Alison J. D. Scott
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Alison J. D. Scott has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
John D. Fenwick
2 shared publicationsAlan E. Nahum
1 shared publication- Alan E. Nahum
University of Liverpool
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 12 June 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (7) , 3132-3144
Monte Carlo modeling of small photon fields: Quantifying the impact of focal spot size on source occlusion and output factors, and exploring miniphantom design for small‐field measurements
The accuracy with which Monte Carlo models of photon beams generated by linear accelerators (linacs) can describe small‐field dose distributions depends on the modeled width of the electron beam profile incident on the linac target. It is known that the electron focal spot width affects penumbra and cross‐field profiles; here, the authors explore the extent to which source occlusion reduces linac output for smaller fields and larger spot sizes. A BEAMnrc Monte Carlo linac model has been used to investigate the variation in penumbra widths and small‐field output factors with electron spot size. A formalism is developed separating head scatter factors into source occlusion and flattening filter factors. Differences between head scatter factors defined in terms of in‐air energy fluence, collision kerma, and terma are explored using Monte Carlo calculations. Estimates of changes in kerma‐based source occlusion and flattening filter factors with field size and focal spot width are obtained by calculating doses deposited in a narrow 2 mm wide virtual “milliphantom” geometry. The impact of focal spot size on phantom scatter is also explored. Modeled electron spot sizes of 0.4–0.7 mm FWHM generate acceptable matches to measured penumbra widths. However the 0.5 cm field output factor is quite sensitive to electron spot width, the measured output only being matched by calculations for a 0.7 mm spot width. Because the spectra of the unscattered primary and head‐scattered photon energy fluences differ, miniphantom‐based collision kerma measurements do not scale precisely with total in‐air energy fluence but with . For most field sizes, on‐axis collision kerma is independent of the focal spot size; but for a 0.5 cm field size and 1.0 mm spot width, it is reduced by around 7% mostly due to source occlusion. The phantom scatter factor of the 0.5 cm field also shows some spot size dependence, decreasing by 6% (relative) as spot size is increased from 0.1 to 1.0 mm. The dependence of small‐field source occlusion and output factors on the focal spot size makes this a significant factor in Monte Carlo modeling of small fields. Changes in penumbra width with spot size are not sufficiently large to accurately pinpoint spot widths. Consequently, while Monte Carlo models based exclusively on large‐field data can quite accurately predict small‐field profiles and PDDs, in the absence of experimental methods of determining incident electron beam profiles it will remain necessary to measure small‐field output factors, fine‐tuning modeled spot sizes to ensure good matching between the Monte Carlo and the measured output factors.
- 12 June 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (7) , 3132-3144
Monte Carlo modeling of small photon fields: Quantifying the impact of focal spot size on source occlusion and output factors, and exploring miniphantom design for small‐field measurements
The accuracy with which Monte Carlo models of photon beams generated by linear accelerators (linacs) can describe small‐field dose distributions depends on the modeled width of the electron beam profile incident on the linac target. It is known that the electron focal spot width affects penumbra and cross‐field profiles; here, the authors explore the extent to which source occlusion reduces linac output for smaller fields and larger spot sizes. A BEAMnrc Monte Carlo linac model has been used to investigate the variation in penumbra widths and small‐field output factors with electron spot size. A formalism is developed separating head scatter factors into source occlusion and flattening filter factors. Differences between head scatter factors defined in terms of in‐air energy fluence, collision kerma, and terma are explored using Monte Carlo calculations. Estimates of changes in kerma‐based source occlusion and flattening filter factors with field size and focal spot width are obtained by calculating doses deposited in a narrow 2 mm wide virtual “milliphantom” geometry. The impact of focal spot size on phantom scatter is also explored. Modeled electron spot sizes of 0.4–0.7 mm FWHM generate acceptable matches to measured penumbra widths. However the 0.5 cm field output factor is quite sensitive to electron spot width, the measured output only being matched by calculations for a 0.7 mm spot width. Because the spectra of the unscattered primary and head‐scattered photon energy fluences differ, miniphantom‐based collision kerma measurements do not scale precisely with total in‐air energy fluence but with . For most field sizes, on‐axis collision kerma is independent of the focal spot size; but for a 0.5 cm field size and 1.0 mm spot width, it is reduced by around 7% mostly due to source occlusion. The phantom scatter factor of the 0.5 cm field also shows some spot size dependence, decreasing by 6% (relative) as spot size is increased from 0.1 to 1.0 mm. The dependence of small‐field source occlusion and output factors on the focal spot size makes this a significant factor in Monte Carlo modeling of small fields. Changes in penumbra width with spot size are not sufficiently large to accurately pinpoint spot widths. Consequently, while Monte Carlo models based exclusively on large‐field data can quite accurately predict small‐field profiles and PDDs, in the absence of experimental methods of determining incident electron beam profiles it will remain necessary to measure small‐field output factors, fine‐tuning modeled spot sizes to ensure good matching between the Monte Carlo and the measured output factors.
- 23 September 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (10) , 4671-4684
Using a Monte Carlo model to predict dosimetric properties of small radiotherapy photon fields
Accurate characterization of small‐field dosimetry requires measurements to be made with precisely aligned specialized detectors and is thus time consuming and error prone. This work explores measurement differences between detectors by using a Monte Carlo model matched to large‐field data to predict properties of smaller fields. Measurements made with a variety of detectors have been compared with calculated results to assess their validity and explore reasons for differences. Unshielded diodes are expected to produce some of the most useful data, as their small sensitive cross sections give good resolution whilst their energy dependence is shown to vary little with depth in a linac beam. Their response is shown to be constant with field size over the range , with a correction of 3% needed for a field size of . BEAMnrc has been used to create a beam model, matched to dosimetric data for square fields larger than , and producing small‐field profiles and percentage depth doses (PDDs) that agree well with unshielded diode data for field sizes down to . For fields sizes of and above, little detector‐to‐detector variation exists in measured output factors, however for a field a relative spread of 18% is seen between output factors measured with different detectors—values measured with the diamond and pinpoint detectors lying below that of the unshielded diode, with the shielded diode value being higher. Relative to the corrected unshielded diode measurement, the Monte Carlo modeled output factor is 4.5% low, a discrepancy that is probably due to the focal spot fluence profile and source occlusion modeling. The large‐field Monte Carlo model can, therefore, currently be used to predict small‐field profiles and PDDs measured with an unshielded diode. However, determination of output factors for the smallest fields requires a more detailed model of focal spot fluence and source occlusion.
- 23 September 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (10) , 4671-4684
Using a Monte Carlo model to predict dosimetric properties of small radiotherapy photon fields
Accurate characterization of small‐field dosimetry requires measurements to be made with precisely aligned specialized detectors and is thus time consuming and error prone. This work explores measurement differences between detectors by using a Monte Carlo model matched to large‐field data to predict properties of smaller fields. Measurements made with a variety of detectors have been compared with calculated results to assess their validity and explore reasons for differences. Unshielded diodes are expected to produce some of the most useful data, as their small sensitive cross sections give good resolution whilst their energy dependence is shown to vary little with depth in a linac beam. Their response is shown to be constant with field size over the range , with a correction of 3% needed for a field size of . BEAMnrc has been used to create a beam model, matched to dosimetric data for square fields larger than , and producing small‐field profiles and percentage depth doses (PDDs) that agree well with unshielded diode data for field sizes down to . For fields sizes of and above, little detector‐to‐detector variation exists in measured output factors, however for a field a relative spread of 18% is seen between output factors measured with different detectors—values measured with the diamond and pinpoint detectors lying below that of the unshielded diode, with the shielded diode value being higher. Relative to the corrected unshielded diode measurement, the Monte Carlo modeled output factor is 4.5% low, a discrepancy that is probably due to the focal spot fluence profile and source occlusion modeling. The large‐field Monte Carlo model can, therefore, currently be used to predict small‐field profiles and PDDs measured with an unshielded diode. However, determination of output factors for the smallest fields requires a more detailed model of focal spot fluence and source occlusion.