Seung Young Park
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Seung Young Park has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David J. Love
Purdue University, West Lafayette, USA
7 shared publications - Daeyoung Park
Inha Univ., Incheon
3 shared publications Dong Hoi Kim
School of Information Technology, Kangwon National University, 192-1 Hyoja-dong, Chuncheon, 200-701, Republic of Korea
2 shared publicationsC.K. Au-Yeung
Student Member
1 shared publicationChung Gu Kang
1 shared publicationDavid J. Love
School of Electrical & Computer Eng., Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 6 January 2014
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 62 (2) , 536-551
Multicell Cooperative Scheduling for Two-Tier Cellular Networks
Cellular wireless network architectures employing a tiered structure, consisting of traditional macro-cells and small-cells, have attracted much attention recently because of their potential to dramatically increase network capacity. These architectures can reduce the distances of transmit-receiver pairs, thus enhancing radio link qualities. However, a tiered cell deployment could incur severe cochannel interference. Prior work for single-tier networks has proposed coordinated multi-point (CoMP) transmission, which includes joint transmission, as a possible solution for overcoming the rate limitations induced by cochannel interference. Because users in each cell experience various interference conditions, each cell needs to support single transmission (in which only one cell transmits to a single user) and joint transmission. In a conventional implementation, a particular combination of transmissions over the entire network is fixed in advance for each time slot and opportunistic scheduling chooses one of the users supported by each transmission. However, when the number of users to be scheduled is small, the throughput improvement from opportunistic scheduling becomes limited. To overcome this problem, we propose a cumulative distribution function-based scheduling scheme which jointly chooses the transmitter set and the corresponding scheduled users in a two-tier network. It is shown that the throughput performance can be improved compared to those of the fixed slot resource allocation scheme because more users "compete" for slot resources.
- 6 January 2014
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 62 (2) , 536-551
Multicell Cooperative Scheduling for Two-Tier Cellular Networks
Cellular wireless network architectures employing a tiered structure, consisting of traditional macro-cells and small-cells, have attracted much attention recently because of their potential to dramatically increase network capacity. These architectures can reduce the distances of transmit-receiver pairs, thus enhancing radio link qualities. However, a tiered cell deployment could incur severe cochannel interference. Prior work for single-tier networks has proposed coordinated multi-point (CoMP) transmission, which includes joint transmission, as a possible solution for overcoming the rate limitations induced by cochannel interference. Because users in each cell experience various interference conditions, each cell needs to support single transmission (in which only one cell transmits to a single user) and joint transmission. In a conventional implementation, a particular combination of transmissions over the entire network is fixed in advance for each time slot and opportunistic scheduling chooses one of the users supported by each transmission. However, when the number of users to be scheduled is small, the throughput improvement from opportunistic scheduling becomes limited. To overcome this problem, we propose a cumulative distribution function-based scheduling scheme which jointly chooses the transmitter set and the corresponding scheduled users in a two-tier network. It is shown that the throughput performance can be improved compared to those of the fixed slot resource allocation scheme because more users "compete" for slot resources.
- 2 November 2011
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 60 (1) , 231
Corrections to `Capacity Limits of Multi-Antenna Multicasting Under Correlated Fading Channels' [Jul 10 2002-2013]
The above paper mistakenly employs the incorrect in- equalities of and in Appendix B, and as a result, it leads to incorrect derivation procedures of the lower and the upper-bounds on the average mutual information.
- 2 November 2011
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 60 (1) , 231
Corrections to `Capacity Limits of Multi-Antenna Multicasting Under Correlated Fading Channels' [Jul 10 2002-2013]
The above paper mistakenly employs the incorrect in- equalities of and in Appendix B, and as a result, it leads to incorrect derivation procedures of the lower and the upper-bounds on the average mutual information.
- 26 August 2010
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 58 (9) , 2741-2751
Throughput Delay Tradeoff for Wireless Multicast Using Hybrid-ARQ Protocols
In this paper, we present a hybrid automatic repeat request (ARQ) scheme for wireless multicast with incremental redundancy channel coding and packet retransmission. With this scheme, we can reliably deliver the same copy of information to different users with mild delay. In addition, the design of the feedback channel for this scheme can be greatly simplified as no effort must be expended to combat cross user interference. We assume that there is always a packet for the transmitter to send whenever the channel is available. The transmitter is assumed to have a buffer of infinite length so that there is no packet-dropping. Three specific schemes are studied, including generalized slotted ALOHA (GSA), repetition time diversity (RTD), and general incremental redundancy (IR). The scaling laws of the average delay and average throughput with respect of the number of users are derived. In addition, we also derive a condition to obtain a linear scaling for both the throughput and the delay with respect to the number of users. Since every user can achieve no more than the ergodic capacity, we actually achieve the optimal scaling law in this case. Simulation results confirm our findings.
- 26 August 2010
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 58 (9) , 2741-2751
Throughput Delay Tradeoff for Wireless Multicast Using Hybrid-ARQ Protocols
In this paper, we present a hybrid automatic repeat request (ARQ) scheme for wireless multicast with incremental redundancy channel coding and packet retransmission. With this scheme, we can reliably deliver the same copy of information to different users with mild delay. In addition, the design of the feedback channel for this scheme can be greatly simplified as no effort must be expended to combat cross user interference. We assume that there is always a packet for the transmitter to send whenever the channel is available. The transmitter is assumed to have a buffer of infinite length so that there is no packet-dropping. Three specific schemes are studied, including generalized slotted ALOHA (GSA), repetition time diversity (RTD), and general incremental redundancy (IR). The scaling laws of the average delay and average throughput with respect of the number of users are derived. In addition, we also derive a condition to obtain a linear scaling for both the throughput and the delay with respect to the number of users. Since every user can achieve no more than the ergodic capacity, we actually achieve the optimal scaling law in this case. Simulation results confirm our findings.
- 8 July 2010
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 58 (7) , 2002-2013
Capacity Limits of Multi-Antenna Multicasting Under Correlated Fading Channels
Physical layer multicasting in wireless networks has been proposed to efficiently send an identical message to multiple users simultaneously. In this paper, we consider multiple antenna multicasting where the transmitter is equipped with Mt antennas and data is transmitted to K single-antenna users. When the downlink channels are assumed to follow an uncorrelated Rayleigh distribution, the multicasting capacity scaling for the large K asymptote is known. On the other hand, the effect of channel spatial correlation on the capacity performance has not been well addressed. Therefore, we investigate the effect of correlation using the channel correlation information at the transmitter. Using extreme value theory, it is shown that signaling using uniformly allocated transmit powers on the spatial channel correlation matrix's eigenvectors with non-zero eigenvalues approaches the multicasting capacity for the large K asymptote. Compared to the performance of uncorrelated fading channels with a constraint on the trace of the spatial correlation matrix, it is shown that the channel correlation degrades the performance. Specifically, if the correlation matrix is full rank the asymptotic outage (average) capacity ratio, which is defined as the ratio of the outage (average) capacities of the correlated fading channel and the uncorrelated fading channel as K goes to infinity, is equivalent to the geometric mean of the eigenvalues of the transmit channel correlation matrix of the correlated channel. On the other hand, if the correlation matrix is not full rank, the capacity ratios become zero. To assess the value of knowledge of the channel correlation information at the transmitter, we compare the asymptotic performances with and without knowledge of the channel correlation information. Specifically, the asymptotic performance improvement due to this correlation knowledge becomes (Mt/M)1/M for the large K asymptote, where M is the rank of the transmit channel correlation matrix. In addition, we discuss the issues of nonidentical transmit channel correlations among the users and correlation between users' channels.
- 8 July 2010
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 58 (7) , 2002-2013
Capacity Limits of Multi-Antenna Multicasting Under Correlated Fading Channels
Physical layer multicasting in wireless networks has been proposed to efficiently send an identical message to multiple users simultaneously. In this paper, we consider multiple antenna multicasting where the transmitter is equipped with Mt antennas and data is transmitted to K single-antenna users. When the downlink channels are assumed to follow an uncorrelated Rayleigh distribution, the multicasting capacity scaling for the large K asymptote is known. On the other hand, the effect of channel spatial correlation on the capacity performance has not been well addressed. Therefore, we investigate the effect of correlation using the channel correlation information at the transmitter. Using extreme value theory, it is shown that signaling using uniformly allocated transmit powers on the spatial channel correlation matrix's eigenvectors with non-zero eigenvalues approaches the multicasting capacity for the large K asymptote. Compared to the performance of uncorrelated fading channels with a constraint on the trace of the spatial correlation matrix, it is shown that the channel correlation degrades the performance. Specifically, if the correlation matrix is full rank the asymptotic outage (average) capacity ratio, which is defined as the ratio of the outage (average) capacities of the correlated fading channel and the uncorrelated fading channel as K goes to infinity, is equivalent to the geometric mean of the eigenvalues of the transmit channel correlation matrix of the correlated channel. On the other hand, if the correlation matrix is not full rank, the capacity ratios become zero. To assess the value of knowledge of the channel correlation information at the transmitter, we compare the asymptotic performances with and without knowledge of the channel correlation information. Specifically, the asymptotic performance improvement due to this correlation knowledge becomes (Mt/M)1/M for the large K asymptote, where M is the rank of the transmit channel correlation matrix. In addition, we discuss the issues of nonidentical transmit channel correlations among the users and correlation between users' channels.
- 19 May 2009
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 57 (5) , 1514-1522
A Simple Dual-Mode Limited Feedback Multiuser Downlink System
Generally limited feedback systems that multiplex multiple user signals are noise power limited in the low signal-tonoise- ratio (SNR) regime and interference power limited in the high SNR regime. If the amount of feedback does not grow with SNR, then there is a sum rate ceiling that increasing the transmit power alone cannot surpass. This paper proposes a simple dual mode system where the base station serves either one user or as many users as the number of transmit antennas. The switching mechanism is smooth and is based on instantaneous system conditions. The mobile determines its preferred transmission mode by using a very simple signal-to-interference-and-noiseratio (SINR) threshold. Based on the mobiles' feedback, the base station chooses the method of signalling accordingly. With a finite number of feedback bits per mobile, it is shown that the proposed system achieves close to the maximum of the sum-rate for single user and multiuser modes. We identify the preferrable mode for an asymptotically large number of users and/or SNR. This proposed architecture is suitable for systems with moderate coherence time, a moderate to large number of users, and a moderate SNR that cannot afford complex processing at the base station or at the mobile.
- 19 May 2009
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 57 (5) , 1514-1522
A Simple Dual-Mode Limited Feedback Multiuser Downlink System
Generally limited feedback systems that multiplex multiple user signals are noise power limited in the low signal-tonoise- ratio (SNR) regime and interference power limited in the high SNR regime. If the amount of feedback does not grow with SNR, then there is a sum rate ceiling that increasing the transmit power alone cannot surpass. This paper proposes a simple dual mode system where the base station serves either one user or as many users as the number of transmit antennas. The switching mechanism is smooth and is based on instantaneous system conditions. The mobile determines its preferred transmission mode by using a very simple signal-to-interference-and-noiseratio (SINR) threshold. Based on the mobiles' feedback, the base station chooses the method of signalling accordingly. With a finite number of feedback bits per mobile, it is shown that the proposed system achieves close to the maximum of the sum-rate for single user and multiuser modes. We identify the preferrable mode for an asymptotically large number of users and/or SNR. This proposed architecture is suitable for systems with moderate coherence time, a moderate to large number of users, and a moderate SNR that cannot afford complex processing at the base station or at the mobile.
- 2 May 2009
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications
- Vol. 8 (4) , 1996-2005
Outage performance of multi-antenna multicasting for wireless networks
Wireless cellular networks often need to convey the same data to multiple users simultaneously. This kind of transmission is known as physical layer multicasting. Unfortunately, when any user fails to receive the data correctly, the information must be retransmitted to all the users, resulting in a waste of radio resources. Thus, it is important to investigate the outage probability of multicast channels, which is defined as the probability that the smallest maximum achievable rate among all of the users is smaller than a specified transmission rate. In this paper, we consider the use of multiple antenna multicast channels where the transmitter is equipped with Mt antennas and independent data is transmitted on each antenna to K users. Using extreme value theory, we derive a closed form limiting distribution that the exact distribution of the multicasting channel converges to when the number of users K is taken to infinity. From this result, we find upper and lower-bounds on the outage probability. It is shown that for a given outage probability the upper-bound becomes sufficiently tight to approximate the exact outage probability with K such that it converges to the exact one with a speed faster than Theta (K-1/M t). Using this upper-bound, we identify conditions on the transmission rate and the transmit power necessary to maintain constant outage performance as K increases. Specifically, the transmission rate should be decreased as Theta (K-1/M t) or the transmit power should be increased as Theta (K1/M t). This means that the outage performance improves as the number of transmit antennas increases, because spatial diversity can be well exploited. However, this increase in the number of transmit antennas requires a significant cost. To improve the performance without requiring additional cost, we consider a multiple-slot multicasting that transmits the same data over multiple slots and an antenna subset selection scheme that transmits the data over some subset of the transmit antennas. It is shown that the transmission rate of multiple-slot scheme can be increased when the number of slots is carefully chosen and the diversity-multiplexing trade-off is the same as that of K = 1. Also, the gain in the transmission rate from selecting some subset of the transmit antennas is derived.
- 2 May 2009
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications
- Vol. 8 (4) , 1996-2005
Outage performance of multi-antenna multicasting for wireless networks
Wireless cellular networks often need to convey the same data to multiple users simultaneously. This kind of transmission is known as physical layer multicasting. Unfortunately, when any user fails to receive the data correctly, the information must be retransmitted to all the users, resulting in a waste of radio resources. Thus, it is important to investigate the outage probability of multicast channels, which is defined as the probability that the smallest maximum achievable rate among all of the users is smaller than a specified transmission rate. In this paper, we consider the use of multiple antenna multicast channels where the transmitter is equipped with Mt antennas and independent data is transmitted on each antenna to K users. Using extreme value theory, we derive a closed form limiting distribution that the exact distribution of the multicasting channel converges to when the number of users K is taken to infinity. From this result, we find upper and lower-bounds on the outage probability. It is shown that for a given outage probability the upper-bound becomes sufficiently tight to approximate the exact outage probability with K such that it converges to the exact one with a speed faster than Theta (K-1/M t). Using this upper-bound, we identify conditions on the transmission rate and the transmit power necessary to maintain constant outage performance as K increases. Specifically, the transmission rate should be decreased as Theta (K-1/M t) or the transmit power should be increased as Theta (K1/M t). This means that the outage performance improves as the number of transmit antennas increases, because spatial diversity can be well exploited. However, this increase in the number of transmit antennas requires a significant cost. To improve the performance without requiring additional cost, we consider a multiple-slot multicasting that transmits the same data over multiple slots and an antenna subset selection scheme that transmits the data over some subset of the transmit antennas. It is shown that the transmission rate of multiple-slot scheme can be increased when the number of slots is carefully chosen and the diversity-multiplexing trade-off is the same as that of K = 1. Also, the gain in the transmission rate from selecting some subset of the transmit antennas is derived.
- 16 May 2008
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing
- Vol. 56 (6) , 2524-2534
Capacity Limits of Multiple Antenna Multicasting Using Antenna Subset Selection
Both military and commercial wireless cellular networks often require the same data to be conveyed to multiple users simultaneously. This technique is usually referred to as physical layer multicasting. Unfortunately, the capacity of this multicasting setup is dictated by the smallest maximum achievable rate among all the users. In this paper, we consider the use of antenna subset selection in multicast channels where the transmitter is equipped with multiple antennas and sends a common message to multiple users. In this set-up, the antenna subset selection scheme selects some subset of the basestation transmit antennas to maximize the minimum signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) among the associated users. Using an asymptotic analysis, the average capacity of the antenna subset selection scheme is compared with that provided by max-min transmit beamforming, which requires channel state information at the transmitter to maximize the minimum user SNR, and an open-loop scheme where independent data is transmitted on each antenna. Then, we identify the minimum required antenna configuration condition for multicasting in which the antenna subset selection scheme universally performs better than the open-loop scheme and outperforms max-min transmit beamforming when the number of users is large. In addition, for a fixed number of radio frequency chains and users, it is shown that the antenna subset selection scheme can exploit the antenna selection diversity and its average capacity grows double logarithmically with the number of transmit antennas without bound.
- 16 May 2008
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing
- Vol. 56 (6) , 2524-2534
Capacity Limits of Multiple Antenna Multicasting Using Antenna Subset Selection
Both military and commercial wireless cellular networks often require the same data to be conveyed to multiple users simultaneously. This technique is usually referred to as physical layer multicasting. Unfortunately, the capacity of this multicasting setup is dictated by the smallest maximum achievable rate among all the users. In this paper, we consider the use of antenna subset selection in multicast channels where the transmitter is equipped with multiple antennas and sends a common message to multiple users. In this set-up, the antenna subset selection scheme selects some subset of the basestation transmit antennas to maximize the minimum signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) among the associated users. Using an asymptotic analysis, the average capacity of the antenna subset selection scheme is compared with that provided by max-min transmit beamforming, which requires channel state information at the transmitter to maximize the minimum user SNR, and an open-loop scheme where independent data is transmitted on each antenna. Then, we identify the minimum required antenna configuration condition for multicasting in which the antenna subset selection scheme universally performs better than the open-loop scheme and outperforms max-min transmit beamforming when the number of users is large. In addition, for a fixed number of radio frequency chains and users, it is shown that the antenna subset selection scheme can exploit the antenna selection diversity and its average capacity grows double logarithmically with the number of transmit antennas without bound.
- 15 April 2008
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 56 (4) , 666-674
Performance Analysis of Multiuser Diversity under Transmit Antenna Correlation
In this paper, we investigate the effect of spatial correlation on throughput performance of downlink multi-antenna transmission schemes exploiting multiuser diversity, in which partial channel information such as signal-to-interference plus noise power ratio (SINR) is available at the transmitter. The asymptotic analysis is performed based on the extreme value theory. From this analysis, we demonstrate that the throughput optimal transmission scheme depends on the degree of the antenna correlation and the operating SNR. Especially, the multiuser spatial multiplexing known as the asymptotically optimal transmission scheme is no longer optimal in highly correlated multiple antenna channels.
- 15 April 2008
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 56 (4) , 666-674
Performance Analysis of Multiuser Diversity under Transmit Antenna Correlation
In this paper, we investigate the effect of spatial correlation on throughput performance of downlink multi-antenna transmission schemes exploiting multiuser diversity, in which partial channel information such as signal-to-interference plus noise power ratio (SINR) is available at the transmitter. The asymptotic analysis is performed based on the extreme value theory. From this analysis, we demonstrate that the throughput optimal transmission scheme depends on the degree of the antenna correlation and the operating SNR. Especially, the multiuser spatial multiplexing known as the asymptotically optimal transmission scheme is no longer optimal in highly correlated multiple antenna channels.
- 24 September 2007
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
- Vol. 56 (5) , 3040-3059
Hybrid Division Duplex System for Next-Generation Cellular Services
The paper proposes a new duplexing scheme, which is called the hybrid division duplex (HDD), that is suitable for fourth-generation mobile communication systems. The proposed mobile communication system is much more flexible and efficient in providing asymmetric data service and managing intercell interference by exploiting the advantages of both time division duplex (TDD) and frequency division duplex (FDD) schemes. The HDD scheme has a pair of frequency bands such as the FDD, performing a TDD operation using one of the bands in such a manner that allows for simultaneous FDD and TDD operations. Considering the properties of the HDD system architecture, frequency hopping orthogonal frequency division multiple (OFDM) access is adopted in one band for the TDD operation and code division multiple access (CDMA) in the other band for the FDD uplink operation. The important advantage of the HDD scheme is the robustness against cross time slot interference that is inherent to the TDD system, which is caused by the asynchronous downlink/uplink switching boundaries among all neighbor cells. From the simulation results, the proposed system can achieve approximately 7% and 30% improvement with regard to the downlink and uplink throughput, respectively, as compared to the conventional TDD system under cell-independent downlink/uplink traffic asymmetries. It demonstrates that the HDD scheme is a viable solution for future communication systems that are projected to have a cell-independent asymmetric-traffic-supported hierarchical cell structure.
- 24 September 2007
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
- Vol. 56 (5) , 3040-3059
Hybrid Division Duplex System for Next-Generation Cellular Services
The paper proposes a new duplexing scheme, which is called the hybrid division duplex (HDD), that is suitable for fourth-generation mobile communication systems. The proposed mobile communication system is much more flexible and efficient in providing asymmetric data service and managing intercell interference by exploiting the advantages of both time division duplex (TDD) and frequency division duplex (FDD) schemes. The HDD scheme has a pair of frequency bands such as the FDD, performing a TDD operation using one of the bands in such a manner that allows for simultaneous FDD and TDD operations. Considering the properties of the HDD system architecture, frequency hopping orthogonal frequency division multiple (OFDM) access is adopted in one band for the TDD operation and code division multiple access (CDMA) in the other band for the FDD uplink operation. The important advantage of the HDD scheme is the robustness against cross time slot interference that is inherent to the TDD system, which is caused by the asynchronous downlink/uplink switching boundaries among all neighbor cells. From the simulation results, the proposed system can achieve approximately 7% and 30% improvement with regard to the downlink and uplink throughput, respectively, as compared to the conventional TDD system under cell-independent downlink/uplink traffic asymmetries. It demonstrates that the HDD scheme is a viable solution for future communication systems that are projected to have a cell-independent asymmetric-traffic-supported hierarchical cell structure.
- 1 January 2006
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 789-793
On User Selection for Multiple Antenna Wireless Networks with Contention-Based Feedback and Delay Constraints
In this paper, we address the effect of a spread spectrum contention-based feedback channel on the throughput performance of a multi-antenna wireless network under delay constraints. We show that an appropriately designed feedback channel satisfies a required delay constraint, in which the probability that the maximum delay is less than a specified value, while maintaining most of the multiuser diversity gain. In addition, we also show that the spectral efficiency improves as the number of users increases while maintaining the performance of the normalized maximum delay which is the ratio of the maximum delay and the number of users.
- 1 January 2006
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 789-793
On User Selection for Multiple Antenna Wireless Networks with Contention-Based Feedback and Delay Constraints
In this paper, we address the effect of a spread spectrum contention-based feedback channel on the throughput performance of a multi-antenna wireless network under delay constraints. We show that an appropriately designed feedback channel satisfies a required delay constraint, in which the probability that the maximum delay is less than a specified value, while maintaining most of the multiuser diversity gain. In addition, we also show that the spectral efficiency improves as the number of users increases while maintaining the performance of the normalized maximum delay which is the ratio of the maximum delay and the number of users.