Toralf Renkwitz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Toralf Renkwitz has a total of 163 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ralph Latteck
Leibniz Institute of Atmospheric Physics University of Rostock Kühlungsborn Germany
52 shared publications Jorge L. Chau
33 shared publications- Christoph Jacobi
Institute for Meteorology Leipzig University Leipzig Germany
23 shared publications - Masaki Tsutsumi
National Institute of Polar Research, Tachikawa, Japan
21 shared publications - Juliana Jaen
Leibniz-Institute of Atmospheric Physics at the University of Rostock, Schloss-Strasse 6, 18225 Kühlungsborn, Germany
18 shared publications - Robin Wing
Leibniz Institute for Atmospheric Physics, Schloßstraße 6, 18225 Kühlungsborn, Germany
16 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Annales Geophysicae
- Vol. 44 (2) , 1315-1330
The SuperDARN Meteor Wind Product: A 31-year archive with modeled altitude contributions and validation
Radar echoes from meteor plasma trails constitute one of the main sources of observations of winds in the mesosphere-lower thermosphere. A new 31-year archive of meteor wind observations has been prepared from data taken at 38 Super Dual Auroral Radar Network (SuperDARN) sites, covering 1993–2024. These observations are not height-resolved, and so an empirical meteor model has been produced to estimate the altitude contribution function, in other words the meteor count distribution. The meteor count model RMSEs were estimated at 0.67 km for the peak height and 1.53 km for the full width at half maximum, based on a validation against independent meteor radar data. The SuperDARN wind observations have been compared against nearby dedicated meteor radar data, with the meteor profiles averaged using the observed count distribution, and against JAWARA reanalysis winds using the new meteor count model. Two case-study comparisons were performed: one for the Andenes meteor radar versus Hankasalmi SuperDARN radar in 2008, and one for the McMurdo meteor radar versus McMurdo SuperDARN radar in 2019. The three datasets were found to be in moderate to strong agreement, with correlations ranging from 0.73–0.90 for the comparison of SuperDARN against the meteor radars and 0.45–0.70 for the comparison of SuperDARN against JAWARA. A summertime equatorward mean flow of 5–15 m s −1 was identified in the northern hemisphere SuperDARN data, consistent with previous reports.
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Annales Geophysicae
- Vol. 44 (2) , 1315-1330
Open AccessThe SuperDARN Meteor Wind Product: A 31-year archive with modeled altitude contributions and validation
Radar echoes from meteor plasma trails constitute one of the main sources of observations of winds in the mesosphere-lower thermosphere. A new 31-year archive of meteor wind observations has been prepared from data taken at 38 Super Dual Auroral Radar Network (SuperDARN) sites, covering 1993–2024. These observations are not height-resolved, and so an empirical meteor model has been produced to estimate the altitude contribution function, in other words the meteor count distribution. The meteor count model RMSEs were estimated at 0.67 km for the peak height and 1.53 km for the full width at half maximum, based on a validation against independent meteor radar data. The SuperDARN wind observations have been compared against nearby dedicated meteor radar data, with the meteor profiles averaged using the observed count distribution, and against JAWARA reanalysis winds using the new meteor count model. Two case-study comparisons were performed: one for the Andenes meteor radar versus Hankasalmi SuperDARN radar in 2008, and one for the McMurdo meteor radar versus McMurdo SuperDARN radar in 2019. The three datasets were found to be in moderate to strong agreement, with correlations ranging from 0.73–0.90 for the comparison of SuperDARN against the meteor radars and 0.45–0.70 for the comparison of SuperDARN against JAWARA. A summertime equatorward mean flow of 5–15 m s −1 was identified in the northern hemisphere SuperDARN data, consistent with previous reports.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
On the applicability of a high-resolution whole-atmosphere model for the development of an empirical D Region emulator
State-of-the-art empirical models of the D region are derived from sounding rocket measurements, which are inherently limited in temporal and spatial coverage. Recent advancements in high-resolution whole-atmosphere modeling promise an improved representation of the mesosphere and thereby also the D region electron density; however, at the cost of high computational demands. We show that the high-resolution configuration of the Whole Atmosphere Climate Community Model with thermosphere and ionosphere extension using a Spherical Elements dycore (SE-WACCM-X) reproduces the Microwave Limb Sounder and Michelson Interferometer for Passive Atmospheric Spectroscopy atmospheric climatology at D region altitudes well. We develop an empirical electron density model, the Neustrelitz D region emulator (NEDE), and apply a 1-year nature run, with fixed solar and geomagnetic conditions, of SE-WACCM-X as an initial data source. The emulator is an annular model, performing separate fits on a pre-defined altitude-latitude grid to handle the strong electron density gradients in these dimensions. The baseline electron density variation with longitude, universal time, and day of year is modeled using trigonometric functions, with linear correction terms for temperature and nitric oxide density. We evaluate NEDE using D region electron density measurements from the Saura partial reflection radar, sounding rocket measurements, and the state-of-the-art Faraday-International Reference Ionosphere (FIRI) model. NEDE reproduces the measurements with an accuracy comparable to or better than FIRI. Future efforts in high-resolution modeling will allow incorporating solar and geomagnetic activity into NEDE, and the application of extended ion chemistry models will improve the D region representation of both SE-WACCM-X and NEDE.
- 11 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessOn the applicability of a high-resolution whole-atmosphere model for the development of an empirical D Region emulator
State-of-the-art empirical models of the D region are derived from sounding rocket measurements, which are inherently limited in temporal and spatial coverage. Recent advancements in high-resolution whole-atmosphere modeling promise an improved representation of the mesosphere and thereby also the D region electron density; however, at the cost of high computational demands. We show that the high-resolution configuration of the Whole Atmosphere Climate Community Model with thermosphere and ionosphere extension using a Spherical Elements dycore (SE-WACCM-X) reproduces the Microwave Limb Sounder and Michelson Interferometer for Passive Atmospheric Spectroscopy atmospheric climatology at D region altitudes well. We develop an empirical electron density model, the Neustrelitz D region emulator (NEDE), and apply a 1-year nature run, with fixed solar and geomagnetic conditions, of SE-WACCM-X as an initial data source. The emulator is an annular model, performing separate fits on a pre-defined altitude-latitude grid to handle the strong electron density gradients in these dimensions. The baseline electron density variation with longitude, universal time, and day of year is modeled using trigonometric functions, with linear correction terms for temperature and nitric oxide density. We evaluate NEDE using D region electron density measurements from the Saura partial reflection radar, sounding rocket measurements, and the state-of-the-art Faraday-International Reference Ionosphere (FIRI) model. NEDE reproduces the measurements with an accuracy comparable to or better than FIRI. Future efforts in high-resolution modeling will allow incorporating solar and geomagnetic activity into NEDE, and the application of extended ion chemistry models will improve the D region representation of both SE-WACCM-X and NEDE.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Reply on RC1
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC1
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Reply on RC2
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC2
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Reply on RC2
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC2
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- Open Access
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 26 (13) , 9571-9587
Automated detection of low-altitude isolated mesospheric radar echoes using YOLOv8: evidence for an ionospheric “C layer” phenomenon below 60 km altitude?
The Earth's ionosphere is created by incident solar radiation and extends from approximately 60 to 800 km altitude. Within the ionosphere distinct regions are formed based on the number density of the dominant chemical species and their ionisation by the incident solar ultraviolet radiation and X-rays. The generally accepted lowermost ionospheric region is called D region and extends during daytime from, for example, 90 km downwards to approximately 60 km. Previous studies suggested the presence of an ionospheric C layer around 60 km mostly for observations at very low frequencies. In recent years, rather faint echoes from below the typically altitude-continuous D region have been observed during the sunlit period using a monostatic 3.17 MHz ground-based radar system at polar latitudes. The aim of this study is to distinguish radar echoes from altitudes near 60 km from regular D region echoes and attribute them to a possible C layer source. To our knowledge, this study might be the first systematic investigation of such a phenomenon through monostatic radar observations. Following an initial manual inspection of the raw data and the corresponding radar image spectra, an automated deep learning approach was developed and employed to detect these isolated low-altitude echoes. We used the pattern recognition tool YOLO (You Only Look Once) to gain statistical information on the occurrence of these radar echoes over four years of radar measurements, which covered conditions ranging from minimum to maximum solar activity. The median altitude of these radar echoes is found to be 58.5 km ( σ =3.9 km), a thickness of ≈ 6 km per layer, and where the majority of detections exhibit a relatively narrow power spectrum. Substantial annual variability was found for these parameters and the occurrence rate, essentially separating them into summer and winter. The reduced occurrence rates during the solar maximum year 2024 and with that also a reduced intensity of galactic cosmic rays (GCR) suggest their role as an ionisation source for the observed layers.
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 26 (13) , 9571-9587
Open AccessAutomated detection of low-altitude isolated mesospheric radar echoes using YOLOv8: evidence for an ionospheric “C layer” phenomenon below 60 km altitude?
The Earth's ionosphere is created by incident solar radiation and extends from approximately 60 to 800 km altitude. Within the ionosphere distinct regions are formed based on the number density of the dominant chemical species and their ionisation by the incident solar ultraviolet radiation and X-rays. The generally accepted lowermost ionospheric region is called D region and extends during daytime from, for example, 90 km downwards to approximately 60 km. Previous studies suggested the presence of an ionospheric C layer around 60 km mostly for observations at very low frequencies. In recent years, rather faint echoes from below the typically altitude-continuous D region have been observed during the sunlit period using a monostatic 3.17 MHz ground-based radar system at polar latitudes. The aim of this study is to distinguish radar echoes from altitudes near 60 km from regular D region echoes and attribute them to a possible C layer source. To our knowledge, this study might be the first systematic investigation of such a phenomenon through monostatic radar observations. Following an initial manual inspection of the raw data and the corresponding radar image spectra, an automated deep learning approach was developed and employed to detect these isolated low-altitude echoes. We used the pattern recognition tool YOLO (You Only Look Once) to gain statistical information on the occurrence of these radar echoes over four years of radar measurements, which covered conditions ranging from minimum to maximum solar activity. The median altitude of these radar echoes is found to be 58.5 km ( σ =3.9 km), a thickness of ≈ 6 km per layer, and where the majority of detections exhibit a relatively narrow power spectrum. Substantial annual variability was found for these parameters and the occurrence rate, essentially separating them into summer and winter. The reduced occurrence rates during the solar maximum year 2024 and with that also a reduced intensity of galactic cosmic rays (GCR) suggest their role as an ionisation source for the observed layers.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Advances in Radio Science
- Vol. 24, 15-28
Possible solar cycle influence on midlatitude mesosphere/lower thermosphere horizontal winds over Germany
At Collm (51.3° N, 13.0° E) mesosphere/lower thermosphere (MLT) zonal and meridional winds have been measured for more than four decades using low-frequency spaced receiver measurements on 177, 225, and 270 kHz, and very high frequency meteor radar observations on 36.2 MHz. We analyse the combined time series of monthly mean horizontal winds at 90 km height from 1979 to 2024 with respect to long-term changes, and in particular to the effect of the 11-year solar cycle (SC). In the 1980s and 1990s there is a negative correlation with solar extreme ultraviolet proxies in spring and early summer, with a weaker jet in the lower thermosphere during solar maximum. This correspondence weakens after the year 2000. In winter, there is a weak positive effect towards stronger westerly winds during solar maximum. Together, the results suggest that solar forcing remains an important, season-dependent driver of mid-latitude MLT dynamics, but its expression is modulated by the recently weakened SCs 24–25, or modified by changing trends of forcing from below. These results are largely in agreement with partial reflection radar observations of mesospheric winds over Juliusruh (54.6° N, 13.4° E) at 3.18 MHz. We also compare them with decadal variations of gravity wave proxies, but these results are partly inconclusive.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Advances in Radio Science
- Vol. 24, 15-28
Open AccessPossible solar cycle influence on midlatitude mesosphere/lower thermosphere horizontal winds over Germany
At Collm (51.3° N, 13.0° E) mesosphere/lower thermosphere (MLT) zonal and meridional winds have been measured for more than four decades using low-frequency spaced receiver measurements on 177, 225, and 270 kHz, and very high frequency meteor radar observations on 36.2 MHz. We analyse the combined time series of monthly mean horizontal winds at 90 km height from 1979 to 2024 with respect to long-term changes, and in particular to the effect of the 11-year solar cycle (SC). In the 1980s and 1990s there is a negative correlation with solar extreme ultraviolet proxies in spring and early summer, with a weaker jet in the lower thermosphere during solar maximum. This correspondence weakens after the year 2000. In winter, there is a weak positive effect towards stronger westerly winds during solar maximum. Together, the results suggest that solar forcing remains an important, season-dependent driver of mid-latitude MLT dynamics, but its expression is modulated by the recently weakened SCs 24–25, or modified by changing trends of forcing from below. These results are largely in agreement with partial reflection radar observations of mesospheric winds over Juliusruh (54.6° N, 13.4° E) at 3.18 MHz. We also compare them with decadal variations of gravity wave proxies, but these results are partly inconclusive.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (12) , 4277-4292
Monitoring of lower thermospheric neutral density variations using meteor head echoes
Observations of neutral density in the mesosphere and lower thermosphere (MLT) region of the terrestrial atmosphere are important for understanding lower atmospheric, geomagnetic, and anthropogenic forcing. This study introduces a statistical method for measuring neutral density variations using an extensive dataset of meteor head echoes that were observed using the MAARSY high-power large-aperture (HPLA) mesosphere–stratosphere–troposphere (MST) radar. The method relies on observing the mean geocentric velocity of meteor head echoes as a function of initial detection altitude and day-of-year. The meteor head echo catalog used contains 1.4 million meteor head echoes between 2016–2023. Neutral density variations are observed with a 6 d time and 2 km altitude resolution between 85–115 km. The measurements show variations in neutral density potentially due to geomagnetic and atmospheric events. Variations of up to 20 % are common in the dataset, and agree with the magnitude of atmospheric neutral density fluctuations from an Upper-Atmosphere ICOsahedral Non-hydrostatic (UA-ICON) atmosphere model run.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (12) , 4277-4292
Open AccessMonitoring of lower thermospheric neutral density variations using meteor head echoes
Observations of neutral density in the mesosphere and lower thermosphere (MLT) region of the terrestrial atmosphere are important for understanding lower atmospheric, geomagnetic, and anthropogenic forcing. This study introduces a statistical method for measuring neutral density variations using an extensive dataset of meteor head echoes that were observed using the MAARSY high-power large-aperture (HPLA) mesosphere–stratosphere–troposphere (MST) radar. The method relies on observing the mean geocentric velocity of meteor head echoes as a function of initial detection altitude and day-of-year. The meteor head echo catalog used contains 1.4 million meteor head echoes between 2016–2023. Neutral density variations are observed with a 6 d time and 2 km altitude resolution between 85–115 km. The measurements show variations in neutral density potentially due to geomagnetic and atmospheric events. Variations of up to 20 % are common in the dataset, and agree with the magnitude of atmospheric neutral density fluctuations from an Upper-Atmosphere ICOsahedral Non-hydrostatic (UA-ICON) atmosphere model run.
- Open Access
- 26 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Comment on egusphere-2026-2857
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- 26 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-26
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2857
We investigate the February 19, 2025, re-entry of a Falcon 9 upper stage using optical observations from 43 meteor cameras across central Europe together with radar detections of re-entry plasma obtained with the 32.55 MHz SIMONe Germany multistatic radar system. Optical observations of fragment emissions between 85 and 36 km altitude were used to reconstruct 30 fragment trajectories, identify two main fragment families, and fit ballistic trajectories to estimate kinetic energy loss per unit mass. The optical detection-height distribution peaks near 60 km with a standard deviation of 10 km, and both optical and radar signatures occur in the same broad altitude region as the maximum kinetic-energy loss. Radar echoes were detected at altitudes between 55 and 75 km, and the radar-derived positions are consistent with those obtained from optical observations. Two distinct radar echo types associated with the re-entry plasma were identified: (1) specular trail echoes from overdense wake plasma, with radar cross-sections (RCS) of up to 60 dBsm, and (2) short-lived non-specular trail echoes with RCS values of 20–30 dBsm, exhibiting a delay of 1–2 s compared to optical signatures. The characteristic decay time of both echo types is approximately 1 s. In the radar-echo altitude range, the estimated Knudsen numbers for meter-scale fragments are well below unity, consistent with continuum-flow conditions and shock-driven plasma production rather than ordinary meteor-like impact ionization. These serendipitous radar observations demonstrate that the atmospheric re-entry of other spacecraft, including objects smaller than the Falcon 9 upper stage such as Starlink satellites, may likewise be detectable using comparable multistatic meteor radar systems deployed globally.
- Open Access
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-20
Reply on RC2
Radar echoes from meteor plasma trails constitute one of the main sources of observations of winds in the mesosphere-lower thermosphere. A new 31-year archive of meteor wind observations has been prepared from data taken at 38 Super Dual Auroral Radar Network (SuperDARN) sites, covering 1993–2024. These observations are not height-resolved, and so an empirical meteor model has been produced to estimate the altitude contribution function, in other words the meteor count distribution. The meteor count model RMSEs were estimated at 1.1 km for the peak height and 1.0 km for the full width at half maximum. Using the meteor model, the SuperDARN wind observations have been compared against nearby dedicated meteor radar data, and against JAWARA reanalysis winds. Two case-study comparisons were performed: one for the Andenes meteor radar versus Hankasalmi SuperDARN radar in 2008, and one for the McMurdo meteor radar versus McMurdo SuperDARN radar in 2019. The three datasets were found to be in reasonable agreement, with correlations ranging from 0.49–0.88 for the comparison of SuperDARN against the meteor and 0.50 – 0.72 for the comparison of SuperDARN against JAWARA. A summertime equatorward mean flow of 5–15 m/s was identified in the northern hemisphere SuperDARN data, consistent with previous reports.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC2
Radar echoes from meteor plasma trails constitute one of the main sources of observations of winds in the mesosphere-lower thermosphere. A new 31-year archive of meteor wind observations has been prepared from data taken at 38 Super Dual Auroral Radar Network (SuperDARN) sites, covering 1993–2024. These observations are not height-resolved, and so an empirical meteor model has been produced to estimate the altitude contribution function, in other words the meteor count distribution. The meteor count model RMSEs were estimated at 1.1 km for the peak height and 1.0 km for the full width at half maximum. Using the meteor model, the SuperDARN wind observations have been compared against nearby dedicated meteor radar data, and against JAWARA reanalysis winds. Two case-study comparisons were performed: one for the Andenes meteor radar versus Hankasalmi SuperDARN radar in 2008, and one for the McMurdo meteor radar versus McMurdo SuperDARN radar in 2019. The three datasets were found to be in reasonable agreement, with correlations ranging from 0.49–0.88 for the comparison of SuperDARN against the meteor and 0.50 – 0.72 for the comparison of SuperDARN against JAWARA. A summertime equatorward mean flow of 5–15 m/s was identified in the northern hemisphere SuperDARN data, consistent with previous reports.