JOJuan María Martínez Otero

Juan María Martínez Otero

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Juan María Martínez Otero has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Protecting Young Users on Social Media: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Content Moderation and Legal Safeguards on Video-Sharing Platforms

    by Fatmaelzahraa Eltaher, Rahul Krishna Gajula, Luis Miralles-Pechuán, Patrick Crotty, Juan Martínez-Otero, Christina Thorpe, Susan Mckeever

    Video-sharing platforms such as TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram implement content moderation policies to reduce the exposure of minors to harmful videos. As video has become the dominant and most immersive form of online content, assessing how effectively these systems protect younger users is increasingly important. This study evaluates the effectiveness of video moderation for different age groups on TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram, based on a focused set of experimental accounts. Accounts were created for simulated users aged 13 and 18, and 3,000 recommended videos were analyzed in two interaction modes: passive scrolling and search-based scrolling. Each video was manually assessed for the severity of the harm using a unified harm classification framework. While low-severity harm was the most prevalent form encountered, the results show that accounts configured as 13-year-olds encountered harmful videos more frequently and rapidly than accounts configured as 18-year-olds. On YouTube, 15% of videos recommended to 13-year-old accounts during passive scrolling were classified as harmful, compared to 8.17% for adult accounts, with exposure occurring within an average of 3:06 minutes. This exposure appeared without user-initiated searches, highlighting weaknesses in algorithmic filtering. Results from our targeted study point to gaps in video moderation systems, suggesting the need for more effective safeguards to better protect minors from harmful online content.


  • Open Access

    La renovación de cargos públicos de designación parlamentaria. Una mirada a los bloqueos institucionales partiendo de la situación valenciana

    by Juan María Martínez Otero

    El presente artículo aborda el bloqueo de las renovaciones parlamentarias en los grandes órganos de nuestro sistema institucional. El análisis se articula en tres epígrafes, que pretenden (1) describir el funcionamiento ideal del modelo de designación parlamentaria por mayoría cualificada; (2) analizar la progresiva degeneración del modelo, atendiendo a sus fases, causas y efectos; y (3) presentar las principales soluciones propuestas para corregir las disfunciones del modelo, ofreciendo una alternativa adicional.

  • Open Access

    Protecting Young Users on Social Media: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Content Moderation and Legal Safeguards on Video Sharing Platforms

    by Fatmaelzahraa Eltaher, Rahul Krishna Gajula, Luis Miralles-Pechuán, Patrick Crotty, Juan Martínez-Otero, Christina Thorpe, Susan McKeever

    Video-sharing social media platforms, such as TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram, implement content moderation policies aimed at reducing exposure to harmful videos among minor users. As video has become the dominant and most immersive form of online content, understanding how effectively this medium is moderated for younger audiences is urgent. In this study, we evaluated the effectiveness of video moderation for different age groups on three of the main video-sharing platforms: TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram. We created experimental accounts for the children assigned ages 13 and 18. Using these accounts, we evaluated 3,000 videos served up by the social media platforms, in passive scrolling and search modes, recording the frequency and speed at which harmful videos were encountered. Each video was manually assessed for level and type of harm, using definitions from a unified framework of harmful content. The results show that for passive scrolling or search-based scrolling, accounts assigned to the age 13 group encountered videos that were deemed harmful, more frequently and quickly than those assigned to the age 18 group. On YouTube, 15\% of recommended videos to 13-year-old accounts during passive scrolling were assessed as harmful, compared to 8.17\% for 18-year-old accounts. On YouTube, videos labelled as harmful appeared within an average of 3:06 minutes of passive scrolling for the younger age group. Exposure occurred without user-initiated searches, indicating weaknesses in the algorithmic filtering systems. These findings point to significant gaps in current video moderation practices by social media platforms. Furthermore, the ease with which underage users can misrepresent their age demonstrates the urgent need for more robust verification methods.


  • Open Access

    Criterios de adjudicación de plazas en centros escolares de la red pública: una mirada crítica y una propuesta alternativa

    by Juan María Martínez Otero

    Objetivos: el presente artículo se propone analizar críticamente los criterios de adjudicación de plazas escasas en centros escolares de la red pública. Metodología: la metodología empleada es el análisis de las fuentes primarias –normativa estatal y autonómica– y secundarias –jurisprudencia y doctrina– y su discusión crítica. El artículo comienza describiendo el sistema de asignación de plazas previsto en la normativa educativa. A continuación, se aborda la compatibilidad del establecimiento de distinciones en el acceso a los servicios públicos educativos con el principio de igualdad. La parte central del estudio se dedica a identificar y discutir los criterios de adjudicación más frecuentemente empleados. Resultados: el análisis realizado evidencia el carácter discutido y discutible de la mayoría de los criterios de adjudicación habitualmente empleados. Conclusiones: como conclusión, el artículo propone un sistema de asignación de plazas alternativo, el sorteo ponderado, que permite equilibrar mejor la libertad de elección de centro de las familias y el principio de equidad.


  • Open Access

    ¿Qué puede hacer la Administración para proteger a los menores frente a la pornografía en Internet?

    by Juan Martínez Otero

    De acuerdo con los últimos estudios publicados en nuestro país, el acceso de los menores a la pornografía online es muy prevalente. El presente estudio analiza cómo la Administración pública puede contribuir a mitigar dicho fenómeno, contribuyendo a proteger a los menores y su derecho a un desarrollo armónico frente a la industria de la pornografía en Internet. Para ello, en primer lugar se expone el marco normativo aplicable a la cuestión. A continuación, se identifican los principales entes públicos llamados a desempeñar un rol activo en la materia que nos ocupa: el Ministerio de Asuntos Económicos y Transformación Digital (MAETD); la Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD); y la Comisión Nacional de los Mercados y la Competencia (CNMC). En tercer lugar, se analizan las medidas de policía, promoción y servicio público que se vienen adoptando y que podrían adoptarse desde las diferentes Administraciones públicas. El estudio se cierra con unas breves conclusiones, a modo de resumen valorativo. La principal contribución del artículo consiste en presentar de forma ordenada una serie de líneas de actuación a través de las cuales la Administración puede asumir su parte de responsabilidad en la protección de los menores frente a la pornografía en Internet.


  • Open Access

    La objeción de conciencia institucional a la práctica de la Eutanasia: ¿Pretensión abusiva o derecho legítimo?

    by Juan María Martínez Otero

    La aprobación de la Ley Orgánica 3/2021, de 24 de marzo, de regulación de la eutanasia, impone a todos los centros sanitarios el deber de prestar la ayuda para morir a las personas que lo soliciten, al tiempo que cierra la puerta a la objeción de conciencia institucional. El presente artículo se plantea si dicha exclusión resulta coherente con el marco constitucional español. Para ello, (1) se analiza la configuración jurídica del derecho a la objeción de conciencia en el ordenamiento jurídico español; (2) se ofrecen los argumentos a favor y en contra de la objeción institucional; y (3) se realizan algunas precisiones relativas al derecho a objetar de entidades del sector público y de entidades jurídico-privadas que prestan indirectamente servicios públicos en el ámbito de la salud. El artículo concluye señalando que admitir la odc institucional es la opción más acorde con el marco constitucional vigente.


  • Open Access

    Policía, servicio público y fomento en el ejercicio de la función administrativa de la Iglesia. Explorando nuevas formas de sistematización del Derecho Administrativo Canónico

    by Juan Martínez-Otero

    This paper aims to contribute to the discussion on the best way of approaching Canonical Administrative Law, one of the most extensive and recent branches of Canon Law. To this end, it proposes recourse to the traditional forms of administrative intervention used by secular approaches in this area (control, public service and promotion) to categorize the way in which administrative functions are exercised in the Church. The article argues for the suitability of these categories to organize and explain many of the actions of ecclesiastical administrative bodies, as well as to improve their regulation by taking developments in secular law as a standard.

  • Open Access

    A juridical-canonical perspective of internal criticism in the Church: Act of service or treason?

    by Juan María Martínez Otero

    In the last decade, we have witnessed a progressive increase in criticism of the Pope, the hierarchy, and the Roman Curia from within the Church itself. In this context of growing contestation and polarization, this paper addresses the legal-canonical admissibility of internal criticisms of the Church hierarchy. To this end, after first delimiting the concepts of criticism and hierarchy, the normative framework applicable to criticism is then described. This framework is essentially composed of canon 212 § 3 (which recognizes freedom of expression) and the canons 209 § 1, 212 § 1 and 223 § 1 (which establish the duties of communion and obedience). Then, the opportunities and dangers of internal criticism in the Church are analyzed. Finally, a series of criteria that may be useful for discerning the lawfulness of internal criticism in the Church is presented.


  • Fake reviews on online platforms: perspectives from the US, UK and EU legislations

    by Juan María Martínez Otero

    User-generated online reviews have become essential sources of information for potential consumers. Given the increasing importance of online reviews on consumer purchases, some traders try to publish or promote fake reviews on online platforms to improve the reputation of their goods or services, or to damage the reputation of their competitors. This paper aims (1) to analyse whether and how fake reviews violate the main legal and ethical principles of advertising, according to the legislations of the US, UK and EU as well as the International Advertising and Marketing Communications Code; (2) to assess how the EU, the UK and the US are dealing with them, and find out which approaches and actions are working best; and (3) to offer normative recommendations for effective prosecution of fake reviews. The paper uses a combination of theoretical and sociological approaches (section 1), black letter analysis of law (sections 2 and 3) and a comparative approach (sections 2 and 3). Among others, the article observes (1) that fake reviews are a form of illegal advertising and (2) that the European regulatory instruments provide more protection against fake reviews than the US and argues (3) that an effective fight against fake reviews requires strong administrative bodies, endowed with sufficient resources.