Ludovico Terzi
Ludovico Terzi has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Davide Astolfi
University of Brescia - Department
7 shared publications - Francesco Castellani
University of Perugia
7 shared publications - Andrea Lombardi
Renvico srl, Via San Gregorio 34, 20124 Milano, Italy
3 shared publications Andrea Lombardi
Renvico s.r.l., Via San Gregorio 34, 20124 Milano, Italy. www.renvicoenergy.com
1 shared publicationDavide Astolfi
University of Perugia - Department of Engineering, Via G. Duranti 93 - 06125 Perugia, Italy
1 shared publication- Francesco Berno
Department of Engineering, University of Perugia, Via G. Duranti 93, 06125 Perugia, Italy
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Wind Turbine Systematic Yaw Error: Operation Data Analysis Techniques for Detecting It and Assessing Its Performance Impact
The widespread availability of wind turbine operation data has considerably boosted the research and the applications for wind turbine monitoring. It is well established that a systematic misalignment of the wind turbine nacelle with respect to the wind direction has a remarkable impact in terms of down-performance, because the extracted power is in first approximation proportional to the cosine cube of the yaw angle. Nevertheless, due to the fact that in the wind farm practice the wind field facing the rotor is estimated through anemometers placed behind the rotor, it is challenging to robustly detect systematic yaw errors without the use of additional upwind sensory systems. Nevertheless, this objective is valuable because it involves the use of data that are available to wind farm practitioners at zero cost. On these grounds, the present work is a two-steps test case discussion. At first, a new method for systematic yaw error detection through operation data analysis is presented and is applied for individuating a misaligned multi-MW wind turbine. After the yaw error correction on the test case wind turbine, operation data of the whole wind farm are employed for an innovative assessment method of the performance improvement at the target wind turbine. The other wind turbines in the farm are employed as references and their operation data are used as input for a multivariate Kernel regression whose target is the power of the wind turbine of interest. Training the model with pre-correction data and validating on post-correction data, it is estimated that a systematic yaw error of affects the performance up to the order of the 1.5% of the Annual Energy Production.Open AccessWind Turbine Systematic Yaw Error: Operation Data Analysis Techniques for Detecting It and Assessing Its Performance Impact
The widespread availability of wind turbine operation data has considerably boosted the research and the applications for wind turbine monitoring. It is well established that a systematic misalignment of the wind turbine nacelle with respect to the wind direction has a remarkable impact in terms of down-performance, because the extracted power is in first approximation proportional to the cosine cube of the yaw angle. Nevertheless, due to the fact that in the wind farm practice the wind field facing the rotor is estimated through anemometers placed behind the rotor, it is challenging to robustly detect systematic yaw errors without the use of additional upwind sensory systems. Nevertheless, this objective is valuable because it involves the use of data that are available to wind farm practitioners at zero cost. On these grounds, the present work is a two-steps test case discussion. At first, a new method for systematic yaw error detection through operation data analysis is presented and is applied for individuating a misaligned multi-MW wind turbine. After the yaw error correction on the test case wind turbine, operation data of the whole wind farm are employed for an innovative assessment method of the performance improvement at the target wind turbine. The other wind turbines in the farm are employed as references and their operation data are used as input for a multivariate Kernel regression whose target is the power of the wind turbine of interest. Training the model with pre-correction data and validating on post-correction data, it is estimated that a systematic yaw error of affects the performance up to the order of the 1.5% of the Annual Energy Production. - 22 October 2019
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 142 (2) , 1-11
An Operation Data-Based Method for the Diagnosis of Zero-Point Shift of Wind Turbines Yaw Angle
The alignment of the wind turbine yaw to the wind direction is an important topic for wind turbine technology by several points of view. For example, the negative impact on power production of an undesired non-optimal yaw alignment can be impressive. The diagnosis of zero-point shifting of the yaw angle is commonly performed by adopting supplementary measurement sources, as for example LIDAR anemometers. The drawback is that these measurement campaigns have a certain cost against an uncertain diagnosis outcome. There is therefore an increasing interest from wind turbine practitioners in the formulation of zero-point yaw angle shift diagnosis techniques through the use of nacelle anemometer data. This work is devoted to this task and is organized as a test case discussion: a wind farm featuring six multi-megawatt wind turbines is considered. The study of the power factor Cp as function of the yaw error (estimated through nacelle anemometer data) is addressed. The proposed method has been validated through the detection of a 8° zero-point shift of the yaw angle of one wind turbine in the test case wind farm. After the correction of this offset, the performance of the wind turbine of interest is shown to be comparable to the nominal. The results of this work therefore support that an appropriate analysis of nacelle anemometer and operation data can be effective for the diagnosis of zero-point shift of the yaw angle of wind turbines.
- 22 October 2019
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 142 (2) , 1-11
An Operation Data-Based Method for the Diagnosis of Zero-Point Shift of Wind Turbines Yaw Angle
The alignment of the wind turbine yaw to the wind direction is an important topic for wind turbine technology by several points of view. For example, the negative impact on power production of an undesired non-optimal yaw alignment can be impressive. The diagnosis of zero-point shifting of the yaw angle is commonly performed by adopting supplementary measurement sources, as for example LIDAR anemometers. The drawback is that these measurement campaigns have a certain cost against an uncertain diagnosis outcome. There is therefore an increasing interest from wind turbine practitioners in the formulation of zero-point yaw angle shift diagnosis techniques through the use of nacelle anemometer data. This work is devoted to this task and is organized as a test case discussion: a wind farm featuring six multi-megawatt wind turbines is considered. The study of the power factor Cp as function of the yaw error (estimated through nacelle anemometer data) is addressed. The proposed method has been validated through the detection of a 8° zero-point shift of the yaw angle of one wind turbine in the test case wind farm. After the correction of this offset, the performance of the wind turbine of interest is shown to be comparable to the nominal. The results of this work therefore support that an appropriate analysis of nacelle anemometer and operation data can be effective for the diagnosis of zero-point shift of the yaw angle of wind turbines.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2018
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 8 (12) , 2639
Numerical and Experimental Methods for the Assessment of Wind Turbine Control Upgrades
Megawatt-scale wind turbine technology is nowadays mature and, therefore, several technical improvements in order to optimize the efficiency of wind power conversion have been recently spreading in the industry. Due to the nonstationary conditions to which wind turbines are subjected because of the stochastic nature of the source, the quantification of the impact of wind turbine power curve upgrades is a complex task and in general, it has been observed that the efficiency of the upgrades can vary considerably depending on the wind flow conditions at the microscale level. In this work, a test case of wind turbine control system improvement was studied numerically and through operational data. The wind turbine is multi-megawatt; it is part of a wind farm sited in a complex terrain in Italy, featuring 17 wind turbines. The analyzed control upgrade is an optimization of the revolutions per minute (rpm) management. The impact of this upgrade was quantified through a method based on operational data: It consists of the study, before and after the upgrade, of the residuals between the measured power output of the wind turbine of interest and an appropriate model of the power output itself. The input variables for the model were selected to be some operational parameters of the nearby wind turbines: They were selected from the data set at disposal with a stepwise regression algorithm. This work also includes a numerical characterization of the problem, by means of aeroelastic simulations performed with the FAST software: By mimicking the pre- and post-upgrade generator rpm–generator torque curve, it is subsequently possible to estimate how the wind turbine power curve changes. The main result of this work is that the two estimates of production improvement have the same order of magnitude (1.0% of the production below rated power). In general, this study sheds light on the perspective of employing not only operational data, but also a sort of digital replica of the wind turbine of interest, in order to reliably quantify the impact of control system upgrades.
- 16 December 2018
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 8 (12) , 2639
Open AccessNumerical and Experimental Methods for the Assessment of Wind Turbine Control Upgrades
Megawatt-scale wind turbine technology is nowadays mature and, therefore, several technical improvements in order to optimize the efficiency of wind power conversion have been recently spreading in the industry. Due to the nonstationary conditions to which wind turbines are subjected because of the stochastic nature of the source, the quantification of the impact of wind turbine power curve upgrades is a complex task and in general, it has been observed that the efficiency of the upgrades can vary considerably depending on the wind flow conditions at the microscale level. In this work, a test case of wind turbine control system improvement was studied numerically and through operational data. The wind turbine is multi-megawatt; it is part of a wind farm sited in a complex terrain in Italy, featuring 17 wind turbines. The analyzed control upgrade is an optimization of the revolutions per minute (rpm) management. The impact of this upgrade was quantified through a method based on operational data: It consists of the study, before and after the upgrade, of the residuals between the measured power output of the wind turbine of interest and an appropriate model of the power output itself. The input variables for the model were selected to be some operational parameters of the nearby wind turbines: They were selected from the data set at disposal with a stepwise regression algorithm. This work also includes a numerical characterization of the problem, by means of aeroelastic simulations performed with the FAST software: By mimicking the pre- and post-upgrade generator rpm–generator torque curve, it is subsequently possible to estimate how the wind turbine power curve changes. The main result of this work is that the two estimates of production improvement have the same order of magnitude (1.0% of the production below rated power). In general, this study sheds light on the perspective of employing not only operational data, but also a sort of digital replica of the wind turbine of interest, in order to reliably quantify the impact of control system upgrades.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 1102 (1) , 012036
Innovative methods for wind turbine power curve upgrade assessment
Wind turbine power curve upgrades have recently been attracting considerable investment in the operation of wind farms and noticeable attention in the wind energy literature. Due to the non-stationary conditions to which wind turbines are subjected, the most consistent strategy for quantifying the production improvement from the installation of an upgrade is comparing, after at least some months of operation, the post-upgrade production against a model of the pre-upgrade production under the same conditions. Formulating adequate models for the power of the upgraded wind turbines is in general non-trivial and it can be difficult to achieve the precision that wind turbine practitioners typically require for the production assessment. In the present work, a multivariate linear method for selecting the most appropriate input for modeling a given output is presented and applied to a test case. The test case is a multi-megawatt wind turbine owned by Renvico, on whose blades vortex generators and passive flow control devices have been installed. Applying the proposed method, it is possible to compute with precision the production improvement in the first five months of post-upgrade operation (purely aerodynamic upgrade) and in the subsequent three months (aerodynamic and control upgrade). It is therefore possible to appreciate the different contributions to the production enhancement from the aerodynamic and control improvement. A non-upgraded wind turbine from the same wind farm is also studied and the precision of the results inspires the use of the proposed method for performance control and monitoring in general.
- 11 October 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 1102 (1) , 012036
Open AccessInnovative methods for wind turbine power curve upgrade assessment
Wind turbine power curve upgrades have recently been attracting considerable investment in the operation of wind farms and noticeable attention in the wind energy literature. Due to the non-stationary conditions to which wind turbines are subjected, the most consistent strategy for quantifying the production improvement from the installation of an upgrade is comparing, after at least some months of operation, the post-upgrade production against a model of the pre-upgrade production under the same conditions. Formulating adequate models for the power of the upgraded wind turbines is in general non-trivial and it can be difficult to achieve the precision that wind turbine practitioners typically require for the production assessment. In the present work, a multivariate linear method for selecting the most appropriate input for modeling a given output is presented and applied to a test case. The test case is a multi-megawatt wind turbine owned by Renvico, on whose blades vortex generators and passive flow control devices have been installed. Applying the proposed method, it is possible to compute with precision the production improvement in the first five months of post-upgrade operation (purely aerodynamic upgrade) and in the subsequent three months (aerodynamic and control upgrade). It is therefore possible to appreciate the different contributions to the production enhancement from the aerodynamic and control improvement. A non-upgraded wind turbine from the same wind farm is also studied and the precision of the results inspires the use of the proposed method for performance control and monitoring in general.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 1102 (1) , 012007
Accuracy quantification of a CFD model in complex site by cross-checking wind measurements
In the present study it is discussed a sensitivity analysis on input parameters of a CFD resource assessment methodology built on top of OpenFOAM 4.1, a well-known open source library for numerical fluid dynamics. RANS are solved for dry uncompressible air, the Atmospheric Boundary Layer is calculated without thermal effects (neutral conditions). It is highlighted how the control of a metric based upon a weighted root mean square error (wRMSE) of the local accelerations (speed ups) can guide the wind analyst in the design of the computational mesh and further numerical settings. Moreover, it will be quantified the wRMSE as a function of the distance to the measurement points. The parameters analysed are the horizontal extension of the model, the horizontal resolution within the refined area, which is covering the layout of the wind farm, three different versions of k-ε turbulence closure and the number of directional sectors considered.
- 10 October 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 1102 (1) , 012007
Open AccessAccuracy quantification of a CFD model in complex site by cross-checking wind measurements
In the present study it is discussed a sensitivity analysis on input parameters of a CFD resource assessment methodology built on top of OpenFOAM 4.1, a well-known open source library for numerical fluid dynamics. RANS are solved for dry uncompressible air, the Atmospheric Boundary Layer is calculated without thermal effects (neutral conditions). It is highlighted how the control of a metric based upon a weighted root mean square error (wRMSE) of the local accelerations (speed ups) can guide the wind analyst in the design of the computational mesh and further numerical settings. Moreover, it will be quantified the wRMSE as a function of the distance to the measurement points. The parameters analysed are the horizontal extension of the model, the horizontal resolution within the refined area, which is covering the layout of the wind farm, three different versions of k-ε turbulence closure and the number of directional sectors considered.
- 14 September 2018
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 141 (1)
About the Extension of Wind Turbine Power Curve in the High Wind Region
The financial sustainability and the profitability of wind farms strongly depend on the efficiency of the conversion of wind kinetic energy. This motivates further research about the improvement of wind turbine power curve. If the site is characterized by a considerable occurrence of very high wind speeds, it can become particularly profitable to update the power curve management. This is commonly done by raising the cut-out velocity and the high wind speed cut-in regulating the hysteresis logic. Doing this, on one side, the wind turbine possibly undergoes strong vibration and loads. On the other side, the energy improvement is almost certain and the point is quantifying precisely its magnitude. In this work, the test case of an onshore wind farm in Italy is studied, featuring 17 2.3 MW wind turbines. Through the analysis of supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) data, the energy improvement from the extension of the power curve in the high wind speed region is simulated and measured. This could be useful for wind farm owners evaluating the realistic profitability of the installation of the power curve upgrade on their wind turbines. Furthermore, the present work is useful for the analysis of wind turbine behavior under extremely stressing load conditions.
- 14 September 2018
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 141 (1)
About the Extension of Wind Turbine Power Curve in the High Wind Region
The financial sustainability and the profitability of wind farms strongly depend on the efficiency of the conversion of wind kinetic energy. This motivates further research about the improvement of wind turbine power curve. If the site is characterized by a considerable occurrence of very high wind speeds, it can become particularly profitable to update the power curve management. This is commonly done by raising the cut-out velocity and the high wind speed cut-in regulating the hysteresis logic. Doing this, on one side, the wind turbine possibly undergoes strong vibration and loads. On the other side, the energy improvement is almost certain and the point is quantifying precisely its magnitude. In this work, the test case of an onshore wind farm in Italy is studied, featuring 17 2.3 MW wind turbines. Through the analysis of supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) data, the energy improvement from the extension of the power curve in the high wind speed region is simulated and measured. This could be useful for wind farm owners evaluating the realistic profitability of the installation of the power curve upgrade on their wind turbines. Furthermore, the present work is useful for the analysis of wind turbine behavior under extremely stressing load conditions.
- Open Access
Wind Turbine Power Curve Upgrades
Full-scale wind turbine is a mature technology and therefore several retrofitting techniques have recently been spreading in the industry to further improve the efficiency of wind kinetic energy conversion. This kind of interventions is costly and, furthermore, the energy improvement is commonly estimated under the hypothesis of ideal wind conditions, but real ones can be very different because of wake interactions and/or wind shear induced by the terrain. A precise quantification of the energy gained in real environment is therefore precious. Wind turbines are subjected to non-stationary conditions and therefore it makes little sense to compare energy production before and after an upgrade: the post-upgrade production should rather be compared to a model of the pre-upgrade production under the same conditions. Since the energy improvement is typically of the order of few percents, a very precise model of wind turbine power output is needed and therefore it should be data-driven. Furthermore, the formulation of the model is heavily affected by the features of the available data set and by the nature of the problem. The objective of this work is the discussion of some wind turbine power curve upgrades on the grounds of operational data analysis. The selected test cases are: improved start-up through pitch angle adjustment near the cut-in, aerodynamic blade retrofitting by means of vortex generators and passive flow control devices, and extension of the power curve through a soft cut-out strategy for very high wind speed. The criticality of each test case is discussed and appropriate data-driven models are formulated. These are employed to estimate the energy improvement from each of the upgrades under investigation. The general outcome of this work is a catalog of generalizable methods for studying wind turbine power curve upgrades. In particular, from the study of the selected test cases, it arises that complex wind conditions might affect wind turbine operation such that the production improvement is non-negligibly different from what can be estimated under the hypothesis of ideal wind conditions. A complex wind flow might actually impact on the efficiency of vortex generators and the soft cut-out strategies at high wind speeds. The general lesson is therefore that it is very important to estimate wind turbine upgrades on real environments through operational data.
Open AccessWind Turbine Power Curve Upgrades
Full-scale wind turbine is a mature technology and therefore several retrofitting techniques have recently been spreading in the industry to further improve the efficiency of wind kinetic energy conversion. This kind of interventions is costly and, furthermore, the energy improvement is commonly estimated under the hypothesis of ideal wind conditions, but real ones can be very different because of wake interactions and/or wind shear induced by the terrain. A precise quantification of the energy gained in real environment is therefore precious. Wind turbines are subjected to non-stationary conditions and therefore it makes little sense to compare energy production before and after an upgrade: the post-upgrade production should rather be compared to a model of the pre-upgrade production under the same conditions. Since the energy improvement is typically of the order of few percents, a very precise model of wind turbine power output is needed and therefore it should be data-driven. Furthermore, the formulation of the model is heavily affected by the features of the available data set and by the nature of the problem. The objective of this work is the discussion of some wind turbine power curve upgrades on the grounds of operational data analysis. The selected test cases are: improved start-up through pitch angle adjustment near the cut-in, aerodynamic blade retrofitting by means of vortex generators and passive flow control devices, and extension of the power curve through a soft cut-out strategy for very high wind speed. The criticality of each test case is discussed and appropriate data-driven models are formulated. These are employed to estimate the energy improvement from each of the upgrades under investigation. The general outcome of this work is a catalog of generalizable methods for studying wind turbine power curve upgrades. In particular, from the study of the selected test cases, it arises that complex wind conditions might affect wind turbine operation such that the production improvement is non-negligibly different from what can be estimated under the hypothesis of ideal wind conditions. A complex wind flow might actually impact on the efficiency of vortex generators and the soft cut-out strategies at high wind speeds. The general lesson is therefore that it is very important to estimate wind turbine upgrades on real environments through operational data.
- 20 February 2018
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 140 (3)
A Study of Wind Turbine Wakes in Complex Terrain Through RANS Simulation and SCADA Data
This work deals with wind turbine wakes in complex terrain. The test case is a cluster of four 2.3 MW wind turbines, sited in a very complex terrain. Their performances are studied through supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) data, suggesting a relevant role of the terrain in distorting the wake of the upstream turbines. The experimental evidences stimulate a deeper comprehension through numerical modeling: computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations are run, using the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) formulation. A novel way of elaborating the output of the simulations is proposed, providing metrics for quantifying the three-dimensional (3D) evolution of the wake. The main outcome of the numerical analysis is that the terrain distorts the wind flow so that the wake profile is severely asymmetric with respect to the lateral displacement. Further, the role of orography singularities is highlighted in dividing the wake front, thus inducing faster wake recovery with respect to flat terrain. This interpretation is confirmed by SCADA data analysis.
- 20 February 2018
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
- Vol. 140 (3)
A Study of Wind Turbine Wakes in Complex Terrain Through RANS Simulation and SCADA Data
This work deals with wind turbine wakes in complex terrain. The test case is a cluster of four 2.3 MW wind turbines, sited in a very complex terrain. Their performances are studied through supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) data, suggesting a relevant role of the terrain in distorting the wake of the upstream turbines. The experimental evidences stimulate a deeper comprehension through numerical modeling: computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations are run, using the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) formulation. A novel way of elaborating the output of the simulations is proposed, providing metrics for quantifying the three-dimensional (3D) evolution of the wake. The main outcome of the numerical analysis is that the terrain distorts the wind flow so that the wake profile is severely asymmetric with respect to the lateral displacement. Further, the role of orography singularities is highlighted in dividing the wake front, thus inducing faster wake recovery with respect to flat terrain. This interpretation is confirmed by SCADA data analysis.
- Open Access
Wind Turbine Loads Induced by Terrain and Wakes: An Experimental Study through Vibration Analysis and Computational Fluid Dynamics
A wind turbine is a very well-known archetype of energy conversion system working at non-stationary regimes. Despite this, a deep mechanical comprehension of wind turbines operating in complicated conditions is still challenging, especially as regards the analysis of experimental data. In particular, wind turbines in complex terrain represent a very valuable testing ground because of the possible combination of wake effects among nearby turbines and flow accelerations caused by the terrain morphology. For these reasons, in this work, a cluster of four full-scale wind turbines from a very complex site is studied. The object of investigation is vibrations, at the level of the structure (tower) and drive-train. Data collected by the on-board condition monitoring system are analyzed and interpreted in light of the knowledge of wind conditions and operating parameters collected by the Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition (SCADA). A free flow Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulation is also performed, and it allows one to better interpret the vibration analysis. The main outcome is the interpretation of how wakes and flow turbulences appear in the vibration signals, both at the structural level and at the drive-train level. Therefore, this wind to gear approach builds a connection between flow phenomena and mechanical phenomena in the form of vibrations, representing a precious tool for assessing loads in different working conditions.
Open AccessWind Turbine Loads Induced by Terrain and Wakes: An Experimental Study through Vibration Analysis and Computational Fluid Dynamics
A wind turbine is a very well-known archetype of energy conversion system working at non-stationary regimes. Despite this, a deep mechanical comprehension of wind turbines operating in complicated conditions is still challenging, especially as regards the analysis of experimental data. In particular, wind turbines in complex terrain represent a very valuable testing ground because of the possible combination of wake effects among nearby turbines and flow accelerations caused by the terrain morphology. For these reasons, in this work, a cluster of four full-scale wind turbines from a very complex site is studied. The object of investigation is vibrations, at the level of the structure (tower) and drive-train. Data collected by the on-board condition monitoring system are analyzed and interpreted in light of the knowledge of wind conditions and operating parameters collected by the Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition (SCADA). A free flow Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulation is also performed, and it allows one to better interpret the vibration analysis. The main outcome is the interpretation of how wakes and flow turbulences appear in the vibration signals, both at the structural level and at the drive-train level. Therefore, this wind to gear approach builds a connection between flow phenomena and mechanical phenomena in the form of vibrations, representing a precious tool for assessing loads in different working conditions.