Umberto Parmeggiani

Injury to cranial nerve represents 5% of negligence litigation against general surgeons and of all malpractice jury verdicts in endocrine surgery 60% accounts for recurrent nerve injuries and 15% for anoxic brain injuries from RLN injuries, unrecognized post-operatively. During Total Thyroidectomy is reported an incidence of failure to find the nerve in 5- 18% of cases and if we think that routine identification of the RLN during thyroid surgery has reduced the injury rate from 10% to less than 4% and that the incidence of nerve paralysis was 3 to 4 times greater in cases where the nerve was not exposed than in cases where was routinely exposed, then we understand the importance of a clear identification during every thyroid dissection 880 Total Thyroidectomies during the last 4 years, since Jannuary 2007 until December 2010, (610 F, 270 M; mean age 44,5 years old, range 14-83). All patients were examined pre and postoperatively (1-6 months after) by direct laryngoscopy or laryngofibroscopy to check vocal cord mobility (medium follow up 25.5 months range 3-50 months). The Authors reviewed charts from two randomized groups, selected by a double blind, statistically designed study and again compared in a multivariate analysis (Stat 2004 ltd): 1) 480 total sutureless thyroidectomies, performed during the previous year with continuous intra-operative nerve monitoring using dedicated endotracheal tube with a last generation Nerve Integrity Monitor Pulse II (N.I.M. pulse II®) 2) 400 total sutureless thyroidectomies: performed with continuous intra-operative nerve monitoring using dedicated Laryngeal Electrode, a self-adhesive device designed to fit onto standard reinforced endotracheal tubes (Neurosign® 1040 - 4 Channel EMG) RESULTS: There were no statistically significative difference between the two groups for distribution of age, sex, epidemiological characteristics, type of pathology etc. The incidence of major complications in thyroid surgery in the first two groups (total Thyroidectomy performed by NIM and by Neurosign), as well as compared with the data of the literature are absolutely overimposable; only significative difference is a reduction of the costs in the second group (Neurosign). The 1st group (NIM) specificity is 90.2% (433/480). There were 6 cases of temporary RLN paralysis (temporary paralysis rate: 1.25 % of patients), 3 true positive and 3 false negative. Finally there were 3 cases of permanent RLN paralysis (0.75%), 2 truepositive and 1 false-negative developed after 10 days (demyelination by thermal injury). The 2nd group (Neurosign) specificity of 89 % (356/400). There were 6 cases of temporary RLN paralysis (rate: 1.5 %, p > 0.5), 2 true positive, 1 false positive and 4 false negative. Finally 2 cases of permanent RLN paralysis (0.5% p > 0.5), 2 true-positive. Our data confirm a useful application of NIM and Neurosign in thyroid dissection nerve prevention. We don't believe that those procedures can be useful for learning thyroid gland surgery, because can't preserve from an accurate dissection and nerve identification technique, but can only support in nerve-at-risk thyroidectomy or during dissection can support expert surgeon's decision, having a clear pre-operative (post-anesthesiologist) and post-operative predictive value. Those procedures are anyway expensive and time consuming (25000-30000 € for the E.M.G. system and almost 200-250 € for each dedicated endotracheal tube in NIM group). So Neurosign group has over-imposable results in terms of complications specificity and accurancy (no statistically significative differences), but it's a much cheaper procedure!

In the present study the authors assess the advantages of new technologies in thyroid surgery: to prevent nerve injury by using an intra-operative continuous nerve-monitoring techniques and to compare the real advantages of advanced coagulation devices. Among a series of 440 thyroidectomies (jan 2004-feb 2006) the Authors reviewed charts from two groups: (1) 240 total thyroidectomies performed using the traditional monopolar electrocautery, non-absorbable stitches for the principal vascular pedicles. (2) 140 total thyroidectomies performed using dedicated small bipolar electro thermal coagulator (ligasure-precise). (3) Since 2006 in a double blind group selection of 70, we've performed sutureless thyroidectomy with continuous intraoperative nerve monitoring using dedicated endotracheal tube. Mean operative time, post-operative bleeding, post-operative stay, incidence of transient or definitive laryngeal nerve lesions, incidence of permanent or transient hypocalcaemia, costs of the procedures were analyzed. Major complications in the first two groups compared with the data of the literature are absolutely over-imposable, except a reduction of incidence of transient hypocalcaemia in the Precise group, but if we compare data of the 3rd group (NIM), we find a significative reduction of transient and permanent laryngeal nerve palsy incidence. This new technology offers several advantages: (1) atraumatic; (2) easy to use; (3) continuous monitoring and audio feedback to the surgeon (4) works outside the operation field (5) high sensitiveness. Cost-analysis confirm that NIM + ligasure have same or less cost and time and probably less complications than traditional Total Thyroidectomy.

Breast cancer in elderly patients occurs frequently and is often inadequately managed. Furthermore, for organizational and social reasons, the incidence of locally advanced neoplasms is higher in this age group than in the younger population. The aim of the study was to assess our experience in this specific pathology and review the international literature on this topic. From 2001 to 2005 116 cases of breast cancer in elderly women (70-95 years old) were observed by our surgical units. Of these, 38 were at a locally advanced stage (10--26.3%--stage IIIA, 28--73.7%--stage IIIB). Comorbidity (two or more diseases) existed in 32 patients. A Madden modified radical mastectomy was carried out in all cases. Resection was extended to the chest-wall tissues in cases of local infiltration. Surgical mortality was 10% (4 cases). Eight of the 34 patients discharged died within 24 months (2 of disease progression). Adjuvant chemotherapy was never offered. On the other hand, all patients received hormone therapy (tamoxifen). 10 of the 26 patients (38.4%) surviving over 2 years underwent redo surgery for local relapse of disease. Our conclusions are: 1) breast cancer in elderly patients is often underestimated and undertreated; 2) disease management cannot be standardized, but must be tailored to the single patient; 3) short- and medium-term results are satisfactory; 4) comorbidity must be carefully assessed.

In the early days of video-assisted laparoscopic cholecystectomy (VLC), obesity was considered a contraindication for the procedure. We reviewed charts from 304 patients undergoing VLC; 90 patients were obese, and among these, according to a classification currently used by medical nutritionists and based on BMI, 45 were overweight (BMI > or = 25 < or = 29.9), 27 were considered conventionally obese (BMI > or = 30 and < 40) and 18 morbidly obese (BMI > or = 40). In this study we considered only the morbidly obese patients (5 males and 13 females). The average age was 42.3 years (range: 21-65) and the average weight 275 Ib (range: 186-331 Ib). Six patients had previously undergone abdominal surgery. All patients were symptomatic for gallstones, and 5 of them were suffering from acute cholecystitis. Mean operative time was 20 minutes (range: 10-45 minutes) longer than that of non-obese patients. No open conversion was necessary. No major postoperative morbidity and no cases of mortality occurred. The mean hospital stay and resumption of normal diet were similar to those of non-obese patients. Regardless of the higher postoperative risks after open cholecystectomy in obese patients (pulmonary complications, thromboembolism, wound infections and cardiovascular complications), we suggest VLC as the procedure of choice for cholecystectomy in these patients.