Siobhan Eithne McCarthy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Siobhan Eithne McCarthy has a total of 74 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Lisa Mellon
Department of Health Psychology, School of Population Health, RCSI University of Medicine & Health Sciences, Dublin, Ireland
7 shared publications- Aileen Hetherton
School of Postgraduate Studies, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin, Leinster, D02 YN77
4 shared publications - Aisling Walsh
Department of Public Health and Epidemiology Dublin Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland
4 shared publications Catherine Hogan
National Quality and Patient Safety Directorate, Office of the Chief Clinical Officer, Health Service Executive, Dublin, Ireland
4 shared publications- Frances Horgan
School of Physiotherapy RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences Dublin Ireland
4 shared publications Jan Sorensen
Healthcare Outcomes Research Centre, RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin 2, Leinster, Ireland
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 9, 98
Frameworks to Guide Medical Staffing and Skill Mix Decisions in Hospital Settings: A Scoping Review of National and International Practices and Implementation Enablers and Barriers
Background In Ireland and internationally, healthcare systems are increasingly challenged by population ageing, multimorbidity, rising service demand, workforce shortages and evolving models of care. These pressures require consideration not only of how many doctors are needed, but of how available doctors should be deployed and configured within clinical services. To address an identified evidence gap, this paper presents a protocol to collate evidence on frameworks and structured approaches to support medical staffing and skill-mix decisions for hospital doctors, including how these have been developed, implemented and their feasibility in practice. Method This scoping review will follow JBI methodology and will be reported in accordance with the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews. Searches will be conducted in Medline, Embase, Scopus and CINAHL, alongside relevant grey literature sources. Sources addressing frameworks for medical staffing and skill mix in hospital settings will be included. Two reviewers will independently screen sources and extract data, with disagreements resolved by a third reviewer. Findings will be summarized descriptively, with reported enablers and barriers mapped to the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation–Behaviour model. Conclusion This review will map frameworks which aim to guide medical staffing and skill mix decisions, including key components, implementation strategies, evaluation approaches and reported enablers and barriers. Post review completion, findings will be used to inform the co-design of a framework to guide medical staffing and skill mix decisions for hospital doctors in Ireland.
- 22 September 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 9, 98
Open AccessFrameworks to Guide Medical Staffing and Skill Mix Decisions in Hospital Settings: A Scoping Review of National and International Practices and Implementation Enablers and Barriers
Background In Ireland and internationally, healthcare systems are increasingly challenged by population ageing, multimorbidity, rising service demand, workforce shortages and evolving models of care. These pressures require consideration not only of how many doctors are needed, but of how available doctors should be deployed and configured within clinical services. To address an identified evidence gap, this paper presents a protocol to collate evidence on frameworks and structured approaches to support medical staffing and skill-mix decisions for hospital doctors, including how these have been developed, implemented and their feasibility in practice. Method This scoping review will follow JBI methodology and will be reported in accordance with the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews. Searches will be conducted in Medline, Embase, Scopus and CINAHL, alongside relevant grey literature sources. Sources addressing frameworks for medical staffing and skill mix in hospital settings will be included. Two reviewers will independently screen sources and extract data, with disagreements resolved by a third reviewer. Findings will be summarized descriptively, with reported enablers and barriers mapped to the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation–Behaviour model. Conclusion This review will map frameworks which aim to guide medical staffing and skill mix decisions, including key components, implementation strategies, evaluation approaches and reported enablers and barriers. Post review completion, findings will be used to inform the co-design of a framework to guide medical staffing and skill mix decisions for hospital doctors in Ireland.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 35 (12) , 5304-5323
Contextual Factors and Intentional Rounding in Acute Hospitals: Understanding What Works, for Whom, in What Settings: A Realist Synthesis
Aim: To synthesise published literature to understand how, when and under what circumstances Intentional Rounding in acute hospital settings improves patient safety and make recommendations for implementation in real‐world settings. Background: Inpatient falls often result in injury due to complex interactions between the hospital environment and patient risk factors. Intentional Rounding (IR) is a structured process whereby nurses and care staff carry out regular checks with individual patients to address their needs in hospital. Design: Realist Synthesis. Methods: Searches were conducted in six bibliographic databases until February 2026. A total of 34 studies were included, and 18 references from grey literature were appraised and included. Results: Fourteen initial programme theories were identified and refined throughout the synthesis to identify five mechanisms which support implementation of IR in an acute hospital setting, with six programme theories developed. The mechanisms included motivation, accountability, engagement, consistency, comprehensiveness, and critical thinking. Contextual factors that may constrain the implementation of IR include the organisational support and availability of resources. Based on our findings, we have seven recommendations for consideration when designing and implementing an IR programme in the acute hospital setting. Conclusion: This synthesis has provided programme theories and recommendations that can guide research design when implementing an intervention at ward level. Implications for the Profession and Patient Care: IR has been used in hospitals as an intervention to improve patient safety and reduce adverse events, such as falls. Reporting Method: Realist And Meta‐narrative Evidence Syntheses: Evolving Standards (RAMESES—1). Patient or Public Consultation: An in‐person stakeholder engagement workshop was facilitated in March 2025, with patient representatives, hospital staff and members of the public. This engagement assisted the process of theory refinement to ensure research findings were clear and useful for those involved in providing and receiving IR in a hospital setting.
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 35 (12) , 5304-5323
Open AccessContextual Factors and Intentional Rounding in Acute Hospitals: Understanding What Works, for Whom, in What Settings: A Realist Synthesis
Aim: To synthesise published literature to understand how, when and under what circumstances Intentional Rounding in acute hospital settings improves patient safety and make recommendations for implementation in real‐world settings. Background: Inpatient falls often result in injury due to complex interactions between the hospital environment and patient risk factors. Intentional Rounding (IR) is a structured process whereby nurses and care staff carry out regular checks with individual patients to address their needs in hospital. Design: Realist Synthesis. Methods: Searches were conducted in six bibliographic databases until February 2026. A total of 34 studies were included, and 18 references from grey literature were appraised and included. Results: Fourteen initial programme theories were identified and refined throughout the synthesis to identify five mechanisms which support implementation of IR in an acute hospital setting, with six programme theories developed. The mechanisms included motivation, accountability, engagement, consistency, comprehensiveness, and critical thinking. Contextual factors that may constrain the implementation of IR include the organisational support and availability of resources. Based on our findings, we have seven recommendations for consideration when designing and implementing an IR programme in the acute hospital setting. Conclusion: This synthesis has provided programme theories and recommendations that can guide research design when implementing an intervention at ward level. Implications for the Profession and Patient Care: IR has been used in hospitals as an intervention to improve patient safety and reduce adverse events, such as falls. Reporting Method: Realist And Meta‐narrative Evidence Syntheses: Evolving Standards (RAMESES—1). Patient or Public Consultation: An in‐person stakeholder engagement workshop was facilitated in March 2025, with patient representatives, hospital staff and members of the public. This engagement assisted the process of theory refinement to ensure research findings were clear and useful for those involved in providing and receiving IR in a hospital setting.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 26 (1)
Implementing after action review in an Irish tertiary hospital: a mixed-methods evaluation of safety culture and second victim experience and support
Evidence for After Action Reviews (AAR), a non-hierarchical debriefing approach, is limited. We explored AAR implementation and measured safety culture and second victim experience and support, before and after introduction of AAR at an Irish hospital. A mixed-methods study which coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic and a health system cyber-attack was conducted. Hospital selected staff were trained as AAR facilitators using a simulation-based programme (July-Sept 2021). The intervention was the hospital introduction of AAR over 12-months (Sept 2021-Aug 2022). Before training, the Hospital Survey on Patient Safety 2.0 (HSOPS 2.0) and Second Victim Experience and Support Tool (SVEST) were distributed to all staff (N = 586), and repeated at 12-months with additional questions on AAR awareness, frequency and duration. At 6-months, focus groups with trained facilitators explored implementation enablers and barriers. Costs were estimated. Quantitative analysis used chi-squared, Fisher's exact and t-tests to compare pre-/post- responses. Qualitative data was analysed using the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation - Behaviour (COM-B) model. Findings were integrated via triangulation, and the level of implementation was categorised using Roger's theory of the diffusion of innovations. Nine per cent (n = 50) of staff were trained as AAR facilitators. Survey response rates were 33% pre- and 16% post- AAR implementation. After 12-months, 37% of staff were aware of AAR and 10% had participated in one, at €48 average cost. Approximately, 39 AARs were conducted. The ratio of informal to formal AARs was 2.6:1. No change in overall safety culture occurred despite a pandemic and cyber-attack. Response to error improved. Triangulation of results confirmed improvement in response to error was associated with staff awareness and participation in AAR. Second victim experience and support showed no change in psychological and physical distress, yet professional self-efficacy, perceived organisational support and turnover intentions worsened, with no observed association with AAR. Simulation-based training and national-level policy supported early adoption of AAR. Implementation of AAR was associated with improved response to error at the hospital, but not second victim experiences.
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessImplementing after action review in an Irish tertiary hospital: a mixed-methods evaluation of safety culture and second victim experience and support
Evidence for After Action Reviews (AAR), a non-hierarchical debriefing approach, is limited. We explored AAR implementation and measured safety culture and second victim experience and support, before and after introduction of AAR at an Irish hospital. A mixed-methods study which coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic and a health system cyber-attack was conducted. Hospital selected staff were trained as AAR facilitators using a simulation-based programme (July-Sept 2021). The intervention was the hospital introduction of AAR over 12-months (Sept 2021-Aug 2022). Before training, the Hospital Survey on Patient Safety 2.0 (HSOPS 2.0) and Second Victim Experience and Support Tool (SVEST) were distributed to all staff (N = 586), and repeated at 12-months with additional questions on AAR awareness, frequency and duration. At 6-months, focus groups with trained facilitators explored implementation enablers and barriers. Costs were estimated. Quantitative analysis used chi-squared, Fisher's exact and t-tests to compare pre-/post- responses. Qualitative data was analysed using the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation - Behaviour (COM-B) model. Findings were integrated via triangulation, and the level of implementation was categorised using Roger's theory of the diffusion of innovations. Nine per cent (n = 50) of staff were trained as AAR facilitators. Survey response rates were 33% pre- and 16% post- AAR implementation. After 12-months, 37% of staff were aware of AAR and 10% had participated in one, at €48 average cost. Approximately, 39 AARs were conducted. The ratio of informal to formal AARs was 2.6:1. No change in overall safety culture occurred despite a pandemic and cyber-attack. Response to error improved. Triangulation of results confirmed improvement in response to error was associated with staff awareness and participation in AAR. Second victim experience and support showed no change in psychological and physical distress, yet professional self-efficacy, perceived organisational support and turnover intentions worsened, with no observed association with AAR. Simulation-based training and national-level policy supported early adoption of AAR. Implementation of AAR was associated with improved response to error at the hospital, but not second victim experiences.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Profiling and Mapping Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Frameworks: Protocol for a Scoping Review to Guide Integration
Background A core remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Conceptual Framework for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is first needed to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- 28 April 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Open AccessProfiling and Mapping Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Frameworks: Protocol for a Scoping Review to Guide Integration
Background A core remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Conceptual Framework for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is first needed to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- 13 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal for Quality in Health Care
- Vol. 38 (2)
The costs of canceled surgeries. What to do about them?
- 13 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal for Quality in Health Care
- Vol. 38 (2)
The costs of canceled surgeries. What to do about them?
- Open Access
- 11 February 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Profiling and Mapping Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Frameworks: Protocol for a Scoping Review to Guide Integration
Background A core remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is required to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- 11 February 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Open AccessProfiling and Mapping Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Frameworks: Protocol for a Scoping Review to Guide Integration
Background A core remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is required to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Open Quality
- Vol. 15 (1) , e003640
Identifying health economic competencies for quality improvement practitioners and educators: a mixed-methods study
Aim: To identify health economic evaluation competencies to guide quality improvement (QI) practice and education in Ireland. Methods: A parallel mixed-methods design was used. A rapid review profiled the focus (cost containment, efficiency and/or equity) and purpose (education, assessment, health system improvement) of health economic evaluation competencies used in healthcare education and management. In parallel, surveys were sent to senior healthcare leaders (N=528) and quality and healthcare management scholars (N=286) in Ireland. These examined knowledge, skills and experiences of using health economics in managing quality and safety, and the perceived usefulness of proposed competencies. Descriptive statistics were generated. Literature and survey findings were integrated to refine the competencies. Results: Of the few competencies available from the literature, most had a multiple focus and purpose. Yet, none were focused on equity and few were used to assess competence. Of 189 survey respondents, few had received training in health economics (25%) or been involved in measurement of healthcare costs (34%), value for money (29%) or budget impact (23%). Barriers were terminology and inadequate infrastructure for linking clinical and financial data. Most (90–95%) endorsed the usefulness of proposed competencies. These were refined to form four major competencies: (1) understand the relationship between cost and quality in healthcare, (2) assess the basic costs and outcomes of a QI initiative, (3) understand and apply cost-effectiveness analysis to QI initiatives and (4) advance capacity for improvement by applying cost-effectiveness analysis to decision-making. Each major competency had four to six sub-competencies. Conclusion: Health economic competencies should be integral to healthcare professionals’ and managers’ education and professional development.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Open Quality
- Vol. 15 (1) , e003640
Open AccessIdentifying health economic competencies for quality improvement practitioners and educators: a mixed-methods study
Aim: To identify health economic evaluation competencies to guide quality improvement (QI) practice and education in Ireland. Methods: A parallel mixed-methods design was used. A rapid review profiled the focus (cost containment, efficiency and/or equity) and purpose (education, assessment, health system improvement) of health economic evaluation competencies used in healthcare education and management. In parallel, surveys were sent to senior healthcare leaders (N=528) and quality and healthcare management scholars (N=286) in Ireland. These examined knowledge, skills and experiences of using health economics in managing quality and safety, and the perceived usefulness of proposed competencies. Descriptive statistics were generated. Literature and survey findings were integrated to refine the competencies. Results: Of the few competencies available from the literature, most had a multiple focus and purpose. Yet, none were focused on equity and few were used to assess competence. Of 189 survey respondents, few had received training in health economics (25%) or been involved in measurement of healthcare costs (34%), value for money (29%) or budget impact (23%). Barriers were terminology and inadequate infrastructure for linking clinical and financial data. Most (90–95%) endorsed the usefulness of proposed competencies. These were refined to form four major competencies: (1) understand the relationship between cost and quality in healthcare, (2) assess the basic costs and outcomes of a QI initiative, (3) understand and apply cost-effectiveness analysis to QI initiatives and (4) advance capacity for improvement by applying cost-effectiveness analysis to decision-making. Each major competency had four to six sub-competencies. Conclusion: Health economic competencies should be integral to healthcare professionals’ and managers’ education and professional development.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2025
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Development of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework to Inform Research Priorities for the Irish Healthcare System: Protocol for a Scoping Review
Background A core part of the remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is required to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- 18 August 2025
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in HRB Open Research
- Vol. 8, 92
Open AccessDevelopment of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework to Inform Research Priorities for the Irish Healthcare System: Protocol for a Scoping Review
Background A core part of the remit of the Evidence Based QUality Improvement and Patient Safety (EQUIPS) Research Network (2024–2029) is to inform research priorities for the Irish healthcare system. Previously, research prioritisation exercises have treated quality improvement (QI) and patient safety research as separate fields. Given the growth of QI research, an integrated approach is required to generate a full view of the continuum of knowledge generation and translation activities in quality and safety contexts. The co-creation of a Quality Improvement and Patient Safety Research Conceptual Framework among researchers, knowledge users and patient groups is required to outline important topics, research questions and methodologies, applicable to all areas of healthcare. A scoping review of the literature is required to examine existing QI and patient safety research frameworks to inform the development of a harmonised conceptual framework for the Irish context. Methods The scoping review will follow JBI guidelines for developing and co-creating scoping review protocols with knowledge users. The completed review will be reported according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews, and Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and the Public 2 (GRIPP2) checklist which supports enhanced reporting of patient and public involvement in research. We will search the following databases from 2000–2025 focussing on literature sources from developed countries: Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science. We will map included papers using an extraction template developed to fulfil the study aims. Two reviewers will independently screen studies, and discrepancies will be addressed by consensus using a third reviewer. Dissemination Findings will be used to inform the development of a meta-framework that will be used to guide QI and patient safety research priority setting, measurement and monitoring, implementation, and knowledge translation activities in Ireland, at local and national levels. OSF https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/FGWUA
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 13 (7) , 690
Reconciling Safety and Safeguarding in Health and Social Care: Implications for Just Culture
Facilitating a just response to staff involved in patient safety events is complex, with varying perceptions of safe behaviour and practice across settings. This viewpoint paper explores the challenges of developing a just culture, particularly in safeguarding situations involving peer-to-peer harm. It argues that established just culture principles, such as balancing staff and organisational accountability and using After Action Review (AAR) debriefs, need to be tailored to these contexts. In particular, organisational accountability is paramount in safeguarding situations, especially where individuals do not have the capacity to understand or intend their behaviours. Furthermore, AARs are inappropriate incident responses for serious aggression, violence, and abuse cases. To counter this, a consistent AAR practice can be valuable for preventative learning when applied to the service user care journey and comprehensive incident learning responses. The incorporation of social workers, service users, and families can help promote learning and the prevention of events. Finally, this paper emphasises the need for consistency in core safety principles across settings and the need to tailor just cultural principles to particular contexts. Future research on the role of AAR in diverse settings is recommended.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 13 (7) , 690
Open AccessReconciling Safety and Safeguarding in Health and Social Care: Implications for Just Culture
Facilitating a just response to staff involved in patient safety events is complex, with varying perceptions of safe behaviour and practice across settings. This viewpoint paper explores the challenges of developing a just culture, particularly in safeguarding situations involving peer-to-peer harm. It argues that established just culture principles, such as balancing staff and organisational accountability and using After Action Review (AAR) debriefs, need to be tailored to these contexts. In particular, organisational accountability is paramount in safeguarding situations, especially where individuals do not have the capacity to understand or intend their behaviours. Furthermore, AARs are inappropriate incident responses for serious aggression, violence, and abuse cases. To counter this, a consistent AAR practice can be valuable for preventative learning when applied to the service user care journey and comprehensive incident learning responses. The incorporation of social workers, service users, and families can help promote learning and the prevention of events. Finally, this paper emphasises the need for consistency in core safety principles across settings and the need to tailor just cultural principles to particular contexts. Future research on the role of AAR in diverse settings is recommended.
- Open Access
- 8 February 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Open Quality
- Vol. 14 (1) , e002967
Developing and piloting a peer quality improvement coaching protocol for front-line healthcare staff
Background: Improving the quality of patient care remains a global necessity. Despite system and professional benefits, current evidence indicates that the spread of improvement principles among front-line healthcare workers remains poor. While education and training alone are unlikely to result in consistent improvement practice, coaching can play a critical role in sustainable, evidence-based improvement implementation. Peer quality improvement coaching (PQIC) places the power and agency in the shared relationship between coach and coachee to shape coachee quality improvement (QI) outcomes. Study objective was to develop and pilot an evidence-based protocol for implementation and evaluation of a PQIC for front-line staff engaged in small to intermediate improvement efforts. Methods: We conducted a multistage case-study design and implementation process. First, a systematised literature review identified themes about the theory and practice of QI coaching (QIC). Second, these themes guided the development of a PQIC protocol. Finally, the protocol was piloted and evaluated among staff in a single-centre tertiary maternity hospital. PQIC effectiveness was assessed using evaluation tools identified in the literature. Results: Effectiveness; strategies and models; moderating factors and methods for evaluation of QIC emerged from the literature. Together with Bloom’s taxonomy and Kirkpatrick’s educational model, these themes informed the development of this PQIC protocol. It was piloted in three steps: education, coaching and evaluation. A survey revealed that the participants in the education step achieved excellent scores. Following the coaching journey, the coached multidisciplinary team leaders completed their improvement initiatives and demonstrated increased QI knowledge and skills measured by the ‘IHI improvement advisor self-assessment tool’ and ‘IHI assessment scale for collaboratives’. Conclusion: Built on established education, peer coaching and QI concepts, this evidence-based PQIC protocol adds to international evidence on how to support front-line healthcare workers in their improvement efforts. Future research needs to assess protocol effectiveness across different settings.
- 8 February 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Open Quality
- Vol. 14 (1) , e002967
Open AccessDeveloping and piloting a peer quality improvement coaching protocol for front-line healthcare staff
Background: Improving the quality of patient care remains a global necessity. Despite system and professional benefits, current evidence indicates that the spread of improvement principles among front-line healthcare workers remains poor. While education and training alone are unlikely to result in consistent improvement practice, coaching can play a critical role in sustainable, evidence-based improvement implementation. Peer quality improvement coaching (PQIC) places the power and agency in the shared relationship between coach and coachee to shape coachee quality improvement (QI) outcomes. Study objective was to develop and pilot an evidence-based protocol for implementation and evaluation of a PQIC for front-line staff engaged in small to intermediate improvement efforts. Methods: We conducted a multistage case-study design and implementation process. First, a systematised literature review identified themes about the theory and practice of QI coaching (QIC). Second, these themes guided the development of a PQIC protocol. Finally, the protocol was piloted and evaluated among staff in a single-centre tertiary maternity hospital. PQIC effectiveness was assessed using evaluation tools identified in the literature. Results: Effectiveness; strategies and models; moderating factors and methods for evaluation of QIC emerged from the literature. Together with Bloom’s taxonomy and Kirkpatrick’s educational model, these themes informed the development of this PQIC protocol. It was piloted in three steps: education, coaching and evaluation. A survey revealed that the participants in the education step achieved excellent scores. Following the coaching journey, the coached multidisciplinary team leaders completed their improvement initiatives and demonstrated increased QI knowledge and skills measured by the ‘IHI improvement advisor self-assessment tool’ and ‘IHI assessment scale for collaboratives’. Conclusion: Built on established education, peer coaching and QI concepts, this evidence-based PQIC protocol adds to international evidence on how to support front-line healthcare workers in their improvement efforts. Future research needs to assess protocol effectiveness across different settings.