MBMichelle F. Bowman

Michelle F. Bowman

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Michelle F. Bowman has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Evaluating a novel Test Site Analysis (TSA) bioassessment approach

    by Michelle F. Bowman, Keith M. Somers

    We compared the performance of Test Site Analysis (TSA) to 2 existing bioassessment methods: the BEnthic Assessment of SedimenT (BEAST), and the multimetric approach. In TSA, simple spreadsheet calculations are used to: 1) derive an overall multivariate measure of dissimilarity between a potentially impaired test site and a reference benchmark using a number of biological summary metrics, 2) classify each site as impaired, potentially impaired, or in reference condition with formal hypothesis tests, and 3) identify the metrics important in distinguishing a significantly impaired test site from the reference benchmark. We used data collected as part of the Fraser River Action Plan (British Columbia, Canada) to compare the biological condition of 15 potentially impaired test sites known to be exposed to agriculture, logging, or mining to the condition of 61 minimally disturbed reference sites with comparable habitat. When TSA was used, the false-positive (i.e., Type-1 error) and false-negative (i.e....


  • Changes in stoichiometric constraints on epilithon and benthic macroinvertebrates in response to slight nutrient enrichment of mountain rivers

    by Michelle F. Bowman, Patricia A. Chambers, David W. Schindler

    Summary: 1. To assess changes in stoichiometric constraints on stream benthos, we measured elemental composition of epilithon and benthic macroinvertebrates in intrinsically P‐limited mountain rivers, upstream and downstream of low‐level anthropogenic nutrient enrichment by effluents of municipal wastewater treatment plants.2. While there was a broad range in the elemental composition of epilithon (C : P ratios of 200–16 500, C : N ratios of 8–280, N : P ratios of 8–535) and heptageniid mayfly scrapers (C : P ratios of 125–300, C : N ratios of 5.1–7.2, N : P ratios of 20–60), the average C : P ratio of epilithon was 10‐fold lower and the average C : N ratio twofold lower at more nutrient‐rich downstream sites. Nutrient ratios in benthic macroinvertebrates were lower than in epilithon and varied little between relatively nutrient‐poor and nutrient‐rich sites.3. We modified the existing definition of producer‐consumer elemental imbalance to allow for variation in consumer nutrient content. We defined this ‘non‐homeostatic’ imbalance as the perpendicular distance between the producer and consumer C : P, C : N, or N : P ratios, and the 1 : 1 line.4. At P‐limited sites, the estimated mayfly N : P recycling ratio was higher than the N : P ratio in epilithon, suggesting nutrient recycling by consumers could accentuate P‐limitation of epilithon.5. Measuring the degree of producer–consumer nutrient imbalance may be important in predicting the magnitude of effects from nutrient enrichment and can help elucidate the causes and consequences of ecological patterns and processes in rivers.


  • Considerations when Using the Reference Condition Approach for Bioassessment of Freshwater Ecosystems

    by Michelle F. Bowman, Keith M. Somers

    The use of the reference condition approach (RCA) in environmental assessments is becoming more prevalent. Although the RCA was not explicitly described in Green's (1979) book on statistical methods for environmental biologists, we expanded his decision key for selecting an appropriate environmental study design to include this approach. The RCA compares the biological community at a potentially impacted ‘test’ site to communities found in minimally impacted ‘reference’ sites. However, to implement the RCA there are a number of assumptions and decisions that must be made. We compare several common multimetric and multivariate bioassessment methods to illustrate that four key decisions inherent in the RCA framework (i.e., criteria used for reference site selection, for grouping similar reference sites, for comparing test and reference sites, and for evaluating the cause of impacts) can markedly affect test site appraisals. Specific guidelines should be developed to select appropriate reference sites. Based on analyses of real and simulated data, we recommend a minimum of 20, but preferably 30 to 50 reference sites per group, and verification of groupings with more than one classification method. New approaches (e.g., test site analysis) incorporating the strengths of both multimetric and multivariate methods can be used to compare test and reference sites. Additional ecological information, models relating degree of impact to a stressor or habitat gradient, and variance partitioning can also be used to isolate the probable cause of impairment, and are particularly valuable when appropriate reference sites are unavailable.