Lloyd J. Winchell
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Lloyd J. Winchell has a total of 38 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
John J. Ross
Brown and Caldwell Walnut Creek California USA
6 shared publicationsKatherine Y. Bell
Brown and Caldwell Walnut Creek California USA
6 shared publicationsJohn W. Norton
Great Lakes Water Authority Detroit Michigan USA
5 shared publicationsMartha J. M. Wells
EnviroChem Services Cookeville Tennessee USA
3 shared publicationsXavier Fonoll
Great Lakes Water Authority Detroit Michigan USA
3 shared publications- Dominic A. Brose
Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago Cicero Illinois USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 97 (2) , e70039
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances in untreated and treated sludge/biosolids from 27 water resource recovery facilities across the United States and Canada
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are being studied in all environmental matrices because of their ubiquitous presence and adverse human health impacts. This study conducted a surveillance of 27 water resource recovery facilities throughout the United States and Canada to screen the range of PFAS concentrations in pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product. Among the 27 water resource recovery facilities, 82% use anaerobic digestion and the rest use chemical stabilization and/or incineration for sludge stabilization. Forty PFAS compounds were evaluated by US Environmental Protection Agency Method SW846/537.1, and four and nine compounds were reported in the pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product, respectively. Concentrations of reported compounds in pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product varied from 5 to 33 ng/g dry basis and 2 to 220 ng/g dry basis, respectively. 3‐Perfluoropentylpropanoic acid (5:3 FTCA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) were the most frequently observed compounds, and PFAS concentrations in the post‐stabilized products were generally higher than the corresponding pre‐stabilized sludge. Practitioner Points: Among the 40 target PFAS, four were above reporting limit in the pre‐stabilized sludge and nine in the post‐stabilized product. Incineration ash (post‐stabilized product) samples did not have any reportable PFAS. 5:3 FTCA and PFOS were the two frequently observed compounds; concentrations were higher in the post‐stabilized product compared to the pre‐stabilized sludge. PFPeA and PFHxA were the only two short chain perfluoroalkyl carboxylic acids reported. PFOA was reported in only one of the 54 samples evaluated.
- 23 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 97 (2) , e70039
Open AccessPer‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances in untreated and treated sludge/biosolids from 27 water resource recovery facilities across the United States and Canada
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are being studied in all environmental matrices because of their ubiquitous presence and adverse human health impacts. This study conducted a surveillance of 27 water resource recovery facilities throughout the United States and Canada to screen the range of PFAS concentrations in pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product. Among the 27 water resource recovery facilities, 82% use anaerobic digestion and the rest use chemical stabilization and/or incineration for sludge stabilization. Forty PFAS compounds were evaluated by US Environmental Protection Agency Method SW846/537.1, and four and nine compounds were reported in the pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product, respectively. Concentrations of reported compounds in pre‐stabilized sludge and post‐stabilized product varied from 5 to 33 ng/g dry basis and 2 to 220 ng/g dry basis, respectively. 3‐Perfluoropentylpropanoic acid (5:3 FTCA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) were the most frequently observed compounds, and PFAS concentrations in the post‐stabilized products were generally higher than the corresponding pre‐stabilized sludge. Practitioner Points: Among the 40 target PFAS, four were above reporting limit in the pre‐stabilized sludge and nine in the post‐stabilized product. Incineration ash (post‐stabilized product) samples did not have any reportable PFAS. 5:3 FTCA and PFOS were the two frequently observed compounds; concentrations were higher in the post‐stabilized product compared to the pre‐stabilized sludge. PFPeA and PFHxA were the only two short chain perfluoroalkyl carboxylic acids reported. PFOA was reported in only one of the 54 samples evaluated.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 96 (11) , e11149
Fate of biosolids‐bound PFAS through pyrolysis coupled with thermal oxidation for air emissions control
Pyrolysis has been identified as a possible thermal treatment process for reducing perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from wastewater solids, though off‐gas from the pyrolysis unit can still be a source of PFAS emissions. In this work, the fate of PFAS through a laboratory‐scale pyrolysis unit coupled with a thermal oxidizer for treatment of off‐gasses is documented. Between 91.5% and >99.9% reduction was observed through the entire system for specific compounds based on targeted analyses. Overall, the pyrolysis and thermal oxidizer system removed 99.4% of the PFAS moles introduced. Furthermore, shorter chain variants comprised the majority of reportable PFAS in the thermal oxidizer flue gas, indicating the longer chain compounds present in the dried biosolids fed to pyrolyzer decompose through the system.Practitioner Points: Thermal oxidation is a promising treatment technology for exhaust systems associated with thermal biosolids treatments. Thermal oxidation demonstrated significant degradation capabilities, with gas phase emissions comprising only 0.200% of initial PFAS concentrations to the system. Short‐chain PFAS made up a higher percent of thermal oxidizer emissions, ranging between 54.4% and 79.5% of PFAS in the exhaust on a molar basis. The possibility of recombinant PFAS formation and partial thermal decomposition of PFAS in thermal oxidation is a needed area of research.
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 96 (11) , e11149
Open AccessFate of biosolids‐bound PFAS through pyrolysis coupled with thermal oxidation for air emissions control
Pyrolysis has been identified as a possible thermal treatment process for reducing perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from wastewater solids, though off‐gas from the pyrolysis unit can still be a source of PFAS emissions. In this work, the fate of PFAS through a laboratory‐scale pyrolysis unit coupled with a thermal oxidizer for treatment of off‐gasses is documented. Between 91.5% and >99.9% reduction was observed through the entire system for specific compounds based on targeted analyses. Overall, the pyrolysis and thermal oxidizer system removed 99.4% of the PFAS moles introduced. Furthermore, shorter chain variants comprised the majority of reportable PFAS in the thermal oxidizer flue gas, indicating the longer chain compounds present in the dried biosolids fed to pyrolyzer decompose through the system.Practitioner Points: Thermal oxidation is a promising treatment technology for exhaust systems associated with thermal biosolids treatments. Thermal oxidation demonstrated significant degradation capabilities, with gas phase emissions comprising only 0.200% of initial PFAS concentrations to the system. Short‐chain PFAS made up a higher percent of thermal oxidizer emissions, ranging between 54.4% and 79.5% of PFAS in the exhaust on a molar basis. The possibility of recombinant PFAS formation and partial thermal decomposition of PFAS in thermal oxidation is a needed area of research.
- Open Access
- 5 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 96 (3) , e11009
Fate of perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) through two full‐scale wastewater sludge incinerators
Perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are an emerging issue in wastewater treatment. High‐temperature thermal processes, incineration being time‐tested, offer the opportunity to destroy and change the composition of PFAS. The fate of PFAS has been documented through wastewater sludge incinerators, including a multiple hearth furnace (MHF) and a fluidized bed furnace (FBF). The dewatered wastewater sludge feedstock averaged 247‐ and 1280‐μmol targeted PFAS per sample run in MHF and FBF feed, respectively. Stack emissions (reportable for all targeted PFAS from MHF only) averaged 5% of that value with shorter alkyl chain compounds comprising the majority of the targeted PFAS. Wet scrubber water streams accumulated nonpolar fluorinated organics from the furnace exhaust with an average of 0.740‐ and 0.114‐mol Fˉ per sample run, for the MHF and FBF, respectively. Simple alkane PFAS measured at the stack represented 0.5%–4.5% of the total estimated facility greenhouse gas emissions.Practitioner Points: The MHF emitted six short chain PFAS from the stack, which were shorter alkyl chain compounds compared with sludge PFAS. The FBF did not consistently emit reportable PFAS from the stack, but contamination complicated the assessment. Five percent of the MHF sludge molar PFAS load was reported in the stack. MHF and FBF wet scrubber water streams accumulated nonpolar fluorinated organics from the furnace exhaust. Ultra‐short volatile alkane PFAS measured at the stack represented 0.5%–4.5% of the estimated facility greenhouse gas emissions.
- 5 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 96 (3) , e11009
Open AccessFate of perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) through two full‐scale wastewater sludge incinerators
Perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are an emerging issue in wastewater treatment. High‐temperature thermal processes, incineration being time‐tested, offer the opportunity to destroy and change the composition of PFAS. The fate of PFAS has been documented through wastewater sludge incinerators, including a multiple hearth furnace (MHF) and a fluidized bed furnace (FBF). The dewatered wastewater sludge feedstock averaged 247‐ and 1280‐μmol targeted PFAS per sample run in MHF and FBF feed, respectively. Stack emissions (reportable for all targeted PFAS from MHF only) averaged 5% of that value with shorter alkyl chain compounds comprising the majority of the targeted PFAS. Wet scrubber water streams accumulated nonpolar fluorinated organics from the furnace exhaust with an average of 0.740‐ and 0.114‐mol Fˉ per sample run, for the MHF and FBF, respectively. Simple alkane PFAS measured at the stack represented 0.5%–4.5% of the total estimated facility greenhouse gas emissions.Practitioner Points: The MHF emitted six short chain PFAS from the stack, which were shorter alkyl chain compounds compared with sludge PFAS. The FBF did not consistently emit reportable PFAS from the stack, but contamination complicated the assessment. Five percent of the MHF sludge molar PFAS load was reported in the stack. MHF and FBF wet scrubber water streams accumulated nonpolar fluorinated organics from the furnace exhaust. Ultra‐short volatile alkane PFAS measured at the stack represented 0.5%–4.5% of the estimated facility greenhouse gas emissions.
- Open Access
- 7 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 94 (4) , e10715
High‐temperature technology survey and comparison among incineration, pyrolysis, and gasification systems for water resource recovery facilities
Solids from wastewater treatment undergo processing to reduce mass, minimize pathogens, and condition the products for specific end uses. However, costs and contaminant concerns (e.g., per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances [PFAS]) challenge traditional landfill and land application practices. Incineration can overcome these issues but has become complicated due to evolving emissions regulations, and it suffers from poor public perception. These circumstances are driving the re‐emergence of pyrolysis and gasification technologies. A survey of suppliers was conducted to document differences with technologies. Both offer advantages over incineration with tailored production of a carbon‐rich solid, currently less stringent air emission requirements, and lower flue gas flows requiring treatment. However, incineration more simply combines drying and thermal processing into one reactor. Equipment costs provided favor pyrolysis and gasification at lower capacities but converge with incineration at higher capacities. Long‐term operational experience will confirm technology competitiveness and elucidate whether pyrolysis and gasification warrant widespread adoption.Practitioner Points: Pyrolysis and gasification systems are gaining traction in the wastewater industry with several full‐scale installations operating, in construction, or design Several advantages, but some disadvantages, are considered in comparison with incineration Organic contaminants, including PFAS, will undergo transformation and potentially complete mineralization through each process
- 7 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 94 (4) , e10715
Open AccessHigh‐temperature technology survey and comparison among incineration, pyrolysis, and gasification systems for water resource recovery facilities
Solids from wastewater treatment undergo processing to reduce mass, minimize pathogens, and condition the products for specific end uses. However, costs and contaminant concerns (e.g., per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances [PFAS]) challenge traditional landfill and land application practices. Incineration can overcome these issues but has become complicated due to evolving emissions regulations, and it suffers from poor public perception. These circumstances are driving the re‐emergence of pyrolysis and gasification technologies. A survey of suppliers was conducted to document differences with technologies. Both offer advantages over incineration with tailored production of a carbon‐rich solid, currently less stringent air emission requirements, and lower flue gas flows requiring treatment. However, incineration more simply combines drying and thermal processing into one reactor. Equipment costs provided favor pyrolysis and gasification at lower capacities but converge with incineration at higher capacities. Long‐term operational experience will confirm technology competitiveness and elucidate whether pyrolysis and gasification warrant widespread adoption.Practitioner Points: Pyrolysis and gasification systems are gaining traction in the wastewater industry with several full‐scale installations operating, in construction, or design Several advantages, but some disadvantages, are considered in comparison with incineration Organic contaminants, including PFAS, will undergo transformation and potentially complete mineralization through each process
- Open Access
- 17 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 94 (3) , e10701
Pyrolysis and gasification at water resource recovery facilities: Status of the industry
Wastewater treatment generates solids requiring subsequent processing. Costs and contaminant concerns (e.g., per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances [PFAS]) are challenging widely used landfilling and land application practices. These circumstances are partly driving the re‐emergence of pyrolysis and gasification technologies along with beneficial reuse prospects of the char solid residual. Previously, technologies experienced operational challenges leading to revised configurations, such as directly coupling a thermal oxidizer to the reactor to destroy tar forming compounds. This paper provides an overview of pyrolysis and gasification technologies, characteristics of the char product, air emission considerations, and potential fate of PFAS and other pollutants through the systems. Results from a survey of viable suppliers illustrate differences in commercially available options. Additional research is required to validate performance over the long‐term operation and confirm contaminant fate, which will help determine whether resurging interest in pyrolysis and gasification warrants widespread adoption.Practitioner Points: Pyrolysis and gasification systems are re‐emerging in the wastewater industry. Direct coupling of thermal oxidizers and other modifications offered by contemporary systems aim to overcome past failures. Process conditions when coupled with a thermal oxidizer will likely destroy most organic contaminants, including PFAS, but requires additional research. Three full‐scale facilities recently operated, several in construction or design that will provide operating experience for widespread technology adoption consideration.
- 17 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 94 (3) , e10701
Open AccessPyrolysis and gasification at water resource recovery facilities: Status of the industry
Wastewater treatment generates solids requiring subsequent processing. Costs and contaminant concerns (e.g., per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances [PFAS]) are challenging widely used landfilling and land application practices. These circumstances are partly driving the re‐emergence of pyrolysis and gasification technologies along with beneficial reuse prospects of the char solid residual. Previously, technologies experienced operational challenges leading to revised configurations, such as directly coupling a thermal oxidizer to the reactor to destroy tar forming compounds. This paper provides an overview of pyrolysis and gasification technologies, characteristics of the char product, air emission considerations, and potential fate of PFAS and other pollutants through the systems. Results from a survey of viable suppliers illustrate differences in commercially available options. Additional research is required to validate performance over the long‐term operation and confirm contaminant fate, which will help determine whether resurging interest in pyrolysis and gasification warrants widespread adoption.Practitioner Points: Pyrolysis and gasification systems are re‐emerging in the wastewater industry. Direct coupling of thermal oxidizers and other modifications offered by contemporary systems aim to overcome past failures. Process conditions when coupled with a thermal oxidizer will likely destroy most organic contaminants, including PFAS, but requires additional research. Three full‐scale facilities recently operated, several in construction or design that will provide operating experience for widespread technology adoption consideration.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Environmental Engineering
- Vol. 148 (1) , 03121003
Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances Presence, Pathways, and Cycling through Drinking Water and Wastewater Treatment
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are compounds of emerging concern based on ubiquitous distribution and potential human health impacts. Whereas manufacturing plants and fire-training/suppression areas are recognized as primary sources of PFAS contamination of the environment, understanding the role of water treatment plants (WTPs) and water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs) in PFAS cycling is important. Literature on the presence and pathways of PFAS within and between WTPs and WRRFs was reviewed and synthesized to address this knowledge gap. The production, use, and disposal of PFAS was connected to the water cycle via aquifers/surface water/sediment, drinking water treatment, domestic/industrial water use, domestic/industrial wastewater treatment, the atmosphere, land application, landfills, thermal treatment of wastes, and food production. WTP and WRRF flows release PFAS in liquid-phase, solid-phase, and gas-phase matrices. The purpose of this review is to educate and inform readers of the fate and transport of PFASs throughout the urban water cycle emphasizing the WTP–WRRF connection. Source reduction programs, treatments that interrupt the PFAS cycle, and comprehensive analytical methods are future research needs.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Environmental Engineering
- Vol. 148 (1) , 03121003
Open AccessPer- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances Presence, Pathways, and Cycling through Drinking Water and Wastewater Treatment
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are compounds of emerging concern based on ubiquitous distribution and potential human health impacts. Whereas manufacturing plants and fire-training/suppression areas are recognized as primary sources of PFAS contamination of the environment, understanding the role of water treatment plants (WTPs) and water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs) in PFAS cycling is important. Literature on the presence and pathways of PFAS within and between WTPs and WRRFs was reviewed and synthesized to address this knowledge gap. The production, use, and disposal of PFAS was connected to the water cycle via aquifers/surface water/sediment, drinking water treatment, domestic/industrial water use, domestic/industrial wastewater treatment, the atmosphere, land application, landfills, thermal treatment of wastes, and food production. WTP and WRRF flows release PFAS in liquid-phase, solid-phase, and gas-phase matrices. The purpose of this review is to educate and inform readers of the fate and transport of PFASs throughout the urban water cycle emphasizing the WTP–WRRF connection. Source reduction programs, treatments that interrupt the PFAS cycle, and comprehensive analytical methods are future research needs.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2020
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 93 (6) , 826-843
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances thermal destruction at water resource recovery facilities: A state of the science review
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a recalcitrant group of chemicals and can be found throughout the environment. They often collect in wastewater systems with virtually no degradation prior to environmental discharge. Some PFAS partitions to solids captured in wastewater treatment which require further processing. Of all the commonly applied solids treatment technologies, incineration offers the only possibility to completely destroy PFAS. Little is known about the fate of PFAS through incineration, in particular, for the systems employed in water resource recovery facilities (WRRF). This review covers available research on the fate of PFAS through incineration systems with a focus on sewage sludge incinerators. This research indicates that at least some PFAS destruction will occur with incineration approaches used at WRRFs. Furthermore, PFAS in flue gas, ash, or water streams used for incinerator pollution control may be undetectable. Future research involving full‐scale fate studies will provide insight on the efficacy of PFAS destruction through incineration and whether other compounds of concern are generated.Practitioner points: Thermal processing is the only commercial approach available to destroy PFAS. Thermal degradation conditions required for destruction of PFAS during incineration processes are discussed. Fate of PFAS through water resource recovery facility incineration technologies remains unclear. Other thermal technologies such as smoldering combustion, pyrolysis, gasification, and hydrothermal liquefaction provide promise but are in developmental phases.
- 15 November 2020
- Published by Wiley in Water Environment Research
- Vol. 93 (6) , 826-843
Open AccessPer‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances thermal destruction at water resource recovery facilities: A state of the science review
Per‐ and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a recalcitrant group of chemicals and can be found throughout the environment. They often collect in wastewater systems with virtually no degradation prior to environmental discharge. Some PFAS partitions to solids captured in wastewater treatment which require further processing. Of all the commonly applied solids treatment technologies, incineration offers the only possibility to completely destroy PFAS. Little is known about the fate of PFAS through incineration, in particular, for the systems employed in water resource recovery facilities (WRRF). This review covers available research on the fate of PFAS through incineration systems with a focus on sewage sludge incinerators. This research indicates that at least some PFAS destruction will occur with incineration approaches used at WRRFs. Furthermore, PFAS in flue gas, ash, or water streams used for incinerator pollution control may be undetectable. Future research involving full‐scale fate studies will provide insight on the efficacy of PFAS destruction through incineration and whether other compounds of concern are generated.Practitioner points: Thermal processing is the only commercial approach available to destroy PFAS. Thermal degradation conditions required for destruction of PFAS during incineration processes are discussed. Fate of PFAS through water resource recovery facility incineration technologies remains unclear. Other thermal technologies such as smoldering combustion, pyrolysis, gasification, and hydrothermal liquefaction provide promise but are in developmental phases.