Hayati Zengin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Hayati Zengin has a total of 33 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ahmet Salih Değermenci
Faculty of Forestry, Department of Forest Management and Planning, Düzce University, Düzce, Turkey
11 shared publications - Pete Bettinger
Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, USA
3 shared publications - Ahmet Yeşil
Faculty of Forestry, Department of Forest Management, Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey
2 shared publications - Hakan Yasin Özdemir
Duzce Universitesi
2 shared publications Mehmet Özcan
Düzce University, Faculty of Forestry, Türkiye
2 shared publications- Tarık Çitgez
Faculty of Forestry, Department of Watershed Management, Düzce University, Düzce, Turkey
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 197 (8) , 1-19
Investigation of changes in leaf area ındex in different forest stands
Leaf area ındex (LAI) is a fundamental metric of forest canopy structure, driving photosynthetic capacity, carbon sequestration, and ecosystem productivity. In this study, we quantified LAI variation across six forest stand types (pure fir, pure beech, pure Scots pine, mixed coniferous, mixed deciduous, and mixed deciduous–coniferous) and six developmental stages in the Düzce region of Turkey, an area characterized by mixed, heterogeneous woodlands. Field measurements from 260 systematically distributed sample plots collected in 2015 employed hemispherical photography for LAI, the N-tree method for basal area (BA) and diameter at breast height (DBH), and atmospherically corrected Landsat 8 OLI imagery for NDVI. Descriptive analyses revealed LAI values ranging from 0.36 m2/m2 in pure Scots pine to 6.30 m2/m2 in mixed deciduous stands. One-way ANOVA and Duncan’s multiple-range tests confirmed significant differences among stand types (p < 0.01), with mixed and vertically stratified stands exhibiting the highest LAI. Developmental stages showed increasing mean LAI trends from juvenile (ab) to mature (d) classes, though stage-only ANOVA was not significant (p = 0.378) due to high within-stage variability (CV ≈ 31%). Pearson correlations indicated moderate positive relationships between LAI and both DBH (r = 0.49) and BA (r = 0.53), whereas NDVI displayed the strongest association (r = 0.75 overall; up to r = 0.80 in mixed stands). A multiple linear regression model integrating NDVI, DBH, and BA explained 60.6% of LAI variance (F = 129.7, p < 0.001; adjusted R2 = 0.601), with NDVI emerging as the dominant predictor (standardized β = 0.683), followed by DBH (β = 0.326) and BA (β = 0.187). These findings underscore the complementary value of integrating spectral indices and structural parameters in the estimation of LAI, particularly in heterogeneous forest stands. The structural complexity of mixed stands appears to play a critical role in enhancing canopy development. To improve estimation accuracy in conifer-dominated or high-LAI forests, future studies should consider incorporating alternative vegetation indices and LiDAR-derived structural metrics to overcome limitations such as spectral saturation and insufficient vertical resolution. Such integrated approaches can significantly enhance the scalability and cost-effectiveness of forest health and productivity monitoring efforts.
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 197 (8) , 1-19
Investigation of changes in leaf area ındex in different forest stands
Leaf area ındex (LAI) is a fundamental metric of forest canopy structure, driving photosynthetic capacity, carbon sequestration, and ecosystem productivity. In this study, we quantified LAI variation across six forest stand types (pure fir, pure beech, pure Scots pine, mixed coniferous, mixed deciduous, and mixed deciduous–coniferous) and six developmental stages in the Düzce region of Turkey, an area characterized by mixed, heterogeneous woodlands. Field measurements from 260 systematically distributed sample plots collected in 2015 employed hemispherical photography for LAI, the N-tree method for basal area (BA) and diameter at breast height (DBH), and atmospherically corrected Landsat 8 OLI imagery for NDVI. Descriptive analyses revealed LAI values ranging from 0.36 m2/m2 in pure Scots pine to 6.30 m2/m2 in mixed deciduous stands. One-way ANOVA and Duncan’s multiple-range tests confirmed significant differences among stand types (p < 0.01), with mixed and vertically stratified stands exhibiting the highest LAI. Developmental stages showed increasing mean LAI trends from juvenile (ab) to mature (d) classes, though stage-only ANOVA was not significant (p = 0.378) due to high within-stage variability (CV ≈ 31%). Pearson correlations indicated moderate positive relationships between LAI and both DBH (r = 0.49) and BA (r = 0.53), whereas NDVI displayed the strongest association (r = 0.75 overall; up to r = 0.80 in mixed stands). A multiple linear regression model integrating NDVI, DBH, and BA explained 60.6% of LAI variance (F = 129.7, p < 0.001; adjusted R2 = 0.601), with NDVI emerging as the dominant predictor (standardized β = 0.683), followed by DBH (β = 0.326) and BA (β = 0.187). These findings underscore the complementary value of integrating spectral indices and structural parameters in the estimation of LAI, particularly in heterogeneous forest stands. The structural complexity of mixed stands appears to play a critical role in enhancing canopy development. To improve estimation accuracy in conifer-dominated or high-LAI forests, future studies should consider incorporating alternative vegetation indices and LiDAR-derived structural metrics to overcome limitations such as spectral saturation and insufficient vertical resolution. Such integrated approaches can significantly enhance the scalability and cost-effectiveness of forest health and productivity monitoring efforts.
- 7 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Sustainable Forestry
- Vol. 44 (6) , 450-470
How Forest Management and Planning Affects the Sustainability of Stumpage Value? A Case Study from Turkey
- 7 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Sustainable Forestry
- Vol. 44 (6) , 450-470
How Forest Management and Planning Affects the Sustainability of Stumpage Value? A Case Study from Turkey
- Open Access
- 28 December 2024
- Published by Duzce University in Düzce Üniversitesi Orman Fakültesi Ormancılık Dergisi
- Vol. 20 (2) , 395-407
Yersel Lidar Verisinden 3DFin Yazılımı ile Ağaçların Göğüs Çapının Belirlenmesi
Göğüs çapı, orman envanterinde ölçülen en yaygın ve en önemli meşcere parametrelerinden birisidir. Orman envanterinde örnek alan içerisindeki tüm ağaçların ölçümü gereklidir. Zor arazi koşullarında envanterin en basit bu işlemi bile zor hale gelmektedir. Bu nedenle gelişen teknolojinin takip edilmesi ve orman envanterine entegrasyonu önemlidir. Yersel lidar tarama ile sağlanan üç boyutlu nokta bulutu verilerinden çeşitli ölçümler yapmak ve göğüs çapı gibi ağaç veya meşcereye ait bazı parametreleri bu verilerden sağlamak mümkün hale gelmektedir. Bu çalışmada Düzce Üniversitesi Yerleşkesi’nde yer alan meşe meşceresinden alınan örnek alan içerisine giren ağaçların çapları önce klasik yöntemle çapölçer vasıtasıyla ölçülmüş ve bulunan değerler daha sonra lidar verisinden hesaplanmış değerlerle karşılaştırılmıştır. Lidar verisinde tek ağaç bazında manuel ölçümler kolayca yapılabilmekle birlikte örnek alan bazındaki çalışmalarda süreci otomatik hale getiren araçlar kullanmak verimliliği artırmaktadır. Bu çalışmada da nokta bulutundan ağaçların göğüs çaplarının belirlenmesi 3DFin yazılımı kullanılarak gerçekleştirilmiştir. Yapılan analizler sonucunda çap ölçer ve lidar ölçümleri arasında %95 güven düzeyinde anlamlı farklar bulunmadığı doğrulanmıştır.
- 28 December 2024
- Published by Duzce University in Düzce Üniversitesi Orman Fakültesi Ormancılık Dergisi
- Vol. 20 (2) , 395-407
Open AccessYersel Lidar Verisinden 3DFin Yazılımı ile Ağaçların Göğüs Çapının Belirlenmesi
Göğüs çapı, orman envanterinde ölçülen en yaygın ve en önemli meşcere parametrelerinden birisidir. Orman envanterinde örnek alan içerisindeki tüm ağaçların ölçümü gereklidir. Zor arazi koşullarında envanterin en basit bu işlemi bile zor hale gelmektedir. Bu nedenle gelişen teknolojinin takip edilmesi ve orman envanterine entegrasyonu önemlidir. Yersel lidar tarama ile sağlanan üç boyutlu nokta bulutu verilerinden çeşitli ölçümler yapmak ve göğüs çapı gibi ağaç veya meşcereye ait bazı parametreleri bu verilerden sağlamak mümkün hale gelmektedir. Bu çalışmada Düzce Üniversitesi Yerleşkesi’nde yer alan meşe meşceresinden alınan örnek alan içerisine giren ağaçların çapları önce klasik yöntemle çapölçer vasıtasıyla ölçülmüş ve bulunan değerler daha sonra lidar verisinden hesaplanmış değerlerle karşılaştırılmıştır. Lidar verisinde tek ağaç bazında manuel ölçümler kolayca yapılabilmekle birlikte örnek alan bazındaki çalışmalarda süreci otomatik hale getiren araçlar kullanmak verimliliği artırmaktadır. Bu çalışmada da nokta bulutundan ağaçların göğüs çaplarının belirlenmesi 3DFin yazılımı kullanılarak gerçekleştirilmiştir. Yapılan analizler sonucunda çap ölçer ve lidar ölçümleri arasında %95 güven düzeyinde anlamlı farklar bulunmadığı doğrulanmıştır.
- 26 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 196 (11) , 1-16
Determination of land surface temperatures for some oak stands with Landsat 8 OLI satellite images: a case study from Turkey
This study investigates the effect of forest cover, development stage and aspect factors on surface temperature (LST) in Demirköy and Düzce Forest Enterprises (FE) using Landsat 8 OLI satellite imagery from July 2021. In Demirköy FE, the highest LST value was recorded in the district center with 47.4 °C, in Düzce FE, the highest LST value was recorded in the provincial center with 44.6 °C, while the lowest value was 14.3 °C in Demirköy FE and 13.02 °C in Düzce FE in densely forested areas. When the stands were evaluated, it was found that pure juvenile oak stands had the highest average LST value with 30.48 °C in Demirköy FE and 23.96 °C in Düzce FE, whereas lower LST values were observed in old oak stands due to more dense cover. In terms of aspect, higher temperatures were recorded in the southern and western aspects in both study areas. In Düzce FE, high LST values were also observed in juvenile stands in the northern direction, indicating the influence of local factors such as topography and solar radiation angle. The highest LST values were observed in open forest areas; 6–9 °C higher temperatures were found in Demirköy and 1–5 °C higher in Düzce compared to vegetated areas. Significant correlations were found between LST and vegetation indices, and the highest correlation was found between LST and Normalized Difference Structuring Index (NDBI) (R2, 0.54 in Demirköy and R2, 0.50 in Düzce). NDVI showed a negative relationship with LST (R2, 0.47 in Demirköy, R2, 0.43 in Düzce). These findings reveal the critical role of forest density, tree species, and forest management practices in regulating surface temperatures, especially in the context of urbanization and deforestation.
- 26 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 196 (11) , 1-16
Determination of land surface temperatures for some oak stands with Landsat 8 OLI satellite images: a case study from Turkey
This study investigates the effect of forest cover, development stage and aspect factors on surface temperature (LST) in Demirköy and Düzce Forest Enterprises (FE) using Landsat 8 OLI satellite imagery from July 2021. In Demirköy FE, the highest LST value was recorded in the district center with 47.4 °C, in Düzce FE, the highest LST value was recorded in the provincial center with 44.6 °C, while the lowest value was 14.3 °C in Demirköy FE and 13.02 °C in Düzce FE in densely forested areas. When the stands were evaluated, it was found that pure juvenile oak stands had the highest average LST value with 30.48 °C in Demirköy FE and 23.96 °C in Düzce FE, whereas lower LST values were observed in old oak stands due to more dense cover. In terms of aspect, higher temperatures were recorded in the southern and western aspects in both study areas. In Düzce FE, high LST values were also observed in juvenile stands in the northern direction, indicating the influence of local factors such as topography and solar radiation angle. The highest LST values were observed in open forest areas; 6–9 °C higher temperatures were found in Demirköy and 1–5 °C higher in Düzce compared to vegetated areas. Significant correlations were found between LST and vegetation indices, and the highest correlation was found between LST and Normalized Difference Structuring Index (NDBI) (R2, 0.54 in Demirköy and R2, 0.50 in Düzce). NDVI showed a negative relationship with LST (R2, 0.47 in Demirköy, R2, 0.43 in Düzce). These findings reveal the critical role of forest density, tree species, and forest management practices in regulating surface temperatures, especially in the context of urbanization and deforestation.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in Contemporary Problems of Ecology
- Vol. 17 (5) , 743-760
Determining the Effect of Green Space Ratio and Urbanization on the Land Surface Temperature, a Case Study in the Istanbul Metropolitan
Studies have shown that the greenspace ratio has a cooling effect on the land surface temperature (LST) in different regions. Sample plots were obtained from 32 different regions in Istanbul. For 1985, 2000, 2013, and 2021, LSTs were determined using Landsat satellite images, and their relationships with GI, NDVI, and NDBI were examined. In the 1985–2021 period, the rate of greenspace in the sample plots decreased from 23 to 6.9%. The lowest LSTs were obtained in 1985, whereas the highest LSTs were found in 2013. Generally, low LSTs values were obtained in areas with a high greenspace ratio. The GI index decreased from 0.23 to 0.07 from 1985–2021. There was an increase of 10.07°C in average LST values in the 1985–2021 period. Negative correlations were found between NDVI and GI indices and LST, and positive correlations were found between NDBI and LST. In 1985, the lowest LST value was obtained in the 31st region with a greenspace ratio of 54%, while in other periods it was 27th region, some of which was covered with forests and the percentage of greenspace ratio decreased from 21 to 11%. The areas with the highest LST values were generally obtained in areas with dense population and urbanization and with a greenspace rate of 1% or less. The DUNCAN test was used to separate regions in terms of LST values.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in Contemporary Problems of Ecology
- Vol. 17 (5) , 743-760
Determining the Effect of Green Space Ratio and Urbanization on the Land Surface Temperature, a Case Study in the Istanbul Metropolitan
Studies have shown that the greenspace ratio has a cooling effect on the land surface temperature (LST) in different regions. Sample plots were obtained from 32 different regions in Istanbul. For 1985, 2000, 2013, and 2021, LSTs were determined using Landsat satellite images, and their relationships with GI, NDVI, and NDBI were examined. In the 1985–2021 period, the rate of greenspace in the sample plots decreased from 23 to 6.9%. The lowest LSTs were obtained in 1985, whereas the highest LSTs were found in 2013. Generally, low LSTs values were obtained in areas with a high greenspace ratio. The GI index decreased from 0.23 to 0.07 from 1985–2021. There was an increase of 10.07°C in average LST values in the 1985–2021 period. Negative correlations were found between NDVI and GI indices and LST, and positive correlations were found between NDBI and LST. In 1985, the lowest LST value was obtained in the 31st region with a greenspace ratio of 54%, while in other periods it was 27th region, some of which was covered with forests and the percentage of greenspace ratio decreased from 21 to 11%. The areas with the highest LST values were generally obtained in areas with dense population and urbanization and with a greenspace rate of 1% or less. The DUNCAN test was used to separate regions in terms of LST values.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Water SA
- Vol. 49 (3 July) , 220-229
Multiple linear regression models for the estimation of water flows for forest management and planning in Türkiye
While there are many factors, including climatology, geography, topography, vegetation and soil, that affect hydrologic processes, understanding the role of forests seems most essential, due to their manageable nature. In this study, a holistic approach was taken, and possible factors affecting streamflow, including tree, sapling, shrub, herb and soil strata, were measured for 29 small catchments/stream basins located in Turkey. Linear regression models were developed in order to estimate water flow (m³‧ha−1). Several models were suggested for use in practice. These models were based on the data on hand and displayed a sufficient level of explained variance in the dependent variable. Model 5, based on the variablesof catchment area (ha), drainage density, ratio of coniferous stand areas in the catchment (%), tree volume (m³‧ha−1), leaf area index, number of short saplings (number‧ha−1), and topsoil sand rate (%), was recommended for flow estimation, achieving a 0.73 adjR² value for test data. These variables can be obtained as part of a survey and water managers can use them to estimate water flow of the catchment. The generated models can be used in multiple-use planning of forests, e.g. in adjusting the volume of stands to get optimum benefit from wood and water production. One of the most interesting results and one that was opposite to that documented in the general literature, was the positive correlation between tree volume and flow per hectare, which suggests a strategy of growing older tree stands to enable greater water production.
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Water SA
- Vol. 49 (3 July) , 220-229
Open AccessMultiple linear regression models for the estimation of water flows for forest management and planning in Türkiye
While there are many factors, including climatology, geography, topography, vegetation and soil, that affect hydrologic processes, understanding the role of forests seems most essential, due to their manageable nature. In this study, a holistic approach was taken, and possible factors affecting streamflow, including tree, sapling, shrub, herb and soil strata, were measured for 29 small catchments/stream basins located in Turkey. Linear regression models were developed in order to estimate water flow (m³‧ha−1). Several models were suggested for use in practice. These models were based on the data on hand and displayed a sufficient level of explained variance in the dependent variable. Model 5, based on the variablesof catchment area (ha), drainage density, ratio of coniferous stand areas in the catchment (%), tree volume (m³‧ha−1), leaf area index, number of short saplings (number‧ha−1), and topsoil sand rate (%), was recommended for flow estimation, achieving a 0.73 adjR² value for test data. These variables can be obtained as part of a survey and water managers can use them to estimate water flow of the catchment. The generated models can be used in multiple-use planning of forests, e.g. in adjusting the volume of stands to get optimum benefit from wood and water production. One of the most interesting results and one that was opposite to that documented in the general literature, was the positive correlation between tree volume and flow per hectare, which suggests a strategy of growing older tree stands to enable greater water production.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Artvin Coruh Universitesi Orman Fakultesi Dergisi in Artvin Çoruh Üniversitesi Orman Fakültesi Dergisi
- Vol. 24 (1) , 64-74
Determination of carbon storage amounts in above-ground biomass using NDVI based on land use/land cover classes in Bolu
In this study, the land use/land cover (LULC) class of Bolu province in 1990, 2006, and 2018 and LULC class transitions between periods were examined. In addition, the amount of carbon storage in LULC classes of above-ground biomass (AGB) for the years 1990-2018 was determined through NDVI. CORINE land classification was used to determine the change of LULC classes. Landsat 5 TM and Landsat 8 OLI satellite images were used to determine the carbon storage amounts for the selected periods. There has been an increase of approximately 81.56% (4797.1 ha) in the LULC class of artificial surfaces in 28 years. A total increase of 2.87% (5539.8 ha) has been experienced in agricultural areas in the 28-year period. Forest and semi-natural areas decreased by 1.83% (11745.5 ha) and water bodies have increased approximately 3.4 times in 28 years. In terms of carbon amounts in AGB of the LULC classes, there has been approximately 59.5% carbon accumulation over 28 years. While a total of 1583467.3 tons of carbon was stored in 1990, this amount increased to 2664549.5 tons of carbon in 2018. Of the total carbon stored in 1990, 82.5% was stored in the forest and semi-natural areas, and 17% was stored in agricultural areas. While in 2018, 76.3% of the total carbon was stored in forest and semi-natural areas, and 23% in agricultural areas. In the 28-year period, a total of 1000151.7 tons of carbon has accumulated in the AGBs of the LULC classes that have not been converted to a different class. On the other hand, a total of 80930.6 tons of carbon was transferred from one class to another over the transformed lands. In total, 1081082.3 tons of carbon accumulation occurred between 1990 and 2018.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Artvin Coruh Universitesi Orman Fakultesi Dergisi in Artvin Çoruh Üniversitesi Orman Fakültesi Dergisi
- Vol. 24 (1) , 64-74
Open AccessDetermination of carbon storage amounts in above-ground biomass using NDVI based on land use/land cover classes in Bolu
In this study, the land use/land cover (LULC) class of Bolu province in 1990, 2006, and 2018 and LULC class transitions between periods were examined. In addition, the amount of carbon storage in LULC classes of above-ground biomass (AGB) for the years 1990-2018 was determined through NDVI. CORINE land classification was used to determine the change of LULC classes. Landsat 5 TM and Landsat 8 OLI satellite images were used to determine the carbon storage amounts for the selected periods. There has been an increase of approximately 81.56% (4797.1 ha) in the LULC class of artificial surfaces in 28 years. A total increase of 2.87% (5539.8 ha) has been experienced in agricultural areas in the 28-year period. Forest and semi-natural areas decreased by 1.83% (11745.5 ha) and water bodies have increased approximately 3.4 times in 28 years. In terms of carbon amounts in AGB of the LULC classes, there has been approximately 59.5% carbon accumulation over 28 years. While a total of 1583467.3 tons of carbon was stored in 1990, this amount increased to 2664549.5 tons of carbon in 2018. Of the total carbon stored in 1990, 82.5% was stored in the forest and semi-natural areas, and 17% was stored in agricultural areas. While in 2018, 76.3% of the total carbon was stored in forest and semi-natural areas, and 23% in agricultural areas. In the 28-year period, a total of 1000151.7 tons of carbon has accumulated in the AGBs of the LULC classes that have not been converted to a different class. On the other hand, a total of 80930.6 tons of carbon was transferred from one class to another over the transformed lands. In total, 1081082.3 tons of carbon accumulation occurred between 1990 and 2018.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2022
- Published by Hrvatsko Sumarsko Drustvo in Šumarski list
- Vol. 146 (9-10) , 415-426
Plant diversity indices for trojan fir stands in Aladağregion of Bolu
640 samples in quadrates of 0.5 x 0.5 m obtained by systematic sampling method were evaluated. Samplings were made in two repetitions in GA (old), GB (young), GC (medium-aged), and GD (irregular) stand types, on north and south aspects. Field studies were carried out in 4 different periods (June, July, August, September) within the vegetation period. 122 plant taxa were determined at the level of species and intraspecific taxa. While 48 of the 122 plant taxa in fir stands were seen only in one of the stands, 41 plant taxa were detected in all stands. 5 taxa were seen only in GA stands, 7 in GB, 15 in GC and 13 only in GD stands, while 8 taxa could not be identified due to the insufficient vegetative and generative organs of the collected samples. The richest stand type in terms of taxa number was determined as the GC stand type with 84 plant taxa, but more individuals per ha were counted in the GA and GD stand types.
- 29 October 2022
- Published by Hrvatsko Sumarsko Drustvo in Šumarski list
- Vol. 146 (9-10) , 415-426
Open AccessPlant diversity indices for trojan fir stands in Aladağregion of Bolu
640 samples in quadrates of 0.5 x 0.5 m obtained by systematic sampling method were evaluated. Samplings were made in two repetitions in GA (old), GB (young), GC (medium-aged), and GD (irregular) stand types, on north and south aspects. Field studies were carried out in 4 different periods (June, July, August, September) within the vegetation period. 122 plant taxa were determined at the level of species and intraspecific taxa. While 48 of the 122 plant taxa in fir stands were seen only in one of the stands, 41 plant taxa were detected in all stands. 5 taxa were seen only in GA stands, 7 in GB, 15 in GC and 13 only in GD stands, while 8 taxa could not be identified due to the insufficient vegetative and generative organs of the collected samples. The richest stand type in terms of taxa number was determined as the GC stand type with 84 plant taxa, but more individuals per ha were counted in the GA and GD stand types.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2021
- Published by University of Zagreb, Faculty of Forestry and Wood Technology in Croatian journal of forest engineering
- Vol. 43 (1) , 185-197
Evaluating the Accuracy of Remote Dendrometers in Tree Diameter Measurements at Breast Height
An accurate tree diameter (DBH) measurement is a significant component of forest inventory. This study assessed the reliability of remote dendrometers to measure tree DBH. We compared direct caliper measurements (reference measurements) to the remote measurements collected from a laser caliper and a smartphone at 0.5 m, 1 m, and 1.5 m distances from each tree within three forest types (pine, oak, and poplar forests). In general, all remote dendrometers underestimated the mean diameter compared to direct caliper measurements, regardless of forest types and distances. We observed that the mean deviation of direct caliper measurement and smartphone measurement at 1.5 m within a pine forest and oak forest were the lowest (0.3 cm and 0.36 cm, respectively). The deviations between direct caliper measurements and smartphone measurements at a 0.5 m distance, across forest types, were noticeably larger compared to others. An ANOVA test was used to determine whether significant deviations existed between caliper measurements and remote measurements at a specific distance, and among three different forest types. We rejected the null hypothesis, which suggested that there were no statistically significant differences (p<0.05) between tree DBH measurements obtained from the direct caliper measurements and indirect measurements (smartphone and laser caliper) captured at a distance. Then, a post-hoc test was performed to examine which set of estimated deviations was different from the reference data. The results suggested that indirect tree DBH measurements using the smartphone app at 1 m and 1.5 m in certain forest types (pine and oak) were not significantly different from direct tree DBH measurements. Also, our test results mostly indicated no significant difference within each forest, except for measurements using the smartphone app at 0.5 m across all forest types when the smartphone measurements were compared to laser caliper measurements. Although forest characteristics and measurement distance may play an important role in remote tree DBH measurement accuracy, the smartphone app may be used as a practical alternative to direct measurement in measuring the DBH of a tree, which may be a positive development for forestry due to the increased use of smartphones and the availability of a free measure app.
- 10 November 2021
- Published by University of Zagreb, Faculty of Forestry and Wood Technology in Croatian journal of forest engineering
- Vol. 43 (1) , 185-197
Open AccessEvaluating the Accuracy of Remote Dendrometers in Tree Diameter Measurements at Breast Height
An accurate tree diameter (DBH) measurement is a significant component of forest inventory. This study assessed the reliability of remote dendrometers to measure tree DBH. We compared direct caliper measurements (reference measurements) to the remote measurements collected from a laser caliper and a smartphone at 0.5 m, 1 m, and 1.5 m distances from each tree within three forest types (pine, oak, and poplar forests). In general, all remote dendrometers underestimated the mean diameter compared to direct caliper measurements, regardless of forest types and distances. We observed that the mean deviation of direct caliper measurement and smartphone measurement at 1.5 m within a pine forest and oak forest were the lowest (0.3 cm and 0.36 cm, respectively). The deviations between direct caliper measurements and smartphone measurements at a 0.5 m distance, across forest types, were noticeably larger compared to others. An ANOVA test was used to determine whether significant deviations existed between caliper measurements and remote measurements at a specific distance, and among three different forest types. We rejected the null hypothesis, which suggested that there were no statistically significant differences (p<0.05) between tree DBH measurements obtained from the direct caliper measurements and indirect measurements (smartphone and laser caliper) captured at a distance. Then, a post-hoc test was performed to examine which set of estimated deviations was different from the reference data. The results suggested that indirect tree DBH measurements using the smartphone app at 1 m and 1.5 m in certain forest types (pine and oak) were not significantly different from direct tree DBH measurements. Also, our test results mostly indicated no significant difference within each forest, except for measurements using the smartphone app at 0.5 m across all forest types when the smartphone measurements were compared to laser caliper measurements. Although forest characteristics and measurement distance may play an important role in remote tree DBH measurement accuracy, the smartphone app may be used as a practical alternative to direct measurement in measuring the DBH of a tree, which may be a positive development for forestry due to the increased use of smartphones and the availability of a free measure app.
- Open Access
A Comparative Analysis of Five Forest Certification Programs
International expansion of forest certification programs has occurred over the last three decades. Both public and private organizations have shown increased interest in becoming certified by one or more forest certification bodies, to assure the public that forest resources are managed adequately in sustaining forest health and socio-economic viability. The Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) program is globally used as a benchmark to implement forest certification at the national and regional levels. The Sustainable Forest Initiative (SFI) and the American Tree Farm System (ATFS) are also used throughout the United States. In Europe, individual countries such as Bulgaria and Turkey have also developed national forest certification programs. The SFI, ATFS and Bulgarian programs are further endorsed by the Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC). The results of a qualitative analysis comparing the FSC forest certification program with the SFI, the ATFS, and the two European national programs (Bulgarian and Turkish) suggest that differences in these programs are not necessarily related to their language, but to the level of detail and prescriptiveness of each program. We find that the FSC is much more detailed and prescriptive in nearly all aspects considered for forest certification. In particular, we find that most of the elements considered in the FSC Principle 6 (Environmental Impact) are either only superficial, or not addressed at all, in the other four programs. Furthermore, the other programs appear to be less comprehensive and detailed in the substance of the FSC monitoring and assessment principles. In a few areas, the Turkish program requires more quantitative indicators for assessing forest management than the other programs. Though a comparison of the legal framework related to forest management in each of the studied countries was briefly introduced, our study focuses on the certification schemes themselves; it may contribute to policy discussions in the future development and implementation of other certification programs.
Open AccessA Comparative Analysis of Five Forest Certification Programs
International expansion of forest certification programs has occurred over the last three decades. Both public and private organizations have shown increased interest in becoming certified by one or more forest certification bodies, to assure the public that forest resources are managed adequately in sustaining forest health and socio-economic viability. The Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) program is globally used as a benchmark to implement forest certification at the national and regional levels. The Sustainable Forest Initiative (SFI) and the American Tree Farm System (ATFS) are also used throughout the United States. In Europe, individual countries such as Bulgaria and Turkey have also developed national forest certification programs. The SFI, ATFS and Bulgarian programs are further endorsed by the Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC). The results of a qualitative analysis comparing the FSC forest certification program with the SFI, the ATFS, and the two European national programs (Bulgarian and Turkish) suggest that differences in these programs are not necessarily related to their language, but to the level of detail and prescriptiveness of each program. We find that the FSC is much more detailed and prescriptive in nearly all aspects considered for forest certification. In particular, we find that most of the elements considered in the FSC Principle 6 (Environmental Impact) are either only superficial, or not addressed at all, in the other four programs. Furthermore, the other programs appear to be less comprehensive and detailed in the substance of the FSC monitoring and assessment principles. In a few areas, the Turkish program requires more quantitative indicators for assessing forest management than the other programs. Though a comparison of the legal framework related to forest management in each of the studied countries was briefly introduced, our study focuses on the certification schemes themselves; it may contribute to policy discussions in the future development and implementation of other certification programs.