Edwin Carawan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Latest Publications
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft mbH in Historia
- Vol. 73 (2) , 128-146
Solon’s Remedy against Hybris and Lawlessness
Recent work suggests that Solon’s graphē procedure was introduced with the graphē hybreōs. This paper argues in support of that thesis with a new interpretation of the second description of the crime,“any act paranomon,” attested by Aeschines 1.15, and in Demosthenes 21.47. The authenticity and meaning of that clause are much disputed, but the prevailing sense of nomos in archaic material suggests a particular value for the paranomon clause as an instrument of the Solonian agenda, and surviving speeches seem to preserve that sense of paranomon as an offense against “all the laws” or the rule of law itself.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft mbH in Historia
- Vol. 73 (2) , 128-146
Solon’s Remedy against Hybris and Lawlessness
Recent work suggests that Solon’s graphē procedure was introduced with the graphē hybreōs. This paper argues in support of that thesis with a new interpretation of the second description of the crime,“any act paranomon,” attested by Aeschines 1.15, and in Demosthenes 21.47. The authenticity and meaning of that clause are much disputed, but the prevailing sense of nomos in archaic material suggests a particular value for the paranomon clause as an instrument of the Solonian agenda, and surviving speeches seem to preserve that sense of paranomon as an offense against “all the laws” or the rule of law itself.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Project MUSE in Classical Journal
- Vol. 118 (2) , 127-155
Deciding the "Judgment of Arms"
The tale of how Achilles' armor was awarded to a worthy successor evolved to reflect customary procedures and emerging ideology. In this article I offer a new reconstruction of that changing story, as variations in the method of decision reshaped the plot to match audience expectations. The epic version began with ad hoc arbitration and an element of chance that left the loser no one to blame. The generations after Cleisthenes developed a Judgment by majority rule in which each voter must choose for himself but all are responsible, and Αjax becomes a reactionary against that new regime.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Project MUSE in Classical Journal
- Vol. 118 (2) , 127-155
Deciding the "Judgment of Arms"
The tale of how Achilles' armor was awarded to a worthy successor evolved to reflect customary procedures and emerging ideology. In this article I offer a new reconstruction of that changing story, as variations in the method of decision reshaped the plot to match audience expectations. The epic version began with ad hoc arbitration and an element of chance that left the loser no one to blame. The generations after Cleisthenes developed a Judgment by majority rule in which each voter must choose for himself but all are responsible, and Αjax becomes a reactionary against that new regime.
- 22 August 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 67 (2) , 400-421
DECREES IN ANDOCIDES'ON THE MYSTERIESAND ‘LATENT FRAGMENTS’ FROM CRATERUS
The manuscript of Andocides' speechOn the Mysteriescontains a series of documentary inserts culminating in the decrees of Patroclides (§§77–9), Tisamenus (§§83–4) and Demophantus (§§96–8). These decrees seem to fit their historical context and they are presented at length, with at least a few of the formalities that we would expect to find in the official record. Modern commentators have relied upon them as substantially genuine, allowing for the usual errors in transmission, but now their authenticity is contested. A close reading by Mirko Canevaro and Edward Harris rejects all three of these documents as products of feckless ‘forgery’. Alan Sommerstein responded with a strong defence of Demophantus' decree, and Mogens Hansen has recently defended Patroclides' decree and Tisamenus' as well. On many points the defenders are persuasive, but the sceptics make a good case, and so it seems reasonable to reconsider how these documents took shape.
- 22 August 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 67 (2) , 400-421
DECREES IN ANDOCIDES'ON THE MYSTERIESAND ‘LATENT FRAGMENTS’ FROM CRATERUS
The manuscript of Andocides' speechOn the Mysteriescontains a series of documentary inserts culminating in the decrees of Patroclides (§§77–9), Tisamenus (§§83–4) and Demophantus (§§96–8). These decrees seem to fit their historical context and they are presented at length, with at least a few of the formalities that we would expect to find in the official record. Modern commentators have relied upon them as substantially genuine, allowing for the usual errors in transmission, but now their authenticity is contested. A close reading by Mirko Canevaro and Edward Harris rejects all three of these documents as products of feckless ‘forgery’. Alan Sommerstein responded with a strong defence of Demophantus' decree, and Mogens Hansen has recently defended Patroclides' decree and Tisamenus' as well. On many points the defenders are persuasive, but the sceptics make a good case, and so it seems reasonable to reconsider how these documents took shape.
- 19 November 2010
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 60 (2) , 381-400
DIADIKASIAI AND THE DEMOTIONID PROBLEM
- 19 November 2010
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 60 (2) , 381-400
DIADIKASIAI AND THE DEMOTIONID PROBLEM
- 12 May 2006
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 56 (1) , 57-76
AMNESTY AND ACCOUNTINGS FOR THE THIRTY
- 12 May 2006
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Classical Quarterly
- Vol. 56 (1) , 57-76
AMNESTY AND ACCOUNTINGS FOR THE THIRTY