TGTania Gergel

Tania Gergel

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Tania Gergel has a total of 90 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    A tool to evaluate the impact of lived experience involvement in research: the Brain and Genomics Hub Impact Log protocol.

    by Tania Gergel, Talen Wright, Lavenda Geshica, Emily Vicary, Jaycee Kennett, Oli Delgaram-Nejad, Carina Edwards, Hashwin V.S. Ganesh, Thomas Kabir, Chloe L. Harrison, et al.

    Background Despite widespread recognition of the value of lived experience involvement (LEI) in healthcare research and increased LE involvement activity, we lack established implementation methods and instruments for reporting and evaluating impact. We present a protocol for an innovative LE-led Impact Log tool and LEI framework, which may help to address some fundamental barriers to LEI. The Impact Log will be implemented within a five-year multidisciplinary transdiagnostic research project on severe mental illness and is also designed for wider adaptation and use. We include a short literature review on LEI impact, to provide in-depth background. Methods The Impact Log framework is designed to integrate inclusive impactful LEI throughout all research stages, and to use a short accessible form to record and evaluate impact across three domains: design and delivery; interpersonal and environmental aspects; systems and processes. Impact Log tool and LEI design and implementation is led by LE study leads and specialist LE advisory panel, with combined research experience and LE, fully integrated within the wider research team. All Hub research participants will be offered accessible opportunities for remunerated lived experience input, and there will be outreach to ensure diverse representation, aided by the Hub’s charity partners. Data collection and analysis will be LE led and will include iterative analysis to inform continuing development. Diverse formal and informal dissemination throughout the project will maximise wider stakeholder engagement. Conclusion The potential value of this research is to implement a novel tool and framework for facilitating, recording and evaluating LEI in complex mental health research, which can be adapted for wider use. Strengths in design are LE leadership and cross-cutting LE research integration, incorporation of multiple domains, and a focus on facilitating diversity and inclusion within LEI. Potential limitations for this project and wider adaptation may include limited resources, risk of bias and health challenges.

  • Open Access

    A tool to evaluate the impact of lived experience involvement in research: the Brain and Genomics Hub Impact Log protocol.

    by Tania Gergel, Talen Wright, Lavenda Geshica, Emily Vicary, Jaycee Kennett, Oli Delgaram-Nejad, Carina Edwards, Hashwin V.S. Ganesh, Thomas Kabir, Chloe L. Harrison, et al.

    Background Despite widespread recognition of the value of lived experience involvement (LEI) in healthcare research and increased LE involvement activity, we lack established implementation methods and instruments for reporting and evaluating impact. We present a protocol for an innovative LE-led Impact Log tool and LEI framework, which may help to address some fundamental barriers to LEI. The Impact Log will be implemented within a five-year multidisciplinary transdiagnostic research project on severe mental illness and is also designed for wider adaptation and use. We include a short literature review on LEI impact, to provide in-depth background. Methods The Impact Log framework is designed to integrate inclusive impactful LEI throughout all research stages, and to use a short accessible form to record and evaluate impact across three domains: design and delivery; interpersonal and environmental aspects; systems and processes. Impact Log design and implementation is led by LE study leads and specialist LE advisory panel, with combined research experience and LE, fully integrated within the wider research team. All Hub research participants will be offered accessible opportunities for remunerated lived experience input, and there will be outreach to ensure diverse representation, aided by the Hub’s charity partners. Data collection and analysis will be LE led and will include iterative analysis to inform continuing development. Diverse formal and informal dissemination throughout the project will maximise wider stakeholder engagement. Conclusion The potential value of this research is to implement a novel tool and framework for facilitating, recording and evaluating LEI in complex mental health research, which can be adapted for wider use. Strengths in design are LE leadership and cross-cutting LE research integration, incorporation of multiple domains, and a focus on facilitating diversity and inclusion within LEI. Potential limitations for this project and wider adaptation may include limited resources, risk of bias and health challenges.

  • Open Access

    A tool to evaluate the impact of lived experience involvement in research: the Brain and Genomics Hub Impact Log literature review and protocol

    by T. Gergel, T. Wright, L. Geshica, E. Vicary, J. Kennett, O. Delgaram-Nejad, C. Edwards, H.V.S. Ganesh, T. Kabir, C.L. Harrison, et al.

    Background: Despite widespread recognition of the value of lived experience (LE) involvement in healthcare research and increased LE involvement activity, we lack established implementation methods and instruments for reporting and evaluating impact. We present a protocol for an innovative LE-led Impact Log tool and co-production framework, which may help to address some fundamental barriers to co-production. The Impact Log will be implemented within a five-year multidisciplinary transdiagnostic research project on severe mental illness, the Brain and Genomics Hub of the UKRI Mental Health Platform, and is also designed for wider adaptation and use. Part I presents a short narrative review of literature pertaining to defining, evaluating, and enhancing the impact of co-production, to provide in-depth background and aid future development. Part II presents the Impact Log protocol. Methods: The Impact Log framework is designed to integrate inclusive and impactful co-production throughout all research stages, and to record and evaluate its impact across three domains using an accessible short form. The three research domains are: design and delivery; interpersonal and environmental aspects; systems and processes. Impact Log design and implementation is led by LE study leads and a specialist advisory panel, who are integrated fully within the wider research team, and all have combined research experience and LE of bipolar or psychotic disorders. All Hub research participants will be offered accessible opportunities for remunerated lived experience input, and there will be outreach to ensure diverse representation, aided by the Hub’s charity partners. Data collection and analysis will be LE led and will include iterative analysis to inform continuing development. Diverse formal and informal dissemination throughout the project will maximise wider stakeholder engagement. Discussion: The potential value of this research is to implement a novel tool and framework for facilitating, recording and evaluating co-production in complex mental health research, which can be adapted for wider use. Strengths in design are LE leadership and cross-cutting LE research integration, incorporation of multiple domains, and a focus on facilitating diversity and inclusion within co-production. Potential limitations for this project and wider adaptation may include limited resources, risk of bias and health challenges. Lay Summary: We have provided a brief lay summary to help people without a research background understand our project . This article explains our plan to develop and test a new way of understanding how research changes when people with personal experience of a mental health condition are part of the research team. We are a team of mental health researchers and many of us have direct experience of bipolar and psychosis. We work alongside other researchers, including people who might also have worked in mental health services or in charities that provide support. Our research project aims to better understand what is happening in the brain, body, lives and experiences of people who have bipolar and psychosis. Many people believe that research is better when it includes the views of people who have direct experience of the health condition being studied. This is called “lived experience”. We have developed a structured approach to make sure that people with lived experience are meaningfully involved in our research team. We have also created a simple tool, called the Impact Log , to record when lived experience members contribute and to help us understand how their involvement influences the research. Finally, we wanted to better understand what other researchers have said about lived experience involvement. We reviewed many published academic studies and reports and brought their findings together in what is called a “narrative review”. This review summarises what is already known about the difference lived experience involvement can make in research.


  • Open Access

    The complexity of delayed diagnosis in bipolar disorder. a systematic review of associated precursors, outcomes, and suggested avenues for improvement

    by Gergel Tania, Al-Janabi Mariam, Talwar Shivangi, Ahmed Haleemah, Wright Talen

    Summary: There are widespread stakeholder concerns about adverse consequences of persistent long delays in diagnosing and treating bipolar disorder. Average five-to-ten-year delays are substantiated by previous evidence synthesis, which has focused primarily on quantifying scale. Nevertheless, we lack a complex and broad understanding of diagnostic delay. This review incorporates a complex intervention framework, using co-produced narrative synthesis of quantitative and qualitative studies to identify associated precursors, outcomes, and suggested avenues for improvement. We searched four databases and included 49 generally high-quality studies from high or middle-income countries. This review reinforces some findings from previous reviews regarding scale of delayed diagnosis and key associated precursors, including: history of depression, suicide attempts, earlier onset, female sex, BD-II presentation. However, we also identify a wider range of associated factors and proposed strategies for improvement, which lead us to conclude that future research and interventions should examine delayed diagnosis in terms of its breadth and complex interrelationships with other aspects of bipolar disorder which remain insufficiently understood. These include: mixed, hypomanic, ‘atypical’, and rapid cycling presentations; suicidality in bipolar and its interrelationship with diagnosis, acknowledging the persistence of suicide risk following diagnosis; interrelationship with diverse mental and physical health conditions; attitudes and management of bipolar; the diagnostic process in lower-and-middle income countries; clinical pathways associated with diagnosis and the complex interplay of socio-economic, cultural, and demographic factors and diagnosis. Our review also highlights the need for deeper insight into stakeholder experiences and attitudes toward bipolar management and diagnosis, particularly through qualitative, mixed-methods, and co-produced research.


  • Open Access

    Reducing the Delay in the Diagnosis of Bipolar Disorder: A Qualitative Study

    by S Watson, N Ahuja, L Azim, A Cipriani, E Clark, J Evans, T Gergel, J Gibson, J Hall, T Kabir, et al.

    Introduction: Patients living with bipolar disorder in the UK face, on average, a delay of 9.5 years from initial presentation of symptoms to confirmation of diagnosis. The aim of this qualitative study was to understand the challenges and facilitators involved in diagnosing individuals with BD from the perspectives of GPs and psychiatrists and how the delay in diagnosis of BD from the first presentation might be reduced. Methods: Semi‐structured interviews with clinicians (GPs and psychiatrists) were used to explore attitudes and perspectives towards diagnosing, managing, and accessing or delivering specialist opinion for BD within the current NHS systems and pathways. Thematic analysis was conducted. Results: GPs report a lack of confidence in identifying BD due to limited understanding of the condition, resources, and lack of continuity of care. Both primary and secondary care clinicians expressed frustrations with the referral pathway in relation to high thresholds for secondary care acceptance and long waiting times for assessments. Clinicians suggest that further education and training in primary care supported by psychometric tools and mood diaries to improve identification of BD. Clinicians also advocated for enhanced communication and collaboration between primary and secondary care to streamline and reduce delays in the diagnostic process. Conclusion: We suggest a number of strategies which could reduce the harmful delay in diagnosis of bipolar. Patient or Public Contribution: A Lived Experience Advisory Panel (LEAP) was convened with the support of the McPin Foundation. LEAP members have contributed towards the development of public‐facing documents, including the topic guides, qualitative data analysis and dissemination of findings.


  • Suicide and bipolar disorder: opportunities to change the agenda

    by Tania Gergel, Frances Adiukwu, Melvin McInnis


  • Should people with mental illness be able to commit themselves to future involuntary treatment?

    by Tania Gergel, Allen Frances, Arun Chopra, Theo Van Willigenburg

    Many people with severe episodic mental illness, such as bipolar disorder, know from past experience that their illness may well expose them to risk during future severe episodes in a way that they won’t be able to control at that point. They may also recognise the likelihood that they’ll resist treatment during such episodes—even though this is when treatment is most desperately needed.

  • Open Access

    Opportunities and challenges of self-binding directives: A comparison of empirical research with stakeholders in three European countries

    by Matthé Scholten, Simone Agnes Efkemann, Mirjam Faissner, Marleen Finke, Jakov Gather, Tania Gergel, Astrid Gieselmann, Lia van der Ham, Georg Juckel, Laura van Melle, et al.

    Background: Self-binding directives (SBDs) are psychiatric advance directives that include a clause in which mental health service users consent in advance to involuntary hospital admission and treatment under specified conditions. Medical ethicists and legal scholars identified various potential benefits of SBDs but have also raised ethical concerns. Until recently, little was known about the views of stakeholders on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs.Aims: This article aims to foster an international exchange on SBDs by comparing recent empirical findings on stakeholders’ views on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs from Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom.Method: Comparisons between the empirical findings were drawn using a structured expert consensus process.Results: Findings converged on many points. Perceived opportunities of SBDs include promotion of autonomy, avoidance of personally defined harms, early intervention, reduction of admission duration, improvement of the therapeutic relationship, involvement of persons of trust, avoidance of involuntary hospital admission, addressing trauma, destigmatization of involuntary treatment, increase of professionals’ confidence, and relief for proxy decision-makers. Perceived challenges include lack of awareness and knowledge, lack of support, undue influence, inaccessibility during crisis, lack of cross-agency coordination, problems of interpretation, difficulties in capacity assessment, restricted therapeutic flexibility, scarce resources, disappointment due to noncompliance, and outdated content. Stakeholders tended to focus on practical challenges and did not often raise fundamental ethical concerns.Conclusions: Stakeholders tend to see the implementation of SBDs as ethically desirable, provided that the associated challenges are addressed.