Mary Lou Sole
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Mary Lou Sole has a total of 46 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Melody Bennett
Center for Nursing Research and Advanced Nursing Practice Orlando Health Orlando Florida
8 shared publicationsAurea Middleton
Aurea Middleton is a clinical research coordinator, Center for Nursing Research and Advanced Nursing Practice, Orlando Health, Orlando, Florida
7 shared publicationsSteven Talbert
Steven Talbert is a clinical assistant professor, College of Nursing, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida
6 shared publicationsDaleen Penoyer
Daleen Penoyer is director, Center for Nursing Research and Advanced Nursing Practice, Orlando Health, Orlando, Florida
5 shared publicationsDevendra Mehta
Devendra Mehta is a pediatric gastroenterologist, Pediatric Specialty Diagnostic Laboratory, Arnold Palmer Hospital, Orlando, Florida
3 shared publicationsLara Deaton
Center for Nursing Research and Advanced Nursing Practice Orlando Health Orlando Florida
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 June 2024
- Published by AACN Publishing in Critical Care Nurse
- Vol. 44 (3) , 45-53
A Review of Chlorhexidine Oral Care in Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation
Background: Chlorhexidine gluconate has been considered the criterion standard of oral care for patients receiving mechanical ventilation because of its ability to reduce the incidence of ventilator-associated events. Optimal concentrations and frequencies remain unclear, as do adverse events related to mortality in various intensive care unit populations. Objective: To examine the current evidence for the efficacy of chlorhexidine gluconate in reducing the incidence of ventilator-associated events, mortality, intensive care unit length of stay, and duration of mechanical ventilation in patients receiving ventilator support. Methods: In this integrative review, CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature), MEDLINE, and Health Source: Nursing/Academic Edition were searched using terms related to mechanical ventilation and chlorhexidine gluconate oral care with dates ranging from 2012 to 2023. Results: Seventeen articles were included in this review: 8 systematic reviews, 8 randomized clinical trials (3 of which were not included in any systematic review), and 1 quasi-experimental study. Chlorhexidine gluconate oral care was associated with a reduced incidence of ventilator-associated events, but efficacy depended on concentration and frequency of administration. With stratification by intensive care unit population type, a nonsignificant trend toward increased mortality was found among non–cardiac surgical patients who received this care. Conclusion: The evidence regarding the efficacy of chlorhexidine gluconate oral care in reducing ventilator-associated events in specific intensive care unit populations is contradictory. Recently published guidelines recommend de-implementation of chlorhexidine gluconate oral care in all patients receiving mechanical ventilation. Such care may be beneficial only in the cardiac surgical population.
- 1 June 2024
- Published by AACN Publishing in Critical Care Nurse
- Vol. 44 (3) , 45-53
A Review of Chlorhexidine Oral Care in Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation
Background: Chlorhexidine gluconate has been considered the criterion standard of oral care for patients receiving mechanical ventilation because of its ability to reduce the incidence of ventilator-associated events. Optimal concentrations and frequencies remain unclear, as do adverse events related to mortality in various intensive care unit populations. Objective: To examine the current evidence for the efficacy of chlorhexidine gluconate in reducing the incidence of ventilator-associated events, mortality, intensive care unit length of stay, and duration of mechanical ventilation in patients receiving ventilator support. Methods: In this integrative review, CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature), MEDLINE, and Health Source: Nursing/Academic Edition were searched using terms related to mechanical ventilation and chlorhexidine gluconate oral care with dates ranging from 2012 to 2023. Results: Seventeen articles were included in this review: 8 systematic reviews, 8 randomized clinical trials (3 of which were not included in any systematic review), and 1 quasi-experimental study. Chlorhexidine gluconate oral care was associated with a reduced incidence of ventilator-associated events, but efficacy depended on concentration and frequency of administration. With stratification by intensive care unit population type, a nonsignificant trend toward increased mortality was found among non–cardiac surgical patients who received this care. Conclusion: The evidence regarding the efficacy of chlorhexidine gluconate oral care in reducing ventilator-associated events in specific intensive care unit populations is contradictory. Recently published guidelines recommend de-implementation of chlorhexidine gluconate oral care in all patients receiving mechanical ventilation. Such care may be beneficial only in the cardiac surgical population.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 30 (2) , 128-132
Pulmonary Microbiome of Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation: Changes Over Time
Interest in the pulmonary microbiome is growing, particularly in patients undergoing mechanical ventilation. To explore the pulmonary microbiome over time in patients undergoing prolonged mechanical ventilation and to evaluate the effect of an oral suctioning intervention on the microbiome. This descriptive subanalysis from a clinical trial involved a random sample of 16 participants (7 intervention, 9 control) who received mechanical ventilation for at least 5 days. Five paired oral and tracheal specimens were evaluated for each participant over time. Bacterial DNA from the paired specimens was evaluated using 16S rRNA gene sequencing. Bacterial taxonomy composition, α-diversity (Shannon index), and β-diversity (Morisita-Horn index) were calculated and compared within and between participants. Participants were predominantly male (69%) and White (63%), with a mean age of 58 years, and underwent mechanical ventilation for a mean of 9.36 days. Abundant bacterial taxa included Prevotella, Staphylococcus, Streptococcus, Stenotrophomonas, and Veillonella. Mean tracheal α-diversity decreased over time for the total group (P = .002) and the control group (P = .02). β-Diversity was lower (P = .04) in the control group (1.905) than in the intervention group (2.607). Prolonged mechanical ventilation was associated with changes in the pulmonary microbiome, with the control group having less diversity. The oral suctioning intervention may have reduced oral-tracheal bacterial transmission.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 30 (2) , 128-132
Pulmonary Microbiome of Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation: Changes Over Time
Interest in the pulmonary microbiome is growing, particularly in patients undergoing mechanical ventilation. To explore the pulmonary microbiome over time in patients undergoing prolonged mechanical ventilation and to evaluate the effect of an oral suctioning intervention on the microbiome. This descriptive subanalysis from a clinical trial involved a random sample of 16 participants (7 intervention, 9 control) who received mechanical ventilation for at least 5 days. Five paired oral and tracheal specimens were evaluated for each participant over time. Bacterial DNA from the paired specimens was evaluated using 16S rRNA gene sequencing. Bacterial taxonomy composition, α-diversity (Shannon index), and β-diversity (Morisita-Horn index) were calculated and compared within and between participants. Participants were predominantly male (69%) and White (63%), with a mean age of 58 years, and underwent mechanical ventilation for a mean of 9.36 days. Abundant bacterial taxa included Prevotella, Staphylococcus, Streptococcus, Stenotrophomonas, and Veillonella. Mean tracheal α-diversity decreased over time for the total group (P = .002) and the control group (P = .02). β-Diversity was lower (P = .04) in the control group (1.905) than in the intervention group (2.607). Prolonged mechanical ventilation was associated with changes in the pulmonary microbiome, with the control group having less diversity. The oral suctioning intervention may have reduced oral-tracheal bacterial transmission.
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Wiley in World Medical & Health Policy
- Vol. 13 (2) , 373-382
A Call for the World Health Organization to Create International Classification of Disease Diagnostic Codes for Post‐Intensive Care Syndrome in the Age of COVID‐19
Post‐intensive care syndrome (PICS), a condition found in survivors of critical illness, is characterized by persistent physical, cognitive, and psychological sequelae that impact the quality of life after discharge from an intensive care unit (ICU). At present, there are no International Classification of Disease (ICD) billing codes for this condition. Without financial alignment, clinicians cannot diagnose PICS, hindering tracking of its prevalence and impeding policy development for this condition. Clinicians should be screening for PICS in all survivors of critical illness, particularly those with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Results from single‐center studies suggest over 75 percent of ARDS survivors develop PICS. With nearly 5 percent of patients with COVID‐19 requiring ICU admission for ARDS, it is important for clinicians to be able to diagnose PICS in survivors, and researchers to be able to track it. Member states should impress upon the World Health Organization to create ICD‐10 codes for PICS.
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Wiley in World Medical & Health Policy
- Vol. 13 (2) , 373-382
A Call for the World Health Organization to Create International Classification of Disease Diagnostic Codes for Post‐Intensive Care Syndrome in the Age of COVID‐19
Post‐intensive care syndrome (PICS), a condition found in survivors of critical illness, is characterized by persistent physical, cognitive, and psychological sequelae that impact the quality of life after discharge from an intensive care unit (ICU). At present, there are no International Classification of Disease (ICD) billing codes for this condition. Without financial alignment, clinicians cannot diagnose PICS, hindering tracking of its prevalence and impeding policy development for this condition. Clinicians should be screening for PICS in all survivors of critical illness, particularly those with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Results from single‐center studies suggest over 75 percent of ARDS survivors develop PICS. With nearly 5 percent of patients with COVID‐19 requiring ICU admission for ARDS, it is important for clinicians to be able to diagnose PICS in survivors, and researchers to be able to track it. Member states should impress upon the World Health Organization to create ICD‐10 codes for PICS.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2020
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 29 (5) , 371-378
Intubation Setting, Aspiration, and Ventilator-Associated Conditions
Patients experience endotracheal intubation in various settings with wide-ranging risks for postintubation complications such as aspiration and ventilator-associated conditions. To evaluate associations between intubation setting, presence of aspiration biomarkers, and clinical outcomes. This study is a subanalysis of data from the NO-ASPIRATE single-blinded randomized clinical trial. Data were prospectively collected for 513 adult patients intubated within 24 hours of enrollment. Patients with documented aspiration events at intubation were excluded. In the NO-ASPIRATE trial, intervention patients received enhanced oropharyngeal suctioning every 4 hours and control patients received sham suctioning. Tracheal specimens for α-amylase and pepsin tests were collected upon enrollment. Primary outcomes were ventilator hours, lengths of stay, and rates of ventilator-associated conditions. Of the baseline tracheal specimens, 76.4% were positive for α-amylase and 33.1% were positive for pepsin. Proportions of positive tracheal α-amylase and pepsin tests did not differ significantly between intubation locations (study hospital, transfer from other hospital, or field intubation). No differences were found for ventilator hours or lengths of stay. Patients intubated at another hospital and transferred had significantly higher ventilator-associated condition rates than did those intubated at the study hospital (P = .02). Ventilator-associated condition rates did not differ significantly between patients intubated in the field and patients in other groups. Higher ventilator-associated condition rates associated with interhospital transfer may be related to movement from bed, vehicle loading and unloading, and transport vehicle vibrations. Airway assessment and care may also be suboptimal in the transport environment.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 29 (5) , 371-378
Open AccessIntubation Setting, Aspiration, and Ventilator-Associated Conditions
Patients experience endotracheal intubation in various settings with wide-ranging risks for postintubation complications such as aspiration and ventilator-associated conditions. To evaluate associations between intubation setting, presence of aspiration biomarkers, and clinical outcomes. This study is a subanalysis of data from the NO-ASPIRATE single-blinded randomized clinical trial. Data were prospectively collected for 513 adult patients intubated within 24 hours of enrollment. Patients with documented aspiration events at intubation were excluded. In the NO-ASPIRATE trial, intervention patients received enhanced oropharyngeal suctioning every 4 hours and control patients received sham suctioning. Tracheal specimens for α-amylase and pepsin tests were collected upon enrollment. Primary outcomes were ventilator hours, lengths of stay, and rates of ventilator-associated conditions. Of the baseline tracheal specimens, 76.4% were positive for α-amylase and 33.1% were positive for pepsin. Proportions of positive tracheal α-amylase and pepsin tests did not differ significantly between intubation locations (study hospital, transfer from other hospital, or field intubation). No differences were found for ventilator hours or lengths of stay. Patients intubated at another hospital and transferred had significantly higher ventilator-associated condition rates than did those intubated at the study hospital (P = .02). Ventilator-associated condition rates did not differ significantly between patients intubated in the field and patients in other groups. Higher ventilator-associated condition rates associated with interhospital transfer may be related to movement from bed, vehicle loading and unloading, and transport vehicle vibrations. Airway assessment and care may also be suboptimal in the transport environment.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2020
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Critical Care Explorations
- Vol. 2 (7) , e0159
Is α-Amylase an Important Biomarker to Detect Aspiration of Oral Secretions in Ventilated Patients?
Alpha-amylase has emerged as a biomarker of interest in detecting aspiration of oral secretions. In several studies, most ventilated patients have α-amylase values detected in pulmonary secretions. Values of α-amylase are high (as expected) in oral secretions and lowest in bronchoalveolar lavage samples. Around 5–7% of oral α-amylase is detectable in tracheal secretions. Once secretions are aspirated, the duration of detection of α-amylase in pulmonary secretions is unknown. Evidence varies on the relationship between α-amylase and clinical outcomes. Although detection of α-amylase in pulmonary secretions is useful to identify that aspiration has occurred, the lack of standardized reference values, the lack of knowledge regarding duration of detection following aspiration, and mixed findings related to clinical outcomes, limit its usefulness as a measurement tool. If α-amylase is to be used in research and/or clinical practice, additional data are needed to assist in interpretation and application of findings.
- 1 July 2020
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Critical Care Explorations
- Vol. 2 (7) , e0159
Open AccessIs α-Amylase an Important Biomarker to Detect Aspiration of Oral Secretions in Ventilated Patients?
Alpha-amylase has emerged as a biomarker of interest in detecting aspiration of oral secretions. In several studies, most ventilated patients have α-amylase values detected in pulmonary secretions. Values of α-amylase are high (as expected) in oral secretions and lowest in bronchoalveolar lavage samples. Around 5–7% of oral α-amylase is detectable in tracheal secretions. Once secretions are aspirated, the duration of detection of α-amylase in pulmonary secretions is unknown. Evidence varies on the relationship between α-amylase and clinical outcomes. Although detection of α-amylase in pulmonary secretions is useful to identify that aspiration has occurred, the lack of standardized reference values, the lack of knowledge regarding duration of detection following aspiration, and mixed findings related to clinical outcomes, limit its usefulness as a measurement tool. If α-amylase is to be used in research and/or clinical practice, additional data are needed to assist in interpretation and application of findings.
- 12 November 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Clinical Gerontologist
- Vol. 43 (4) , 378-390
Shifting Maladaptive Fall Risk Appraisal in Older Adults through an in-Home Physio-fEedback and Exercise pRogram (PEER): A Pilot Study
1) examine the preliminary effectiveness of the Physio-feEdback and Exercise pRogram (PEER) for shifting maladaptive to adaptive fall risk appraisal and reducing fall risk, 2) determine the partici...
- 12 November 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Clinical Gerontologist
- Vol. 43 (4) , 378-390
Shifting Maladaptive Fall Risk Appraisal in Older Adults through an in-Home Physio-fEedback and Exercise pRogram (PEER): A Pilot Study
1) examine the preliminary effectiveness of the Physio-feEdback and Exercise pRogram (PEER) for shifting maladaptive to adaptive fall risk appraisal and reducing fall risk, 2) determine the partici...
- 26 June 2019
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 75 (11) , 3045-3057
Impact of deep oropharyngeal suctioning on microaspiration, ventilator events, and clinical outcomes: A randomized clinical trial
Aims To evaluate a deep oropharyngeal suction intervention (NO‐ASPIRATE) in intubated patients on microaspiration, ventilator‐associated events and clinical outcomes. Design Prospective, two‐group, single‐blind, randomized clinical trial. Methods The study was conducted between 2014 ‐ 2017 in 513 participants enrolled within 24 hours of intubation and randomized into NO‐ASPIRATE or usual care groups. Standard oral care was provided to all participants every four hours and deep oropharyngeal suctioning was added to the NO‐ASPIRATE group. Oral and tracheal specimens were obtained to quantify α‐amylase as an aspiration biomarker. Results Data were analyzed for 410 study completers enrolled at least 36 hours: NO‐ASPIRATE (N=206) and usual care (N=204). Percent of tracheal specimens positive for α‐amylase, mean tracheal α‐amylase levels over time and ventilator‐associated events were not different between groups. The NO‐ASPIRATE group had a shorter hospital length of stay and a subgroup with moderate aspiration at baseline had significantly lower α‐amylase levels across time. Conclusion Hospital length of stay was shorter in the NO‐ASPIRATE group and a subgroup of intervention participants had lower α‐amylase across time. Delivery of standardized oral care to all participants may have been an intervention itself and possibly associated with the lack of significant findings for most outcomes. Impact This trial compared usual care to oral care with a deep suctioning intervention on microaspiration and ventilator‐associated events, as this has not been systematically studied. Further research on the usefulness of α‐amylase as an aspiration biomarker and the role of oral suctioning, especially for certain populations, is indicated.
- 26 June 2019
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 75 (11) , 3045-3057
Impact of deep oropharyngeal suctioning on microaspiration, ventilator events, and clinical outcomes: A randomized clinical trial
Aims To evaluate a deep oropharyngeal suction intervention (NO‐ASPIRATE) in intubated patients on microaspiration, ventilator‐associated events and clinical outcomes. Design Prospective, two‐group, single‐blind, randomized clinical trial. Methods The study was conducted between 2014 ‐ 2017 in 513 participants enrolled within 24 hours of intubation and randomized into NO‐ASPIRATE or usual care groups. Standard oral care was provided to all participants every four hours and deep oropharyngeal suctioning was added to the NO‐ASPIRATE group. Oral and tracheal specimens were obtained to quantify α‐amylase as an aspiration biomarker. Results Data were analyzed for 410 study completers enrolled at least 36 hours: NO‐ASPIRATE (N=206) and usual care (N=204). Percent of tracheal specimens positive for α‐amylase, mean tracheal α‐amylase levels over time and ventilator‐associated events were not different between groups. The NO‐ASPIRATE group had a shorter hospital length of stay and a subgroup with moderate aspiration at baseline had significantly lower α‐amylase levels across time. Conclusion Hospital length of stay was shorter in the NO‐ASPIRATE group and a subgroup of intervention participants had lower α‐amylase across time. Delivery of standardized oral care to all participants may have been an intervention itself and possibly associated with the lack of significant findings for most outcomes. Impact This trial compared usual care to oral care with a deep suctioning intervention on microaspiration and ventilator‐associated events, as this has not been systematically studied. Further research on the usefulness of α‐amylase as an aspiration biomarker and the role of oral suctioning, especially for certain populations, is indicated.
- 3 December 2018
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 75 (5) , 1108-1118
Nursing oral suction intervention to reduce aspiration and ventilator events (NO‐ASPIRATE): A randomized clinical trial
Aim: The primary aim of this study is to compare an oropharyngeal suction intervention versus usual care on microaspiration in intubated patients. Secondary aims are to evaluate the intervention on ventilator‐associated condition rates, time to occurrence and compare tracheal‐oral α‐amylase ratios between groups. Design: Prospective randomized clinical trial. Methods: The study received funding from the National Institutes of Health in February 2014 and Institutional Review Board approval in July 2013. Over 4 years, a convenience sample of 600 orally intubated, ventilated adult patients will be enrolled within 24 hr of intubation. The target sample is 400 participants randomized to the two groups. The intervention involves enhanced suctioning of the mouth and oropharynx every 4 hr, while the usual care group receives a sham suctioning. The research team will deliver usual oral care to all patients every 4 hr and collect oral and tracheal specimens every 12 hr, to quantify α‐amylase levels to detect aspiration of oral secretions. Study completers must be enrolled at least 36 hr (baseline and three paired samples). Outcomes include α‐amylase levels, percent of positive specimens, ventilator‐associated conditions, length of stay, ventilator hours, and discharge disposition. Discussion: Enrolment has closed, and data analysis has begun. Subgroup analyses emerged, contributing to future research knowledge. Impact: Standardized interventions have reduced but do not address all risk factors associated with ventilator‐associated conditions. This study provides the potential to reduce microaspiration and associated sequelae in critically ill, intubated patients.
- 3 December 2018
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 75 (5) , 1108-1118
Nursing oral suction intervention to reduce aspiration and ventilator events (NO‐ASPIRATE): A randomized clinical trial
Aim: The primary aim of this study is to compare an oropharyngeal suction intervention versus usual care on microaspiration in intubated patients. Secondary aims are to evaluate the intervention on ventilator‐associated condition rates, time to occurrence and compare tracheal‐oral α‐amylase ratios between groups. Design: Prospective randomized clinical trial. Methods: The study received funding from the National Institutes of Health in February 2014 and Institutional Review Board approval in July 2013. Over 4 years, a convenience sample of 600 orally intubated, ventilated adult patients will be enrolled within 24 hr of intubation. The target sample is 400 participants randomized to the two groups. The intervention involves enhanced suctioning of the mouth and oropharynx every 4 hr, while the usual care group receives a sham suctioning. The research team will deliver usual oral care to all patients every 4 hr and collect oral and tracheal specimens every 12 hr, to quantify α‐amylase levels to detect aspiration of oral secretions. Study completers must be enrolled at least 36 hr (baseline and three paired samples). Outcomes include α‐amylase levels, percent of positive specimens, ventilator‐associated conditions, length of stay, ventilator hours, and discharge disposition. Discussion: Enrolment has closed, and data analysis has begun. Subgroup analyses emerged, contributing to future research knowledge. Impact: Standardized interventions have reduced but do not address all risk factors associated with ventilator‐associated conditions. This study provides the potential to reduce microaspiration and associated sequelae in critically ill, intubated patients.
- 1 July 2018
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 27 (4) , 305-311
Collecting Nursing Research Data 24 Hours a Day: Challenges, Lessons, and Recommendations
Background Research on many routine nursing interventions requires data collection around the clock each day (24/7). Strategies for implementing and coordinating a study 24/7 are not discussed in the literature, and best practices are needed. Objective To identify strategies incorporated into implementing a nursing intervention trial 24/7, including key lessons learned. Methods Strategies to facilitate implementation of a clinical trial of a nursing intervention with patients undergoing mechanical ventilation are shared. Challenges and changes for future studies also are discussed. Results Adequate planning, including a detailed operations manual, guides study implementation. Staffing is the most challenging and costly part of a study but is essential to a study’s success. Other important strategies include communication among the study personnel and with collaborators and direct care staff. An electronic method of recording study-related data also is essential. Conclusions A nursing clinical trial that requires interventions on a 24/7 basis can be done with thorough planning, staffing, and continuous quality improvement activities.
- 1 July 2018
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 27 (4) , 305-311
Collecting Nursing Research Data 24 Hours a Day: Challenges, Lessons, and Recommendations
Background Research on many routine nursing interventions requires data collection around the clock each day (24/7). Strategies for implementing and coordinating a study 24/7 are not discussed in the literature, and best practices are needed. Objective To identify strategies incorporated into implementing a nursing intervention trial 24/7, including key lessons learned. Methods Strategies to facilitate implementation of a clinical trial of a nursing intervention with patients undergoing mechanical ventilation are shared. Challenges and changes for future studies also are discussed. Results Adequate planning, including a detailed operations manual, guides study implementation. Staffing is the most challenging and costly part of a study but is essential to a study’s success. Other important strategies include communication among the study personnel and with collaborators and direct care staff. An electronic method of recording study-related data also is essential. Conclusions A nursing clinical trial that requires interventions on a 24/7 basis can be done with thorough planning, staffing, and continuous quality improvement activities.
- Open Access
- 31 August 2017
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 26 (5) , 395-400
Enrollment Challenges in Critical Care Nursing Research
Background Enrollment challenges for critical care research are common. Contributing factors include short enrollment windows, the crisis nature of critical illness, lack of research staff, unavailable legal proxy, family dynamics, and language barriers. Objective To describe enrollment statistics for an ongoing critical care nursing trial, barriers to recruitment, and strategies to enhance enrollment. Methods Two years’ worth of recruitment and enrollment data from an oral care intervention trial in critically ill adults receiving mechanical ventilation at 1 hospital were analyzed. Recruitment logs include number of patients screened, eligible, enrolled, and declined and patients’ sex, race, and ethnicity. Results Target enrollment (15.5 patients per month) was based on experience and historical data. Strategies implemented to promote enrollment included providing study personnel at least 18 hours per day for 7 days per week, regular rounds, communication with direct care staff, and Spanish consent processes. In 2 years, 6963 patients were screened; 1551 (22%) were eligible. Consent was sought from 366 (24% of eligible patients). Enrollment averaged 13.3 patients per month (86% of projected target). The main factor impeding enrollment was unavailability of a legal proxy to provide consent (88%). The refusal rates of white (11%), black (13%), and Hispanic (16%) patients did not differ significantly. However, those classified as Asian or as more than 1 race declined significantly more often (35%) than did white or black patients (P = .02). Conclusions Unavailability of a legal proxy within a short enrollment window was the major challenge to enrollment. Various factors influenced consent decisions. Clinical study design requires more conservative estimates.
- 31 August 2017
- Published by AACN Publishing in American Journal of Critical Care
- Vol. 26 (5) , 395-400
Open AccessEnrollment Challenges in Critical Care Nursing Research
Background Enrollment challenges for critical care research are common. Contributing factors include short enrollment windows, the crisis nature of critical illness, lack of research staff, unavailable legal proxy, family dynamics, and language barriers. Objective To describe enrollment statistics for an ongoing critical care nursing trial, barriers to recruitment, and strategies to enhance enrollment. Methods Two years’ worth of recruitment and enrollment data from an oral care intervention trial in critically ill adults receiving mechanical ventilation at 1 hospital were analyzed. Recruitment logs include number of patients screened, eligible, enrolled, and declined and patients’ sex, race, and ethnicity. Results Target enrollment (15.5 patients per month) was based on experience and historical data. Strategies implemented to promote enrollment included providing study personnel at least 18 hours per day for 7 days per week, regular rounds, communication with direct care staff, and Spanish consent processes. In 2 years, 6963 patients were screened; 1551 (22%) were eligible. Consent was sought from 366 (24% of eligible patients). Enrollment averaged 13.3 patients per month (86% of projected target). The main factor impeding enrollment was unavailability of a legal proxy to provide consent (88%). The refusal rates of white (11%), black (13%), and Hispanic (16%) patients did not differ significantly. However, those classified as Asian or as more than 1 race declined significantly more often (35%) than did white or black patients (P = .02). Conclusions Unavailability of a legal proxy within a short enrollment window was the major challenge to enrollment. Various factors influenced consent decisions. Clinical study design requires more conservative estimates.