Christopher I. Vahl
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Christopher I. Vahl has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Elizabeth A. E. Boyle
Kansas State University Department of Animal Sciences and Industry
3 shared publications - Francisco Najar-Villarreal
Kansas State University Department of Animal Science and Industry
3 shared publications Q. Kang
Independent Statistical Consultant, Manhattan, KS 66503, USA
3 shared publicationsD. A. Blasi
2 shared publicationsD. U. Thomson
2 shared publications- Daniel Vega
Kansas State University Department of Animal Sciences and Industry
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 August 2021
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
Determining the longissimus lumborum and psoas major beef steak color life threshold and effect of post-mortem aging time using meta-analysis
Longissimuslumborum (LL) and psoas major (PM) steaks duringretail display and the effect of postmortem aging time (PMT) on the displaycolor life of LL and PM steaks using meta-analysis was determined. In phaseone, data were retrieved from 13 and 3 referred journal articles, for LL andPM, respectively, that included a* and subjective visual scores. The total display dayobservations for LL and PM were 148 and 27, respectively. Lower bound estimatesusing a 95% confidence interval for a* as a borderline for the display colorlife of LL and PM steaks were 20.24 and 20.99, respectively. For phase two, datawere retrieved from 26 and 10 referred journal articles, for LL and PM,respectively, that included a* and PMT. The total display dayobservations for LL and PM in phase two were 255 and 71, respectively. For LLsteaks, the actual PMT was grouped into five categories: 0-7 d; 8-14 d; 15-21d; 22-28 d; and 29-65 d. Additionally, the PMT of PM steaks was grouped intotwo categories: 0-7 d and 8-21 d. The first 21 d PMT for LL steaks had thelongest color life with 7 d of color life. Additionally, 22-28 and 29-65 d ofPMT had 5 and 4 d, respectively, of color life for LL steaks. The borderlineacceptability estimated for PM steaks with 0-7 d and 8-21 of PMT was 3 and 2 dof color life, respectively. Estimations from this meta-analysis demonstrate that usingLL and PM subprimals having a PMT of 21 d or less and 7 d or less, respectively,would optimize retail display color life of aerobically packaged steaks.
- 25 August 2021
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
Open AccessDetermining the longissimus lumborum and psoas major beef steak color life threshold and effect of post-mortem aging time using meta-analysis
Longissimuslumborum (LL) and psoas major (PM) steaks duringretail display and the effect of postmortem aging time (PMT) on the displaycolor life of LL and PM steaks using meta-analysis was determined. In phaseone, data were retrieved from 13 and 3 referred journal articles, for LL andPM, respectively, that included a* and subjective visual scores. The total display dayobservations for LL and PM were 148 and 27, respectively. Lower bound estimatesusing a 95% confidence interval for a* as a borderline for the display colorlife of LL and PM steaks were 20.24 and 20.99, respectively. For phase two, datawere retrieved from 26 and 10 referred journal articles, for LL and PM,respectively, that included a* and PMT. The total display dayobservations for LL and PM in phase two were 255 and 71, respectively. For LLsteaks, the actual PMT was grouped into five categories: 0-7 d; 8-14 d; 15-21d; 22-28 d; and 29-65 d. Additionally, the PMT of PM steaks was grouped intotwo categories: 0-7 d and 8-21 d. The first 21 d PMT for LL steaks had thelongest color life with 7 d of color life. Additionally, 22-28 and 29-65 d ofPMT had 5 and 4 d, respectively, of color life for LL steaks. The borderlineacceptability estimated for PM steaks with 0-7 d and 8-21 of PMT was 3 and 2 dof color life, respectively. Estimations from this meta-analysis demonstrate that usingLL and PM subprimals having a PMT of 21 d or less and 7 d or less, respectively,would optimize retail display color life of aerobically packaged steaks.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Kansas State University in Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station Research Reports
- Vol. 7 (1) , 12
Differences in Rumination and Animal Activity Can Be Quantified by Utilizing New Technologies
Objective: Utilizing new technologies such as Allflex eSense Ear Tags to (Allflex Livestock Intelligence, Madison, WI) evaluate the impacts of limit feeding a high-energy diet in the backgrounding phase on daily rumination and activity in growing cattle. Study Description: This project was conducted in conjunction with the performance backgrounding study at the Kansas State University Beef Stocker Unit in 2019. Crossbred heifers (n = 418) were outfitted with an ear tag that measured rumination and activity throughout the day and the 84-day backgrounding study. This data was continuously collected via an onsite antenna, downloaded to a computer, and analyzed in a software program. The Bottom Line: High-energy, limit-fed cattle ruminate less than high roughage, ad libitum cattle by 45 minutes in this study. There were no detected differences in animal activity.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Kansas State University in Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station Research Reports
- Vol. 7 (1) , 12
Open AccessDifferences in Rumination and Animal Activity Can Be Quantified by Utilizing New Technologies
Objective: Utilizing new technologies such as Allflex eSense Ear Tags to (Allflex Livestock Intelligence, Madison, WI) evaluate the impacts of limit feeding a high-energy diet in the backgrounding phase on daily rumination and activity in growing cattle. Study Description: This project was conducted in conjunction with the performance backgrounding study at the Kansas State University Beef Stocker Unit in 2019. Crossbred heifers (n = 418) were outfitted with an ear tag that measured rumination and activity throughout the day and the 84-day backgrounding study. This data was continuously collected via an onsite antenna, downloaded to a computer, and analyzed in a software program. The Bottom Line: High-energy, limit-fed cattle ruminate less than high roughage, ad libitum cattle by 45 minutes in this study. There were no detected differences in animal activity.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
- Vol. 5 (1)
Correlation of Bioelectrical Impedance With Freshness Quality Attributes of Beef Longissimus Lumborum Steaks
The quality attributes of beef longissimus lumborum during 15 d of retail display were assessed using surface bioelectrical impedance analysis (S-BIA) and internal bioelectrical impedance analysis (I-BIA). Beef loins (N = 18) were obtained from 3 commercial processors with 3 postmortem (PM) ages (27, 34, and 37 d). Loins were fabricated into twelve 2.54-cm-thick steaks, subdivided into 6 consecutively cut pairs, and randomly assigned to one of 6 display days (DD): 0, 3, 6, 9, 12, or 15. Steaks were assessed for S-BIA and I-BIA. Three locations were analyzed within each steak: top, middle, and bottom. Microbiological analysis, BIA, pH, instrumental color, proximate composition, and lipid oxidation were measured. There was a location × PM day × DD interaction (P < 0.05) for longissimus lumborum steaks for S-BIA. Among all 3 locations, steaks aged 27 d had higher (P < 0.05) S-BIA values on day 9 and 12 than steaks aged 34 and 37 d. There were no location × PM day × DD or two-way interactions (P > 0.05) for I-BIA. Display day affected (P < 0.05) all instrumental color data regardless of PM aging times. Among all PM aging times, steaks aged 27 d were 13% and 7% higher for a* and b* , respectively, compared with 34 and 37 d PM. There was a PM day × DD interaction (P < 0.05) for aerobic plate counts (APC). From day 0 and 9 of display, APC of steaks aged 27 d PM were 1 to 2.0 log colony-forming units/cm 2 lower than steaks aged 34 and 37 d. Quality attributes, including a*, b* , APC, and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances, were correlated (r = 0.70, − 0.64, − 0.56, and 0.69, respectively) with S-BIA. Overall, BIA values increased on aerobically packaged longissimus lumborum steaks and were correlated with various freshness quality parameters.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
- Vol. 5 (1)
Open AccessCorrelation of Bioelectrical Impedance With Freshness Quality Attributes of Beef Longissimus Lumborum Steaks
The quality attributes of beef longissimus lumborum during 15 d of retail display were assessed using surface bioelectrical impedance analysis (S-BIA) and internal bioelectrical impedance analysis (I-BIA). Beef loins (N = 18) were obtained from 3 commercial processors with 3 postmortem (PM) ages (27, 34, and 37 d). Loins were fabricated into twelve 2.54-cm-thick steaks, subdivided into 6 consecutively cut pairs, and randomly assigned to one of 6 display days (DD): 0, 3, 6, 9, 12, or 15. Steaks were assessed for S-BIA and I-BIA. Three locations were analyzed within each steak: top, middle, and bottom. Microbiological analysis, BIA, pH, instrumental color, proximate composition, and lipid oxidation were measured. There was a location × PM day × DD interaction (P < 0.05) for longissimus lumborum steaks for S-BIA. Among all 3 locations, steaks aged 27 d had higher (P < 0.05) S-BIA values on day 9 and 12 than steaks aged 34 and 37 d. There were no location × PM day × DD or two-way interactions (P > 0.05) for I-BIA. Display day affected (P < 0.05) all instrumental color data regardless of PM aging times. Among all PM aging times, steaks aged 27 d were 13% and 7% higher for a* and b* , respectively, compared with 34 and 37 d PM. There was a PM day × DD interaction (P < 0.05) for aerobic plate counts (APC). From day 0 and 9 of display, APC of steaks aged 27 d PM were 1 to 2.0 log colony-forming units/cm 2 lower than steaks aged 34 and 37 d. Quality attributes, including a*, b* , APC, and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances, were correlated (r = 0.70, − 0.64, − 0.56, and 0.69, respectively) with S-BIA. Overall, BIA values increased on aerobically packaged longissimus lumborum steaks and were correlated with various freshness quality parameters.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
- Vol. 4 (1)
Effect of Extended Hanging Time on the Microbial Quality of Pork Carcasses and Blade Steaks
To evaluate the effect of extended post-harvest hanging time on pork carcass sides (n = 20), aerobic plate count (APC), Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and mold populations, pH, and moisture content were determined. Pork carcasses were sampled on d 1, 7, 14, and 21 to determine their microbial quality from the lean tissue of 3 anatomical locations, the flank, shoulder, and jowl. After the 21-d extended hanging time, pork shoulder butts (n = 17) (Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications #406; USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, 2014) were fabricated from these carcasses into 2.54-cm pork blade steaks. Pork blade steaks were vacuum packaged, stored up to 35 d at 0°C ± 1°C, and evaluated for APC, Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and mold populations, and pH on d 0, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 35. Pork carcass surface moisture content declined (P < 0.01) from 65.1% on d 1 to 50.5% on d 21. The carcass pH was similar (P > 0.42) at 5.88 on d 1, 7, and 14; however, the pH declined (P < 0.05) to 5.72 at d 21. Pork carcass APC populations remained relatively low during the extended hanging time; however, the jowl had the highest (P < 0.05) APC populations among all anatomical locations. In addition, the proportion of yeast populations above the detection limit for the jowl was found to be greatest (P < 0.05) compared to the flank and the shoulder. Pork blade steak APC population was 5.06 log colony-forming units/g (CFU/g) on d 35; however, these counts were below 108 log CFU/g, which is when meat is considered spoiled. There was a day effect for Enterobacteriaceae and mold populations (P < 0.05). These results indicate that pork carcasses and vacuum-packaged steaks fabricated from pork carcasses have acceptable microbial quality when they undergo an extended hanging time.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Iowa State University in Meat and Muscle Biology
- Vol. 4 (1)
Open AccessEffect of Extended Hanging Time on the Microbial Quality of Pork Carcasses and Blade Steaks
To evaluate the effect of extended post-harvest hanging time on pork carcass sides (n = 20), aerobic plate count (APC), Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and mold populations, pH, and moisture content were determined. Pork carcasses were sampled on d 1, 7, 14, and 21 to determine their microbial quality from the lean tissue of 3 anatomical locations, the flank, shoulder, and jowl. After the 21-d extended hanging time, pork shoulder butts (n = 17) (Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications #406; USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, 2014) were fabricated from these carcasses into 2.54-cm pork blade steaks. Pork blade steaks were vacuum packaged, stored up to 35 d at 0°C ± 1°C, and evaluated for APC, Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and mold populations, and pH on d 0, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 35. Pork carcass surface moisture content declined (P < 0.01) from 65.1% on d 1 to 50.5% on d 21. The carcass pH was similar (P > 0.42) at 5.88 on d 1, 7, and 14; however, the pH declined (P < 0.05) to 5.72 at d 21. Pork carcass APC populations remained relatively low during the extended hanging time; however, the jowl had the highest (P < 0.05) APC populations among all anatomical locations. In addition, the proportion of yeast populations above the detection limit for the jowl was found to be greatest (P < 0.05) compared to the flank and the shoulder. Pork blade steak APC population was 5.06 log colony-forming units/g (CFU/g) on d 35; however, these counts were below 108 log CFU/g, which is when meat is considered spoiled. There was a day effect for Enterobacteriaceae and mold populations (P < 0.05). These results indicate that pork carcasses and vacuum-packaged steaks fabricated from pork carcasses have acceptable microbial quality when they undergo an extended hanging time.
- Open Access
- 11 May 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Equine Veterinary Science
- Vol. 76, 70
Changes in cecal environment and forage intake of horses fed increasing amounts of starch
- 11 May 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Equine Veterinary Science
- Vol. 76, 70
Open AccessChanges in cecal environment and forage intake of horses fed increasing amounts of starch
- 13 December 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Veterinary Parasitology
- Vol. 272, 83-94
Statistical analyses of chicken intestinal lesion scores in battery cage studies of anti-coccidial drugs
- 13 December 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Veterinary Parasitology
- Vol. 272, 83-94
Statistical analyses of chicken intestinal lesion scores in battery cage studies of anti-coccidial drugs
- 16 June 2017
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 16 (5) , 361-377
Testing for bioequivalence of highly variable drugs from TR‐RT crossover designs with heterogeneous residual variances
Traditional bioavailability studies assess average bioequivalence (ABE) between the test (T) and reference (R) products under the crossover design with TR and RT sequences. With highly variable (HV) drugs whose intrasubject coefficient of variation in pharmacokinetic measures is 30% or greater, assertion of ABE becomes difficult due to the large sample sizes needed to achieve adequate power. In 2011, the FDA adopted a more relaxed, yet complex, ABE criterion and supplied a procedure to assess this criterion exclusively under TRR‐RTR‐RRT and TRTR‐RTRT designs. However, designs with more than 2 periods are not always feasible. This present work investigates how to evaluate HV drugs under TR‐RT designs. A mixed model with heterogeneous residual variances is used to fit data from TR‐RT designs. Under the assumption of zero subject‐by‐formulation interaction, this basic model is comparable to the FDA‐recommended model for TRR‐RTR‐RRT and TRTR‐RTRT designs, suggesting the conceptual plausibility of our approach. To overcome the distributional dependency among summary statistics of model parameters, we develop statistical tests via the generalized pivotal quantity (GPQ). A real‐world data example is given to illustrate the utility of the resulting procedures. Our simulation study identifies a GPQ‐based testing procedure that evaluates HV drugs under practical TR‐RT designs with desirable type I error rate and reasonable power. In comparison to the FDA's approach, this GPQ‐based procedure gives similar performance when the product's intersubject standard deviation is low (≤0.4) and is most useful when practical considerations restrict the crossover design to 2 periods.
- 16 June 2017
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 16 (5) , 361-377
Testing for bioequivalence of highly variable drugs from TR‐RT crossover designs with heterogeneous residual variances
Traditional bioavailability studies assess average bioequivalence (ABE) between the test (T) and reference (R) products under the crossover design with TR and RT sequences. With highly variable (HV) drugs whose intrasubject coefficient of variation in pharmacokinetic measures is 30% or greater, assertion of ABE becomes difficult due to the large sample sizes needed to achieve adequate power. In 2011, the FDA adopted a more relaxed, yet complex, ABE criterion and supplied a procedure to assess this criterion exclusively under TRR‐RTR‐RRT and TRTR‐RTRT designs. However, designs with more than 2 periods are not always feasible. This present work investigates how to evaluate HV drugs under TR‐RT designs. A mixed model with heterogeneous residual variances is used to fit data from TR‐RT designs. Under the assumption of zero subject‐by‐formulation interaction, this basic model is comparable to the FDA‐recommended model for TRR‐RTR‐RRT and TRTR‐RTRT designs, suggesting the conceptual plausibility of our approach. To overcome the distributional dependency among summary statistics of model parameters, we develop statistical tests via the generalized pivotal quantity (GPQ). A real‐world data example is given to illustrate the utility of the resulting procedures. Our simulation study identifies a GPQ‐based testing procedure that evaluates HV drugs under practical TR‐RT designs with desirable type I error rate and reasonable power. In comparison to the FDA's approach, this GPQ‐based procedure gives similar performance when the product's intersubject standard deviation is low (≤0.4) and is most useful when practical considerations restrict the crossover design to 2 periods.
- 22 November 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 155 (5) , 812-831
Statistical strategies for multiple testing in the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop
Hazard identification is the first step in assessing the risk of a genetically modified (GM) crop. It employs the concept of substantial equivalence to evaluate crop safety. The current process relies on subjective opinions to integrate various comparisons among the GM crop, the non-GM counterpart and an assortment of non-GM references over an array of key endpoints measured in field trials. The pre-eminent need to control the consumer's risk in hazard identification has been left unaddressed. The current paper develops statistical strategies to resolve this issue. Hypotheses of individual tests are explicitly defined to reflect the study objectives. They are then grouped into families and connected by logical operators according to decision rules commonly used in crop safety evaluation. This pre-specification of hypotheses arranged in an organized layout leads to a simple, transparent decision-making process where the consumer's risk can be managed directly. A two-stage multiplicity adjustment procedure is created by applying fundamental principles for multiple testing to the newly assembled families of hypotheses. The practical utility of the proposed procedure is shown in a real-world example. Besides being easy to implement and convey, the proposed statistical strategies accommodate the addition of supportive evidence for safety and allow the nature of the genetic modification to be taken into account.
- 22 November 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 155 (5) , 812-831
Statistical strategies for multiple testing in the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop
Hazard identification is the first step in assessing the risk of a genetically modified (GM) crop. It employs the concept of substantial equivalence to evaluate crop safety. The current process relies on subjective opinions to integrate various comparisons among the GM crop, the non-GM counterpart and an assortment of non-GM references over an array of key endpoints measured in field trials. The pre-eminent need to control the consumer's risk in hazard identification has been left unaddressed. The current paper develops statistical strategies to resolve this issue. Hypotheses of individual tests are explicitly defined to reflect the study objectives. They are then grouped into families and connected by logical operators according to decision rules commonly used in crop safety evaluation. This pre-specification of hypotheses arranged in an organized layout leads to a simple, transparent decision-making process where the consumer's risk can be managed directly. A two-stage multiplicity adjustment procedure is created by applying fundamental principles for multiple testing to the newly assembled families of hypotheses. The practical utility of the proposed procedure is shown in a real-world example. Besides being easy to implement and convey, the proposed statistical strategies accommodate the addition of supportive evidence for safety and allow the nature of the genetic modification to be taken into account.
- 22 January 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 154 (8) , 1392-1412
Statistical procedures for testing hypotheses of equivalence in the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop
SUMMARY: Safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop entails assessing its equivalence to conventional crops under multi-site randomized block field designs. Despite mounting petitions for regulatory approval, there lack a scientifically sound and powerful statistical method for establishing equivalence. The current paper develops and validates two procedures for testing a recently identified class of equivalence uniquely suited to crop safety. One procedure employs the modified large sample (MLS) method; the other is based on generalized pivotal quantities (GPQs). Because both methods were originally created under balanced designs, common issues associated with incomplete and unbalanced field designs were addressed by first identifying unfulfilled theoretical assumptions and then replacing them with user-friendly approximations. Simulation indicated that the MLS procedure could be very conservative in many occasions irrespective of the balance of the design; the GPQ procedure was mildly liberal with its type I error rate near the nominal level when the design is balanced. Additional pros and cons of these two procedures are also discussed. Their utility is demonstrated in a case study using summary statistics derived from a real-world dataset.
- 22 January 2016
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 154 (8) , 1392-1412
Statistical procedures for testing hypotheses of equivalence in the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop
SUMMARY: Safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop entails assessing its equivalence to conventional crops under multi-site randomized block field designs. Despite mounting petitions for regulatory approval, there lack a scientifically sound and powerful statistical method for establishing equivalence. The current paper develops and validates two procedures for testing a recently identified class of equivalence uniquely suited to crop safety. One procedure employs the modified large sample (MLS) method; the other is based on generalized pivotal quantities (GPQs). Because both methods were originally created under balanced designs, common issues associated with incomplete and unbalanced field designs were addressed by first identifying unfulfilled theoretical assumptions and then replacing them with user-friendly approximations. Simulation indicated that the MLS procedure could be very conservative in many occasions irrespective of the balance of the design; the GPQ procedure was mildly liberal with its type I error rate near the nominal level when the design is balanced. Additional pros and cons of these two procedures are also discussed. Their utility is demonstrated in a case study using summary statistics derived from a real-world dataset.
- 8 April 2015
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 154 (3) , 383-406
Equivalence criteria for the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop: a statistical perspective
SUMMARY: Safety evaluation of a genetically modified (GM) crop is accomplished by establishing its substantial equivalence to non-GM reference crops with a history of safe use. Testing hypotheses of equivalence rather than difference is the appropriate statistical approach. A necessary first step in this regard is to specify a reasonable equivalence criterion that includes a measure for discrepancy between the GM and reference crops as well as a regulatory threshold. The present work explored several equivalence criteria and discussed their pros and cons. Each criterion addresses one of three ordered classes of equivalence: super, conditional and marginal equivalence. Their implications were investigated over an array of parameter values estimated from a real-world dataset. Marginal equivalence was identified as adhering most closely to the concept of substantial equivalence. Because conditional equivalence logically implies marginal equivalence and is practically quantifiable from current field designs, the present work recommends conditional equivalence criteria while encouraging producers to improve their design to enable testing marginal equivalence in the future. Contrary to concerns of the ag-biotech industry, empirical evidence from recent publications indicates that a linear mixed model currently implemented by the European Food Safety Authority is adequate for assessing equivalence despite its lack of genotype-by-environment interaction terms.
- 8 April 2015
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 154 (3) , 383-406
Equivalence criteria for the safety evaluation of a genetically modified crop: a statistical perspective
SUMMARY: Safety evaluation of a genetically modified (GM) crop is accomplished by establishing its substantial equivalence to non-GM reference crops with a history of safe use. Testing hypotheses of equivalence rather than difference is the appropriate statistical approach. A necessary first step in this regard is to specify a reasonable equivalence criterion that includes a measure for discrepancy between the GM and reference crops as well as a regulatory threshold. The present work explored several equivalence criteria and discussed their pros and cons. Each criterion addresses one of three ordered classes of equivalence: super, conditional and marginal equivalence. Their implications were investigated over an array of parameter values estimated from a real-world dataset. Marginal equivalence was identified as adhering most closely to the concept of substantial equivalence. Because conditional equivalence logically implies marginal equivalence and is practically quantifiable from current field designs, the present work recommends conditional equivalence criteria while encouraging producers to improve their design to enable testing marginal equivalence in the future. Contrary to concerns of the ag-biotech industry, empirical evidence from recent publications indicates that a linear mixed model currently implemented by the European Food Safety Authority is adequate for assessing equivalence despite its lack of genotype-by-environment interaction terms.