PBPaul Best

Paul Best

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Paul Best has a total of 104 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    A qualitative exploration of online mental health peer support use in Northern Ireland and China: Implications for youth mental health social work

    by Shuting Yuan, Gavin Davidson, Jinyu Chen, Paul Best

    The rising need and demand for mental health support are presenting challenges for mental health services including youth mental health social work. Online peer support is emerging as a promising pathway for effective support for young people facing mental health challenges. However, there is limited information about service users’ narratives of engagement and effectiveness of online peer support especially in relation to different cultural contexts. This study aimed to explore the user perspective on their experience of online peer support use with a focus on participation styles, motivations, barriers, and the evaluation of engagement. We conducted 25 semi-structured interviews (nine in Northern Ireland and 16 in China) with users who had experience of online peer support. The findings identified four themes as well as 22 subthemes and highlighted some considerations about the possible barriers and the different ways people may engage. Two of the subthemes primarily described benefits of online peer support, which have been identified as potentially used for promotion, prevention and intervention. Experiences of online mental health peer support were largely positive in Northern Ireland (NI) and China. This type of support may provide an important and relatively accessible component of mental health social work intervention.

  • Open Access

    Systematic bibliographic database searching in social work evidence synthesis: Methodological reflections from a scoping review

    by Jessica Cushnan, Paul McCafferty, Paul Best

    Digital capability is increasingly recognized as essential within social work, extending beyond communication technologies and digital service delivery to include the ability to locate, evaluate, and synthesize research evidence. This paper presents a methodological reflection on systematic searching through a completed scoping review examining clinicians’ perspectives on immersive virtual reality in mental health settings. Drawing on the Joanna Briggs Institute framework, the paper explores interdisciplinary evidence retrieval, database selection, search strategy, screening management, and database performance. Consistent with previous methodological studies, findings suggest that database effectiveness is shaped by the interdisciplinary nature of the topic. Particular attention is given to sensitivity, precision, screening burden, and the retrieval of unique studies across databases. Substantial variation in database performance was identified. Scopus proved indispensable for broad interdisciplinary retrieval, identifying all included studies and most unique records, but generated a considerable screening burden due to low precision. More specialized databases demonstrated greater efficiency but contributed fewer unique studies. The paper conceptualizes systematic searching as an iterative and reflexive methodological practice shaped by database infrastructures, conceptual ambiguity, and researcher judgement. It highlights the importance of evidence literacy and digital capability, establishing systematic searching as central to rigorous, transparent, and critically informed social work research.

  • Open Access

    Artificial Intelligence and Spirituality: A Systematic Scoping Review of Human-AI Engagement

    by Anna Burcombe, Patricia Carlisle, Paul Best

    Conversational AI increasingly features in spiritual life among religious and non-religious users alike, from prayer and pastoral guidance to divination, wellness applications and existential reflection, yet no review has mapped how the literature understands this engagement. This scoping review followed the Arksey and O'Malley framework with PRISMA-ScR guidance, searching ten databases for English-language studies published since November 2022 to May 2026 and screening by title, then title and abstract, then full text. Nineteen studies met the inclusion criteria, spanning qualitative, survey and mixed methods design. Thematic synthesis identified four patterns: AI as a source of spiritual authority and knowledge, as a companion for emotional and spiritual disclosure, as a facilitator of ritual and devotional practice and as an ethical and governance concern. Users often valued these systems because they are not human. Conversations would contain disclosures kept from clergy, family or therapists, while simultaneously voicing scepticism about the same systems' authority and reliability. Most included sources raised concerns about bias, privacy, dependency and inadequate oversight. The evidence base is small, cross-sectional and concentrated in institutional religious contexts. The review concludes that conversational AI already functions as a tool for spiritual and existential engagement for some users. Questions of authority, authenticity and responsibility remain unresolved.

  • Open Access

    “I Was in the House”: The emotional and pedagogical impact of virtual reality in pre-entry social work education

    by Paul McCafferty, Gerry Marshall, Jessica Cushnan, Nicola Booth, Brenda Brady, Alex Quinn, Paul Best

    This study examines the pedagogical potential of virtual reality (VR) as an early exposure tool for introducing prospective social work learners to the emotional and ethical complexity of child-protection decision-making. Participants were eighteen 17-year-old students enrolled in a 1-week widening-participation Pathway Program at a UK university. The program was a pre-entry introduction to social work and did not constitute enrolment or guarantee progression. Learning activities were framed as orientation rather than preparation for practice, with an emphasis on ethical reflection and informed decision-making about future study. Using a crossover design, participants engaged with both a VR home-visit simulation and a text-based case report. Quantitative measures assessed empathy, preparedness, self-efficacy and cognitive load, while focus groups explored emotional engagement. Findings indicated significant increases in empathy and preparedness across both modalities, with no significant changes in self-efficacy or cognitive load. The VR experience consisted of a twenty-minute immersive simulation delivered through Meta Quest 2 headsets. Students reported that VR strengthened identification with the social work role and enhanced understanding of children’s perspectives, although some experienced technical difficulties and emotional intensity. The study supports inclusive pedagogies integrating immersive and traditional approaches to strengthen ethical awareness and early professional formation.

  • Open Access

    Online mental health peer support use among young people in Northern Ireland and China: A comparative cross-sectional study

    by Shuting Yuan, Paul Best, Gavin Davidson, Si Chen, Yan Liu

    Online mental health peer support is a developing approach which appeals to young people and also contributes to central challenges and possible opportunities for social work practice. This quantitative study explored the use of online peer support and youth mental well-being in Northern Ireland and China and examined potential factors associated with the selection of online peer support. The findings revealed a country-specific disparity in the use of online peer support. Social work practitioners should be aware of the potential of online peer support for youth mental health as an accessible supplement to traditional services.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Effectiveness and Experiences of Online Mental Health Peer Support for Young People: Systematic Scoping Review

    by Shuting Yuan, Gavin Davidson, Sebastian Kurten, Paul Best

    Background: The prevalence of mental health conditions among young people is high and further increasing. Despite this considerable need, barriers remain to accessing and engaging with traditional mental health services. Online mental health peer support is increasingly popular among young people seeking help. However, research examining the effectiveness of online mental health peer support and user-centered experiences remains limited. Objective: This systematic scoping review aimed to synthesize research evidence on the effectiveness and experiences of online mental health peer support for young people, compare these across different forms, and identify possible applications of online peer support. Methods: This scoping review followed the 5-stage framework proposed by Arksey and O’Malley and revised by Levac et al. Three reviewers screened the articles. The IBSS, SSCI, Scopus, PsycINFO, MEDLINE, and Social Policy and Practice databases were searched by title and Retrieved studies (N=8327) were double-screened, and 38 articles met the inclusion criteria. Studies were included if they focused on young people aged up to and including 25 years and if the intervention was online peer support primarily aimed at supporting mental health. Results: The number of participants (posts/comments) in each study ranged from 10 to 36,934. Seventeen studies reported on the effectiveness of online peer support, and 28 studies reported on young users’ experiences. This review summarized evidence of overall positive clinical outcomes, personal recovery outcomes (including improved social connectedness and other personal recovery outcomes), and multidimensional experiences of online mental health peer support (such as fostering resonance or fatigue). Conclusions: Overall, online mental health peer support demonstrated positive effects on clinical and personal recovery outcomes. However, findings related to user experiences were mixed. Experiences were influenced by factors such as safety, anonymity, and the quality of peer interactions. These insights may inform the role alongside traditional services, attractive platform design, and safeguarding. Future research should further explore the integration of online peer support with traditional services and various digital platforms to better address young people’s mental health needs and further examine its effectiveness as well as experiences in practice to maximize the peer support benefits and reduce risks.


  • Open Access

    Online mental health peer support: a systematic scoping review of theoretical mechanisms of effect

    by Shuting Yuan, Gavin Davidson, Paul Best

    Background: The mental health of young people is a major public health concern and there is a high demand for support, but available mental health resources are limited. To address this problem, online peer support has potential to complement traditional approaches to providing mental health services. While some studies have identified possible mechanisms of peer support, there is limited understanding regarding the potential mechanisms underpinning mental health peer support delivered online. The aim of this systematic scoping review was to identify and summarise the mechanisms that have been proposed to explain why young people may use and benefit from online mental health peer support from the perspective of both the participants themselves and the external characteristics of online communities. The review also explored possible negative aspects of mechanisms and how associated risks may be managed. Methods: The IBSS, SSCI, Scopus, PsycINFO, Medline and Social Policy and Practice databases were searched to identify relevant literature. Retrieved studies (n = 7495) were double screened and 24 articles met the criteria to be included in the review and analysed to identify key themes. Results: Five main proposed theoretical mechanisms were found to underpin effective online peer support for young people with mental health issues: unidirectional interaction, one-way pointing to help-seekers from peer supporters and reciprocal (mutual) interaction between peer supporters and help seekers, which was the main interaction; knowledge about mental health including experiential knowledge; understanding which includes self-understanding, understanding others and feeling understood by others; social support; and the characteristics of the online community environment. Negative aspects associated with the challenges of online mental health peer support were also identified. Conclusions: The identified, proposed theoretical mechanisms offer a better understanding of online peer support for youth mental health. They may explain why some young people choose online mental health peer support and they provide professionals and developers with insights for designing digital intervention tools. Future research is needed to explore the relative effectiveness of the proposed mechanisms, and the components within them. This could include comparing the effectiveness of online and offline peer support, and examining how these various mechanisms may contribute and combine to achieve maximum effectiveness.


  • Open Access

    Developing and testing a community based, online vs. face-to-face peer led intervention to improve mental well-being in Cambodian adults with physical disabilities

    by Paul Best, Alan Maddock, Nil Ean, Lorna Montgomery, Cherie Armour, Ciaran Mulholland, Carolyn Blair, \R\Npaul Best

    Background: Despite growing international attention, there remains an urgent need to develop mental health services within low and middle income countries. The Khmer Rouge period in Cambodia saw the destruction of all health services infrastructure in the 1970s. Consequently, Cambodia has struggled to rebuild both its economy and healthcare system, with the number of qualified mental health clinicians remaining disproportionately low. Resultantly, there is a pressing need to develop low-cost community based alternatives of mental healthcare.Methods: Using a mixed methods design, researchers developed an 8-week peer-led intervention, known as a Friendship Group, for adults with physical disabilities using both face-to-face and online delivery methods. The Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test was used to assess changes in pre-post survey scores and qualitative data was collected in form of five focus groups post intervention.Results: 41 participants were allocated across four Friendship groups – two were online and two face-to-face. Attrition rate was 22% post-intervention (n = 32). ITT analyses showed a statistically significant decrease in psychological distress scores [Z = −3.808, p < .001] from pre [Mdn = 20, IQR = 16.5–25.5] to post [Mdn = 16, IQR = 14–18.5] intervention. A Wilcoxon signed-ranks test also showed a statistically significant decrease in PTSD scores [Z = −2.239, p < .025] from pre [Mdn = 4, IQR = 3–5] to post [Mdn = 3, IQR = 2.75–4] intervention. There was also a statistically significant decrease in worry scores [Z = −3.904, p < .001] from pre [Mdn = 5, IQR = 3.5–6.5] to post [Mdn = 3, IQR = 3–4] intervention. There were no significant group differences between the face to face and online groups. A number of interconnected themes emerged from focus group data (n = 5), these included the mental health benefits of Friendship Groups as conceptualised through knowledge acquisition, skill development and peer support.Conclusions: The Friendship group intervention delivered in both online and face-to-face formats appears feasible and acceptable within the Cambodian context. Initial data revealed positive findings in terms of reduction in psychological distress, worry and PTSD symptoms as well increased feeling as calm.


  • Open Access

    Immersive virtual environments as a tool to improve confidence and role expectancy in prospective social work students: a proof-of-concept study

    by Paul Best, Gerry Marshall, Jessica Cushnan, Paul McCafferty, Nichola Booth

    In the rapidly evolving landscape of professional education, technological innovations are reshaping the ways in which learners are trained. Particularly in the field of social work, where practiti...