GMGuzel I. Makarova

Guzel I. Makarova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Guzel I. Makarova has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Theoretical approaches to the study of urban identity in a Russian industrial city

    by G. I. Makarova, Г. И. Макарова

    In the context of current geopolitical challenges, understanding how urban identity develops in Russian industrial centers has become increasingly important. A strong urban identity can influence residents’ migration intentions. The article aims to to systematize theoretical approaches to the study of urban identity, with a particular focus on industrial cities. The study uses theoretical analysis and a review of empirical research by Russian scholars published over the past decade. We selected the studies from scientometric databases, classified them by research topic, and used a comparative approach to examine them alongside international perspectives. The study considers three main research perspectives: the sociological perspective, which focuses on identification with the urban community; the geographical and anthropological and urban studies perspectives, which focus on identification with place; and the political science perspective, which examines discourses. The cognitive, emotional, behavioral, and value-based and meaning-related components of urban identity are identified. The analysis shows a shift in the understanding of the industrial dimension of identity in industrial cities. Researchers increasingly view it not as a given characteristic but as an issue that requires purposeful transformation.

  • Open Access

    Non-Capital Industrial Cities of Tatarstan: Factors of Attractiveness for Young People

    by Guzel I. Makarova, Макарова Гузель Ильясовна

    Introduction. In the context of new industrialization, the main challenge for industrial cities is preserving human potential, which is linked to the ability to attract and retain young people. Using the Republic of Tatarstan as an example, the aim of this study is to identify factors that make non-capital industrial cities attractive to young people in the context of their life choices. Materials and Methods. The study is based on a combined methodological design. The empirical base consisted of 12 focus groups conducted in 2024 in four industrial cities (Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk) with three key groups: employees of city-forming enterprises employed in the non-manufacturing sector, as well as students from schools, colleges, and universities. Qualitative data from the focus groups and the results of quantitative mass surveys conducted in 2021 and 2024 were integrated. Additional depth was achieved by including expert interviews and interviews with residents' families. Results. It was found that the dominant factors for young people in assessing a city's attractiveness are salary levels and opportunities for professional fulfillment and advancement. Education plays a significant role in their life choices. Among the pressing issues identified were a shortage of specialized doctors, environmental concerns, and personal safety (due to the emergence of new migrant workers). While the region has successfully addressed the challenges of creating a comfortable urban environment, the underdevelopment of the leisure and entertainment sector was noted. Discussion and Conclusion. The study demonstrates the need for comprehensive measures to enhance the attractiveness of industrial cities. Key areas include creating conditions for career and educational advancement, targeted support for young professionals in addressing housing issues, systematic efforts to enhance the prestige of engineering and blue-collar jobs, and the development of a clear, shared vision for urban development. The findings contribute to the study of youth migration behavior, provide a practical basis for managing the human potential of industrial territories, and can be used by municipal, regional, and federal authorities.

  • Open Access

    From L.M. Drobizheva’s ideas to understanding modern ethnosocial reality

    by Guzel I. Makarova, Gulnara F. Gabdrakhmanova

    The article opens a special issue of the Historical Ethnology journal, dedicated to the work, ideas and approaches of L.M. Drobizheva, an outstanding scholar who is considered one of the founders of Soviet and Russian ethnosociology. Her research, distinguished by the depth of its conceptualization and the impeccability of its methods, laid the foundation for understanding the history of the peoples of the former USSR and contemporary ethnosocial processes from the perspective of ethno-sociological science. The issue begins with a series of memoir papers which highlight various stages and aspects of her academic curriculum vitae and personal biography, her work ethics and humane qualities. It contains articles written by researchers from different regions of the country, which reflect the idea of her personality and legacy by those who worked and studied with her and interacted on various discussion platforms. The authors point out Leokadia Mikhailovna’s sincere dedication to ethno-sociological science, as she was charged with ideas for its development for the benefit of the country, honesty, integrity in upholding a scholarly point of view, and the ability to line-up a team of like-minded researchers behind her. A number of papers are devoted to the importance of developing the theoretical foundations of ethnosociology, further understanding of its subject and methods, and clarifying the conceptual framework. Their authors speak out against the one-sided opposition of primordialism and constructivism/instrumentalism, advocate for special attention to the specifics of using terms in various socio-political, historical and cultural contexts, and the importance of understanding the new agenda of the ethnic field of Russia. Some of the articles present the results of empirical research, in which L.M. Drobizheva’s theoretical, methodological approaches and methodological developments are used to analyze the modern ethnosocial situation and interethnic attitudes. The presented material proves the relevance of the approaches developed by L.M. Drobizheva, for whom the highest value was acquiring the knowledge of social reality with the purpose to improve Russian society. Her honesty, ability to summarize the key aspects of reality and support scholars’ most talented initiatives laid down the traditions that today fruitfully stimulate the search for adequate responses to the new challenges of the time.

  • Open Access

    2nd Drobizheva Readings, or Russian ethnosociologists’s involvement in the study of the new agenda of Russia’s ethnic field

    by Gulnara F. Gabdrakhmanova, Guzel I. Makarova

    In the article, the authors reflect on the ways of further development of Russian ethnosociology, based on the analysis of the topics range at the sections and roundtable discussions, as well as the content of the reports presented at the conference “2nd Drobizheva Readings: Ethnic and Social Dimensions.” The event was dedicated to one of the founders of this branch of the Russian sociological science, L.M. Drobizheva. The forum demonstrated to what extent the research of contemporary ethnosociologists from different regions of the Russian Federation reflects the changes associated with the profound transformation of the world order and the emergence of a new political reality both in the country and at the global level. The authors of the plenary reports and speeches associated the conceptual foundations of understanding the ethnosocial field of Russia primarily with the ideas of the state-civilization and new methodological approaches to the study of Russian identity. That identity was the central research object for Russian ethnosociologists, who presented comprehensive data on its current state at the conference. At the same time, the forum revealed a noticeable decrease in scholars’ attention to other types of identities and ethnic communities. The subject matter of state-civil integration of Russian society has gained relevance for the current political agenda. The topic was highlighted as part of the analysis of the ethnosocial situation in the South and Southwest of Russia, in the new regions of the country, as well as in connection with the state of interethnic relations. The participants discussed migration processes in the context of serious restructuring of the Russian Federation migration policy. Summary of the issues of the sections and reports indicated the importance of further improving the conceptual framework for studying complex ethnosocial phenomena. It revealed the need for Russian scholars to deepen their understanding of the rapidly changing socio-political reality. Such a deeper and more extended approach is designed to provide adequate, synchronized data regarding the impact of this reality on the consolidation of Russian society, the adaptation of ethnic communities to it, the meanings and manifestations of modern diverse identities, as well as its impact on interethnic relations, migration, and ethnocultural demands. The authors of the article drew attention to the statement articulated by L.M. Drobizheva that during transitional periods of society’s development, the boundaries of social differentiation become more prominent. The topic of social changes in ethnic groups and the relationships of their representatives in the context of the new political agenda is gaining not only academic, but also practical significance in Russia.

  • Industrial Cities of Tatarstan, Their Actors, and Development Prospects as Perceived by the Population

    by Guzel Makarova

    This article analyses the changing perceptions of residents of Tatarstan's industrial cities about their city, the leading actors in urban development, and the population itself, as well as the dynamics of their migration sentiments in the context of changes occurring in the country and globally. This article is based on an analysis of data obtained from a mass trend survey of the population in four industrial cities of the region: Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk. Data from Kazan was also included for some aspects. In the context of the extreme turbulence of modern society, research has shown that self-identification with residents of the same settlement has increased, along with civic (Russian), regional, and ethno-confessional identities. Conflicting trends in attitudes toward the city were identified, with, in the author's view, a predominance of positive ones. They are influenced by a multitude of factors, ranging from the development and strategies of leading enterprises' participation in urban processes (determined by the directions of state economic policy, the industry affiliation of production, and the priorities of their management), the interaction of multiple actors and the media coverage of their activities, to regional programmes for improving infrastructure and the urban environment. According to city residents, a positive trend is the growing opportunity to choose a job, a profession, and find well-paying employment in the region's industrial settlements. Some settlements are offering greater opportunities for high-quality education, and cultural and leisure activities are developing. Others are distinguished by relatively low housing prices and a favourable environmental situation. According to the majority of respondents, the leading actors in urban development are the city administration and local governments, city-forming and other large enterprises, and regional authorities. Survey results also showed a weakening of migration sentiment among residents in the industrial cities of Tatarstan studied, although it remains quite high. Among possible migration destinations, Moscow and St. Petersburg are currently the priority, as are other cities in the region (preferably its capital, Kazan).


  • Open Access

    The Tatar language in interpersonal communication and public spaces of Tatarstan cities

    by Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, Gulnara F. Gabdrakhmanova, Guzel I. Makarova

    The article analyzes the use of the Tatar language by residents of the five largest cities of Tatarstan (Kazan, Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk) in interpersonal communication and in various institutions and urban public environments. It is based on the data of a mass-scale ethno-sociological survey conducted in late 2024 – early 2025. In the course of integrating the data, the authors sought to use certain new approaches to the analysis of ethnolinguistic processes – by posing the question of the choice of the language of communication not only in connection with the respondents’ belonging to a particular ethnic group, but also in relation to the environment and situation of communication, socio-cultural practices and expectations. The study showed that the Tatar language is chosen significantly more often in the private life of city residents and to a lesser extent in their public life. Nevertheless, in the social and institutional sphere it is noticed to one degree or another (“constantly” and “sometimes”) by about 90% of city residents. The Tatar language is used slightly less in educational institutions, somewhat more in administrative and medical institutions, and it is heard noticeably more frequently in public spaces of cities. In all spheres of interpersonal communication, the Russian language is predominant among the Russian settlements under examination. Tatar-Russian bilingualism or Tatar monolingualism prevails among Tatars. Two languages are used by 60–80% of Tatars in friendly communication, half in business, as well as when talking with parents, spouses, grandparents, and a third when they address their brothers and sisters. 75–96% of respondents recognize the importance of the representation of the Tatar language in the socio-cultural space of their cities. However, when assessing the real situation, from a fifth to a third of Tatars in different settlements pointed out the insufficiency of its presence. The identified public demand for the Tatar language, its perception as an organic part of the urban landscape by a significant proportion of representatives of different nationalities, demonstrates the significant role of this language in interpersonal communication and in the socio-cultural development of large cities in Tatarstan.


  • Images of Industrial Cities of Tatarstan in the Vision of the Leaders of Urban Communities and Ordinary Residents

    by Guzel I. Makarova, Макарова Гузель Ильясовна

    The article examines the verbally recorded dominants of the vision and construction of images of non-capital industrial cities of Tatarstan by their leading actors, accepted and described in their own way by ordinary citizens. They are supplemented by the author’s personal observations and analysis of the meanings embedded in urban symbols and toponymy, monumental propaganda and works of art. Conducted in 2021–2022 in Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk, expert interviews and problem-oriented interviews with families showed that their industrial specialization (and, accordingly, the designation as a city of mechanical engineers, chemists, oil workers, shipbuilders), as well as the associated features of the mentality of the residents, continued to determine their images. Moreover, the plant becomes a kind of invisible “partner” for every city dweller, setting the rhythm and style of life, key moments of historical memory. At the same time, the individuality of settlements is influenced by the peculiarities of the formation of their population, sociocultural spaces and urban culture, including ethnocultural specifics.

  • Open Access

    On the issues of ethnosociality in the city: introduction

    by Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, Guzel I. Makarova, Gulnara F. Gabdrakhmanova

    The article opens the issue dedicated to the ethnosocial problems of the city. Its authors – the compiler and scientific editor of the issue and the editor-in-chief of Historical Ethnology – substantiate an approach to the topic in relation to the ideology of the journal. It is intended to present manifestations of ethnicity in urban settlements in the broad context of the economic, political, social, historical and cultural processes which occur in them. The sections offered to readers reflect this aim and focus on the following aspects: identifying the directions for studying cities, as laid down in the works of ethnosociology classics; the issues of state national policy as applied to them and the influence of various social factors on interethnic engagement; the topic of urban identity in its relationship with ethnic, regional and all-Russian identities, as well as in the context of the impact on the migration mobility of the population; urban ethno-confessional, linguistic and cultural practices that reflect socio-political and economic changes in the post-Soviet space. A brief overview of the articles presents their main ideas and the perspective chosen by each author on the topic. It is concluded that revealing the dialectical relationship between historical, political, economic and ethnosocial development opens up prospects for further research of the city as a social community.


  • Open Access

    Ethnic aspects of identification and linguistic situation in non-capital cities of Tatarstan

    by Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, Guzel I. Makarova

    The article is dedicated to the topic of the social functioning of the Tatar language – a topic that is not losing relevance in the region – and the ethnic aspects of urban identity. Its use in the communication process in public spaces of non-capital industrial cities of Tatarstan has been examined, based on the materials of mass-scale sociological surveys conducted in Naberezhnye Chelny, Nizhnekamsk, Almetyevsk, and Zelenodolsk. The paper analyses the vision and assessments of the Tatars and Russians, who live in the given cities, regarding the situation developing with the use of the language in administrative, medical, preventive, and educational institutions of settlements, in public transport, on the streets and shopping areas, and at mass cultural events. A conclusion is drawn about the similarity of views of representatives of the identified ethnic groups concerning the importance of its presence in the socio-cultural space of the city, which is the result of the long-term language policy of the republic. On the other hand, discrepancies were discovered in their assessments of the frequency of the Tatar language use in different environments. Among other things, this is due to the differences in its perception by Tatars and Russians. Certain differences in the degree of the Tatar language use between the cities of interest have been noted. It is related to the ethnic composition and, to some extent, the location of the cities. Generally, the language can be heard in the non-capital industrial cities of the republic somewhat more often than in Kazan, with the exception of its satellite city, Zelenodolsk. The conducted study showed a reasonably high degree of the significance of local identity and the continuing relevance of ethnic identity for residents of the cities in question. At the same time, among the factors in the formation of a positive attitude towards the cities, the ethno-cultural factor (the answer option “there is an opportunity to live among representatives of my nationality and communicate in my native language here”) turned out to be important for a little more or less than a tenth of Tatar townspeople.


  • Open Access

    Стратегии акторов городского развития и целевой образ нестоличных промышленных городов Татарстана

    by Гузель Ильясовна Макарова

    Развитие современных городов определяется не только инициативами «сверху», но и наличием/отсутствием в них реальных акторов, способных интегрировать сообщества, выстроить стратегии участия в городских процессах и внутригородское взаимодействие. Проведенные в четырех промышленных поселениях Татарстана – Набережных Челнах, Нижнекамске, Альметьевске, Зеленодольске – экспертные интервью показали, что такими акторами выступают прежде всего лидеры градообразующих предприятий. В их стратегиях выделяются косвенный (путем социальной поддержки работников и вложений в их профессиональный рост) и прямой виды (когда они участвуют в разного рода экологических проектах территорий, в совершенствовании их инфраструктуры, в проведении городских мероприятий). Они чаще концептуализированы и заявлены в программных формах, а ход их реализации отражен в корпоративной социальной отчетности. Масштабы и характер участия компаний в развитии городов зависят от их отраслевой, функциональной принадлежности и интенций руководства. Стратегии местных властей также концептуально выстроены и имеют заявленные формы, в то же время их реальные стратегии часто остаются ситуативными. Главной функцией муниципальных органов является организация взаимодействия участников городских процессов для решения задач комплексного развития территорий. Однако в изучаемых кейсах они осуществляют ее с каждой группой акторов в отдельности, причем эта коммуникация редко оказывается связанной с выстраиванием целевого образа города. Новыми субъектами в промышленных городах выступают представители малого и среднего бизнеса, сообщества которых во многих из них только формируются, соответственно и деятельность в отношении городов скорее ситуативна. Не получают четкого концептуального выражения и действия общественников, по большей части выстраиваемые вокруг благоустройства районов и дворов, конкретных волонтерских проектов. В сфере культуры выделяются старые и новые (представители креативных индустрий) акторы, от взаимодействия которых зависит культурное содержание выстраиваемых образов места и привлекательность пространств. Одновременно значимым игроком в поле промышленных городов Татарстана являются региональные акторы. При наличии у выделенных субъектов действия своих стратегий единое, четко сформулированное видение ими проективного образа города в изучаемых кейсах скорее отсутствует. Они мало ориентированы на долгосрочные цели и действуют зачастую тактически. Тем не менее экспертные интервью позволили выделить возможные векторы перспективного развития каждого из нестоличных промышленных центров Республики Татарстан.