Judith Tonhauser
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Judith Tonhauser has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Craige Roberts
The Ohio State University
1 shared publication - David Beaver
Stanford University
1 shared publication - Mandy Simons
Department of Philosophy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 December 2016
- Published by Linguistic Society of America in Semantics and Linguistic Theory
- Vol. 26, 934-960
Prosodic cues to presupposition projection
In English utterances with factive predicates, the content of the clausal complement of the predicate may project, i.e., taken to be a commitment of the speaker, even when the factive predicate is embedded under an entailment canceling operator (e.g., Kiparsky & Kiparsky 1971; Karttunen 1971). Based on impressionistic judgments, Beaver (2010) and Simons, Beaver, Roberts & Tonhauser (to appear) suggested that whether the content of the complement of an utterance with a factive predicate projects depends on the information structure of the utterance and, since information structure is prosodically marked, on the prosodic realization of the utterance. This paper describes the results of three perception experiments designed to explore the influence of the prosodic realization of an utterance with a factive predicate on the projection of the content of the complement. The results of the experiments suggest that the prosodic realization of such utterances provides a cue to the projectivity of the content of the complement. These findings provide empirical support for the question-based analysis of projection advanced in Simons et al. to appear.
- 5 December 2016
- Published by Linguistic Society of America in Semantics and Linguistic Theory
- Vol. 26, 934-960
Open AccessProsodic cues to presupposition projection
In English utterances with factive predicates, the content of the clausal complement of the predicate may project, i.e., taken to be a commitment of the speaker, even when the factive predicate is embedded under an entailment canceling operator (e.g., Kiparsky & Kiparsky 1971; Karttunen 1971). Based on impressionistic judgments, Beaver (2010) and Simons, Beaver, Roberts & Tonhauser (to appear) suggested that whether the content of the complement of an utterance with a factive predicate projects depends on the information structure of the utterance and, since information structure is prosodically marked, on the prosodic realization of the utterance. This paper describes the results of three perception experiments designed to explore the influence of the prosodic realization of an utterance with a factive predicate on the projection of the content of the complement. The results of the experiments suggest that the prosodic realization of such utterances provides a cue to the projectivity of the content of the complement. These findings provide empirical support for the question-based analysis of projection advanced in Simons et al. to appear.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2015
- Published by Linguistic Society of America in Semantics and Linguistic Theory
- Vol. 20 (20) , 309-327
What projects and why
Projection is widely used as a diagnostic for presupposition, but many expression types yield projection even though they do not have standard properties of presupposition, for example appositives, expressives, and honorifics (Potts 2005). While it is possible to analyze projection piecemeal, clearly a unitary explanation is to be preferred. Yet we show that standard explanations of projective behavior (common ground based theories, anaphoric theories, and multi-dimensional theories) do not extend to the full range of triggers. Instead, we propose an alternative explanation based on the following claim: Meanings project IFF they are not at-issue, where at-issueness is defined in terms of the Roberts' (1995) discourse theory. Thus, and despite their apparent heterogeneity, projective meaning triggers emerge as a natural class on the basis of the not at-issue status of their projective inference.
- 3 April 2015
- Published by Linguistic Society of America in Semantics and Linguistic Theory
- Vol. 20 (20) , 309-327
Open AccessWhat projects and why
Projection is widely used as a diagnostic for presupposition, but many expression types yield projection even though they do not have standard properties of presupposition, for example appositives, expressives, and honorifics (Potts 2005). While it is possible to analyze projection piecemeal, clearly a unitary explanation is to be preferred. Yet we show that standard explanations of projective behavior (common ground based theories, anaphoric theories, and multi-dimensional theories) do not extend to the full range of triggers. Instead, we propose an alternative explanation based on the following claim: Meanings project IFF they are not at-issue, where at-issueness is defined in terms of the Roberts' (1995) discourse theory. Thus, and despite their apparent heterogeneity, projective meaning triggers emerge as a natural class on the basis of the not at-issue status of their projective inference.
- 4 February 2015
- Published by Wiley in Language and Linguistics Compass
- Vol. 9 (2) , 77-101
Are ‘informative presuppositions’ presuppositions?
Presuppositions are contents of utterances that must be mutually known by the interlocutors, i.e. the speaker and the addressees, in order for an utterance of a sentence with the presupposition trigger to be judged to be acceptable. However, a substantial subset of contents traditionally taken to be presuppositions does not exhibit this property and can instead be used to inform the addressee about the supposedly presuppositional content. Classical analyses of these so‐called ‘informative presuppositions’ nevertheless assume that they are associated with a common ground requirement but one that can be accommodated. According to an alternative characterization, ‘informative presuppositions’ are not associated with a common ground requirement but are informative like Potts' conventional implicatures; such a characterization does not need to make reference to accommodation. The debate about the characterization of ‘informative presuppositions’ has been based almost exclusively on judgments about English provided by native speaker researchers. This paper explores how results from research with theoretically untrained speakers (including one‐on‐one elicitation and experiments) as well as corpus studies can bear on this debate. I argue that such results, though tenuous, support the alternative characterization at least for some ‘informative presuppositions’ and emphasize the merit of bringing data collected through a wide range of methodologies to bear on theoretical research on meaning.
- 4 February 2015
- Published by Wiley in Language and Linguistics Compass
- Vol. 9 (2) , 77-101
Are ‘informative presuppositions’ presuppositions?
Presuppositions are contents of utterances that must be mutually known by the interlocutors, i.e. the speaker and the addressees, in order for an utterance of a sentence with the presupposition trigger to be judged to be acceptable. However, a substantial subset of contents traditionally taken to be presuppositions does not exhibit this property and can instead be used to inform the addressee about the supposedly presuppositional content. Classical analyses of these so‐called ‘informative presuppositions’ nevertheless assume that they are associated with a common ground requirement but one that can be accommodated. According to an alternative characterization, ‘informative presuppositions’ are not associated with a common ground requirement but are informative like Potts' conventional implicatures; such a characterization does not need to make reference to accommodation. The debate about the characterization of ‘informative presuppositions’ has been based almost exclusively on judgments about English provided by native speaker researchers. This paper explores how results from research with theoretically untrained speakers (including one‐on‐one elicitation and experiments) as well as corpus studies can bear on this debate. I argue that such results, though tenuous, support the alternative characterization at least for some ‘informative presuppositions’ and emphasize the merit of bringing data collected through a wide range of methodologies to bear on theoretical research on meaning.
- 1 May 2011
- Published by Springer Nature in Linguistics and Philosophy
- Vol. 34 (3) , 257-303
Temporal reference in Paraguayan Guaraní, a tenseless language
- 1 May 2011
- Published by Springer Nature in Linguistics and Philosophy
- Vol. 34 (3) , 257-303
Temporal reference in Paraguayan Guaraní, a tenseless language