Crystal A. Ennis
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Crystal A. Ennis has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alejandro Fernández del Rio
Constitutional Law, Political and Administrative Sciences, Universitat de Valencia, Valencia, Valencian Community, 46010, Spain
2 shared publications - Ana Luisa de Moraes Azenha
Portulans Institute, Portulans Institute, Washington D.C., District of Columbia, 20005, USA
2 shared publications Andrea Medrado
Department of Communications, Drama and Film, University of Exeter Department of Film Studies, Exeter, England, EX4 4QJ, UK
2 shared publicationsAndreu Teruel
Constitutional Law, Political and Administrative Sciences, Universitat de Valencia, Valencia, Valencian Community, 46010, Spain
2 shared publications- Ben O'LOughlin
Department of Politics, International Relations and Philosophy, Royal Holloway University of London Department of Politics and International Relations, Egham, England, TW20 0EX, UK
2 shared publications Bessma Momani
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 August 2026
- Published by CERN in Open Research Europe
Us and artificial intelligence: Questioning agency and the need for critical and humanist perspectives
This essay explores how Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping political and social relations, arguing for the need to reclaim AI as ‘ours’ and indicating how critical and humanist research can contribute to this process. While AI technologies are increasingly integrated into public infrastructures, their development is mainly driven by market logics that prioritise efficiency, prediction, and optimisation—frequently at the expense of democratic participation, epistemic plurality, and environmental sustainability. The essay results from a two-day international workshop held at the University of Valencia, which brought together interdisciplinary researchers to engage in experiential, reflexive, and collaborative theory-building. Using world cafés, scenario-building, and AI-assisted role-play, participants collectively identified five key challenges of AI-mediated social life: the ideological framing of efficiency, exclusions within participatory processes, the epistemological authority of AI systems, the erasure of historicity, and the instability of predictive infrastructures. In response, we propose a minimal framework to reorient AI research toward more inclusive and pluralistic agendas. These include reclaiming predictive power, critically assessing participation and exclusion, and addressing the environmental and geopolitical dimensions of AI. We also reflect on the meaning of research impact in AI scholarship, advocating for a broader conception that embraces critique, friction, and reflexivity. Overall, the essay argues that reclaiming agency in the age of AI requires not only better tools or regulations but a fundamental rethinking of the social relations, epistemologies, and political imaginaries that shape technological development.
- 21 August 2026
- Published by CERN in Open Research Europe
Open AccessUs and artificial intelligence: Questioning agency and the need for critical and humanist perspectives
This essay explores how Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping political and social relations, arguing for the need to reclaim AI as ‘ours’ and indicating how critical and humanist research can contribute to this process. While AI technologies are increasingly integrated into public infrastructures, their development is mainly driven by market logics that prioritise efficiency, prediction, and optimisation—frequently at the expense of democratic participation, epistemic plurality, and environmental sustainability. The essay results from a two-day international workshop held at the University of Valencia, which brought together interdisciplinary researchers to engage in experiential, reflexive, and collaborative theory-building. Using world cafés, scenario-building, and AI-assisted role-play, participants collectively identified five key challenges of AI-mediated social life: the ideological framing of efficiency, exclusions within participatory processes, the epistemological authority of AI systems, the erasure of historicity, and the instability of predictive infrastructures. In response, we propose a minimal framework to reorient AI research toward more inclusive and pluralistic agendas. These include reclaiming predictive power, critically assessing participation and exclusion, and addressing the environmental and geopolitical dimensions of AI. We also reflect on the meaning of research impact in AI scholarship, advocating for a broader conception that embraces critique, friction, and reflexivity. Overall, the essay argues that reclaiming agency in the age of AI requires not only better tools or regulations but a fundamental rethinking of the social relations, epistemologies, and political imaginaries that shape technological development.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 281-293
Towards a Global Political Economy Scholarship on Global Migration Governance
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 281-293
Open AccessTowards a Global Political Economy Scholarship on Global Migration Governance
- Open Access
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-24
Assemblages of Migration: Rethinking the Political Economy of Non-Western Migration Governance
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-24
Open AccessAssemblages of Migration: Rethinking the Political Economy of Non-Western Migration Governance
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Bristol University Press in Global Political Economy
- Vol. 5 (1) , 143-155
A promise of mobility? Migrant gig workers in multinational food delivery platform companies in the Netherlands
This commentary examines highly educated migrant gig workers who drive for multinational food delivery platforms in the Netherlands. It is part of the collection on The global politics of precarity and insecure work . Our study finds that the relative ease of securing a position in a delivery platform company offers educated migrants entry to the Dutch labour market built on the hope that this will facilitate their ability to secure a position in their respective fields. Delivery platforms capitalise on workers in what we call ‘positional limbo’, attracting educated, high-performing workers for low-paid, low-skilled positions. This precarious form of employment is instituted and sustained within the framework of labour and immigration management in the Netherlands. We find that this form of migration through the performance of platform labour is shaped by an increasingly flexible labour recruitment system alongside the internalisation of neoliberal discourses on work. We argue that together these sustain platform companies, reproduce inequalities in the labour market and produce a form of mobility-precarity that exists in the intersection of migration and platform capitalism. Our findings contribute to the development of scholarship on the global political economy (GPE) of labour and how digital technologies are impacting the future of work and immigration.
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Bristol University Press in Global Political Economy
- Vol. 5 (1) , 143-155
A promise of mobility? Migrant gig workers in multinational food delivery platform companies in the Netherlands
This commentary examines highly educated migrant gig workers who drive for multinational food delivery platforms in the Netherlands. It is part of the collection on The global politics of precarity and insecure work . Our study finds that the relative ease of securing a position in a delivery platform company offers educated migrants entry to the Dutch labour market built on the hope that this will facilitate their ability to secure a position in their respective fields. Delivery platforms capitalise on workers in what we call ‘positional limbo’, attracting educated, high-performing workers for low-paid, low-skilled positions. This precarious form of employment is instituted and sustained within the framework of labour and immigration management in the Netherlands. We find that this form of migration through the performance of platform labour is shaped by an increasingly flexible labour recruitment system alongside the internalisation of neoliberal discourses on work. We argue that together these sustain platform companies, reproduce inequalities in the labour market and produce a form of mobility-precarity that exists in the intersection of migration and platform capitalism. Our findings contribute to the development of scholarship on the global political economy (GPE) of labour and how digital technologies are impacting the future of work and immigration.
- Open Access
- 16 October 2025
- Published by CERN in Open Research Europe
- Vol. 5, 318
Us and artificial intelligence: Questioning agency and the need for critical and humanist perspectives
This essay explores how Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping political and social agency, arguing for the need to ground AI research in critical and humanist perspectives. While AI technologies are increasingly integrated into public infrastructures, their development is often driven by market logics that prioritise efficiency, prediction, and optimisation at the expense of democratic participation, epistemic plurality, and environmental sustainability. The essay results from a two-day international workshop held at the University of Valencia, which brought together interdisciplinary researchers to engage in experiential, reflexive, and collaborative theory-building. Using world cafés, scenario-building, and AI-assisted role-play, participants collectively identified five key challenges of AI-mediated social life: the ideological framing of efficiency, exclusions within participatory processes, the epistemological authority of AI systems, the erasure of historicity, and the instability of predictive infrastructures. In response, we propose a minimal framework to reorient AI research toward feminist, decolonial critical agendas. These include reclaiming predictive power, critically assessing participation and exclusion, and addressing the environmental and geopolitical dimensions of AI. We also reflect on the meaning of research impact in AI scholarship, advocating for a broader conception that embraces critique, friction, and reflexivity. Overall, the essay argues that reclaiming agency in the age of AI requires not only better software-design or regulations but a fundamental rethinking of the social relations, epistemologies, and political imaginaries of technological development.
- 16 October 2025
- Published by CERN in Open Research Europe
- Vol. 5, 318
Open AccessUs and artificial intelligence: Questioning agency and the need for critical and humanist perspectives
This essay explores how Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping political and social agency, arguing for the need to ground AI research in critical and humanist perspectives. While AI technologies are increasingly integrated into public infrastructures, their development is often driven by market logics that prioritise efficiency, prediction, and optimisation at the expense of democratic participation, epistemic plurality, and environmental sustainability. The essay results from a two-day international workshop held at the University of Valencia, which brought together interdisciplinary researchers to engage in experiential, reflexive, and collaborative theory-building. Using world cafés, scenario-building, and AI-assisted role-play, participants collectively identified five key challenges of AI-mediated social life: the ideological framing of efficiency, exclusions within participatory processes, the epistemological authority of AI systems, the erasure of historicity, and the instability of predictive infrastructures. In response, we propose a minimal framework to reorient AI research toward feminist, decolonial critical agendas. These include reclaiming predictive power, critically assessing participation and exclusion, and addressing the environmental and geopolitical dimensions of AI. We also reflect on the meaning of research impact in AI scholarship, advocating for a broader conception that embraces critique, friction, and reflexivity. Overall, the essay argues that reclaiming agency in the age of AI requires not only better software-design or regulations but a fundamental rethinking of the social relations, epistemologies, and political imaginaries of technological development.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2025
- Published by McMaster University Library in Global Labour Journal
- Vol. 16 (1)
Driving Gigs in Oman: Women and Techno-Fixes in the Platform Economy
Digital platforms mediating work between customers and service providers have expanded exponentially in the past decade, driving a growing research agenda on the impact of platform capitalism, AI and the gig economy on labour around the world. This paper is interested in understanding the platform economy at the intersection of gender with the political economy of labour. Focusing on the Omani case of a new women’s taxi service (OFemale) through the digital platform OTaxi, it asks how ride-hailing platforms are impacting women’s employment futures. Using rapid ethnography, elite interviews and a survey, the article examines both the launch and expansion of the business alongside the experiences of Omani women as taxi drivers. The article excavates three gendered discourses of freedom, protection and job creation around platform labour and female labour market participation in the region. It argues that digital platforms such as OTaxi offer techno-fixes to fill gaps in the market and respond to the need to generate job opportunities for female citizens in the country. At the same time, women make use of these opportunities and interpret their experience in diverse ways that problematise the neo-liberal promises of innovative technologies, job flexibility and autonomy embodied in platform capitalism.
- 31 January 2025
- Published by McMaster University Library in Global Labour Journal
- Vol. 16 (1)
Open AccessDriving Gigs in Oman: Women and Techno-Fixes in the Platform Economy
Digital platforms mediating work between customers and service providers have expanded exponentially in the past decade, driving a growing research agenda on the impact of platform capitalism, AI and the gig economy on labour around the world. This paper is interested in understanding the platform economy at the intersection of gender with the political economy of labour. Focusing on the Omani case of a new women’s taxi service (OFemale) through the digital platform OTaxi, it asks how ride-hailing platforms are impacting women’s employment futures. Using rapid ethnography, elite interviews and a survey, the article examines both the launch and expansion of the business alongside the experiences of Omani women as taxi drivers. The article excavates three gendered discourses of freedom, protection and job creation around platform labour and female labour market participation in the region. It argues that digital platforms such as OTaxi offer techno-fixes to fill gaps in the market and respond to the need to generate job opportunities for female citizens in the country. At the same time, women make use of these opportunities and interpret their experience in diverse ways that problematise the neo-liberal promises of innovative technologies, job flexibility and autonomy embodied in platform capitalism.
- Open Access
- 1 November 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Journal of Middle East Studies
- Vol. 52 (4) , 759-764
Citizenship without Belonging? Contesting Economic Space in Oman
How do perceptions of not belonging inform economic life? For many young Omanis, the labor market is a site of contestation and a space of struggle. In this essay, I explore a neglected dimension of belonging in the Gulf—citizen labor—by looking at Omani millennials in the labor market. Despite holding legal citizenship, a sense of belonging remains elusive in much of the private sector. Many Omani young people perceive a tenuous economic citizenship, complicating narratives around belonging or not belonging in the Arabian Peninsula. I draw from lessons learned while researching my current book and exploring social relations and regulation of labor markets, and reflect on how the knowledge and theories produced concerning Gulf labor markets rarely engage with the citizens in them.
- 1 November 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Journal of Middle East Studies
- Vol. 52 (4) , 759-764
Open AccessCitizenship without Belonging? Contesting Economic Space in Oman
How do perceptions of not belonging inform economic life? For many young Omanis, the labor market is a site of contestation and a space of struggle. In this essay, I explore a neglected dimension of belonging in the Gulf—citizen labor—by looking at Omani millennials in the labor market. Despite holding legal citizenship, a sense of belonging remains elusive in much of the private sector. Many Omani young people perceive a tenuous economic citizenship, complicating narratives around belonging or not belonging in the Arabian Peninsula. I draw from lessons learned while researching my current book and exploring social relations and regulation of labor markets, and reflect on how the knowledge and theories produced concerning Gulf labor markets rarely engage with the citizens in them.
- Open Access
- 6 December 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal: Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis
- Vol. 73 (4) , 573-595
Reading entrepreneurial power in small Gulf states: Qatar and the UAE
Qatar and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have become crucial players in the Middle East North Africa regional order. Few would have expected such a transformation even 20 years ago. This paper examines the constitution of Qatari and Emirati power. It demonstrates how understanding the entrepreneurial power of states is central to explanations of growth, strength, and position in regional and global orders. The analysis argues that the entrepreneurial powerhood of Qatar and the UAE is constituted by their development narrative and pursuit of status, which is facilitated by their material capabilities and their governance style characterized by flexible autocracy.
- 6 December 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal: Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis
- Vol. 73 (4) , 573-595
Open AccessReading entrepreneurial power in small Gulf states: Qatar and the UAE
Qatar and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have become crucial players in the Middle East North Africa regional order. Few would have expected such a transformation even 20 years ago. This paper examines the constitution of Qatari and Emirati power. It demonstrates how understanding the entrepreneurial power of states is central to explanations of growth, strength, and position in regional and global orders. The analysis argues that the entrepreneurial powerhood of Qatar and the UAE is constituted by their development narrative and pursuit of status, which is facilitated by their material capabilities and their governance style characterized by flexible autocracy.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Political Economy
- Vol. 24 (3) , 365-384
The Gendered Complexities of Promoting Female Entrepreneurship in the Gulf
This paper explores women’s entrepreneurial activities in the Oman and Qatar in light of the state attention given to promoting entrepreneurship in the region over the past decade. In the Gulf Arab countries, like in many rapidly developing economies, neoliberal growth discourse abounds. Along with this, the promotion of entrepreneurship and embrace of individual enterprise is paramount. Despite the dominance of the state in political and economic spaces, Gulf governments have embraced the rhetoric of the market and entrepreneurship. Drawing from semi-structured interviews, focus groups, and participant observation conducted between 2011 and 2015, this paper examines this phenomenon. In a region stereotyped with weak gender development outcomes, female entrepreneurship is largely cast as a positive development aimed at liberating and empowering women through individual enterprise. In contrast, this paper finds that the same forces that are meant to empower women often reproduce or reinforce certain gender norms while introducing new forms of dependency. Gulf female entrepreneurs confront competing tensions within three intersecting political economy logics: the structural logic of the economy, the logic of development narratives, and the logic of socio-economic organisation.
- 21 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Political Economy
- Vol. 24 (3) , 365-384
Open AccessThe Gendered Complexities of Promoting Female Entrepreneurship in the Gulf
This paper explores women’s entrepreneurial activities in the Oman and Qatar in light of the state attention given to promoting entrepreneurship in the region over the past decade. In the Gulf Arab countries, like in many rapidly developing economies, neoliberal growth discourse abounds. Along with this, the promotion of entrepreneurship and embrace of individual enterprise is paramount. Despite the dominance of the state in political and economic spaces, Gulf governments have embraced the rhetoric of the market and entrepreneurship. Drawing from semi-structured interviews, focus groups, and participant observation conducted between 2011 and 2015, this paper examines this phenomenon. In a region stereotyped with weak gender development outcomes, female entrepreneurship is largely cast as a positive development aimed at liberating and empowering women through individual enterprise. In contrast, this paper finds that the same forces that are meant to empower women often reproduce or reinforce certain gender norms while introducing new forms of dependency. Gulf female entrepreneurs confront competing tensions within three intersecting political economy logics: the structural logic of the economy, the logic of development narratives, and the logic of socio-economic organisation.
- Open Access
- 7 November 2017
- Published by SAGE Publications in Global Social Policy
- Vol. 18 (2) , 169-188
Labour market regulation as global social policy: The case of nursing labour markets in Oman
This article examines global social policy formation in the area of skilled migration, with a focus on the Gulf Arab region. Across the globe, migration governance presents challenges to multiple levels of authority; its complexity crosses many scales and involves a multitude of actors with diverse interests. Despite this jurisdictional complexity, migration remains one of the most staunchly defended realms of sovereign policy control. Building on global social policy literature, this article examines how ‘domestic’ labour migration policies reflect the entanglement of multiple states’ and agencies’ interests. Such entanglements result in what we characterize as a ‘multiplex system’, where skilled-migration policies are formed within, and shaped by, globalized policy spaces. To illustrate, we examine policies that shape the nursing labour market in Oman during a period when the state aims to transition from dependence on an expatriate to an increasingly nationalized labour force. Engaging a case-study methodology including a survey of migrant healthcare workers, semi-structured interviews and data analysis, we find that nursing labour markets in Oman represent an example of global policy formation due to the interaction of domestic and expatriate labour policies and provisioning systems. The transnational structuring of policy making that emerges reflects a contingent process marked by conflicting outcomes. We contend that Oman’s nursing labour market is an example of new spaces where global social policies emerge from the tension of competing national state and market interests.
- 7 November 2017
- Published by SAGE Publications in Global Social Policy
- Vol. 18 (2) , 169-188
Open AccessLabour market regulation as global social policy: The case of nursing labour markets in Oman
This article examines global social policy formation in the area of skilled migration, with a focus on the Gulf Arab region. Across the globe, migration governance presents challenges to multiple levels of authority; its complexity crosses many scales and involves a multitude of actors with diverse interests. Despite this jurisdictional complexity, migration remains one of the most staunchly defended realms of sovereign policy control. Building on global social policy literature, this article examines how ‘domestic’ labour migration policies reflect the entanglement of multiple states’ and agencies’ interests. Such entanglements result in what we characterize as a ‘multiplex system’, where skilled-migration policies are formed within, and shaped by, globalized policy spaces. To illustrate, we examine policies that shape the nursing labour market in Oman during a period when the state aims to transition from dependence on an expatriate to an increasingly nationalized labour force. Engaging a case-study methodology including a survey of migrant healthcare workers, semi-structured interviews and data analysis, we find that nursing labour markets in Oman represent an example of global policy formation due to the interaction of domestic and expatriate labour policies and provisioning systems. The transnational structuring of policy making that emerges reflects a contingent process marked by conflicting outcomes. We contend that Oman’s nursing labour market is an example of new spaces where global social policies emerge from the tension of competing national state and market interests.