of a new measure of comorbidity, the Index of Co-Existent Diseases (ICED); and to see if its predictive power could be improved. Design. Logistic regression using data from two retrospective cohorts with prospective outcome data collection. Setting. Six hospitals (three teaching, three non-teaching) in the UK and 15 (12 teaching, three non-teaching) hospitals in Japan. Study participants. Patients undergoing total hip replacement (THR) surgery in the UK (n = 268) and in Japan (n = 249). Main outcome measures. Serious complications before hospital discharge and change in three measures of general health status [basic activities of daily living (ADL); instrumental ADL; social activities]. Results. The distribution of levels of comorbidity differed between the UK and Japan: none (26.1 versus 42.2%); mild (30.6 versus 43.0%); moderate (23.5 versus 12.0%); and severe (19.8 versus 2.8%). In the UK, the incidence of serious complications was higher in patients with moderate (27.0%) or severe (26.4%) comorbidity than in those with no (14.3%) or mild (13.4%) comorbidity (PPConclusions. Comorbidity is a significant determinant of serious complications following THR but not of changes in functional or health status. Comparisons of clinical performance using post-operative complications must take levels of comorbidity into account if they are to be meaningful. The ICED is of less validity in the UK and Japan than in its country of origin, the USA. Further work to develop better instruments for the UK and Japan is needed.
- 1 April 1998
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal for Quality in Health Care
- Vol. 10 (2) , 113-123
Open AccessDoes comorbidity affect the outcome of surgery? Total hip replacement in the UK and Japan
Objectives. To assess the impact of comorbidity on the outcome of surgery in the UK and in Japan; to determine the predictive ability of a new measure of comorbidity, the Index of Co-Existent Diseases (ICED); and to see if its predictive power could be improved. Design. Logistic regression using data from two retrospective cohorts with prospective outcome data collection. Setting. Six hospitals (three teaching, three non-teaching) in the UK and 15 (12 teaching, three non-teaching) hospitals in Japan. Study participants. Patients undergoing total hip replacement (THR) surgery in the UK (n = 268) and in Japan (n = 249). Main outcome measures. Serious complications before hospital discharge and change in three measures of general health status [basic activities of daily living (ADL); instrumental ADL; social activities]. Results. The distribution of levels of comorbidity differed between the UK and Japan: none (26.1 versus 42.2%); mild (30.6 versus 43.0%); moderate (23.5 versus 12.0%); and severe (19.8 versus 2.8%). In the UK, the incidence of serious complications was higher in patients with moderate (27.0%) or severe (26.4%) comorbidity than in those with no (14.3%) or mild (13.4%) comorbidity (PPConclusions. Comorbidity is a significant determinant of serious complications following THR but not of changes in functional or health status. Comparisons of clinical performance using post-operative complications must take levels of comorbidity into account if they are to be meaningful. The ICED is of less validity in the UK and Japan than in its country of origin, the USA. Further work to develop better instruments for the UK and Japan is needed.
Impact of surgery for stress incontinence on morbidity: cohort study
Objectives: To describe the impact of surgery for stress incontinence on the severity of symptoms, other mental and physical symptoms, and overall health. To describe the incidence of postoperative complications. Design: Prospective cohort study; questionnaires completed by patients before and 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery. Questionnaires completed by surgeons both before and after surgery. Setting: 18 hospitals in the North Thames region. Subjects: 442 women treated surgically for stress incontinence between January 1993 and June 1994. 367 women returned the 3 month questionnaire; 364 returned the 6 month questionnaire; and 359 returned the 12 month questionnaire. 49 surgeons provided perioperative information on 285 of the 442 women and postoperative information on 278. Main outcome measures: Stress incontinence symptom severity index, other urinary symptoms, bowel function, mental health, complications, global measures. Results: Most women (288; 87%) reported an improvement in the severity of their stress incontinence, though only 92 (28%) were cured (continent). These improvements persisted for at least 12 months. The likelihood of improvement was similar regardless of whether urodynamic pressure studies had been conducted before surgery. Following surgery, women were less likely to suffer from urinary frequency, nocturia, postvoid fullness, dysuria, and urgency. While mental health improved for 194 (71%), a quarter of women reported deterioration. Only 37 (10%) were satisfied with postoperative pain control. A third experienced one or more complications while in hospital, most commonly difficulty urinating. This problem affected 1 in 11 women after discharge. A year after surgery two thirds of women reported feeling better (251; 72%), that the outcome met or exceeded their expectations (230; 66%), and that they would recommend the operation to a friend in a similar situation (239; 68%). Surgeons tended to be more optimistic about the effects of surgery; they were satisfied with the outcome in 176 (85%) cases and would again treat 245 (94%) of the women as they had done previously. Conclusions: Although surgery reduces the severity of stress incontinence it is not as effective as current textbooks suggest. Women considering surgery should be provided with more accurate information on the likelihood of an improvement in symptoms and the occurrence of complications, including postoperative pain. Urgency and urge incontinence should not be considered contraindications to surgery. The need for urodynamic assessment before surgery should be reappraised. Key messages: Although surgery improves stress incontinence in most women (87%), only 28% are continent one year later The need for preoperative urodynamic testing should be reappraised Urgency and urge incontinence should not be considered contraindications to surgery Women considering surgery should receive more accurate information on the probability of an improvement in symptoms and possible complications There is a need for a rigorous, pragmatic, randomised trial of surgery for stress incontinence
Impact of surgery for stress incontinence on morbidity: cohort study
Objectives: To describe the impact of surgery for stress incontinence on the severity of symptoms, other mental and physical symptoms, and overall health. To describe the incidence of postoperative complications. Design: Prospective cohort study; questionnaires completed by patients before and 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery. Questionnaires completed by surgeons both before and after surgery. Setting: 18 hospitals in the North Thames region. Subjects: 442 women treated surgically for stress incontinence between January 1993 and June 1994. 367 women returned the 3 month questionnaire; 364 returned the 6 month questionnaire; and 359 returned the 12 month questionnaire. 49 surgeons provided perioperative information on 285 of the 442 women and postoperative information on 278. Main outcome measures: Stress incontinence symptom severity index, other urinary symptoms, bowel function, mental health, complications, global measures. Results: Most women (288; 87%) reported an improvement in the severity of their stress incontinence, though only 92 (28%) were cured (continent). These improvements persisted for at least 12 months. The likelihood of improvement was similar regardless of whether urodynamic pressure studies had been conducted before surgery. Following surgery, women were less likely to suffer from urinary frequency, nocturia, postvoid fullness, dysuria, and urgency. While mental health improved for 194 (71%), a quarter of women reported deterioration. Only 37 (10%) were satisfied with postoperative pain control. A third experienced one or more complications while in hospital, most commonly difficulty urinating. This problem affected 1 in 11 women after discharge. A year after surgery two thirds of women reported feeling better (251; 72%), that the outcome met or exceeded their expectations (230; 66%), and that they would recommend the operation to a friend in a similar situation (239; 68%). Surgeons tended to be more optimistic about the effects of surgery; they were satisfied with the outcome in 176 (85%) cases and would again treat 245 (94%) of the women as they had done previously. Conclusions: Although surgery reduces the severity of stress incontinence it is not as effective as current textbooks suggest. Women considering surgery should be provided with more accurate information on the likelihood of an improvement in symptoms and the occurrence of complications, including postoperative pain. Urgency and urge incontinence should not be considered contraindications to surgery. The need for urodynamic assessment before surgery should be reappraised. Key messages: Although surgery improves stress incontinence in most women (87%), only 28% are continent one year later The need for preoperative urodynamic testing should be reappraised Urgency and urge incontinence should not be considered contraindications to surgery Women considering surgery should receive more accurate information on the probability of an improvement in symptoms and possible complications There is a need for a rigorous, pragmatic, randomised trial of surgery for stress incontinence
- 1 May 1997
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Public Health
- Vol. 18 (1) , 485-505
A NATIONAL STRATEGY FOR RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT:Lessons from England
▪ Abstract Increasing concern about the state of basic and clinical research in England during the 1980s led to an influential parliamentary review. Surprisingly, the review recommended the strengthening of public health and health services research through the establishment of a research and development (R&D) program for the National Health Service (NHS). The program that started in 1991 was unique in that it was fully integrated into the management structure of the NHS. No country had ever attempted such an ambitious approach. While a review of the first five years of the program reveals many achievements, it also raises several concerns: Debate about the philosophy and aims of the program continues; the need to maintain political support requires constant attention; policy changes in other areas need to be accommodated; central control of a national, coordinated R&D program has to be guarded; methods of priority setting need to be enhanced; insufficient human resources to run the program have to be contended with; and the program needs to be rigorously evaluated. Other countries with a unified health system could learn much from the English experience. Countries with pluralist systems might benefit from specific parts of the experience.
- 1 May 1997
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Public Health
- Vol. 18 (1) , 485-505
A NATIONAL STRATEGY FOR RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT:Lessons from England
▪ Abstract Increasing concern about the state of basic and clinical research in England during the 1980s led to an influential parliamentary review. Surprisingly, the review recommended the strengthening of public health and health services research through the establishment of a research and development (R&D) program for the National Health Service (NHS). The program that started in 1991 was unique in that it was fully integrated into the management structure of the NHS. No country had ever attempted such an ambitious approach. While a review of the first five years of the program reveals many achievements, it also raises several concerns: Debate about the philosophy and aims of the program continues; the need to maintain political support requires constant attention; policy changes in other areas need to be accommodated; central control of a national, coordinated R&D program has to be guarded; methods of priority setting need to be enhanced; insufficient human resources to run the program have to be contended with; and the program needs to be rigorously evaluated. Other countries with a unified health system could learn much from the English experience. Countries with pluralist systems might benefit from specific parts of the experience.
- 1 January 1996
- Published by Wiley in Neurourology and Urodynamics
- Vol. 15 (6) , 630-640
Development of a symptom severity index and a symptom impact index for stress incontinence in women
- 1 January 1996
- Published by Wiley in Neurourology and Urodynamics
- Vol. 15 (6) , 630-640
Development of a symptom severity index and a symptom impact index for stress incontinence in women