Samuel Challéat
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Samuel Challéat has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dany Lapostolle
Aménagement de l’espace et urbanisme, Université de Bourgogne, UMR THEMA
8 shared publications - Johan Milian
University of Paris 8, UMR LADYSS CNRS Saint‐Denis France
5 shared publications - Kévin Barré
Centre d'Ecologie et des Sciences de la Conservation (CESCO), Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique Sorbonne Université Paris France
5 shared publications - Laurent Godet
CNRS, LETG Nantes Université, BP 81223 Nantes France
2 shared publications - Magalie Franchomme
CNRS Nocturnal Environment Observatory, France
2 shared publications - Nicolas Farrugia
IMT Atlantique, Lab-STICC, UMR CNRS 6285, Brest, France
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 17 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space
The illusion of control: Do we need dark infrastructures to address light pollution?
The spread of artificial light at night (ALAN) has become a growing concern in conservation science and environmental governance. In France, the Trame Noire policy (TNP) was introduced as a spatial response to ALAN's ecological effects and institutionalised through the concept of Dark Infrastructure (DI). Framed as a science-based, data-driven solution, DI embodies a technocratic vision of environmental control, reducing the complexity of nocturnal ecologies to zoning tools, cartographic templates, and optimisation algorithms. Drawing on a decade of situated fieldwork and research-action programmes, this article adopts a constructivist and critical policy approach to analyse how scientific knowledge is translated into planning instruments. We show how DI, as a policy device, standardises darkness, marginalises local ecological and social knowledge, and promotes a narrow, depoliticised intervention logic. Far from transforming lighting practices or power relations, DI often consolidates existing infrastructural norms and spatial routines. To move beyond this epistemic and political dead end, we mobilise the concept of Dark Ecological Network (DEN) as a strategic horizon for adaptive and territorially grounded governance. We also introduce the Lit Infrastructure (LI) as a situated logic of action that emphasises stakeholder engagement, collective deliberation, and infrastructural restraint. Rather than engineering darkness through technocratic fixes, this approach focuses on reducing ALAN at its source by questioning lighting norms, dismantling excessive illumination, and enabling territorial experimentation. This shift reframes darkness not as an object to be designed and controlled, but as a condition to be collectively reclaimed through democratic negotiation, care, and spatial retreat of ALAN. In doing so, we contribute to outlining an ecology of withdrawal—an alternative approach to environmental governance grounded in infrastructural downscaling, situated action, and the reconfiguration of normative spatial interventions.
- 17 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space
The illusion of control: Do we need dark infrastructures to address light pollution?
The spread of artificial light at night (ALAN) has become a growing concern in conservation science and environmental governance. In France, the Trame Noire policy (TNP) was introduced as a spatial response to ALAN's ecological effects and institutionalised through the concept of Dark Infrastructure (DI). Framed as a science-based, data-driven solution, DI embodies a technocratic vision of environmental control, reducing the complexity of nocturnal ecologies to zoning tools, cartographic templates, and optimisation algorithms. Drawing on a decade of situated fieldwork and research-action programmes, this article adopts a constructivist and critical policy approach to analyse how scientific knowledge is translated into planning instruments. We show how DI, as a policy device, standardises darkness, marginalises local ecological and social knowledge, and promotes a narrow, depoliticised intervention logic. Far from transforming lighting practices or power relations, DI often consolidates existing infrastructural norms and spatial routines. To move beyond this epistemic and political dead end, we mobilise the concept of Dark Ecological Network (DEN) as a strategic horizon for adaptive and territorially grounded governance. We also introduce the Lit Infrastructure (LI) as a situated logic of action that emphasises stakeholder engagement, collective deliberation, and infrastructural restraint. Rather than engineering darkness through technocratic fixes, this approach focuses on reducing ALAN at its source by questioning lighting norms, dismantling excessive illumination, and enabling territorial experimentation. This shift reframes darkness not as an object to be designed and controlled, but as a condition to be collectively reclaimed through democratic negotiation, care, and spatial retreat of ALAN. In doing so, we contribute to outlining an ecology of withdrawal—an alternative approach to environmental governance grounded in infrastructural downscaling, situated action, and the reconfiguration of normative spatial interventions.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
"Sauver la nuit" : empreinte lumineuse, urbanisme et gouvernance des territoires
Notre société entretient une relation complexe avec la nuit, espace-temps souvent hors des cadences diurnes qui favorise la réflexion, l’imaginaire, la création, l’écoute et le rapprochement de l’autre, tout en révélant la ségrégation, la peur, et donc la restriction. Par cette recherche, nous mettons en regard de l’éclairage urbain – véritable projet lumière porteur d’une symbolique forte – les coûts socioculturels, écologiques et sanitaires engendrés par la lumière artificielle. L’éclairage urbain génère un entrelacs géographique d’empreintes lumineuses d’échelles différenciées, que nous approchons par différentes modélisations, sans pour autant nous en interdire l’analyse sensible. Nous explicitons, à différentes échelles, les jeux d’acteurs institutionnels et les contraintes entourant la gouvernance de l’éclairage public en France, et soulignons la multiplication des possibilités offertes pour sa gestion locale. Une caractérisation des différents impacts de la lumière artificielle nocturne à l’aide d’outils conceptuels de l’économie de l’environnement permet de définir comme réelles pollutions les dégradations écologiques et sanitaires, et comme nuisance la diminution – voire la perte – de l’accessibilité au ciel étoilé. Nous montrons comment le bien environnemental « ciel étoilé » a été saisi par les astronomes pour porter un projet positif intégrant désormais l’environnement nocturne dans son ensemble : « Sauver la nuit ». Des oppositions à ce projet ont jalonné son histoire, mais les nécessaires économies d’énergie et les contraintes budgets des collectivités territoriales amènent désormais les acteurs locaux à reconsidérer avec plus d’intérêt les différentes propositions faites par les associations de « protection du ciel et de l’environnement nocturnes ». Mais la difficile efficience des mécanismes de marchandage coasiens nous amène à soutenir que la protection de ces biens publics purs,non appropriables et non marchandables, doit être prise en charge par la puissance publique.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
"Sauver la nuit" : empreinte lumineuse, urbanisme et gouvernance des territoires
Notre société entretient une relation complexe avec la nuit, espace-temps souvent hors des cadences diurnes qui favorise la réflexion, l’imaginaire, la création, l’écoute et le rapprochement de l’autre, tout en révélant la ségrégation, la peur, et donc la restriction. Par cette recherche, nous mettons en regard de l’éclairage urbain – véritable projet lumière porteur d’une symbolique forte – les coûts socioculturels, écologiques et sanitaires engendrés par la lumière artificielle. L’éclairage urbain génère un entrelacs géographique d’empreintes lumineuses d’échelles différenciées, que nous approchons par différentes modélisations, sans pour autant nous en interdire l’analyse sensible. Nous explicitons, à différentes échelles, les jeux d’acteurs institutionnels et les contraintes entourant la gouvernance de l’éclairage public en France, et soulignons la multiplication des possibilités offertes pour sa gestion locale. Une caractérisation des différents impacts de la lumière artificielle nocturne à l’aide d’outils conceptuels de l’économie de l’environnement permet de définir comme réelles pollutions les dégradations écologiques et sanitaires, et comme nuisance la diminution – voire la perte – de l’accessibilité au ciel étoilé. Nous montrons comment le bien environnemental « ciel étoilé » a été saisi par les astronomes pour porter un projet positif intégrant désormais l’environnement nocturne dans son ensemble : « Sauver la nuit ». Des oppositions à ce projet ont jalonné son histoire, mais les nécessaires économies d’énergie et les contraintes budgets des collectivités territoriales amènent désormais les acteurs locaux à reconsidérer avec plus d’intérêt les différentes propositions faites par les associations de « protection du ciel et de l’environnement nocturnes ». Mais la difficile efficience des mécanismes de marchandage coasiens nous amène à soutenir que la protection de ces biens publics purs,non appropriables et non marchandables, doit être prise en charge par la puissance publique.
- 17 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Pollution
- Vol. 396, 127837
Part-night lighting fails to restore natural song rhythms in urban European Robins
- 17 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Pollution
- Vol. 396, 127837
Part-night lighting fails to restore natural song rhythms in urban European Robins
- Open Access
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Data
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-16
A dataset of acoustic measurements from soundscapes collected worldwide during the COVID-19 pandemic
Political responses to the COVID-19 pandemic led to changes in city soundscapes around the globe. From March to October 2020, a consortium of 261 contributors from 35 countries brought together by the Silent Cities project built a unique soundscape recordings collection to report on local acoustic changes in urban areas. We present this collection here, along with metadata including observational descriptions of the local areas from the contributors, open-source environmental data, open-source confinement levels and calculation of acoustic descriptors. We performed a technical validation of the dataset using statistical models run on a subset of manually annotated soundscapes. Results confirmed the large-scale usability of ecoacoustic indices and automatic sound event recognition in the Silent Cities soundscape collection. We expect this dataset to be useful for research in the multidisciplinary field of environmental sciences.
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Data
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-16
Open AccessA dataset of acoustic measurements from soundscapes collected worldwide during the COVID-19 pandemic
Political responses to the COVID-19 pandemic led to changes in city soundscapes around the globe. From March to October 2020, a consortium of 261 contributors from 35 countries brought together by the Silent Cities project built a unique soundscape recordings collection to report on local acoustic changes in urban areas. We present this collection here, along with metadata including observational descriptions of the local areas from the contributors, open-source environmental data, open-source confinement levels and calculation of acoustic descriptors. We performed a technical validation of the dataset using statistical models run on a subset of manually annotated soundscapes. Results confirmed the large-scale usability of ecoacoustic indices and automatic sound event recognition in the Silent Cities soundscape collection. We expect this dataset to be useful for research in the multidisciplinary field of environmental sciences.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by OpenEdition in Temporalités
- Vol. 37-38
Les territorialités nocturnes à La Réunion : des rapports à la nuit en recomposition
Cet article porte un regard sur les temporalités et les territorialités nocturnes des pratiques et des usages quotidiens à l’île de la Réunion. Peu d’études en sciences sociales ont jusqu’alors réussi à s’extraire des grandes métropoles du Nord pour décentrer leur regard et s’intéresser aux nuits des espaces urbains tropicaux. Dans cette perspective, l’une des tâches de fond consiste à étudier la place de l’obscurité dans le vécu et l’imaginaire des populations réunionnaises, gageant qu’une meilleure connaissance et compréhension des territorialités nocturnes pourrait aider à consolider les démarches de protection de l’environnement nocturne dans le quotidien de l’aménagement des territoires.L’île a vu depuis plusieurs décennies ses campagnes se transformer profondément, pour certaines très marquées par l’exode, pour d’autres avalées dans un processus d’urbanisation non maîtrisé. C’est dans ce contexte que notre équipe a commencé à installer, en partenariat avec le Parc national de La Réunion, une démarche plus englobante de la protection de l’environnement nocturne et d’arrimer des enjeux sociaux, en faisant émerger dans le débat public, au côté de la pollution lumineuse et ses effets écologiques, la question des spécificités des temporalités du nocturne par la prise en compte des perceptions, des pratiques et modes d’habiter du quotidien.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by OpenEdition in Temporalités
- Vol. 37-38
Open AccessLes territorialités nocturnes à La Réunion : des rapports à la nuit en recomposition
Cet article porte un regard sur les temporalités et les territorialités nocturnes des pratiques et des usages quotidiens à l’île de la Réunion. Peu d’études en sciences sociales ont jusqu’alors réussi à s’extraire des grandes métropoles du Nord pour décentrer leur regard et s’intéresser aux nuits des espaces urbains tropicaux. Dans cette perspective, l’une des tâches de fond consiste à étudier la place de l’obscurité dans le vécu et l’imaginaire des populations réunionnaises, gageant qu’une meilleure connaissance et compréhension des territorialités nocturnes pourrait aider à consolider les démarches de protection de l’environnement nocturne dans le quotidien de l’aménagement des territoires.L’île a vu depuis plusieurs décennies ses campagnes se transformer profondément, pour certaines très marquées par l’exode, pour d’autres avalées dans un processus d’urbanisation non maîtrisé. C’est dans ce contexte que notre équipe a commencé à installer, en partenariat avec le Parc national de La Réunion, une démarche plus englobante de la protection de l’environnement nocturne et d’arrimer des enjeux sociaux, en faisant émerger dans le débat public, au côté de la pollution lumineuse et ses effets écologiques, la question des spécificités des temporalités du nocturne par la prise en compte des perceptions, des pratiques et modes d’habiter du quotidien.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by OpenEdition in Tracés
- Vol. #22, 23-45
Construire et travailler un objet de recherche en interdisciplinarité : l’exemple de l’environnement nocturne à La Réunion
La notion d’environnement nocturne émerge à la suite de la requalification de la lumière artificielle nocturne en pollution lumineuse. Elle entend caractériser les systèmes humains et non humains fonctionnellement liés à l’obscurité. Contrairement à la notion de pollution lumineuse, elle oblige à penser conjointement les multiples enjeux du couple lumière artificielle/obscurité. En l’inscrivant dans le cadre d’analyse des systèmes socio-écologiques, nous faisons de l’environnement nocturne un objet de recherche à part entière apte à structurer une interdisciplinarité entre sciences de la nature et sciences humaines et sociales. C’est sur le territoire réunionnais que nous mettons cet objet relationnel à l’épreuve du monde réel, dans un travail partenarial mené avec le Parc national de La Réunion autour des enjeux d’aménagement que soulève sa volonté de préservation holistique de la ressource obscurité et de l’environnement nocturne. Du savoir à l’action, de la construction d’un objet de recherche à l’installation d’un dispositif collaboratif dédié à la production de connaissances scientifiques situées sur l’environnement nocturne et à l’accompagnement des acteurs locaux dans une démarche de préservation et de valorisation de l’obscurité, cet article rend compte d’un processus de recherche hybride (recherche fondamentale et recherche-action) qui puise sa vitalité dans une interdisciplinarité radicale.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by OpenEdition in Tracés
- Vol. #22, 23-45
Open AccessConstruire et travailler un objet de recherche en interdisciplinarité : l’exemple de l’environnement nocturne à La Réunion
La notion d’environnement nocturne émerge à la suite de la requalification de la lumière artificielle nocturne en pollution lumineuse. Elle entend caractériser les systèmes humains et non humains fonctionnellement liés à l’obscurité. Contrairement à la notion de pollution lumineuse, elle oblige à penser conjointement les multiples enjeux du couple lumière artificielle/obscurité. En l’inscrivant dans le cadre d’analyse des systèmes socio-écologiques, nous faisons de l’environnement nocturne un objet de recherche à part entière apte à structurer une interdisciplinarité entre sciences de la nature et sciences humaines et sociales. C’est sur le territoire réunionnais que nous mettons cet objet relationnel à l’épreuve du monde réel, dans un travail partenarial mené avec le Parc national de La Réunion autour des enjeux d’aménagement que soulève sa volonté de préservation holistique de la ressource obscurité et de l’environnement nocturne. Du savoir à l’action, de la construction d’un objet de recherche à l’installation d’un dispositif collaboratif dédié à la production de connaissances scientifiques situées sur l’environnement nocturne et à l’accompagnement des acteurs locaux dans une démarche de préservation et de valorisation de l’obscurité, cet article rend compte d’un processus de recherche hybride (recherche fondamentale et recherche-action) qui puise sa vitalité dans une interdisciplinarité radicale.
- 7 September 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science
- Vol. 49 (3) , 1024-1047
Cross-analysis for the assessment of urban environmental quality: An interdisciplinary and participative approach
The goal of this research is to assess environmental quality at the neighbourhood level through a multi-dimensional and multi-sensory approach that combines social and physical methodologies. For this purpose, an interdisciplinary protocol has been designed to simultaneously collect physical parameter measurements (related to microclimate and acoustics) and survey data on perceptions (involving residents and non-residents). The cross-referenced analysis of data collected at six contrasting places in a district in Toulouse (France) enabled us (i) to better understand and prioritise the factors that influence residents' assessment of the quality of their living environment and (ii) to understand to what extent the differentiation of the places by the inhabitants converges with the differentiation of these places based on acoustic and micrometeorological measurements. The statistical analysis based on individuals showed the importance of noise and air quality that rank just after the aesthetic dimension for all respondents. Nevertheless, the quality of maintenance and the feeling of security that the place inspires seem to be as crucial as these environmental criteria for the inhabitants. The analysis focused on the sites highlighted the consistency between the typology of places based on perceptions and that based on acoustic measurements, which confirms the high inhabitants' sensitivity to this environmental component.
- 7 September 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science
- Vol. 49 (3) , 1024-1047
Cross-analysis for the assessment of urban environmental quality: An interdisciplinary and participative approach
The goal of this research is to assess environmental quality at the neighbourhood level through a multi-dimensional and multi-sensory approach that combines social and physical methodologies. For this purpose, an interdisciplinary protocol has been designed to simultaneously collect physical parameter measurements (related to microclimate and acoustics) and survey data on perceptions (involving residents and non-residents). The cross-referenced analysis of data collected at six contrasting places in a district in Toulouse (France) enabled us (i) to better understand and prioritise the factors that influence residents' assessment of the quality of their living environment and (ii) to understand to what extent the differentiation of the places by the inhabitants converges with the differentiation of these places based on acoustic and micrometeorological measurements. The statistical analysis based on individuals showed the importance of noise and air quality that rank just after the aesthetic dimension for all respondents. Nevertheless, the quality of maintenance and the feeling of security that the place inspires seem to be as crucial as these environmental criteria for the inhabitants. The analysis focused on the sites highlighted the consistency between the typology of places based on perceptions and that based on acoustic measurements, which confirms the high inhabitants' sensitivity to this environmental component.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Ecology and Society
- Vol. 26 (1)
Grasping darkness: the dark ecological network as a social-ecological framework to limit the impacts of light pollution on biodiversity
Challéat, S., K. Barré, A. Laforge, D. Lapostolle, M. Franchomme, C. Sirami, I. Le Viol, J. Milian, and C. Kerbiriou. 2021. Grasping darkness: the dark ecological network as a social-ecological framework to limit the impacts of light pollution on biodiversity. Ecology and Society 26(1):15. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-12156-260115
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Ecology and Society
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessGrasping darkness: the dark ecological network as a social-ecological framework to limit the impacts of light pollution on biodiversity
Challéat, S., K. Barré, A. Laforge, D. Lapostolle, M. Franchomme, C. Sirami, I. Le Viol, J. Milian, and C. Kerbiriou. 2021. Grasping darkness: the dark ecological network as a social-ecological framework to limit the impacts of light pollution on biodiversity. Ecology and Society 26(1):15. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-12156-260115
- Open Access
- 27 August 2020
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 24 (2) , 259-267
Artificial light may change flight patterns of bats near bridges along urban waterways
Artificial light at night (ALAN) is considered as a major threat to biodiversity, especially to nocturnal species, as it reduces availability, quality and functionality of habitats. However, its effects on the way species use landscape elements such as rivers are still largely understudied, especially the effect of crossing infrastructure lighting on bridges. These elements are nevertheless key commuting and foraging habitats in heavily urbanised landscapes for several taxa such as bats that are particularly affected by ALAN. We studied the effects of the illumination of facades and undersides of bridges on the relative abundance of pipistrelle bats, on their 3D distribution and their behavioural response (i.e. flight speed) close to bridges. We set‐up an innovative approach based on a microphone‐array to reconstruct positions and flight trajectories in 3D. We studied the effect of lighting on bats in the close proximity of six similar bridges, mostly differentiated by the presence or absence of lighting (3 lit and 3 unlit). All bridges cross the same waterway, within a uniformly and highly urbanized agglomeration (Toulouse, France). We found that bat activity was 1.7 times lower in lit sites. Bats tended to keep a larger distance, and to fly faster close to illuminated bridges. These results suggest that bridge lighting strongly reduces habitat availability and likely connectivity for bats. In that case, results call for switching off the illumination of such bridges crossing riverine ecosystems to preserve their functionality as habitats and corridors for bats.
- 27 August 2020
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 24 (2) , 259-267
Open AccessArtificial light may change flight patterns of bats near bridges along urban waterways
Artificial light at night (ALAN) is considered as a major threat to biodiversity, especially to nocturnal species, as it reduces availability, quality and functionality of habitats. However, its effects on the way species use landscape elements such as rivers are still largely understudied, especially the effect of crossing infrastructure lighting on bridges. These elements are nevertheless key commuting and foraging habitats in heavily urbanised landscapes for several taxa such as bats that are particularly affected by ALAN. We studied the effects of the illumination of facades and undersides of bridges on the relative abundance of pipistrelle bats, on their 3D distribution and their behavioural response (i.e. flight speed) close to bridges. We set‐up an innovative approach based on a microphone‐array to reconstruct positions and flight trajectories in 3D. We studied the effect of lighting on bats in the close proximity of six similar bridges, mostly differentiated by the presence or absence of lighting (3 lit and 3 unlit). All bridges cross the same waterway, within a uniformly and highly urbanized agglomeration (Toulouse, France). We found that bat activity was 1.7 times lower in lit sites. Bats tended to keep a larger distance, and to fly faster close to illuminated bridges. These results suggest that bridge lighting strongly reduces habitat availability and likely connectivity for bats. In that case, results call for switching off the illumination of such bridges crossing riverine ecosystems to preserve their functionality as habitats and corridors for bats.
- 19 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 111 (1) , 196-215
Making Darkness a Place-Based Resource: How the Fight against Light Pollution Reconfigures Rural Areas in France
Light pollution refers to the degradation of darkness through the use of artificial light at night in and around human infrastructures. This pollution is intrinsically related to urbanization and spills out from urban areas to affect both rural and protected areas. Several countries are organizing the fight against light pollution. There, local communities are experimenting with environmental policies designed to protect darkness. The challenge is about preserving biodiversity and fostering the energy transition. In France, a number of pioneering rural areas are experimenting with mechanisms that include this dual implication. Two of them provide the case study for this article. We show how these areas turn darkness into a specific resource. We identify three specification processes. The first obeys an anthropocentric utilitarian rationale and is part of the “economicization” of the environment in the line of shallow ecology. The second follows a rationale of ecocentric conservation and is part of the radical ecologization of the economy, in line with deep ecology. The third is in keeping with an integrated socioecosystemic rationale enshrining the interdependence between development, planning, the preservation of biodiversity, and energy savings. Local areas are plagued with specification controversies. These areas become incubation rooms; that is, spaces for resolving these controversies. These are reflected in a transition operator enabling the local area to take a fresh trajectory in terms of development and planning.
- 19 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 111 (1) , 196-215
Making Darkness a Place-Based Resource: How the Fight against Light Pollution Reconfigures Rural Areas in France
Light pollution refers to the degradation of darkness through the use of artificial light at night in and around human infrastructures. This pollution is intrinsically related to urbanization and spills out from urban areas to affect both rural and protected areas. Several countries are organizing the fight against light pollution. There, local communities are experimenting with environmental policies designed to protect darkness. The challenge is about preserving biodiversity and fostering the energy transition. In France, a number of pioneering rural areas are experimenting with mechanisms that include this dual implication. Two of them provide the case study for this article. We show how these areas turn darkness into a specific resource. We identify three specification processes. The first obeys an anthropocentric utilitarian rationale and is part of the “economicization” of the environment in the line of shallow ecology. The second follows a rationale of ecocentric conservation and is part of the radical ecologization of the economy, in line with deep ecology. The third is in keeping with an integrated socioecosystemic rationale enshrining the interdependence between development, planning, the preservation of biodiversity, and energy savings. Local areas are plagued with specification controversies. These areas become incubation rooms; that is, spaces for resolving these controversies. These are reflected in a transition operator enabling the local area to take a fresh trajectory in terms of development and planning.