MWMarcus A. Winters

Marcus A. Winters

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Marcus A. Winters has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Identifying Retention Effects in the Presence of Remediation-Based Exemptions

    by Marcus A. Winters, Abigail Francis

    Test-based promotion policies that retain students who fail a gateway exam are often evaluated using a fuzzy regression-discontinuity (RD) design that exploits the discontinuity in retention probability at the passing threshold. This approach requires an exclusion restriction that fails when, as in many states, schools must provide remedial instruction to students who are promoted despite failing the gateway test. We show that the reduced-form effect of failing the test is a weighted average of the effects of retention and remediation, and we use this relationship to recover informative bounds on the causal effect of retention. An upper bound, equivalent to the conventional fuzzy RD estimand, follows from assuming remediation is not harmful. A lower bound follows from the empirically grounded assump-tion that schools negatively select failing students into retention rather than remediation. Applying this framework to administrative data from Indiana’s third-grade promotion policy, we find that even under our most conservative assumptions, policy-induced retention raised fourth-grade test scores by approximately 0.3–0.4σ, with effects persisting through middle school. Our results illustrate how insti-tutional rules that allocate individuals across multiple treatment margins complicate the interpretation of standard quasi-experimental estimators.

  • Open Access

    Fewer Licenses, Similar Teachers Changing Licensing Tests in Indiana

    by John Fallon, Marcus A. Winters

    We use longitudinal administrative data from Indiana to examine changes in teacher quality following the state’s shift to a more difficult licensure test. Despite a significant drop in new licenses issued following the change in the licensure test standard, the overall quality of incoming teachers and the relative quality of licensed teachers compared to unlicensed teachers remained largely unchanged. We find some heterogeneity by subject and school setting, with urban schools experiencing a modest decline in teacher quality, particularly in math. Our findings raise questions about the value of requiring prospective teachers to pass licensure tests to obtain a license.

  • Open Access

    Fewer Licenses, Similar Teachers Changing Licensing Tests in Indiana

    by John Fallon, Marcus A. Winters

    We use longitudinal administrative data from Indiana to examine changes in teacher quality following the state’s shift to a more difficult licensure test. Despite a significant drop in new licenses issued following the change in the licensure test standard, the overall quality of incoming teachers and the relative quality of licensed teachers compared to unlicensed teachers remained largely unchanged. We find some heterogeneity by subject and school setting, with urban schools experiencing a modest decline in teacher quality, particularly in math. Our findings raise questions about the value of requiring prospective teachers to pass licensure tests to obtain a license.

  • Open Access

    Special Education Substantially Improves Learning: Evidence from Three States

    by Stephanie Coffey, Joshua Goodman, Amy Ellen Schwartz, Leanna Stiefel, Marcus A. Winters, Yunee Yoon

    Special education serves more than one in seven U.S. students yet its causal impact remains understudied. Using longitudinal data from Massachusetts, Indiana, and Connecticut, we estimate the effect of individualized supports with an event-study design that tracks achievement around initial classification. Students’ scores decline prior to placement and rise sharply afterward, yielding a consistent V-shaped pattern. Within three years, achievement is 0.2–0.4σ higher than counterfactual trends imply. Gains are similar across disability categories and subgroups, are not driven by testing accommodations, and remain under conservative assumptions. Individualized supports substantially increase learning productivity.Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.

  • Open Access

    Licensure Tests and Teacher Supply

    by Alexis Orellana, Marcus A. Winters

    We apply a sharp regression discontinuity design to administrative data from Connecticut to investigate the impact of failing the first attempt at a licensure test on teacher supply. We find deterrent effects from failing both a basic skills test required to enter an educator preparation program (Praxis I) and a subject-matter test used for ultimate certification (Praxis II). Failing Praxis II especially deters those seeking endorsement to teach within the shortage areas of STEM and special education. Failing Praxis II disproportionately pushes out relatively effective potential teachers and those who would have taught in schools with relatively smaller proportions of students who are Black or Hispanic, learning English, and eligible for subsidized lunch.


  • Service Delivery Models: Impacts for Students With and Without Disabilities

    by Nathan Jones, Lindsey Kaler, Jessica Markham, Josefina Senese, Marcus A. Winters

    Students with and without disabilities may be educated across various service delivery models (SDMs): general education, cotaught, pull-out, and self-contained. Still, evidence for their relative effectiveness at scale remains limited. Using longitudinal administrative data from Indiana, we measured the effect of different SDMs on test scores, attendance, and disciplinary incidents. We leveraged within-student variation in SDM assignments and differences across students, applying student fixed effects and lagged outcomes models, which bound the causal effect within a narrow, policy-relevant range. Students with disabilities performed better in less restrictive environments, although the magnitude was often modest and varied across SDMs. Coteaching had a positive impact on students without disabilities. This work contributes to our understanding of inclusive practices’ effectiveness as experienced statewide.


  • Open Access

    The Impact of Principal Attrition and Replacement on Indicators of School Quality

    by Marcus A. Winters, Brian Kisida, Ikhee Cho

    Transitions to a new principal are common, especially within urban public schools, and potentially highly disruptive to a school's culture and operations. We use longitudinal data from New York City to investigate if the effect of principal transitions differs by whether the incoming principal was hired externally or promoted from within the school. We take advantage of variation in the timing of principal transitions within an event-study approach to estimate the causal effect of principal changes. Changing principals has an immediate negative effect on student test scores that is sustained over several years regardless of whether hired internally or externally. However, externally hired principals lead to an increase in teacher turnover and a decline in perceptions of the school's learning environment, whereas transitions to an internally promoted principal have no such effects. This pattern of results raises important questions about leadership transitions and the nature of principal effects on school quality.


  • Are Two Teachers Better Than One?

    by Nathan Jones, Marcus A. Winters

    Co-teaching, in which a general education teacher and special education teacher collaboratively provide instruction to students with and without disabilities in the same classroom, is widely endorsed as a strategy to give instructional support to students with disabilities within inclusive environments. We leverage longitudinal administrative data in Massachusetts to provide the first causal estimate for the effect of co-teaching across a large public school system. We find evidence that co-teaching leads to statistically significant test score improvements for both students with and without disabilities. However, the benefits for students with disabilities are much smaller than reported in prior studies.


  • For teachers, a better kind of pension plan

    by Marcus A. Winters

    Public school teachers deserve a compensation system that puts them on a secure path toward retirement. The severely backloaded structure of today’s public school teacher pension systems benefit only a small proportion of entering teachers while putting the rest on an insecure retirement path. But there is a cost-neutral solution to this problem that would benefit most teachers entering public school classrooms today without removing any of the protections from the stock market with which teachers have become accustomed. Teacher pensions could be restructured so that teachers earn retirement wealth in relatively equal intervals throughout their careers. The author calls these Smooth Accrual Defined Benefit plans.

  • Open Access

    Choices, Choices: Determining Significant Predictors of Choosing a School and Choosing Charters in Denver's Universal School Enrollment Program

    by Marcus A. Winters, Dick Carpenter, Grant Clayton

    Through charter school laws, more than 40 states now enable parents to send their child to a school other than their neighborhood school. Given the option, what kinds of schools do parents prefer -- charter or traditional public schools? Are there differences in preferences based on family and student performance characteristics? To answer these questions, a body of literature has examined enrollment patterns, but for various reasons of policy and practice, enrollment patterns are not necessarily accurate representations of parental preferences. This study takes advantage of a rare centralized enrollment system in Denver, Colorado, that enabled the authors to track the actual stated choices/preferences of parents. Results indicate the most consistent predictor of affirmatively choosing a school and choosing a charter school is race/ethnicity. In particular, black families are almost always more likely than White families to choose and to choose charters. The same is also usually true for Hispanic families. Beyond race/ethnicity, few other variables demonstrate consistent patterns of relationships or significance across dependent measures or grades. ELL students, those with IEPs, and students who quality for free or reduced lunch sometimes choose or choose charters at significantly greater or lesser rates, but not consistently so. Finally, actual prior academic performance and prior enrollment in a charter school appear to play only a trivial role in predicting whether parents choose or choose charters.