Cornelia E. Farnum

Two positional characteristics of the ciliary axoneme—its location on the plasma membrane as it emerges from the cell, and its orientation in three‐dimensional (3D) space—are known to be critical for optimal function of actively motile cilia (including nodal cilia), as well as for modified cilia associated with special senses. However, these positional characteristics have not been analyzed to any significant extent for primary cilia. This review briefly summarizes the history of knowledge of these two positional characteristics across a wide spectrum of cilia, emphasizing their importance for proper function. Then the review focuses what is known about these same positional characteristics for primary cilia in all major tissue types where they have been reported. The review emphasizes major areas that would be productive for future research for understanding how positioning and 3D orientation of primary cilia may be related to their hypothesized signaling roles within different cellular populations. Developmental Dynamics 240:2405–2431, 2011.

Primary cilia have functions as sensory organelles integral to signal transduction and establishment of cell polarity. In articular cartilage the primary cilium has been hypothesized to function as an antenna to sense the biomechanical environment, regulate the secretion of extracellular matrix components, and maintain cellular positional information, leading to high tissue anisotropy. We used analysis of electron microscopy serial sections to demonstrate positional attributes of the primary cilium of adult equine articular chondrocytes in situ. Data for ∼500 axonemes, comparing superficial to radiate chondrocytes from both load‐bearing and non‐load‐bearing regions, were graphed using spherical co‐ordinates θ, φ. The data demonstrate the axoneme has a definable orientation in 3D space differing in superficial and radiate zone chondrocytes, cells that differ by 90° in the orientation of their major axes to the articular surface. Axonemal orientation is more definable in load‐bearing than in non‐load‐bearing areas. The position of emergence of the axoneme from the cell also is variable. In load‐bearing regions of the superficial zone, extension of the axoneme is from the cellular side facing the subchondral bone. In radiate zone cells, axonemes extend from either face of the chondrocyte, that is, both toward the articular surface or toward the subchondral bone. In non‐load‐bearing regions this consistency is lost. These observations relate to current hypotheses concerning establishment of tissue anisotropy in articular cartilage during development, involving both migration of cells from the joint periphery and a restricted zone of division within the tissue resulting in the columnar arrangement of radiate zone cells. Anat Rec, 2011.

Bones elongate postnatally by endochondral ossification as cells of the cartilaginous growth plate undergo a differentiation cascade of proliferation, cellular hypertrophy and matrix synthesis. Interspecific comparisons of homologous bones elongating at different rates has been a useful approach for studying the dynamics of this process. The purpose of this study was to measure quantitative stereological parameters of growth plates of the third digit of the manus and pes of the laboratory mouse, and make comparisons to chondrocytic performance parameters in the homologous bones of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus, where extremely rapid postnatal elongation of bones of the manus is associated with skeletal modifications for powered flight. Measurements were made across all zones of forelimb and hindlimb autopod growth plates by dividing each growth plate into strata of equal height (from thirteen 200-µm-high strata in the metacarpus to five 40-µm-high strata in phalangeal bones of the pes). Results indicate that all chondrocytic performance parameters known to quantitatively contribute to the elongation potential of a growth plate change together. A significant finding was that in growth plates of the chiropteran manus, final hypertrophic cell size and shape were achieved early in the zone of hypertrophy, indicating that interstitial expansion of the growth plate resulting from the incremental chondrocytic height increase in the direction of elongation was completed soon after the transition from the cessation of proliferation to the initiation of hypertrophy. This is unlike what has been reported in most mammalian growth plates previously analyzed, but is the situation in the proximal tibial growth plate of rapidly growing frogs and precocial birds. This suggests that a similar adaptation for stabilization of a rapidly elongating bone has evolved independently in three widely separated groups that have in common rapid growth in limbs to be used for early active, powered locomotion.

The morphology of the chiropteran forelimb demonstrates musculoskeletal specializations for powered flight essentially unique among mammals, including extreme elongation of the distal skeletal elements. Recent studies have focused primarily on the relative timing and levels of gene expression during early stages of endochondral ossification in the chiropteran embryo for clues to the molecular basis of the evolutionary origins of flight in these species. The goal of the current study was to examine how elongation of skeletal elements of the forelimb autopod is achieved through a combination of cellular proliferation, cellular enlargement and matrix synthesis during a period of rapid postnatal growth in Eptesicus fuscus. Quantitative analyses were done of multiple performance parameters of growth plate chondrocytes during all phases of the differentiation cascade. Fourteen autopodial growth plates from the forelimb and hindlimb of one individual, as well as the proximal tibial growth plate, were collected and analyzed. Significant differences were seen in all performance parameters examined. Particularly striking were the differences between growth plates of the manus and pes in the size of the pool of chondrocytes in all cellular zones and rates of turnover of terminal cells. The magnitude of hypertrophy of chondrocytes in growth plates of the manus in E. fuscus far exceeded what has been reported previously in any species, even in rapidly elongating rodent long bones. Volume changes approaching ×70 and height changes of 50–60 µm/cell (paralleling the direction of growth) occurred after proliferation in the most rapidly growing growth plates. The data demonstrate that final differences in lengths of homologous skeletal elements in the autopod of the forelimb and hindlimb of this species result not just from an initiating factor early in development, but from continued quantitative differences in chondrocytic performance during postnatal bone elongation as measured by multiple kinetic-based parameters.

Bone elongation by endochondral ossification occurs through the differentiation cascade of chondrocytes of cartilaginous growth plates. Molecules from the systemic vasculature reach the growth plate from three different directions: epiphyseal, metaphyseal, and a ring vessel and plexus associated with the perichondrium. This study is an analysis of the real‐time dynamics of entrance of fluoresceinated tracers of different molecular weights into the growth plate from the systemic vasculature and tests the hypothesis that molecular weight is a key variable in the determination of both the directionality and the extent of tracer movement into the growth plate. Multiphoton microscopy was used for direct in vivo imaging of the murine proximal tibial growth plate in anesthetized 4‐ to 5‐week‐old transgenic mice with green fluorescent protein linked to the collagen II promoter. Mice were given an intracardiac injection of either fluorescein (332.3 Da) or fluoresceinated dextrans of 3, 10, 40, 70 kDa, singly or sequentially. For each tracer, directionality and rate of arrival, together with extent of movement within the growth plate, were imaged in real time. For small molecules (up to 10 kDa), vascular access from all three directions was observed and entrance was equally permissive from the metaphyseal and the epiphyseal sides. Within our detection limit (a few percent of vascular concentration), 40 kDa and larger dextrans did not enter. These results have implications both for understanding systemic and paracrine regulation of growth plate chondrocytic differentiation, as well as variables associated with effective drug delivery to growth plate chondrocytes.

Although it has been demonstrated clinically that controlled compression across a growth plate will slow the rate of endochondral ossification and thus can be used to correct angular limb deformities, the cellular-based mechanism by which altered growth is achieved is poorly understood. This study used short-term uniaxial stapling of the rat proximal tibial growth plate as an experimental system to study chondrocytic responses in the growth plate that account quantitatively for the decreased rate of growth. Growth plates were labeled with oxytetracycline to measure bone growth, and with bromodeoxyuridine to analyze proliferative cell kinetics. Multiple indicators of chondrocytic activity, measured by stereological parameters, were analyzed using growth rate as the primary dependent variable. The unique feature of this analysis was the creation of three-dimensional reconstructions that allowed analysis of data in all directions with distance from the staple. A significant observation was that for the entire operated limb after both 3 and 6 days, all chondrocytic kinetic parameters were affected, indicating that proliferative and hypertrophic responses both act to decrease growth rate in response to stapling. This contradicted our hypothesis that proliferative and hypertrophic responses could occur independently, and that small changes in rate would be attributed primarily to the former and large changes to the latter. The data from this study also demonstrate that volume regulation during hypertrophy can be affected by a primarily mechanical perturbation. Because changes in hypertrophic cell number and volume throughout the growth plate that occur by day 3 remain similar at day 6, the initial modulation of chondrocytic volume and shape may represent the limit of the response while maintaining a growth plate capable of continued growth.