Tamás Molnár
Tamás Molnár has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ramses A. Wessel
University of Groningen
13 shared publications - Daniela Vitiello
Department of Law and Humanities, University of Tuscia, 01100 Viterbo, Italy
1 shared publication - Marion Panizzon
University of Bern
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 11 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 147-172
Algorithmic Decision-Making in Migration and Security in the EU: Challenges in Ensuring Effective Legal Remedies
- 11 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 147-172
Algorithmic Decision-Making in Migration and Security in the EU: Challenges in Ensuring Effective Legal Remedies
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 199-224
Intra-EU responsibility of member states under EU law and international law
In addition to the international responsibility of the EU as an entity, there are many situations in which the EU Member States may face responsibility under international law, either as ‘EU Member States’ or as sovereign ‘states’. This Chapter takes the Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (ARSIWA) as a starting point in analysing the way in which international law deals with the responsibilities of EU Member States in the various identities they have in relation to the EU. The question of the application of international rules not only occurs in relation to non-EU Member States (‘third states’), but also between EU Member States, in intra-EU situations not covered by EU law. At the same time, when issues are covered by EU law, questions on the hierarchy of norms occur, for instance on whether the ARISWA rules are to be regarded as a residual, fall-back regime filling in some gaps; or whether the EU can be regarded as a ‘self-contained regime’ in these matters. This chapter thus analyses the applicable international and EU law rules to situations of Member States responsibility.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 199-224
Intra-EU responsibility of member states under EU law and international law
In addition to the international responsibility of the EU as an entity, there are many situations in which the EU Member States may face responsibility under international law, either as ‘EU Member States’ or as sovereign ‘states’. This Chapter takes the Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (ARSIWA) as a starting point in analysing the way in which international law deals with the responsibilities of EU Member States in the various identities they have in relation to the EU. The question of the application of international rules not only occurs in relation to non-EU Member States (‘third states’), but also between EU Member States, in intra-EU situations not covered by EU law. At the same time, when issues are covered by EU law, questions on the hierarchy of norms occur, for instance on whether the ARISWA rules are to be regarded as a residual, fall-back regime filling in some gaps; or whether the EU can be regarded as a ‘self-contained regime’ in these matters. This chapter thus analyses the applicable international and EU law rules to situations of Member States responsibility.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Interactions Between EU Law and International Law
"Interactions Between EU Law and International Law" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Interactions Between EU Law and International Law
"Interactions Between EU Law and International Law" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Index
"Index" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Index
"Index" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 175-198
The international responsibility of the European Union
As an international organisation, the EU is responsible for any wrongful acts under international law. However, due to the division of competences between the EU and its Member States, attributing responsibilities to the Union has traditionally been complex. This Chapter examines the rules of international law on the responsibility of international organisations and applies them to the European Union - to the extent they fit. It addresses specific situations in which EU’s responsibility may be triggered on the basis of international treaty law (as lex specialis), taking into account rules of attribution that are for instance relevant in the case of EU military missions. With the increasing number and variety of international activities of the Union, questions of its responsibility on the international plane become more prominent. A key question in this Chapter is to what extent the law on international responsibility is capable of grasping the complex internal structure of the EU.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 175-198
The international responsibility of the European Union
As an international organisation, the EU is responsible for any wrongful acts under international law. However, due to the division of competences between the EU and its Member States, attributing responsibilities to the Union has traditionally been complex. This Chapter examines the rules of international law on the responsibility of international organisations and applies them to the European Union - to the extent they fit. It addresses specific situations in which EU’s responsibility may be triggered on the basis of international treaty law (as lex specialis), taking into account rules of attribution that are for instance relevant in the case of EU military missions. With the increasing number and variety of international activities of the Union, questions of its responsibility on the international plane become more prominent. A key question in this Chapter is to what extent the law on international responsibility is capable of grasping the complex internal structure of the EU.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 259-268
Conclusions and future perspectives on the interactions between EU law and international law
While the previous chapters analysed different aspects and dimensions of the interactions between EU law and international law, this final Chapter concludes on the dynamic and consequences. Indeed, allowing a ‘regional integration organisation’ such as the EU, with its specific characteristics, to play along in an international legal system that is largely composed of states (and ‘ordinary’ international organisations), poses a number of challenges. This concluding chapter first of all maps these challenges that are all more or less related to the EU’s exceptionalism. These include the Union’s claim for legal autonomy, its difficult participation in international dispute settlement mechanisms, the burden laid on international partners having to accept ‘mixed agreements’ (as well as related declarations of competences or disconnection clauses), and ways to deal with treaty conflicts or with an unclear division of international responsibilities between the Union and its members. The Chapter then presents a number of possible solutions to the challenges that emerge from the EU’s presence and activities in the international legal system. Linking back to the observations in the introductory Chapter, this ‘farewell’ chapter provides a comprehensive overview and summary of the different ways in which EU law and international law interact, from both directions, also with a view to future developments.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 259-268
Conclusions and future perspectives on the interactions between EU law and international law
While the previous chapters analysed different aspects and dimensions of the interactions between EU law and international law, this final Chapter concludes on the dynamic and consequences. Indeed, allowing a ‘regional integration organisation’ such as the EU, with its specific characteristics, to play along in an international legal system that is largely composed of states (and ‘ordinary’ international organisations), poses a number of challenges. This concluding chapter first of all maps these challenges that are all more or less related to the EU’s exceptionalism. These include the Union’s claim for legal autonomy, its difficult participation in international dispute settlement mechanisms, the burden laid on international partners having to accept ‘mixed agreements’ (as well as related declarations of competences or disconnection clauses), and ways to deal with treaty conflicts or with an unclear division of international responsibilities between the Union and its members. The Chapter then presents a number of possible solutions to the challenges that emerge from the EU’s presence and activities in the international legal system. Linking back to the observations in the introductory Chapter, this ‘farewell’ chapter provides a comprehensive overview and summary of the different ways in which EU law and international law interact, from both directions, also with a view to future developments.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 80-103
Division of competences between the EU and its member states and international law
Perhaps the most complex - and for third states and international organisations perhaps at times annoying - feature of the European Union (EU) is the division of competences with its Member States. Because of this division, for each and every international agreement it needs to be decided whether it can be concluded by the EU at all, and if so, whether it can be concluded by the EU only, or Member States need to become parties as well. The latter situation leads to the famous ‘mixed agreements’, which from an EU perspective make perfect sense, but have raised a number of questions under international law (e.g. treaty law and the law of international responsibility). This chapter brings the various aspects of international law and EU law requirements together in relation to joint and separate agreements concluded by the EU and its Member States. In particular, it aims to assess the rationale of the division of competences and what methods exist, or can be further developed, to reassuringly deal with this situation - both in relation to international agreements as well as in international organisations in which the Union participates (or in which Member States participate on behalf of the Union).
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 80-103
Division of competences between the EU and its member states and international law
Perhaps the most complex - and for third states and international organisations perhaps at times annoying - feature of the European Union (EU) is the division of competences with its Member States. Because of this division, for each and every international agreement it needs to be decided whether it can be concluded by the EU at all, and if so, whether it can be concluded by the EU only, or Member States need to become parties as well. The latter situation leads to the famous ‘mixed agreements’, which from an EU perspective make perfect sense, but have raised a number of questions under international law (e.g. treaty law and the law of international responsibility). This chapter brings the various aspects of international law and EU law requirements together in relation to joint and separate agreements concluded by the EU and its Member States. In particular, it aims to assess the rationale of the division of competences and what methods exist, or can be further developed, to reassuringly deal with this situation - both in relation to international agreements as well as in international organisations in which the Union participates (or in which Member States participate on behalf of the Union).
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Bibliography
"Bibliography" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Bibliography
"Bibliography" published on 04 Oct 2024 by Edward Elgar Publishing.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 225-258
The interactions between EU law and international law in context: two case studies
On the basis of two case studies, this Chapter investigates the interactions between EU law and international law in practice. By looking at a substantive field (migration and refugee law), the Chapter aims to show how rules work at different (meso-)levels. Following that, analysing a more procedural field (international dispute settlement), the Chapter reveals the many practical problems that need to be overcome when an international organisation enters into international dispute settlement mechanisms that were largely designed for state actors. Both case studies continue to shift the vantage point from international law to EU law.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 225-258
The interactions between EU law and international law in context: two case studies
On the basis of two case studies, this Chapter investigates the interactions between EU law and international law in practice. By looking at a substantive field (migration and refugee law), the Chapter aims to show how rules work at different (meso-)levels. Following that, analysing a more procedural field (international dispute settlement), the Chapter reveals the many practical problems that need to be overcome when an international organisation enters into international dispute settlement mechanisms that were largely designed for state actors. Both case studies continue to shift the vantage point from international law to EU law.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 1-26
Introduction: comparing international law and European Union (EU) law
This Chapter sets the stage by introducing the origins of the distinction between international law and EU law, mainly as a result of the early EU claims to have established ‘a separate legal order, distinct from international law’. What does it mean for the EU to have a separate (autonomous) legal order, with its special characteristics; and how is this perceived from the vantage point of general international law and non-EU states and international organisations? What exactly is it that makes the EU law different from international law and is the clear line of separation that is often drawn supported by empirical evidence? This Chapter compares EU law and international law on various conceptual accounts. It clearly points to the differences, but equally highlights features of EU law that reveal a clear presence of traditional public international law elements in the functioning of the EU legal order, both internally and in its relations with third parties and the international community.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 1-26
Introduction: comparing international law and European Union (EU) law
This Chapter sets the stage by introducing the origins of the distinction between international law and EU law, mainly as a result of the early EU claims to have established ‘a separate legal order, distinct from international law’. What does it mean for the EU to have a separate (autonomous) legal order, with its special characteristics; and how is this perceived from the vantage point of general international law and non-EU states and international organisations? What exactly is it that makes the EU law different from international law and is the clear line of separation that is often drawn supported by empirical evidence? This Chapter compares EU law and international law on various conceptual accounts. It clearly points to the differences, but equally highlights features of EU law that reveal a clear presence of traditional public international law elements in the functioning of the EU legal order, both internally and in its relations with third parties and the international community.