Don L. Anderson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Don L. Anderson has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Dean C. Presnall
5 shared publicationsGillian R. Foulger
4 shared publicationsJames H. Natland
4 shared publications- Gillian Rose Foulger
Department of Earth Sciences Durham University Durham UK
2 shared publications - James H. Natland
Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, University of Miami, Miami, FL 33156, USA
2 shared publications - James H. Natland
Department of Marine Geosciences, Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, University of Miami, Miami, FL 33149
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 September 2014
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 111 (41) , E4298-E4304
Mantle updrafts and mechanisms of oceanic volcanism
Significance: Lord Kelvin’s name is associated with the laws of thermodynamics and the cooling Earth hypothesis. The widely accepted mantle plume conjecture has been justified by experiments and calculations that violate the laws of thermodynamics for an isolated cooling planet. Hotspots such as Hawaii, Samoa, Iceland, and Yellowstone are due to a thermal bump in the shallow mantle, a consequence of the cooling of the Earth. They are not due to ∼100- to 200-km-wide tubes extending upward from fixed points near the Earth’s core. Seismic imaging shows that features associated with hotspots are thousands of kilometers across, and inferred ascent rates are low. Plate tectonic-induced updrafts and a cooling planet explain hotspots and the volcanoes at oceanic ridges.
- 8 September 2014
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 111 (41) , E4298-E4304
Open AccessMantle updrafts and mechanisms of oceanic volcanism
Significance: Lord Kelvin’s name is associated with the laws of thermodynamics and the cooling Earth hypothesis. The widely accepted mantle plume conjecture has been justified by experiments and calculations that violate the laws of thermodynamics for an isolated cooling planet. Hotspots such as Hawaii, Samoa, Iceland, and Yellowstone are due to a thermal bump in the shallow mantle, a consequence of the cooling of the Earth. They are not due to ∼100- to 200-km-wide tubes extending upward from fixed points near the Earth’s core. Seismic imaging shows that features associated with hotspots are thousands of kilometers across, and inferred ascent rates are low. Plate tectonic-induced updrafts and a cooling planet explain hotspots and the volcanoes at oceanic ridges.
- 26 September 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Australian Journal of Earth Sciences
- Vol. 60 (6-7) , 657-673
The persistent mantle plume myth
Seismology, thermodynamics and classical physics—the physics associated with the names of Fourier, Debye, Born, Grüneisen, Kelvin, Rayleigh, Rutherford, Ramberg and Birch—show that ambient shallow mantle under large long-lived plates is hundreds of degrees hotter than in the passive upwellings that fuel the global spreading ridge system, that potential temperatures in mantle below about 200 km generally decrease with depth and that deep mantle low shear wave-speed features are broad, sluggish and dome-like rather than narrow and mantle-plume-like. The surface boundary layer of the mantle is more voluminous and potentially hotter than regions usually considered as sources for intraplate volcanoes. This means that the ‘mantle plume’ explanation for Hawaii and large igneous provinces is unnecessary. In isolated systems, heated from within and cooled from above, upwellings are passive and large, which suggests that tomographic features, and upwellings, are responses to plate tectonics, spreading and subduction, at least until melting introduces a small intrinsic buoyancy at shallow depths. Melting anomalies, or ‘hotspots,’ are side-effects of plate tectonics and are fed primarily by shear-driven processes in the boundary layer (BL), not by deep buoyant upwellings. A dense basal melange (BAM) component further stabilises the lower boundary layer of the mantle. Mid-ocean ridges and associated broad passive depleted mantle (DM) upwellings probably originate in the transition region. Deeper mantle upwellings are broad domes that stay in the lower mantle.
- 26 September 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Australian Journal of Earth Sciences
- Vol. 60 (6-7) , 657-673
The persistent mantle plume myth
Seismology, thermodynamics and classical physics—the physics associated with the names of Fourier, Debye, Born, Grüneisen, Kelvin, Rayleigh, Rutherford, Ramberg and Birch—show that ambient shallow mantle under large long-lived plates is hundreds of degrees hotter than in the passive upwellings that fuel the global spreading ridge system, that potential temperatures in mantle below about 200 km generally decrease with depth and that deep mantle low shear wave-speed features are broad, sluggish and dome-like rather than narrow and mantle-plume-like. The surface boundary layer of the mantle is more voluminous and potentially hotter than regions usually considered as sources for intraplate volcanoes. This means that the ‘mantle plume’ explanation for Hawaii and large igneous provinces is unnecessary. In isolated systems, heated from within and cooled from above, upwellings are passive and large, which suggests that tomographic features, and upwellings, are responses to plate tectonics, spreading and subduction, at least until melting introduces a small intrinsic buoyancy at shallow depths. Melting anomalies, or ‘hotspots,’ are side-effects of plate tectonics and are fed primarily by shear-driven processes in the boundary layer (BL), not by deep buoyant upwellings. A dense basal melange (BAM) component further stabilises the lower boundary layer of the mantle. Mid-ocean ridges and associated broad passive depleted mantle (DM) upwellings probably originate in the transition region. Deeper mantle upwellings are broad domes that stay in the lower mantle.
- Open Access
- 2 December 2010
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Petrology
- Vol. 52 (7-8) , 1547-1577
Hawaii, Boundary Layers and Ambient Mantle—Geophysical Constraints
Recent high-resolution seismic observations and geodynamic calculations suggest that mid-plate swells and volcanoes are plausibly controlled by processes and materials entirely in the upper boundary layer (VSV and VSH, and they vary differently with depth. VSH is mainly sensitive to the temperature gradient and indicates a high thermal gradient to 220 km depth. VSV is mainly sensitive to melt content. The depth of the minimum isotropic shear velocity, Vs, under young plates occurs near 60 km and this rapidly increases to 150 km under older oceanic plates, including Hawaii; 150 km may represent the depth of isostatic compensation for swells and the source of tholeiiic basalt magmas. The high-velocity seismic lid thickens as the square-root of age across the entire Pacific, but the underlying mantle is not isothermal; average sub-ridge mantle is colder, by various measures, than mid-plate mantle. Ambient mantle potential temperature at depth under the central Pacific may be ∼200°C higher, without deep mantle plume input, than near spreading ridges. This is consistent with bathymetry and seismic velocities and the temperature range of non-ridge magmas. Some of the thinnest and, in terms of traditional interpretations, hottest transition zones (TZ; ∼410–650 km depth) are under hotspot-free areas of western North America, Greenland, Europe, Russia, Brazil and India. The lowest seismic velocity regions in the upper mantle BL are under young oceanic plates, back-arc basins and hotspot-free areas of California and the Pacific and Indian oceans. Cold slabs may displace hotter material out of the TZ but geophysical data, and geodynamic simulations, do not require deeper sources. Magmas extracted from deep in a thick conduction layer are expected to be hotter than shallower oceanic ridge magmas and more variable in temperature. Mid-plate magmas appear to represent normal ambient mantle at depths of ∼150 km, rather than very localized very deep upwellings. Shear-driven upwellings from the base of the BL explain mid-plate magmatism and its association with fracture zones and anomalous anisotropy, and the persistence of some volcanic chains and the short duration of others. The hotter deeper part of the surface BL is moving at a fraction of the plate velocity and is sampled only where sheared or displaced upwards by tectonic structures and processes that upset the usual stable laminar flow. If mid-plate volcanoes are sourced in the lower half of the BL, between 100 and 220 km depth, or below, then they will appear to define a relatively fixed reference system and the associated temperatures will increase with depth of magma extraction. Lithospheric architecture and stress control the locations of volcanoes, not localized thermal anomalies or deep mantle plumes.
- 2 December 2010
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Petrology
- Vol. 52 (7-8) , 1547-1577
Open AccessHawaii, Boundary Layers and Ambient Mantle—Geophysical Constraints
Recent high-resolution seismic observations and geodynamic calculations suggest that mid-plate swells and volcanoes are plausibly controlled by processes and materials entirely in the upper boundary layer (VSV and VSH, and they vary differently with depth. VSH is mainly sensitive to the temperature gradient and indicates a high thermal gradient to 220 km depth. VSV is mainly sensitive to melt content. The depth of the minimum isotropic shear velocity, Vs, under young plates occurs near 60 km and this rapidly increases to 150 km under older oceanic plates, including Hawaii; 150 km may represent the depth of isostatic compensation for swells and the source of tholeiiic basalt magmas. The high-velocity seismic lid thickens as the square-root of age across the entire Pacific, but the underlying mantle is not isothermal; average sub-ridge mantle is colder, by various measures, than mid-plate mantle. Ambient mantle potential temperature at depth under the central Pacific may be ∼200°C higher, without deep mantle plume input, than near spreading ridges. This is consistent with bathymetry and seismic velocities and the temperature range of non-ridge magmas. Some of the thinnest and, in terms of traditional interpretations, hottest transition zones (TZ; ∼410–650 km depth) are under hotspot-free areas of western North America, Greenland, Europe, Russia, Brazil and India. The lowest seismic velocity regions in the upper mantle BL are under young oceanic plates, back-arc basins and hotspot-free areas of California and the Pacific and Indian oceans. Cold slabs may displace hotter material out of the TZ but geophysical data, and geodynamic simulations, do not require deeper sources. Magmas extracted from deep in a thick conduction layer are expected to be hotter than shallower oceanic ridge magmas and more variable in temperature. Mid-plate magmas appear to represent normal ambient mantle at depths of ∼150 km, rather than very localized very deep upwellings. Shear-driven upwellings from the base of the BL explain mid-plate magmatism and its association with fracture zones and anomalous anisotropy, and the persistence of some volcanic chains and the short duration of others. The hotter deeper part of the surface BL is moving at a fraction of the plate velocity and is sampled only where sheared or displaced upwards by tectonic structures and processes that upset the usual stable laminar flow. If mid-plate volcanoes are sourced in the lower half of the BL, between 100 and 220 km depth, or below, then they will appear to define a relatively fixed reference system and the associated temperatures will increase with depth of magma extraction. Lithospheric architecture and stress control the locations of volcanoes, not localized thermal anomalies or deep mantle plumes.
- 22 November 2007
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 450 (7169) , E15
Evidence for mantle plumes?
Geophysical hotspots have been attributed to partially molten asthenosphere, fertile blobs, small-scale convection and upwellings driven by core heat. Most are short-lived or too close together to be deeply seated, and do not have anomalous heat flow or temperature; many are related to tectonic features. Bourdon et al. investigate the dynamics of mantle plumes from uranium-series geochemistry and interpret their results as evidence for thermal plumes. Here we show why alternative mechanisms of upwelling and melting should be considered.
- 22 November 2007
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 450 (7169) , E15
Evidence for mantle plumes?
Geophysical hotspots have been attributed to partially molten asthenosphere, fertile blobs, small-scale convection and upwellings driven by core heat. Most are short-lived or too close together to be deeply seated, and do not have anomalous heat flow or temperature; many are related to tectonic features. Bourdon et al. investigate the dynamics of mantle plumes from uranium-series geochemistry and interpret their results as evidence for thermal plumes. Here we show why alternative mechanisms of upwelling and melting should be considered.
- 1 December 2005
- Published by Mineralogical Society of America in Elements
- Vol. 1 (5) , 271-275
Large Igneous Provinces, Delamination, and Fertile Mantle
When continental crust gets too thick, the dense eclogitic bottom detaches, causing uplift, asthenospheric upwelling, and pressure-release melting. Delamination introduces warm blocks of lower crust with a low melting point into the mantle; these eventually heat up, ascend, decompress, and melt. The mantle below 100 km depth is mainly below the melting point of dry peridotite, but its temperature will be above the melting point of recycled fertile (basaltic or eclogitic) components, obviating the need for excess temperature to form “hotspots” or “melting anomalies”. When plates pull apart or delaminate, the mantle upwells; entrained crustal fragments of various ages are fertile and create melting anomalies along developing mid-ocean ridges, fracture zones, and old suture zones. Eclogites associated with delamination are warmer and less dense than subducted oceanic crust and more susceptible to melting and entrainment.
- 1 December 2005
- Published by Mineralogical Society of America in Elements
- Vol. 1 (5) , 271-275
Large Igneous Provinces, Delamination, and Fertile Mantle
When continental crust gets too thick, the dense eclogitic bottom detaches, causing uplift, asthenospheric upwelling, and pressure-release melting. Delamination introduces warm blocks of lower crust with a low melting point into the mantle; these eventually heat up, ascend, decompress, and melt. The mantle below 100 km depth is mainly below the melting point of dry peridotite, but its temperature will be above the melting point of recycled fertile (basaltic or eclogitic) components, obviating the need for excess temperature to form “hotspots” or “melting anomalies”. When plates pull apart or delaminate, the mantle upwells; entrained crustal fragments of various ages are fertile and create melting anomalies along developing mid-ocean ridges, fracture zones, and old suture zones. Eclogites associated with delamination are warmer and less dense than subducted oceanic crust and more susceptible to melting and entrainment.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Genesis of the Iceland melt anomaly by plate tectonic processes
Iceland is the best studied, large-volume, active volcanic region in the world. It features the largest subaerial exposure of any hotspot at a spreading ridge, and it is conventionally attributed to a thermal plume in the mantle. However, whereas the apparently large melt productivity and low-wavespeed mantle seismic anomaly are consistent with this attribution, at any more detailed level, the observations are poorly predicted by the plume hypothesis. There is no time-progressive volcanic track, the melt anomaly having been persistently centered on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. Spatial variations in crustal structure are inconsistent with the southeastward migration that is required of a plume fixed with respect to other Indo-Atlantic hotspots. The mantle seismic anomaly weakens with depth and does not extend into the lower mantle. Estimates of excess temperature using a broad range of methods are inconsistent with a mantle potential temperature anomaly greater than a few tens of K. Much of the lava erupted in Iceland has geochemistry little different from normal mid-ocean ridge basalt, and the detailed spatial geochemical pattern bears little resemblance to what is predicted for a plume beneath central Iceland. We propose an alternative model in an attempt to explain the observations at Iceland with fewer difficulties. Our model involves only shallow plate tectonic processes and attributes the large melt volume to the remelting of subducted oceanic crust trapped in the Caledonian suture in the form of eclogite or mantle peridotite fertilized by resorbed eclogite. Delaminated continental mantle lithosphere may also be involved. Such a source can produce several times more melt than pure peridotite without the need for high temperatures. The longevity of anomalous volcanism at the Mid-Atlantic Ridge at the latitude of Iceland is attributed to its location on a Caledonian structure that runs transversely across the north Atlantic. Many aspects of the geochemistry of Icelandic lavas fit this model, which also provides an explanation for the high maximum helium isotope ratios observed there. The “depleted plume component” may be derived from abyssal olivine gabbro cumulates and the “enriched plume component” from recycled enriched material that forms part of the crustal section of subducted slabs. Such a model for the Iceland melting anomaly raises new questions concerning how much thermal energy can be generated by isentropic upwelling of eclogite at a ridge, the location of the homogenizing reservoirs required, and the mechanism by which fertile material is incorporated into the asthenosphere beneath new oceans. Most fundamentally, if validated, such a model can explain the generic observations associated with hotspots as shallow processes associated with plate tectonics, and thus raises the question of whether thermal plumes are required in general in the Earth.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Genesis of the Iceland melt anomaly by plate tectonic processes
Iceland is the best studied, large-volume, active volcanic region in the world. It features the largest subaerial exposure of any hotspot at a spreading ridge, and it is conventionally attributed to a thermal plume in the mantle. However, whereas the apparently large melt productivity and low-wavespeed mantle seismic anomaly are consistent with this attribution, at any more detailed level, the observations are poorly predicted by the plume hypothesis. There is no time-progressive volcanic track, the melt anomaly having been persistently centered on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. Spatial variations in crustal structure are inconsistent with the southeastward migration that is required of a plume fixed with respect to other Indo-Atlantic hotspots. The mantle seismic anomaly weakens with depth and does not extend into the lower mantle. Estimates of excess temperature using a broad range of methods are inconsistent with a mantle potential temperature anomaly greater than a few tens of K. Much of the lava erupted in Iceland has geochemistry little different from normal mid-ocean ridge basalt, and the detailed spatial geochemical pattern bears little resemblance to what is predicted for a plume beneath central Iceland. We propose an alternative model in an attempt to explain the observations at Iceland with fewer difficulties. Our model involves only shallow plate tectonic processes and attributes the large melt volume to the remelting of subducted oceanic crust trapped in the Caledonian suture in the form of eclogite or mantle peridotite fertilized by resorbed eclogite. Delaminated continental mantle lithosphere may also be involved. Such a source can produce several times more melt than pure peridotite without the need for high temperatures. The longevity of anomalous volcanism at the Mid-Atlantic Ridge at the latitude of Iceland is attributed to its location on a Caledonian structure that runs transversely across the north Atlantic. Many aspects of the geochemistry of Icelandic lavas fit this model, which also provides an explanation for the high maximum helium isotope ratios observed there. The “depleted plume component” may be derived from abyssal olivine gabbro cumulates and the “enriched plume component” from recycled enriched material that forms part of the crustal section of subducted slabs. Such a model for the Iceland melting anomaly raises new questions concerning how much thermal energy can be generated by isentropic upwelling of eclogite at a ridge, the location of the homogenizing reservoirs required, and the mechanism by which fertile material is incorporated into the asthenosphere beneath new oceans. Most fundamentally, if validated, such a model can explain the generic observations associated with hotspots as shallow processes associated with plate tectonics, and thus raises the question of whether thermal plumes are required in general in the Earth.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Scoring hotspots: The plume and plate paradigms
The origin of midplate and along-ridge melting anomalies is controversial. Hypotheses involve, at one extreme, concentrated hot mantle upwellings from the deepest mantle and, at the other extreme, shallow processes dominated by stress, plate tectonics, and fertility variations, along with an asthenosphere that is near the melting point. An updated hotspot list is presented and is tested against criteria relevant to both the deep thermal plume and the shallow (plate and asthenosphere) hypotheses. The unique polling approach of Courtillot et al. (2003) is applied to the plume hypothesis and to other hypotheses for melting anomalies. Although some “primary” (i.e., potentially deep-seated) hotspots (Iceland, Hawaii, Easter, Louisville, Afar, Ré-union, and Tristan) score well using the chosen subjective plume criteria, they score poorly using criteria more appropriate to deep or thermal processes, such as magma temperature, heatflow, transition zone thickness, and high-resolution upper and lower mantle seismic tomographic results. In particular, Iceland, Easter, Afar, Tristan, and Yellowstone have not been confirmed by tomography. They are shallow features with well-defined plate tectonic explanations. For most melting anomalies (aka “hotspots”) the plume hypothesis scores poorly against competing hypotheses such as stress- and crack-controlled magmatism, mechanisms that are associated with plate tectonics. Based on the results, most “hotspots,” including proposed “primary” or plume-candidate hotspots, are unlikely to be caused by thermal plumes from deep thermal boundary layers. Melting anomalies, on- or off-ridge, appear to be a natural result of nonrigid plate tectonics, including recycling, and do not require an extraordinary explanation, such as narrow thermal instabilities that traverse the whole mantle. Thus plate tectonics, plate boundaries, global plate reorganization, normal magmatism, melting anomalies, volcanic chains, and mantle geochemistry can be unified into a single theory. We see that many assumptions used in previous hypotheses can be discarded as unnecessary … there is no need to locate the source of plumes in the lower mantle. —Richter and Parsons (1975)
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Scoring hotspots: The plume and plate paradigms
The origin of midplate and along-ridge melting anomalies is controversial. Hypotheses involve, at one extreme, concentrated hot mantle upwellings from the deepest mantle and, at the other extreme, shallow processes dominated by stress, plate tectonics, and fertility variations, along with an asthenosphere that is near the melting point. An updated hotspot list is presented and is tested against criteria relevant to both the deep thermal plume and the shallow (plate and asthenosphere) hypotheses. The unique polling approach of Courtillot et al. (2003) is applied to the plume hypothesis and to other hypotheses for melting anomalies. Although some “primary” (i.e., potentially deep-seated) hotspots (Iceland, Hawaii, Easter, Louisville, Afar, Ré-union, and Tristan) score well using the chosen subjective plume criteria, they score poorly using criteria more appropriate to deep or thermal processes, such as magma temperature, heatflow, transition zone thickness, and high-resolution upper and lower mantle seismic tomographic results. In particular, Iceland, Easter, Afar, Tristan, and Yellowstone have not been confirmed by tomography. They are shallow features with well-defined plate tectonic explanations. For most melting anomalies (aka “hotspots”) the plume hypothesis scores poorly against competing hypotheses such as stress- and crack-controlled magmatism, mechanisms that are associated with plate tectonics. Based on the results, most “hotspots,” including proposed “primary” or plume-candidate hotspots, are unlikely to be caused by thermal plumes from deep thermal boundary layers. Melting anomalies, on- or off-ridge, appear to be a natural result of nonrigid plate tectonics, including recycling, and do not require an extraordinary explanation, such as narrow thermal instabilities that traverse the whole mantle. Thus plate tectonics, plate boundaries, global plate reorganization, normal magmatism, melting anomalies, volcanic chains, and mantle geochemistry can be unified into a single theory. We see that many assumptions used in previous hypotheses can be discarded as unnecessary … there is no need to locate the source of plumes in the lower mantle. —Richter and Parsons (1975)
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
A brief history of the plume hypothesis and its competitors: Concept and controversy
The modern plume hypothesis began as a concept for a special form of thermal convection in which narrow, geographically well-defined regions of upwelling are balanced by diffuse downwelling in a manner similar to atmospheric phenomena such as thunderheads (Morgan, 1972b). These narrow active upwellings were an alternative to giant convection cells (e.g., Holmes, 1929, 1944; Hess, 1962); they drove plate tectonics and fueled the asthenosphere. The number of plumes has varied from the original “∼20” to recent estimates of 5200 for the number of moderate-sized plumes and 6 or so for the number of “primary” plumes; this suggests some uncertainty in what constitutes a plume. Tozer (1973) showed that what geologists had in mind for mantle upwellings could not be the same as fluid dynamic plumes and could not be explained by the same physics. The effects of pressure on material properties reinforce these conclusions. Interest in various versions of the diapir and plume hypotheses peaked in 1950, 1970, and especially 1990, but these versions fell into disfavor or disinterest in the intervening years because of various paradoxes, contradictions, and increasing interest in alternative mechanisms. The physical basis of plumes was questioned, and still is. Since 1990 specialists in diverse disciplines have adopted the plume hypothesis in spite of the various paradoxes and the still outstanding lack of a physical basis under conditions appropriate for the Earth's mantle. In this highly selective view of the history of explanations for “melting anomalies” we focus on the underlying assumptions, physics, and philosophy and on key turning points in that history. We concentrate on the anomalies, neglected physics, petrology, and deep mantle aspects rather than on the better-known tectonic, geochronological, and geochemical ones. We also discuss briefly the alternatives to the plume hypothesis. A primary assumption of the plume hypothesis is that the mantle is to the first order composed of a homogenous lherzolite or pyrolite. Mantle homogeneity is the cornerstone of petrological models that attempt to estimate the potential temperature and magma productivity of the mantle. A general theory of plate tectonics, one that involves recycling, incipient and reactivated plate boundaries, and ephemeral plates, may remove the necessity to have different theories for plate tectonics, large igneous provinces, and linear island chains. Cooling of the mantle from above, and forces from cooling plates and subducting slabs, may be adequate to drive the plates, break the plates, close up or reactivate plate boundaries, reorganize plates, and drive underlying mantle flow. In such a scenario the mantle—variable in fertility and melting point because of recycling—is by and large passively responding to gravitationally driven motions of the top; dikes and plate boundaries are the result of variable stress in the lithosphere, and melting anomalies reflect the variable fertility of the underlying mantle.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
A brief history of the plume hypothesis and its competitors: Concept and controversy
The modern plume hypothesis began as a concept for a special form of thermal convection in which narrow, geographically well-defined regions of upwelling are balanced by diffuse downwelling in a manner similar to atmospheric phenomena such as thunderheads (Morgan, 1972b). These narrow active upwellings were an alternative to giant convection cells (e.g., Holmes, 1929, 1944; Hess, 1962); they drove plate tectonics and fueled the asthenosphere. The number of plumes has varied from the original “∼20” to recent estimates of 5200 for the number of moderate-sized plumes and 6 or so for the number of “primary” plumes; this suggests some uncertainty in what constitutes a plume. Tozer (1973) showed that what geologists had in mind for mantle upwellings could not be the same as fluid dynamic plumes and could not be explained by the same physics. The effects of pressure on material properties reinforce these conclusions. Interest in various versions of the diapir and plume hypotheses peaked in 1950, 1970, and especially 1990, but these versions fell into disfavor or disinterest in the intervening years because of various paradoxes, contradictions, and increasing interest in alternative mechanisms. The physical basis of plumes was questioned, and still is. Since 1990 specialists in diverse disciplines have adopted the plume hypothesis in spite of the various paradoxes and the still outstanding lack of a physical basis under conditions appropriate for the Earth's mantle. In this highly selective view of the history of explanations for “melting anomalies” we focus on the underlying assumptions, physics, and philosophy and on key turning points in that history. We concentrate on the anomalies, neglected physics, petrology, and deep mantle aspects rather than on the better-known tectonic, geochronological, and geochemical ones. We also discuss briefly the alternatives to the plume hypothesis. A primary assumption of the plume hypothesis is that the mantle is to the first order composed of a homogenous lherzolite or pyrolite. Mantle homogeneity is the cornerstone of petrological models that attempt to estimate the potential temperature and magma productivity of the mantle. A general theory of plate tectonics, one that involves recycling, incipient and reactivated plate boundaries, and ephemeral plates, may remove the necessity to have different theories for plate tectonics, large igneous provinces, and linear island chains. Cooling of the mantle from above, and forces from cooling plates and subducting slabs, may be adequate to drive the plates, break the plates, close up or reactivate plate boundaries, reorganize plates, and drive underlying mantle flow. In such a scenario the mantle—variable in fertility and melting point because of recycling—is by and large passively responding to gravitationally driven motions of the top; dikes and plate boundaries are the result of variable stress in the lithosphere, and melting anomalies reflect the variable fertility of the underlying mantle.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Global tectonic maps
Full article available in PDF version.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Geological Society of America
Global tectonic maps
Full article available in PDF version.