ÉGÉlodie Giroux

Élodie Giroux

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Élodie Giroux has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    "Suivre la science" en temps de pandémie

    by Thomas Bonnin, Elodie Giroux

    Au cours de la pandémie de Covid-19, les idées d’“écouter la science” ou de “suivre les scientifiques” ont été fréquemment mobilisées comme arme rhétorique pour asseoir la légitimité ou la supériorité de décisions politiques. Dans cet article, nous partons de ce cas d’étude pour discuter de l’emploi adéquat des connaissances scientifiques dans la prise de décision politique. Nous faisons d'abord une discussion critique du "modèle linéaire", vision où le consensus scientifique dicte les décisions politiques. Ce modèle s'avère contre-productif et stérile pour les situations décisionnelles complexes, telles que la pandémie de Covid-19. A partir de ces critiques, nous articulons un modèle pluraliste, où les options politiques sont construites et informées par un dialogue entre une science pluraliste des valeurs (non-)épistémiques. Nous montrons enfin que les obstacles identifiés à l'application pratique de ce modèle sont soit infondés ou impropres au pluralisme en particulier.


  • Open Access

    Risk and Disease: Two Alternative Ways of Modelling Health Phenomena

    by Élodie Giroux

    The notion of risk questions our dominant and traditional medical approach to health phenomena: a binary normal-pathological model anchored in the pathophysiological framework. For risk factors which are continuous biological variables such as hypertension or hypercholesterolemia, the demarcation line between a level which would be ‘normal’, ‘at risk’, or ‘pathological’ is drawn in a conventional and non-fixed manner. Above all, these risk factors, which are the subject of preventive treatment, are increasingly considered as diseases in their own right. This shift would reinforce the pathologisation of human life and the associated problems of overdiagnosis and overtreatment. However, while it is easy to see the value of clarifying and specifying the distinction between ‘risk’ and ‘disease’ when dealing with those problems, finding the best way to do so remains challenging. In this chapter, I begin by describing the confusion between these two categories. I then show that the conceptual analysis, in particular, the naturalistic definition of disease, fails to provide a satisfactory distinction. Finally, I argue that this distinction can be better established if we understand the epidemiological risk approach as a different way of modelling health phenomena than the binary and categorical approach of pathophysiology.


  • Narratives in exposomics: A reversed heuristic determinism?

    by Francesca Merlin, Élodie Giroux

    Since the completion of the Human Genome Project (HGP), biomedical sciences have moved away from a gene-centred view and towards a multi-factorial one in which environment, broadly speaking, plays a central role in the determination of human health and disease. Environmental exposures have been shown to be highly prevalent in disease causation. They are considered as complementary to genetic factors in the etiology of diseases, hence the introduction of the concept of the “exposome” as encompassing the totality of human environmental exposures, from conception onwards (Wild in Cancer Epidemiol Biomark Prev 14:1847–1850, 2005), and the launch of the Human Exposome Project (HEP) which aims to complement the HGP. At first sight, and seen as complementary to the genome, the exposome could thus appear as contributing to the rise of novel postgenomic deterministic narratives which place the environment at their core. Is this really the case? If so, what sort of determinism is at work in exposomics research? Is it a case of environmental determinism, and if so, in what sense? Or is it a new sort of deterministic view? In this paper, we first show that causal narratives in exposomics are still very similar to gene-centred deterministic narratives. They correspond to a form of Laplacian determinism and, above all, to what Claude Bernard called the “determinism of a phenomenon”. Second, we introduce the notion of “reversed heuristic determinism” to characterize the specific deterministic narratives present in exposomics. Indeed, the accepted sorts of external environmental exposures conceived as being at the origins of diseases are determined, methodologically speaking, by their identifiable internal and biological markers. We conclude by highlighting the most relevant implications of the presence of this heuristic determinism in exposomics research.


  • Diagnostic staging and stratification in psychiatry and oncology: clarifying their conceptual, epistemological and ethical implications

    by Julia Tinland, Christophe Gauld, Pierre Sujobert, Élodie Giroux

    Staging and stratification are two diagnostic approaches that have introduced a more dynamic outlook on the development of diseases, thus participating in blurring the line between the normal and the pathological. First, diagnostic staging, aiming to capture how diseases evolve in time and/or space through identifiable and gradually more severe stages, may be said to lean on an underlying assumption of “temporal determinism”. Stratification, on the other hand, allows for the identification of various prognostic or predictive subgroups based on specific markers, relying on a more “mechanistic” or “statistical” form of determinism. There are two medical fields in which these developments have played a significant role and have given rise to sometimes profound nosological transformations: oncology and psychiatry. Drawing on examples from these two fields, this paper aims to provide much needed conceptual clarifications on both staging and stratification in order to outline how several epistemological and ethical issues may, in turn, arise. We argue that diagnostic staging ought to be detached from the assumption of temporal determinism, though it should still play an essential role in adapting interventions to stage. In doing so, it would help counterbalance stratification’s own epistemological and ethical shortcomings. In this sense, the reflections and propositions developed in psychiatry can offer invaluable insights regarding how adopting a more transdiagnostic and cross-cutting perspective on temporality and disease dynamics may help combine both staging and stratification in clinical practice.


  • Can populations be healthy? Perspectives from Georges Canguilhem and Geoffrey Rose

    by Élodie Giroux

    Canguilhem criticized the concept of “public health”: health and disease are concepts that only apply to individuals, taken as organic totalities. Their extension to a different level of organization is purely metaphorical. The importance assumed by epidemiology in the construction of our knowledge of the normal and the pathological does, however, call for reflection on the role and the status of the population level of organization in our approach to health phenomena. The entanglement of the biological and the social in human life and in contemporary societies justifies this level of analysis for better understanding the complexity and the interaction of health determinants both at the level of individuals and their interactions and at that of the population. But is this population level just a useful level of analysis that makes it possible to bring to light the social determinants of health at the individual level, or does it rest instead on characteristics of the population that are irreducible to individual characteristics, but which are nevertheless important for understanding and taking action with respect to both population and individual health? Defending this second alternative, I show how the epidemiological point of view, and in particular that of social epidemiology, leads us to rethink the possibility of a concept of “population health” that is not reducible to the sum of individual instances of health.