David Harte
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
David Harte has a total of 46 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mark Bebbington
Volcanic Risk Solutions, School of Agriculture and Environment, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand
7 shared publications J. M. Cowley
Applied Statistics Group, Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, P.O. Box 2526, Wellington, New Zealand
4 shared publicationsR. T. Baker
Applied Statistics Group, Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, P.O. Box 2526, Wellington, New Zealand
4 shared publicationsDavid Vere‐Jones
Statistics Research Associate, PO Box 12649, Thorndon Wellington 6144 New Zealand
3 shared publicationsLi Ma
China Seismological Bureau
2 shared publicationsLi-Feng Wang
China Seismological Bureau
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 February 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Engineering Geology
- Vol. 281
Can artesian groundwater and earthquake-induced aquifer leakage exacerbate the manifestation of liquefaction?
- 1 February 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Engineering Geology
- Vol. 281
Open AccessCan artesian groundwater and earthquake-induced aquifer leakage exacerbate the manifestation of liquefaction?
- 18 February 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 217 (3) , 1894-1914
Evaluation of earthquake stochastic models based on their real-time forecasts: a case study of Kaikoura 2016
The M7.8 Kaikoura NZ earthquake started at 2016-11-13 11:02:56 (UTC) with epicentre (173.02°E, 42.69°S), 15 km NE of Culverden, and lasted for about two minutes. It caused multiple fault ruptures to the north as far as Seddon, the location of a large sequence in 2013. Since the mainshock, the bulk of the aftershock activity has also migrated to the north. We analyse real-time probability forecasts produced during the Kaikoura 2016 aftershock sequence, based on a spatial ETAS model. Forecasts were derived by simulating the model forward over the required time interval multiple times. Each forecast was evaluated at the end of the forecast time interval by comparing with the number of events that eventually occurred. Further, the spatial and temporal forecast characteristics were evaluated by comparing the actual log-likelihood with those of the simulations. We show that the model was forecasting too few aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, and too many aftershocks in the later stages of the sequence. The too few aftershocks is probably caused by many missing smaller events early in the sequence and an initial large under-estimate of the mainshock magnitude, being 6.6 with a final solution of 7.8 three days later. Over forecasting in the later stages is partially caused by a magnitude discrepancy between the CUSP and SeisComP3 software. The CUSP software was used to solve event solutions until the end of 2011, and the SeisComP3 software has been used since 2012. Our ETAS model parameters were estimated using catalogue data until the end of 2011 (CUSP). Other catalogue, model and methodological problems become evident during such a real-time exercise and these are also discussed.
- 18 February 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 217 (3) , 1894-1914
Evaluation of earthquake stochastic models based on their real-time forecasts: a case study of Kaikoura 2016
The M7.8 Kaikoura NZ earthquake started at 2016-11-13 11:02:56 (UTC) with epicentre (173.02°E, 42.69°S), 15 km NE of Culverden, and lasted for about two minutes. It caused multiple fault ruptures to the north as far as Seddon, the location of a large sequence in 2013. Since the mainshock, the bulk of the aftershock activity has also migrated to the north. We analyse real-time probability forecasts produced during the Kaikoura 2016 aftershock sequence, based on a spatial ETAS model. Forecasts were derived by simulating the model forward over the required time interval multiple times. Each forecast was evaluated at the end of the forecast time interval by comparing with the number of events that eventually occurred. Further, the spatial and temporal forecast characteristics were evaluated by comparing the actual log-likelihood with those of the simulations. We show that the model was forecasting too few aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, and too many aftershocks in the later stages of the sequence. The too few aftershocks is probably caused by many missing smaller events early in the sequence and an initial large under-estimate of the mainshock magnitude, being 6.6 with a final solution of 7.8 three days later. Over forecasting in the later stages is partially caused by a magnitude discrepancy between the CUSP and SeisComP3 software. The CUSP software was used to solve event solutions until the end of 2011, and the SeisComP3 software has been used since 2012. Our ETAS model parameters were estimated using catalogue data until the end of 2011 (CUSP). Other catalogue, model and methodological problems become evident during such a real-time exercise and these are also discussed.
- 14 May 2018
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 115 (22) , 5686-5691
Pacing of Paleozoic macroevolutionary rates by Milankovitch grand cycles
Significance: There has been long-standing debate about the relative roles of intrinsic biotic interactions vs. extrinsic environmental factors as drivers of biodiversity change. Here, we show that, relatively early in the history of complex life, Milankovitch “grand cycles” associated with astronomical rhythms explain between 9 and 16% of variation in species turnover probability (extinction probability plus speciation probability) in a major Early Paleozoic zooplankton group, the graptoloids. These grand cycles would have modulated climate variability, alternating times of relative stability in the environment with times of maximum volatility, which influenced oceanic circulation and structure and thus, phytoplankton populations at the base of the marine food web.
- 14 May 2018
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 115 (22) , 5686-5691
Pacing of Paleozoic macroevolutionary rates by Milankovitch grand cycles
Significance: There has been long-standing debate about the relative roles of intrinsic biotic interactions vs. extrinsic environmental factors as drivers of biodiversity change. Here, we show that, relatively early in the history of complex life, Milankovitch “grand cycles” associated with astronomical rhythms explain between 9 and 16% of variation in species turnover probability (extinction probability plus speciation probability) in a major Early Paleozoic zooplankton group, the graptoloids. These grand cycles would have modulated climate variability, alternating times of relative stability in the environment with times of maximum volatility, which influenced oceanic circulation and structure and thus, phytoplankton populations at the base of the marine food web.
- 14 April 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 214 (2) , 759-772
Effect of sample size on parameter estimates and earthquake forecasts
The Epidemic Type Aftershock Sequence (ETAS) model is widely used for producing probability forecasts of aftershocks in some space-time-magnitude volume following a major earthquake. It is empirically based, embodying the Omori and Gutenberg-Richter relationships. The model is generally calibrated (parameter estimation) using historical data. If there are insufficient historical data (i.e. sample size), our calibration could be poor. We initially quantify the effect of temporal sample size on the distributional properties of parameter estimates of a spatial ETAS model. Using these distributions, indexed by time the temporal sample size, we then determine the effect of parameter uncertainty on earthquake forecast uncertainty.
- 14 April 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 214 (2) , 759-772
Effect of sample size on parameter estimates and earthquake forecasts
The Epidemic Type Aftershock Sequence (ETAS) model is widely used for producing probability forecasts of aftershocks in some space-time-magnitude volume following a major earthquake. It is empirically based, embodying the Omori and Gutenberg-Richter relationships. The model is generally calibrated (parameter estimation) using historical data. If there are insufficient historical data (i.e. sample size), our calibration could be poor. We initially quantify the effect of temporal sample size on the distributional properties of parameter estimates of a spatial ETAS model. Using these distributions, indexed by time the temporal sample size, we then determine the effect of parameter uncertainty on earthquake forecast uncertainty.
- 11 April 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 210 (1) , 90-104
Probability distribution of forecasts based on the ETAS model
- 11 April 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 210 (1) , 90-104
Probability distribution of forecasts based on the ETAS model
- 22 March 2016
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
- Vol. 106 (2) , 398-407
A Revised Local Magnitude (ML) Scale for New Zealand Earthquakes
- 22 March 2016
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
- Vol. 106 (2) , 398-407
A Revised Local Magnitude (ML) Scale for New Zealand Earthquakes
- 24 February 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 205 (2) , 1180-1189
Statistical estimation of the duration of aftershock sequences
It is well known that large earthquakes generally trigger aftershock sequences. However, the duration of those sequences is unclear due to the gradual power-law decay with time. The triggering time is assumed to be infinite in the epidemic type aftershock sequence (ETAS) model, a widely used statistical model to describe clustering phenomena in observed earthquake catalogues. This assumption leads to the constraint that the power-law exponent p of the Omori-Utsu decay has to be larger than one to avoid supercritical conditions with accelerating seismic activity on long timescales. In contrast, seismicity models based on rate- and state-dependent friction observed in laboratory experiments predict p ≤ 1 and a finite triggering time scaling inversely to the tectonic stressing rate. To investigate this conflict, we analyse an ETAS model with finite triggering times, which allow smaller values of p. We use synthetic earthquake sequences to show that the assumption of infinite triggering times can lead to a significant bias in the maximum likelihood estimates of the ETAS parameters. Furthermore, it is shown that the triggering time can be reasonably estimated using real earthquake catalogue data, although the uncertainties are large. The analysis of real earthquake catalogues indicates mainly finite triggering times in the order of 100 days to 10 years with a weak negative correlation to the background rate, in agreement with expectations of the rate- and state-friction model. The triggering time is not the same as the apparent duration, which is the time period in which aftershocks dominate the seismicity. The apparent duration is shown to be strongly dependent on the mainshock magnitude and the level of background activity. It can be much shorter than the triggering time. Finally, we perform forward simulations to estimate the effective forecasting period, which is the time period following a mainshock, in which ETAS simulations can improve rate estimates after the occurrence of a mainshock. We find that this effective forecasting period is only in the order of 100 days for moderate mainshocks and in the order of a few years for large events, even if the underlying triggering process lasts much longer.
- 24 February 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 205 (2) , 1180-1189
Statistical estimation of the duration of aftershock sequences
It is well known that large earthquakes generally trigger aftershock sequences. However, the duration of those sequences is unclear due to the gradual power-law decay with time. The triggering time is assumed to be infinite in the epidemic type aftershock sequence (ETAS) model, a widely used statistical model to describe clustering phenomena in observed earthquake catalogues. This assumption leads to the constraint that the power-law exponent p of the Omori-Utsu decay has to be larger than one to avoid supercritical conditions with accelerating seismic activity on long timescales. In contrast, seismicity models based on rate- and state-dependent friction observed in laboratory experiments predict p ≤ 1 and a finite triggering time scaling inversely to the tectonic stressing rate. To investigate this conflict, we analyse an ETAS model with finite triggering times, which allow smaller values of p. We use synthetic earthquake sequences to show that the assumption of infinite triggering times can lead to a significant bias in the maximum likelihood estimates of the ETAS parameters. Furthermore, it is shown that the triggering time can be reasonably estimated using real earthquake catalogue data, although the uncertainties are large. The analysis of real earthquake catalogues indicates mainly finite triggering times in the order of 100 days to 10 years with a weak negative correlation to the background rate, in agreement with expectations of the rate- and state-friction model. The triggering time is not the same as the apparent duration, which is the time period in which aftershocks dominate the seismicity. The apparent duration is shown to be strongly dependent on the mainshock magnitude and the level of background activity. It can be much shorter than the triggering time. Finally, we perform forward simulations to estimate the effective forecasting period, which is the time period following a mainshock, in which ETAS simulations can improve rate estimates after the occurrence of a mainshock. We find that this effective forecasting period is only in the order of 100 days for moderate mainshocks and in the order of a few years for large events, even if the underlying triggering process lasts much longer.
- 30 December 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 204 (2) , 1266-1287
Model parameter estimation bias induced by earthquake magnitude cut-off
We evaluate the bias in parameter estimates of the ETAS model. We show that when a simulated catalogue is magnitude-truncated there is considerable bias, whereas when it is not truncated there is no discernible bias. We also discuss two further implied assumptions in the ETAS and other self-exciting models. First, that the triggering boundary magnitude is equivalent to the catalogue completeness magnitude. Secondly, the assumption in the Gutenberg–Richter relationship that numbers of events increase exponentially as magnitude decreases. These two assumptions are confounded with the magnitude truncation effect. We discuss the effect of these problems on analyses of real earthquake catalogues.
- 30 December 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 204 (2) , 1266-1287
Model parameter estimation bias induced by earthquake magnitude cut-off
We evaluate the bias in parameter estimates of the ETAS model. We show that when a simulated catalogue is magnitude-truncated there is considerable bias, whereas when it is not truncated there is no discernible bias. We also discuss two further implied assumptions in the ETAS and other self-exciting models. First, that the triggering boundary magnitude is equivalent to the catalogue completeness magnitude. Secondly, the assumption in the Gutenberg–Richter relationship that numbers of events increase exponentially as magnitude decreases. These two assumptions are confounded with the magnitude truncation effect. We discuss the effect of these problems on analyses of real earthquake catalogues.
- 12 March 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Pure and Applied Geophysics
- Vol. 173 (1) , 5-20
Cumulative Coulomb Stress Triggering as an Explanation for the Canterbury (New Zealand) Aftershock Sequence: Initial Conditions Are Everything?
- 12 March 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Pure and Applied Geophysics
- Vol. 173 (1) , 5-20
Cumulative Coulomb Stress Triggering as an Explanation for the Canterbury (New Zealand) Aftershock Sequence: Initial Conditions Are Everything?
- 5 March 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 201 (2) , 711-723
Log-likelihood of earthquake models: evaluation of models and forecasts
There has been debate in the Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability project about the most appropriate form of the likelihood function to use to evaluate earthquake forecasts in specified discrete space–time intervals, and also to evaluate the validity of the model itself. The debate includes whether the likelihood function should be discrete in nature, given that the forecasts are in discrete space–time bins, or continuous. If discrete, can different bins be assumed to be statistically independent, and is it satisfactory to assume that the forecasted count in each bin will have a Poisson distribution? In order to discuss these questions, we start with the most simple models (homogeneous Poisson), and progressively develop the model complexity to include self exciting point process models. For each, we compare the discrete and continuous time likelihoods. Examples are given where it is proven that the counts in discrete space–time bins are not Poisson. We argue that the form of the likelihood function is intrinsic to the given model, and the required forecast for some specified space–time region simply determines where the likelihood function should be evaluated. We show that continuous time point process models where the likelihood function is also defined in continuous space and time can easily produce forecasts over discrete space–time intervals.
- 5 March 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 201 (2) , 711-723
Log-likelihood of earthquake models: evaluation of models and forecasts
There has been debate in the Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability project about the most appropriate form of the likelihood function to use to evaluate earthquake forecasts in specified discrete space–time intervals, and also to evaluate the validity of the model itself. The debate includes whether the likelihood function should be discrete in nature, given that the forecasts are in discrete space–time bins, or continuous. If discrete, can different bins be assumed to be statistically independent, and is it satisfactory to assume that the forecasted count in each bin will have a Poisson distribution? In order to discuss these questions, we start with the most simple models (homogeneous Poisson), and progressively develop the model complexity to include self exciting point process models. For each, we compare the discrete and continuous time likelihoods. Examples are given where it is proven that the counts in discrete space–time bins are not Poisson. We argue that the form of the likelihood function is intrinsic to the given model, and the required forecast for some specified space–time region simply determines where the likelihood function should be evaluated. We show that continuous time point process models where the likelihood function is also defined in continuous space and time can easily produce forecasts over discrete space–time intervals.