TMTimothy MacNeill

Timothy MacNeill

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Timothy MacNeill has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    All Computing and No Dividend: How Weak Institutions Locked the Computer Revolution into Extractive Stagnation

    by Timothy MacNeill

    The computer revolution was the largest sustained investment in a general-purpose technology in the postwar record, yet it produced no aggregate productivity dividend. This article argues that this paradox is not the result of bad measurement or weak technology, but of weak (captured, corrupted, and ineffectual) institutions. Two institutional explanations, one that returns are captured before they aggregate and another that markets chronically misallocate the technology, have been named but rarely investigated as causes. This article develops both, joining critical political economy, institutional economics, and economic sociology in a comparative-historical study of energy and computing, tracking productivity, distribution, and institutional domains: antitrust, regulatory capacity, disclosure, and redistribution. It shows that a technology can be deployed, through mimetic and normative adoption pressures, far beyond the scope its productivity justifies, while its gains are enclosed by the firms that control it. Institutional capture/failure thus can cause a technology that is useful at the task level to be unproductive in aggregate, and yet highly profitable for a concentrated few. Where institutions correct this, the result can be a more shared dividend; where they fail, the result can be a durable equilibrium of extractive stagnationary diffusion. The energy buildout, corrected by early antitrust and New Deal reform, shared its dividend somewhat. Computing, under weaker neoliberal-era institutions, did not. The same institutional choice now confronts the AI build-out, which shows the same absence of reward.

  • Open Access

    Extractive Stagnationary Diffusion: Compute Lock-In, the Productivity Paradox, and the Political Economy of AI

    by Timothy MacNeill

    The international build-out of artificial-intelligence infrastructure is among the largest concentrated capital commitments in history, yet the productivity gains meant to justify it remain difficult to detect. Commentary has organised around two expectations: vindication or financial bust. This article argues it may be neither. Adapting carbon lock-in theory from energy research to computing power, while drawing on organisational sociology and the political economy, we develop a theory of extractive compute lock-in driven by a selfreinforcing AI techno-institutional complex. Its signature is extractive stagnationary diffusion: AI spreading into ever more areas while economy-wide productivity stays flat or falls. The argument turns on a distinction the dominant framings miss: task-level efficiency need not aggregate to economy-level efficiency. Economics has noted this aggregation gap but explained it with neutral mechanisms that predict eventual resolution. In contrast, we supply a structural political-economy explanation for the gap's persistence: AI lock-in spurs inefficient resource allocation while value is captured by AI supply oligopolies, shielded from correction by political protection and information opacity. Ten measurable indicators developed here as a monitoring instrument are evaluated against early-2026 data. That evidence is consistent with extractive stagnationary diffusion, though definitive judgement awaits possible resolution due to information and depreciation lags.

  • Green Basic Income: Evaluating the Bolsa Verde Project in the Brazilian Amazon

    by Timothy MacNeill, Clarisse Drummond

    We analyze the Bolsa Verde Program, arguing that it likely was the world’s first largescale institution of a Green Basic Income Program. As such, the initiative presents a unique opportunity to evaluate the potential environmental uses and implications of Basic Income initiatives. Our study relies on a socially-embedded analysis of the program as it functioned in the context of the Brazilian Amazon. This involves analysis of qualitative data from former program beneficiaries, community leaders, program evaluators, and managers. This research suggests that the program operated socially as a de facto Green Basic Income program, despite being designed as a hybrid Payment for Environmental Services initiative. Our analysis suggests that Bolsa Verde was successful in reducing both deforestation and poverty, and these successes were achieved without undermining collective community institutions that could have positive anti-poverty and environmental protection benefits of their own.


  • Open Access

    Indigenous Culture and Nature Relatedness: Results from a Community-Led Study

    by Mamaweswen Niigaaniin, Timothy MacNeill

    Indigenous social movements and environmental policy for just transitions to sustainability often draw on the claim that indigenous cultures are more closely related with nature and, thus, indigenous governance of resources will lead to better environmental outcomes. But neither this assumption, nor the details of a presumed indigenous-nature relationship, have yet been examined quantitatively. We use a collaborative community-designed survey to examine indigenous culture and nature relatedness, finding a strong positive relation between Anishinaabe culture of Central/Southern Canada and nature relatedness. This relationship is not simply driven by repeated interactions with nature associated with certain cultural practices, but by communicated elements such as ceremonies, stories, and songs. Findings support the suggestion that indigenous governance and cultural revitalization programs may improve environmental policy outcomes. This may happen through direct Indigenous governance, or through knowledge/cultural transfer from Indigenous to non-Indigenous people – both of which may promote the normalization, capacity-building, and coalition building required to support effective environmental policy. Since the general cultural elements that are found to be significant in this study are common to indigenous populations worldwide, there is a possibility that these findings are generalizable amongst indigenous cultures globally. The paper advances a quantitative decolonial research method that may be used to investigate this further.

  • Open Access

    Corrigendum to: Decolonizing social services through community development: an Anishinaabe experience

    by Mamaweswen Niigaaniin, Timothy MacNeill, Carola Ramos-Cortez

    In the originally published version of this manuscript, the first author affiliation and corresponding author email address were incorrect. The first author's affiliation should read as follows ``North Shore Tribal Council, Canada'' instead of ``University of Ontario Institute of Technology, Canada.'' These errors have been corrected online and in print.


  • From strain theory to the capacity to aspire: A contribution to the cultural political economy of development

    by Timothy MacNeill, Christopher O’Connor, Tyler Frederick, Esther James-Charles

    The idea of the capacity to aspire (CtA) has recently been used in attempts to incorporate cultural and psychological factors into political and economic theories of community development. When integrated with capabilities and capital assets approaches, CtA can be used to explain psychological and cultural development traps, but may be incomplete in its formulation. Through a theoretical discussion and a case study in a post disaster situation, we show that the integration of strain theory can make CtA more meaningful, nuanced, and powerful in its framing of community development processes. We suggest that this integrated theory offers a more thorough understanding of the cultural political economy of development, and a richer trajectory for future research and practice than does CtA theory alone.


  • Open Access

    Indigenous food sovereignty in a captured state: the Garifuna in Honduras

    by Timothy MacNeill

    This study explores the emergence of the Afro-Indigenous food sovereignty movement in the context of a captured Honduran state and unequal political economy. In contrast with national-level research that has advocated a policy of food security in the context of non-indigenous campesino movements, this work explains how food sovereignty is more appropriate regarding Garifuna Hondurans. In a political economy that has precluded other options, and given the deep cultural relation that Garifuna activists have to land and autonomy, food sovereignty provides a possibility around which Indigenous development can be animated. It encapsulates a local ‘fight’ response to repression as an alternative to northern ‘flight’, often via migrant caravans, that many Garifuna have undertaken. This study shows how food sovereignty, more than being a technical policy set, is a discursive and material node through which dispossessed and especially indigenous populations can enhance decolonial power in the contestation of entrenched hegemonic and institutionalised power in a corrupt, unequal and colonised political economy.


  • Open Access

    Culture in Development Theory

    by Timothy MacNeill

    After WWII, development became a major global pursuit, and culture played a key role in ideas of how to nurture its occurrence. This chapter scrutinizes postwar, largely uncritical, development theory—focusing on the way in which culture appears in these ideas.