Benjamin Alberti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Benjamin Alberti has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Yvonne Marshall
University of Southampton
2 shared publications - Andrés Laguens
Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
1 shared publication Ing-Marie Back Danielsson
Stockholm University
1 shared publication- Ing-Marie Back Danielsson
Stockholm University
1 shared publication - Tamara L. Bray
Wayne State University, College of Liberal Arts & Sciences, 4841 Cass Avenue, 2155 Old Main, Detroit, MI 48201, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Universitatsbibliothek Kiel in EAZ – Ethnographisch-Archaeologische Zeitschrift
- Vol. 59 (2)
Recursive Archaeology: An Ontological Approach to Interpreting Anthropomorphic Ceramics from Northwest Argentina
The question driving this paper is how to understand anthropomorphism in archaeological material, particularly in three-dimensional artefactual form. Typically, anthropomorphism in artefacts is interpreted as a result of a scheme transfer, in which meanings associated with the human body are transferred to other materials. Alternatively, it is understood as a representational practice through which cultural narratives are played out in material form. It may even be understood as an externalized cognitive process. Such approaches rely on specific concepts of ‘body,’ ‘representation’ and ‘materiality,’ among others. What I call a ‘recursive approach,’ in contrast, puts into question these concepts by working with our material in a way that maximizes the potential for ontological difference to emerge. The goal of a recursive archaeology is to recognize and feel the impact of the alterity latent in our materials, which can then form the basis for analysis and conceptual innovation. Recursion occurs when concepts developed locally through encounters with alterity are allowed to stand against archaeological ones, such that the latter are transformed by the former. By way of example, I develop an alternative theory of anthropomorphism in relation to a series of anthropo-, zoo- and biomorphic ceramics from first-millennium AD Northwest Argentina.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Universitatsbibliothek Kiel in EAZ – Ethnographisch-Archaeologische Zeitschrift
- Vol. 59 (2)
Open AccessRecursive Archaeology: An Ontological Approach to Interpreting Anthropomorphic Ceramics from Northwest Argentina
The question driving this paper is how to understand anthropomorphism in archaeological material, particularly in three-dimensional artefactual form. Typically, anthropomorphism in artefacts is interpreted as a result of a scheme transfer, in which meanings associated with the human body are transferred to other materials. Alternatively, it is understood as a representational practice through which cultural narratives are played out in material form. It may even be understood as an externalized cognitive process. Such approaches rely on specific concepts of ‘body,’ ‘representation’ and ‘materiality,’ among others. What I call a ‘recursive approach,’ in contrast, puts into question these concepts by working with our material in a way that maximizes the potential for ontological difference to emerge. The goal of a recursive archaeology is to recognize and feel the impact of the alterity latent in our materials, which can then form the basis for analysis and conceptual innovation. Recursion occurs when concepts developed locally through encounters with alterity are allowed to stand against archaeological ones, such that the latter are transformed by the former. By way of example, I develop an alternative theory of anthropomorphism in relation to a series of anthropo-, zoo- and biomorphic ceramics from first-millennium AD Northwest Argentina.
- 5 October 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Archaeology
- Vol. 26 (4) , 539-542
Felipe Rojas, Byron Ellsworth Hamann and Benjamin Anderson, eds. Otros pasados. Ontologías alternativas y el estudio de lo que ha sido (Other Pasts: Alternative Ontologies and the Study of What has Been) (Bogotá: Universidad de los Andes, Ediciones Uniandes, Fondo de Promoción de la Cultura, 2022, 372pp., numerous b/w and colour illustr., pbk, ISBN 978-958-9003-93-0 (pbk), 978-958-9003-94-7 (e-book). Open Access limited to three chapters: https://musa.com.co/otros-pasados/)
- 5 October 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Archaeology
- Vol. 26 (4) , 539-542
Felipe Rojas, Byron Ellsworth Hamann and Benjamin Anderson, eds. Otros pasados. Ontologías alternativas y el estudio de lo que ha sido (Other Pasts: Alternative Ontologies and the Study of What has Been) (Bogotá: Universidad de los Andes, Ediciones Uniandes, Fondo de Promoción de la Cultura, 2022, 372pp., numerous b/w and colour illustr., pbk, ISBN 978-958-9003-93-0 (pbk), 978-958-9003-94-7 (e-book). Open Access limited to three chapters: https://musa.com.co/otros-pasados/)
- 26 October 2020
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 4498-4507
Gender, Feminist, and Queer Archaeologies: USA Perspective
- 26 October 2020
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 4498-4507
Gender, Feminist, and Queer Archaeologies: USA Perspective
- Open Access
- 24 August 2019
- Published by Universidad Nacional de Córdoba in Revista del Museo de Antropología
- Vol. 12 (2) , 55-66
Habitando espacios vacíos. Cuerpos, paisajes y ontologías en el poblamiento inicial del centro de Argentina
Los modelos de poblamiento inicial de territorios desconocidos implícitamente ponen en juego ontologías del cuerpo y del espacio o la naturaleza, con dos ideas fuertes: la de espacios vacíos de humanos y la de un medio desconocido, una ‘terra ignota’. Se trata siempre de un encuentro entre grupos humanos y un espacio a descubrir, a experienciar, y en cuyo recorrido las poblaciones van relacionándose activamente con materialidades particulares y construyendo sus paisajes. Nuevas indagaciones nos llevan a cuestionar esta visión y la de una arqueología del paisaje que no considere la particularidad ontológica de la idea de cuerpo. Nos remitimos a un caso de estudio en San Luis, Argentina, y veremos qué sucede cuando el mismo es visto desde una ontología particular situada – en este caso el perspectivismo sudamericano. Entendemos que poblar ‘terra ignota’ desde un cuerpo y una ontología perspectivista no es crear paisajes, sino habitar un espacio de interrelaciones que, si bien se va definiendo y manteniendo activa y constantemente a través de relaciones, prácticas y experiencias entre sujetos, humanos y no humanos, en definitiva es un mundo de interrelaciones pre-constituidas, a partir de la propia ontología de los sujetos en cuestión.
- 24 August 2019
- Published by Universidad Nacional de Córdoba in Revista del Museo de Antropología
- Vol. 12 (2) , 55-66
Open AccessHabitando espacios vacíos. Cuerpos, paisajes y ontologías en el poblamiento inicial del centro de Argentina
Los modelos de poblamiento inicial de territorios desconocidos implícitamente ponen en juego ontologías del cuerpo y del espacio o la naturaleza, con dos ideas fuertes: la de espacios vacíos de humanos y la de un medio desconocido, una ‘terra ignota’. Se trata siempre de un encuentro entre grupos humanos y un espacio a descubrir, a experienciar, y en cuyo recorrido las poblaciones van relacionándose activamente con materialidades particulares y construyendo sus paisajes. Nuevas indagaciones nos llevan a cuestionar esta visión y la de una arqueología del paisaje que no considere la particularidad ontológica de la idea de cuerpo. Nos remitimos a un caso de estudio en San Luis, Argentina, y veremos qué sucede cuando el mismo es visto desde una ontología particular situada – en este caso el perspectivismo sudamericano. Entendemos que poblar ‘terra ignota’ desde un cuerpo y una ontología perspectivista no es crear paisajes, sino habitar un espacio de interrelaciones que, si bien se va definiendo y manteniendo activa y constantemente a través de relaciones, prácticas y experiencias entre sujetos, humanos y no humanos, en definitiva es un mundo de interrelaciones pre-constituidas, a partir de la propia ontología de los sujetos en cuestión.
- 2 October 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Interdisciplinary Science Reviews
- Vol. 43 (3-4) , 280-294
Art, craft, and the ontology of archaeological things
Tim Ingold's ‘science of correspondence’ describes a kind of epistemological intimacy in the practices of art, science, and anthropology. Archaeology would benefit from cultivating correspondence as a way to understand its research process. Ingold's model, however, appears to elide art and craft. Though both are necessary, I argue they should be kept separate for analytical purposes. Correspondence as pre-conceptual practice provides a way to understand that the form of archaeological objects is the outcome of processes of growth rather than design. Artworks as non-conceptual outcomes of practice provide insight into the nature of archaeological things beyond what can be understood under the general terms of correspondence. Artworks and archaeological things share the ontological problem of how to make something new out of materials. Artists work on materials to generate sensations never before experienced. Archaeologists work on a more circumscribed body of material to produce a past not thought of or experienced before. Unlike artworks, archaeological things carry both sensation and the residue of concepts with them. An archaeological sensibility can help archaeologists resurrect not the original concepts themselves but the conceptual potential immanent to the specific arrangements of materials and the forms they, however temporarily, take on.
- 2 October 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Interdisciplinary Science Reviews
- Vol. 43 (3-4) , 280-294
Art, craft, and the ontology of archaeological things
Tim Ingold's ‘science of correspondence’ describes a kind of epistemological intimacy in the practices of art, science, and anthropology. Archaeology would benefit from cultivating correspondence as a way to understand its research process. Ingold's model, however, appears to elide art and craft. Though both are necessary, I argue they should be kept separate for analytical purposes. Correspondence as pre-conceptual practice provides a way to understand that the form of archaeological objects is the outcome of processes of growth rather than design. Artworks as non-conceptual outcomes of practice provide insight into the nature of archaeological things beyond what can be understood under the general terms of correspondence. Artworks and archaeological things share the ontological problem of how to make something new out of materials. Artists work on materials to generate sensations never before experienced. Archaeologists work on a more circumscribed body of material to produce a past not thought of or experienced before. Unlike artworks, archaeological things carry both sensation and the residue of concepts with them. An archaeological sensibility can help archaeologists resurrect not the original concepts themselves but the conceptual potential immanent to the specific arrangements of materials and the forms they, however temporarily, take on.
- 2 November 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Archaeological Dialogues
- Vol. 23 (2) , 138-145
Archaeologies of risk and wonder
In this statement, I argue that one way for archaeology to realize the potential of its materials to tell us something different about the past is to confront the question of alterity, understood as the ontological difference that lies at the roots of much archaeological material. If we accept alterity as a starting point of analysis then we stand a chance of challenging the strictures of interpretive frameworks that foreclose the possibility of encountering something new. Methodologically and theoretically I argue for risk-taking, especially taking on conceptual resources from indigenous thinkers and adopting a stance of wonder in the face of our materials which can open up unsuspected archaeological realities.
- 2 November 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Archaeological Dialogues
- Vol. 23 (2) , 138-145
Archaeologies of risk and wonder
In this statement, I argue that one way for archaeology to realize the potential of its materials to tell us something different about the past is to confront the question of alterity, understood as the ontological difference that lies at the roots of much archaeological material. If we accept alterity as a starting point of analysis then we stand a chance of challenging the strictures of interpretive frameworks that foreclose the possibility of encountering something new. Methodologically and theoretically I argue for risk-taking, especially taking on conceptual resources from indigenous thinkers and adopting a stance of wonder in the face of our materials which can open up unsuspected archaeological realities.
- Top Cited Papers
- 21 October 2016
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Anthropology
- Vol. 45 (1) , 163-179
Archaeologies of Ontology
Bruno Latour and Eduardo Viveiros de Castro provided the initial impetus for explicitly ontological research in archaeology. Their impact on archaeologists, however, has been quite different. What I call the “metaphysical archaeologists” trace their genealogy from Latour, though they are now equally influenced by “new materialism” and the “new ontological realism” ( Gabriel 2015 ). They have introduced an alternative metaphysical orthodoxy to archaeology. In contrast, Viveiros de Castro and colleagues have authorized the return of the grand ethnographic analogy to archaeology, particularly in the case of animism. A second, quite different tendency inspired by these same anthropologists is to engage with indigenous ideas as theories to reconfigure archaeological concepts and practice. I suggest that a point of convergence between the metaphysical and the latter anthropological approaches exists in their focus on the concept of alterity.
- 21 October 2016
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Anthropology
- Vol. 45 (1) , 163-179
Top Cited PapersArchaeologies of Ontology
Bruno Latour and Eduardo Viveiros de Castro provided the initial impetus for explicitly ontological research in archaeology. Their impact on archaeologists, however, has been quite different. What I call the “metaphysical archaeologists” trace their genealogy from Latour, though they are now equally influenced by “new materialism” and the “new ontological realism” ( Gabriel 2015 ). They have introduced an alternative metaphysical orthodoxy to archaeology. In contrast, Viveiros de Castro and colleagues have authorized the return of the grand ethnographic analogy to archaeology, particularly in the case of animism. A second, quite different tendency inspired by these same anthropologists is to engage with indigenous ideas as theories to reconfigure archaeological concepts and practice. I suggest that a point of convergence between the metaphysical and the latter anthropological approaches exists in their focus on the concept of alterity.
- 26 November 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Archaeological Dialogues
- Vol. 21 (2) , 159-162
How does water mean?
The St Anthony's Day procession was caught in a bitter, driving rainstorm, accompanied by thunder and lightning. We elected to carry on to the church, despite the weather and the sense of threat. By the time we reached our destination we were soaked through. Locals were happy for the rain and all it implied, students and faculty to have shared the powerful experience which appeared to close an affective gap with our hosts.
- 26 November 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Archaeological Dialogues
- Vol. 21 (2) , 159-162
How does water mean?
The St Anthony's Day procession was caught in a bitter, driving rainstorm, accompanied by thunder and lightning. We elected to carry on to the church, despite the weather and the sense of threat. By the time we reached our destination we were soaked through. Locals were happy for the rain and all it implied, students and faculty to have shared the powerful experience which appeared to close an affective gap with our hosts.
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 February 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Archaeological Journal
- Vol. 24 (1) , 19-36
A Matter of Difference: Karen Barad, Ontology and Archaeological Bodies
This article explores the implications of adopting Karen Barad's agential realist approach in archaeology. We argue that the location of Barad's work in quantum physics and feminism means it is uniquely placed to inform the ontological turn currently gaining favour for understanding the materiality of bodies. We outline Barad's approach using a comparative reading of Sofaer's book The Body as Material Culture and Barad's Meeting the Universe Halfway. To illustrate, we think through Barad's key concepts of ‘phenomenon’, ‘intra-action’ and ‘apparatus’ in relation to specific archaeological bodies; New Zealand Maori chevron amulets, Argentinean La Candelaria body-pots, Pacific Northwest Coast stone artefacts and Nuu-chah-nulth ceremonial objects. Barad's theory transforms the way we understand and think these object bodies. In particular, her relational ontology, which contrasts with a conventional binary separation of matter and meaning, produces difference in a new way; a difference which facilitates analyses conceptually unthinkable in conventional representationalist terms.
- 1 February 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Archaeological Journal
- Vol. 24 (1) , 19-36
Top Cited PapersA Matter of Difference: Karen Barad, Ontology and Archaeological Bodies
This article explores the implications of adopting Karen Barad's agential realist approach in archaeology. We argue that the location of Barad's work in quantum physics and feminism means it is uniquely placed to inform the ontological turn currently gaining favour for understanding the materiality of bodies. We outline Barad's approach using a comparative reading of Sofaer's book The Body as Material Culture and Barad's Meeting the Universe Halfway. To illustrate, we think through Barad's key concepts of ‘phenomenon’, ‘intra-action’ and ‘apparatus’ in relation to specific archaeological bodies; New Zealand Maori chevron amulets, Argentinean La Candelaria body-pots, Pacific Northwest Coast stone artefacts and Nuu-chah-nulth ceremonial objects. Barad's theory transforms the way we understand and think these object bodies. In particular, her relational ontology, which contrasts with a conventional binary separation of matter and meaning, produces difference in a new way; a difference which facilitates analyses conceptually unthinkable in conventional representationalist terms.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 2988-2997
Gender, Feminist, and Queer Archaeologies: USA Perspective
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 2988-2997
Gender, Feminist, and Queer Archaeologies: USA Perspective