Denis Byrne
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Denis Byrne has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Allison Cadzow
University of Technology, Sydney
1 shared publication- Heather Goodall
University of Technology Sydney, Australia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 March 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 29 (4) , 329-345
The migration heritage corridor: transnationalism, modernity and race
Currently, heritage practice brings a nation-centric lens to the heritage of migration, privileging narratives of arrival and settlement over narratives of return, circulatory transnational flows, and cross-border connectivity. Drawing on the case of Chinese migration to Australia in the period from the 1840s to the 1940s, the ‘heritage corridor’ concept is proposed here as an aid in conceptualising a heritage that escapes the nation-state frame of reference. The aspirational modernity of Chinese migrants in this period led them to construct new houses, schools, and infrastructure in their home villages in China using money earned in Australia, even though in Australia at this time Chinese migrants were characterised as premodern misfits by a white majority that saw itself as modern and progressive. In relegating Chinese migrants to the past, white Australia conferred on them a state of non-belonging that I argue is perpetuated in the country’s heritage system by a form of structural racism which, embedded in site listing processes, minimises the visibility of Chinese Australians in the heritage record.
- 8 March 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 29 (4) , 329-345
Open AccessThe migration heritage corridor: transnationalism, modernity and race
Currently, heritage practice brings a nation-centric lens to the heritage of migration, privileging narratives of arrival and settlement over narratives of return, circulatory transnational flows, and cross-border connectivity. Drawing on the case of Chinese migration to Australia in the period from the 1840s to the 1940s, the ‘heritage corridor’ concept is proposed here as an aid in conceptualising a heritage that escapes the nation-state frame of reference. The aspirational modernity of Chinese migrants in this period led them to construct new houses, schools, and infrastructure in their home villages in China using money earned in Australia, even though in Australia at this time Chinese migrants were characterised as premodern misfits by a white majority that saw itself as modern and progressive. In relegating Chinese migrants to the past, white Australia conferred on them a state of non-belonging that I argue is perpetuated in the country’s heritage system by a form of structural racism which, embedded in site listing processes, minimises the visibility of Chinese Australians in the heritage record.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 14-32
Transborder lives and materialities
The focus of this chapter is on the lives of four individual migrants each of whom departed Zhongshan County, in Guangdong Province, for Australia in the century after 1840. In examining the trajectories of their lives, attention is on the material imprint they left in the places they lived and worked in Australia and on the places they continued to be associated with in China. In reviewing these trajectories, it becomes clear that for these people the act of migration was not conceived as a one-way journey but rather as an extension of their existing lives across transnational space. First-generation Chinese migrants tended to make multiple return visits back to China, some ultimately returned there permanently, and all tended to maintain close relations with relatives in their home villages. It becomes clear that key sites that populated the lifelines of these migrants – whether located in Australia or China – cannot be considered in isolation from each other. The connectivity between them is the basis for thinking of these sites as collectively forming a ‘heritage corridor’ comprising an array of transnationally distributed places.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 14-32
Transborder lives and materialities
The focus of this chapter is on the lives of four individual migrants each of whom departed Zhongshan County, in Guangdong Province, for Australia in the century after 1840. In examining the trajectories of their lives, attention is on the material imprint they left in the places they lived and worked in Australia and on the places they continued to be associated with in China. In reviewing these trajectories, it becomes clear that for these people the act of migration was not conceived as a one-way journey but rather as an extension of their existing lives across transnational space. First-generation Chinese migrants tended to make multiple return visits back to China, some ultimately returned there permanently, and all tended to maintain close relations with relatives in their home villages. It becomes clear that key sites that populated the lifelines of these migrants – whether located in Australia or China – cannot be considered in isolation from each other. The connectivity between them is the basis for thinking of these sites as collectively forming a ‘heritage corridor’ comprising an array of transnationally distributed places.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 88-103
Diasporic modernity
From the 18th century, China and Chinese culture were categorised by the West, via discourses of alterity and Orientalism, as the Other of what the West saw as its own progressive modernity. Chinese architecture, old and new, was seen as representing a culture mired in tradition and incapable of progress. It is argued here that the heritage of Chinese migrants in destination counties such as the USA, Canada and Australia has been similarly constructed as representing a timeless Oriental culture, an interpretation that is at odds with the self-identification of Chinese migrants as modern subjects. The Chinatowns of San Francisco, Vancouver and Sydney are shown to be exemplars of the Orientalist portrayal of an essential Chineseness. It is proposed that heritage experts in Australia have focused on structures such as temples and mosques to stress the difference of non-Anglo migrant cultures from an implied core Anglo culture which remains unalloyed by multiculturalism. It is argued that the ‘core culture’ construct has its counterpart in a ‘core heritage’ practice, a form of heritage practice that is overly concerned with difference and privileges the original form of old buildings over the material traces of their modification by migrants.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 88-103
Diasporic modernity
From the 18th century, China and Chinese culture were categorised by the West, via discourses of alterity and Orientalism, as the Other of what the West saw as its own progressive modernity. Chinese architecture, old and new, was seen as representing a culture mired in tradition and incapable of progress. It is argued here that the heritage of Chinese migrants in destination counties such as the USA, Canada and Australia has been similarly constructed as representing a timeless Oriental culture, an interpretation that is at odds with the self-identification of Chinese migrants as modern subjects. The Chinatowns of San Francisco, Vancouver and Sydney are shown to be exemplars of the Orientalist portrayal of an essential Chineseness. It is proposed that heritage experts in Australia have focused on structures such as temples and mosques to stress the difference of non-Anglo migrant cultures from an implied core Anglo culture which remains unalloyed by multiculturalism. It is argued that the ‘core culture’ construct has its counterpart in a ‘core heritage’ practice, a form of heritage practice that is overly concerned with difference and privileges the original form of old buildings over the material traces of their modification by migrants.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 104-121
Making heritage in the transnational landscape of migration
In this concluding chapter, Australia’s multiculturalist framing of migrant heritage is described as one based on a narrative of migrant arrival and settlement that excludes the history of ongoing engagement by migrants in the life of their origin countries. This is compared with China’s interpretation of the many old buildings constructed by ‘overseas Chinese’ in their home villages and towns as representing their ongoing loyalty to China. It is argued that both approaches are fundamentally nationalist. This book’s framing of migration heritage in terms of cross-border flows is offered as an alternative. As an illustration of these flows, and of the heritage corridor approach, an account is given of the connectivity between a particular street in Sydney’s Chinatown and a street in downtown Zhongshan. Tim Ingold’s ‘meshwork’ concept is then discussed in relation to its usefulness in depicting, from a material heritage perspective, the mobility of migrant lives and the links between migrant-associated sites situated at either end of a migration corridor. The chapter concludes with a proposition for using the meshwork concept in the development of a museum of Chinese migration to be situated in a building in Sydney’s Chinatown that formerly housed a remittance agency.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 104-121
Making heritage in the transnational landscape of migration
In this concluding chapter, Australia’s multiculturalist framing of migrant heritage is described as one based on a narrative of migrant arrival and settlement that excludes the history of ongoing engagement by migrants in the life of their origin countries. This is compared with China’s interpretation of the many old buildings constructed by ‘overseas Chinese’ in their home villages and towns as representing their ongoing loyalty to China. It is argued that both approaches are fundamentally nationalist. This book’s framing of migration heritage in terms of cross-border flows is offered as an alternative. As an illustration of these flows, and of the heritage corridor approach, an account is given of the connectivity between a particular street in Sydney’s Chinatown and a street in downtown Zhongshan. Tim Ingold’s ‘meshwork’ concept is then discussed in relation to its usefulness in depicting, from a material heritage perspective, the mobility of migrant lives and the links between migrant-associated sites situated at either end of a migration corridor. The chapter concludes with a proposition for using the meshwork concept in the development of a museum of Chinese migration to be situated in a building in Sydney’s Chinatown that formerly housed a remittance agency.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 26 (9) , 857-873
Divinely significant: towards a postsecular approach to the materiality of popular religion in Asia
The material embeddedness of the divine in the objects and sites of popular religion in Asia establishes the grounds for a conflict between devotees and heritage practitioners - the same objects are central to the practice of each but each hones in on them via a radically different ontology. While in principle offering an even-handed consideration of all aspects of a thing's meaning, the secular-rationalist underpinning of the practice of significance-assessment in heritage management acts to marginalise or even efface the eruptively miraculous qualities of divine sites and objects. It serves, in other words, as a regime of insignificance. Against this background, I argue that the posthuman turn in the humanities and social sciences, and in particular its openness to forms of agency, vibrancy and vitality in the object world, offers prospects for a kind of heritage practice newly comfortable with the vibrancy that belief in the supernatural lends to the things of popular religion. There has, I suggest, never been a better time for heritage practice to get over its problem with the supernatural.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 26 (9) , 857-873
Divinely significant: towards a postsecular approach to the materiality of popular religion in Asia
The material embeddedness of the divine in the objects and sites of popular religion in Asia establishes the grounds for a conflict between devotees and heritage practitioners - the same objects are central to the practice of each but each hones in on them via a radically different ontology. While in principle offering an even-handed consideration of all aspects of a thing's meaning, the secular-rationalist underpinning of the practice of significance-assessment in heritage management acts to marginalise or even efface the eruptively miraculous qualities of divine sites and objects. It serves, in other words, as a regime of insignificance. Against this background, I argue that the posthuman turn in the humanities and social sciences, and in particular its openness to forms of agency, vibrancy and vitality in the object world, offers prospects for a kind of heritage practice newly comfortable with the vibrancy that belief in the supernatural lends to the things of popular religion. There has, I suggest, never been a better time for heritage practice to get over its problem with the supernatural.
- 3 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fabrications
- Vol. 30 (2) , 176-201
Dream Houses in China: Migrant-built Houses in Zhongshan County (1890s–1940s) as Transnationally “Distributed” Entities
The hundreds of houses built in their home villages by people who had migrated from Zhongshan County, China, to Australia between the mid-nineteenth century and the 1940s represent a remarkable record of transnational flows. Beginning as enlarged versions of vernacular houses, by the 1920s many of the houses were being built in a neoclassical style based on reinforced concrete frames. It is argued here that these houses drew inspiration not from Australia as a country but from a colonial architectural milieu in which Australia participated. The relation of the Zhongshan houses to Australian architecture was to a large degree one of simultaneity rather than a unilinear flow of influence. It is proposed that the houses represent a transnationally “distributed” form of heritage that provokes a rethinking of the conventional approach to migrant heritage in places like Australia where a unilinear, one-way narrative of migration has been imposed, a narrative which disregards the ongoing history of transnational mobility and belonging that is common to many or most peoples’ experience of migration.
- 3 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fabrications
- Vol. 30 (2) , 176-201
Dream Houses in China: Migrant-built Houses in Zhongshan County (1890s–1940s) as Transnationally “Distributed” Entities
The hundreds of houses built in their home villages by people who had migrated from Zhongshan County, China, to Australia between the mid-nineteenth century and the 1940s represent a remarkable record of transnational flows. Beginning as enlarged versions of vernacular houses, by the 1920s many of the houses were being built in a neoclassical style based on reinforced concrete frames. It is argued here that these houses drew inspiration not from Australia as a country but from a colonial architectural milieu in which Australia participated. The relation of the Zhongshan houses to Australian architecture was to a large degree one of simultaneity rather than a unilinear flow of influence. It is proposed that the houses represent a transnationally “distributed” form of heritage that provokes a rethinking of the conventional approach to migrant heritage in places like Australia where a unilinear, one-way narrative of migration has been imposed, a narrative which disregards the ongoing history of transnational mobility and belonging that is common to many or most peoples’ experience of migration.
- Open Access
Prospects for a Postsecular Heritage Practice: Convergences between Posthumanism and Popular Religious Practice in Asia
By failing to document popular belief in the supernatural attributes of religious sites and by drawing up conservation management plans that fail to attend to such beliefs, current heritage regimes effectively perform a secular translation of them. I argue that the posthuman turn in the humanities and social sciences, and in particular its openness to forms of agency, vibrancy and vitality in the object world, offers prospects for a kind of heritage practice newly comfortable with the vibrancy that belief in the supernatural lends to the things of popular religion. Focusing on the material heritage of popular religion in Asia—in particular in China and Southeast Asia—attitudes of devotees to the rebuilding of temples and shrines are examined. Practices of rebuilding and restoration come to be seen as a form of worship. While ontological differences between worshipers and heritage practitioners remain, it is possible to be positive about the prospects for a postsecular heritage practice precisely because the rationalist authority of established practice is so under challenge by the counter discourses of posthumanism, the new materialism, and related streams of thought.
Open AccessProspects for a Postsecular Heritage Practice: Convergences between Posthumanism and Popular Religious Practice in Asia
By failing to document popular belief in the supernatural attributes of religious sites and by drawing up conservation management plans that fail to attend to such beliefs, current heritage regimes effectively perform a secular translation of them. I argue that the posthuman turn in the humanities and social sciences, and in particular its openness to forms of agency, vibrancy and vitality in the object world, offers prospects for a kind of heritage practice newly comfortable with the vibrancy that belief in the supernatural lends to the things of popular religion. Focusing on the material heritage of popular religion in Asia—in particular in China and Southeast Asia—attitudes of devotees to the rebuilding of temples and shrines are examined. Practices of rebuilding and restoration come to be seen as a form of worship. While ontological differences between worshipers and heritage practitioners remain, it is possible to be positive about the prospects for a postsecular heritage practice precisely because the rationalist authority of established practice is so under challenge by the counter discourses of posthumanism, the new materialism, and related streams of thought.
- 11 September 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 25 (6) , 628-630
Consensus building, negotiation, and conflict resolution for heritage place management
This volume is the proceedings of a workshop held at the Getty Conservation Institute in Los Angeles in 2009 as part of a move to introduce consensus building concepts and techniques to the heritag...
- 11 September 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Heritage Studies
- Vol. 25 (6) , 628-630
Consensus building, negotiation, and conflict resolution for heritage place management
This volume is the proceedings of a workshop held at the Getty Conservation Institute in Los Angeles in 2009 as part of a move to introduce consensus building concepts and techniques to the heritag...
- 4 June 2018
- Published by Equinox Publishing in Journal of Contemporary Archaeology
- Vol. 5 (1) , 53-65
Time on the Waterline
- 4 June 2018
- Published by Equinox Publishing in Journal of Contemporary Archaeology
- Vol. 5 (1) , 53-65
Time on the Waterline