HSHolly Sullivan-Toole

Holly Sullivan-Toole

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Holly Sullivan-Toole has a total of 78 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Emotional and physical abuse have dissociable impacts on punishment learning and task engagement during adolescence

    by Holly Sullivan-Toole, Jeremy Matthew Haynes, John McClellan France, Suzanne C. Perkins, Monica Luciana, Bart Larsen, Thomas M Olino

    Childhood adversity is a robust risk factor for psychopathology, and growing evidence implicates developmental alterations in reward and punishment learning as potent mechanisms shaping this vulnerability. However, little is known about how specific types of adversity impact different learning processes, particularly during the sensitive adolescent period. To examine effects of different types of adversity on the development of valenced learning processes, we combined a subtype-specific approach to childhood adversity, a behavioral task and reinforcement learning (RL) model that capture distinct component processes of learning, and a longitudinal design in youth aged 9-17 (n = 166). Task performance metrics included traditional summary scores and RL-derived estimates for reward learning rate, punishment learning rate, win/loss frequency sensitivity, and go bias (general tendency to play). Analyses probing adversity subtypes and component learning processes revealed dissociable effects: emotional abuse attenuated normative developmental increases in punishment learning rate, and physical abuse attenuated normative increases in both go bias and a summary score of reward learning (FDR < .05). In contrast, analyses relying on a gross summary score of net success and composite variables representing broad adversity dimensions (abuse vs. neglect) obscured these effects, highlighting the need for fine-grained characterization of both adversity and learning processes. Additionally, adversity did not predict differences in net success, suggesting that youth high and low in adversity reach similar behavioral outcomes through divergent learning strategies. This study is among the first to identify unique effects of different adversity types on specific component processes of valenced learning during adolescence.

  • Open Access

    A Scalable fMRI Estimate of Basal Ganglia Brain Tissue Iron for Use in Developmental and Translational Neuroscience

    by Holly Sullivan-Toole, Ashley Clare Parr, Carina Heller, Brenden Tervo-Clemmens, rae McCollum, Amar Ojha, Eric J Feczko, Erik Lee, Will Foran, Finnegan J. Calabro, et al.

    Dopaminergic (DA) function and basal ganglia neurobiology are central to reward learning, motivation, and cognitive control, and dysregulation of these systems contributes to neuropsychiatric conditions that emerge during development. Adolescence is marked by profound reorganization of DAergic basal ganglia circuitry, yet direct in vivo assessment of the DA system remains limited in youth. Brain tissue iron is a developmentally sensitive marker of DA-related neurobiology that can be measured non-invasively via magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Iron is an essential co-factor for DA synthesis and a foundational metabolic resource that supports cellular metabolism, myelination, and energetic demands of the basal ganglia. T2*-weighted echo-planar imaging (EPI), collected during functional MRI (fMRI), is sensitive to magnetic susceptibility of non-heme brain iron. Leveraging this property, we demonstrate the validity and broad applicability of an iron-sensitive metric that can be derived from conventional single-echo fMRI: ΔR2*. In a longitudinal developmental dataset (N = 151; age range 12–31), ΔR2* showed high reliability, strong longitudinal stability, and validity via robust convergence with established quantitative relaxometry-based iron measures (R2* and R2’). Critically, ΔR2* can be retrospectively estimated from extant fMRI data and derived in large-scale consortium data repositories, demonstrated here in the Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development (ABCD) baseline cohort (N = 8,366; ages 9–11). We show that ΔR2* captures known age-related increases in basal ganglia iron, highlighting neurodevelopmental sensitivity at population-scale. Together, these findings establish ΔR2* as a reliable, widely accessible marker of basal ganglia iron, enabling scalable investigation of lifespan trajectories and neuropsychiatric risk in existing and future datasets.


  • Open Access

    Reward and Punishment Learning Among People with a Lifetime History of Anxiety, Depression, and Substance Use Disorder

    by Jeremy Matthew Haynes, Holly Sullivan-Toole, Nathaniel Haines, Thomas M Olino

    Reward and punishment learning are critical across multiple clinical populations. The Iowa Gambling Task (IGT) is frequently used to assess these constructs and multiple forms of psychopathology are associated with IGT performance. However, it is not clear whether alterations in IGT performance are general to psychopathology, or specific to different forms of psychopathology. Thus, we examined whether IGT performance was uniquely predicted by anxiety, depression, and substance use disorder. We tested a sample of adults (N=293) on the play-or-pass version of the IGT. We characterized behavior using a hierarchical Bayesian computational model, formalizing parameters underlying task behavior. With the model, we examined unique associations between IGT performance and lifetime diagnostic history of anxiety, depression, and substance use disorder. Anxiety, but not depression or substance use, was associated with higher punishment learning rates, posterior mean β = 0.15, 95% CI [0.01,0.28]. In addition, women showed lower punishment learning rates, posterior mean β = -0.17, 95% CI [-0.30,-0.03], and lower response bias, posterior mean β = -0.30, 95% CI [-0.56,-0.05]. The relation between punishment learning rates and history of anxiety was small; however, our findings were consistent with established findings in anxiety derived from self-report. In addition, only main effects of diagnostic status were examined; thus, future research should examine comorbidity between diagnoses on IGT performance. Overall, our findings are consistent with research showing that anxiety is associated with punishment avoidance. In addition, our behavioral findings with respect to gender are also consistent with previous research employing the IGT.

  • Open Access

    Alcohol intoxication and negative mood similarly affect reward learning but not punishment learning in the Iowa Gambling Task

    by Jonas Dora, Holly Sullivan-Toole, Catherine Zhang, Morgan Opdahl, Kevin Michael King

    This study investigated how alcohol intoxication and negative mood affect decision-making in the Iowa Gambling Task (IGT) in a high-risk sample of adults who regularly drink alcohol. Using a 2×2 between-subjects design (N=160), we experimentally manipulated alcohol intoxication (target BrAC=.06% vs. .00%) and mood (negative vs. neutral) and employed computational modeling to identify underlying mechanisms. Results showed that alcohol intoxication impaired IGT performance, with intoxicated participants selecting fewer cards from advantageous decks (estimate=-8.12, 95% CI=[-12.83, -3.23]). Evidence for an effect of negative mood was moderate but inconclusive (estimate=-4.82, 95% CI=[-9.66, 0.02]). Computational modeling revealed that both alcohol (estimate=.13, 95% CI=[.05, .21]) and negative mood (estimate=.12, 95% CI=[.04, .20]) increased reward learning rates without affecting punishment learning rates. No interaction effects were observed. These findings suggest that impaired decision-making during alcohol intoxication and negative mood states stems from heightened sensitivity to immediate rewards rather than diminished sensitivity to punishments but these effects do not appear to be additive, providing novel insights into the computational mechanisms underlying alcohol-related decision-making deficits.

  • Open Access

    Reduced reward bias for exerting personal control is associated with self-reported anhedonia

    by Holly Sullivan-Toole

    Anhedonia is a pernicious and transdiagnostic set of psychiatric symptoms, including decreased motivation and blunted response to rewards. These reward processing deficits are found across a range of psychiatric conditions including depression, social anxiety, and substance use disorder, and are linked to worse psychiatric outcomes. Healthy individuals are known to experience reward responses to a variety of stimuli including perceived opportunities to make choices (i.e., exert personal control) that lead to monetary outcomes. Critically, perceived personal control has been shown to be rewarding even when exerting control cannot lead to greater monetary reward. However, the association between anhedonia and responsivity to personal control is not well understood. Using a sample of university students (n = 62), the current study examined the association between self-reported anhedonia and behavioral responsivity to opportunities to exert (perceived) personal control over monetary outcomes in a signal detection task. In a novel behavioral task, the ‘Choice Bias Task’, participants were shown stimuli linked to monetary outcomes. In one task condition, participants were given a ‘free choice’ (perceived personal control condition) between stimuli for a subsequent monetary reward and in another task condition, participants were given a ‘forced choice’ and told which stimuli to choose for a subsequent monetary reward (no control condition). Critically, monetary outcomes were equal between the personal control and no control conditions. Using signal detection analyses, I examined the development of a bias for personal control across blocks of the task and how this ‘choice bias’ was associated with anhedonia. While there was no bias for choice across at the group level, choice bias was significantly associated with self-reported anticipatory and consummatory anhedonia, such that more anhedonic individuals exhibited lower decisional bias towards perceived opportunities to exert personal control. These findings suggest that opportunities for exerting personal control may be less reinforcing for individuals with higher levels of anhedonia. Future work should examine associations between anhedonia and reward responses across different reward domains including the domain of personal control, which has been shown to be normatively rewarding.

  • Open Access

    Reward-specific learning parameters change across normative adolescent development and are blunted in youth with high risk for depression.

    by Holly Sullivan-Toole, Jeremy Matthew Haynes, Helen Schmidt, Bart Larsen, Nathaniel Haines, Thomas M Olino

    Background: Reward learning is thought to undergo refinement in adolescence, but little is known about how computational components of reinforcement learning develop. Given that adolescence is a sensitive period for reward system plasticity with associated vulnerability for depression, it is important to understand developmental trajectories of different reinforcement learning parameters in normative development and in youth at risk for depression.Methods: Youth aged 9-17 years completed the Play-or-Pass Iowa Gambling Task (PoP-IGT) across five timepoints. We calculated task metrics using a traditional scoring approach—yielding summary scores for good deck play, bad deck play, and net play—and a computational modeling approach—yielding parameters for reward learning rate, punishment learning rate, go bias, and sensitivity to win/loss frequency ignoring outcome magnitude. We examined normative developmental trajectories for each traditional and computational performance metric using multilevel models. Further, we examined whether maternal history of depression was associated with individual differences in these trajectories. Results: As hypothesized, youth showed a significant age-related increase in net play (p = .003), a measure of overall good performance. Exploratory analyses found that youth showed significant developmental change in reward-specific learning parameters including age-related increases in win/loss frequency sensitivity (FDR = .016) and age-related decreases in reward learning rate (FDR < .001). In line with hypotheses, youth at high-risk for depression showed lower reward learning rates in early adolescence (p = .041). Conclusion: The observed developmental changes in traditional and computational metrics are largely consistent with the optimization of learning from rewards across adolescence. Further, the observed developmental changes in specifically reward-related computational parameters are consistent with heightened adolescent reward system plasticity. Additionally, there was support for our hypothesis that maternal history of depression may exert a unique effect on learning from rewards specifically, but further research across additional reward learning tasks is needed.

  • Open Access

    Understanding Gaslighting: A Data-Driven Analysis of Themes, Features, and Effects on Subjective Memory

    by Camille Johnston, Büsra Tanriverdi, Holly Sullivan-Toole, Jamie Reilly, Thomas M Olino, Johanna Jarcho

    Gaslighting is a form of psychological manipulation where victims are led to doubt their own thoughts, perception of reality, or memories. Despite the growing popularity of the term and purported harmful implications, empirical efforts to operationalize and define gaslighting remain sparse. This study aimed to define common features and themes of self-reported gaslighting experiences. Young adults (N=250) completed several questionnaires and open-ended prompts relating to gaslighting experiences. Using a variety of natural language processing techniques, we explore the gaslighting construct using a data-driven approach from the perspective of self-reported targets of gaslighting. These data confirm that gaslighting is a type of interpersonal manipulation aimed at making a person feel 'crazy' or doubt their memories. Romantic partners were reported to be the most common perpetrators of gaslighting, and both beneficial (e.g., awareness of manipulative people) and detrimental (e.g., self-doubt) consequences of experiencing gaslighting appear to be long-lasting. Additionally, we found that more severe, frequent, and long-lasting gaslighting experiences are associated with broader subjective memory deficits, even extending to other memories outside of the gaslighting event itself. This study highlights pervasive cognitive and psychological impacts of gaslighting, and underscores the need for further empirical research and informed clinical strategies.

  • Open Access

    MNLFA Nhanes

    by Daniel P. Moriarity, Holly Sullivan-Toole, Jeffrey Gassen, Chiyoung Lee, Thomas M Olino, George M. Slavich

    To be updated after updated models completed

  • Open Access

    Test-Retest Reliability of the Play-or-Pass Version of the Iowa Gambling Task (Haynes et al.)

    by Jeremy Matthew Haynes, Nathaniel Haines, Holly Sullivan-Toole, Thomas M Olino

    The Iowa Gambling Task (IGT) is widely used to assess decision-making deficits in clinical populations (e.g., individuals with brain injury). We evaluated the test-retest reliability of a modified version of the IGT, the “play-or-pass” IGT. Participants completed the task across two sessions along with self-reported measures of reward/punishment sensitivity and internalizing symptoms. We evaluated test-retest reliability by calculating the absolute (i.e., mean-level) and relative (i.e., rank-order) stability of behavioral measures using a traditional scoring approach, involving session-wide choice proportions, and a computational modeling approach, involving estimates of different aspects of trial-level learning. Overall, measures using both approaches were reliable; however, the computational modeling approach provided more insights regarding changes in task performance between sessions as well as how performance was related to reward/punishment sensitivity and internalizing symptoms. Our results show promise in using the play-or-pass IGT to assess decision-making; however, further work is still necessary to validate the play-or-pass IGT.

  • Open Access

    Adolescents at risk for depression show increased white matter microstructure with age across diffuse areas of the brain

    by Holly Sullivan-Toole, Katie R. Jobson, Linda J. Hoffman, Lindsey C. Stewart, Ingrid R. Olson, Thomas M. Olino