Alexandre Chiapolino
Research Subjects
Alexandre Chiapolino has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Richard Saurel
Institut Universitaire des Systèmes Thermiques Industriels
8 shared publications - François Fraysse
RS2N SAS, St Zachane, France
3 shared publications - Loann Neron
RS2N SAS, 371 Chemin de Gaumin , 83640 , Saint-Zacharie , France
2 shared publications - Richard Saurel
SAS Saint Zacharie France
2 shared publications - Ashwin Chinnayya
Institut Pprime, UPR 3346 CNRS, ISAE-ENSMA and Université de Poitiers 2 , BP 40109, 86961 Futuroscope-Chasseneuil Cedex
1 shared publication Boniface Nkonga
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 September 2025
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 37 (9)
Thermodynamic relaxation method: Relaxation kernel and predictor equation of state
The use of complex equations of state (EOSs) in compressible flow solvers presents significant theoretical and numerical challenges. These EOSs often present a limited range of validity, leading to “loss-of-convexity” issues, affecting the computed thermodynamic state. Additionally, the complexity of these formulations increases computational cost, as iterative numerical procedures are required, thereby reducing robustness. A novel thermodynamic framework has recently been developed to address these issues. This method, known as the “thermodynamic relaxation method (TRM),” is relevant due to its simplicity, efficiency, and robustness. The method is based on two EOSs: a target equation of state, which represents the physical equation of state, and a predictor equation of state (PEOS), which is simple and convex over a wide range of thermodynamical states. The PEOS is used in the numerical method to close the corresponding hyperbolic system of equations, while thermodynamic parameters are relaxed after each time step to map the solution to the physical target equation. This approach results in faster and more efficient computations. However, the relaxation step, as developed in previous works, is based on heuristic relations, leaving opportunities to strengthen the mathematical foundation of the method. This paper aims to refine the theoretical basis of the TRM and to propose a novel and enhanced relaxation kernel. Additionally, the refinement of the PEOS is discussed. The method also yields a more accurate and consistent thermal equilibrium temperature.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 37 (9)
Thermodynamic relaxation method: Relaxation kernel and predictor equation of state
The use of complex equations of state (EOSs) in compressible flow solvers presents significant theoretical and numerical challenges. These EOSs often present a limited range of validity, leading to “loss-of-convexity” issues, affecting the computed thermodynamic state. Additionally, the complexity of these formulations increases computational cost, as iterative numerical procedures are required, thereby reducing robustness. A novel thermodynamic framework has recently been developed to address these issues. This method, known as the “thermodynamic relaxation method (TRM),” is relevant due to its simplicity, efficiency, and robustness. The method is based on two EOSs: a target equation of state, which represents the physical equation of state, and a predictor equation of state (PEOS), which is simple and convex over a wide range of thermodynamical states. The PEOS is used in the numerical method to close the corresponding hyperbolic system of equations, while thermodynamic parameters are relaxed after each time step to map the solution to the physical target equation. This approach results in faster and more efficient computations. However, the relaxation step, as developed in previous works, is based on heuristic relations, leaving opportunities to strengthen the mathematical foundation of the method. This paper aims to refine the theoretical basis of the TRM and to propose a novel and enhanced relaxation kernel. Additionally, the refinement of the PEOS is discussed. The method also yields a more accurate and consistent thermal equilibrium temperature.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 37 (1)
Relaxation method for detonations in condensed explosives with pressure–temperature-equilibrium models and Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state
This paper deals with detonation waves in condensed explosives in the context of pressure and temperature equilibrium models. Most engineering solvers for detonation waves in condensed explosives are based on the reactive Euler equations, which model flows evolving in both temperature and pressure equilibrium conditions. Although the assumption of thermal equilibrium is physically questionable, the reactive Euler equations remain the most popular model because of its convenience. Conventional methods rely on Mie–Grüneisen equations of state (EOS) and are challenged by their limited applicability, high computational complexity, and frequent failure. A previous publication addressed these issues by using the Noble–Abel-stiffened-gas EOS as a predictor, followed by a relaxation step to map the solution to the physical target EOS. This novel thermodynamic relaxation framework was originally introduced in the context of mechanical equilibrium. The present work builds on this novel method to encompass both mechanical and thermal equilibrium, thus enabling the treatment of detonation waves in condensed explosives within the framework of pressure and temperature equilibrium models. The proposed method is capable of treating both interfacial flows through “diffuse interface” formulations, and mixture flows in mechanical and thermal equilibrium. In addition, the proposed method demonstrates improved computational robustness, a significant increase in efficiency, and greater flexibility.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 37 (1)
Relaxation method for detonations in condensed explosives with pressure–temperature-equilibrium models and Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state
This paper deals with detonation waves in condensed explosives in the context of pressure and temperature equilibrium models. Most engineering solvers for detonation waves in condensed explosives are based on the reactive Euler equations, which model flows evolving in both temperature and pressure equilibrium conditions. Although the assumption of thermal equilibrium is physically questionable, the reactive Euler equations remain the most popular model because of its convenience. Conventional methods rely on Mie–Grüneisen equations of state (EOS) and are challenged by their limited applicability, high computational complexity, and frequent failure. A previous publication addressed these issues by using the Noble–Abel-stiffened-gas EOS as a predictor, followed by a relaxation step to map the solution to the physical target EOS. This novel thermodynamic relaxation framework was originally introduced in the context of mechanical equilibrium. The present work builds on this novel method to encompass both mechanical and thermal equilibrium, thus enabling the treatment of detonation waves in condensed explosives within the framework of pressure and temperature equilibrium models. The proposed method is capable of treating both interfacial flows through “diffuse interface” formulations, and mixture flows in mechanical and thermal equilibrium. In addition, the proposed method demonstrates improved computational robustness, a significant increase in efficiency, and greater flexibility.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (11)
Existence condition for detonations in condensed explosives with pressure–temperature equilibrium models
Most engineering tools dealing with detonation waves in condensed explosives are based on the reactive Euler equations, which involve a thermodynamic closure based on temperature and pressure equilibrium conditions. Indeed, the reactant and the detonation products are assumed to evolve in mechanical and thermal equilibrium. Although the assumption of thermal equilibrium is physically questionable, the reactive Euler equations are used for convenience. This choice is supported by several reasons. When considering thermal equilibrium, the assessment of thermal exchanges between the reactant and the detonation products is simplified, as no exchange coefficient needs to be determined. Furthermore, the reactive Euler equations are in conservative form and the shock relations are well-defined. This model appears to be the simplest option for addressing detonations in condensed explosives. However, this simplicity has limitations and conceals a subtle difficulty that can lead to pathological detonations. The present contribution investigates this difficulty and presents a global exothermic condition to preserve exothermic detonations in the frame of temperature–pressure equilibrium flow models. This condition depends on the equations of state only. It is independent of the kinetics used to model the decomposition of the explosive. By meticulously selecting the thermodynamic parameters of the equations of state for the reactant and detonation products, pathological detonations are prevented, thereby maintaining a globally exothermic reaction consistent with the Zeldovich–von Neumann–Döring theory.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (11)
Existence condition for detonations in condensed explosives with pressure–temperature equilibrium models
Most engineering tools dealing with detonation waves in condensed explosives are based on the reactive Euler equations, which involve a thermodynamic closure based on temperature and pressure equilibrium conditions. Indeed, the reactant and the detonation products are assumed to evolve in mechanical and thermal equilibrium. Although the assumption of thermal equilibrium is physically questionable, the reactive Euler equations are used for convenience. This choice is supported by several reasons. When considering thermal equilibrium, the assessment of thermal exchanges between the reactant and the detonation products is simplified, as no exchange coefficient needs to be determined. Furthermore, the reactive Euler equations are in conservative form and the shock relations are well-defined. This model appears to be the simplest option for addressing detonations in condensed explosives. However, this simplicity has limitations and conceals a subtle difficulty that can lead to pathological detonations. The present contribution investigates this difficulty and presents a global exothermic condition to preserve exothermic detonations in the frame of temperature–pressure equilibrium flow models. This condition depends on the equations of state only. It is independent of the kinetics used to model the decomposition of the explosive. By meticulously selecting the thermodynamic parameters of the equations of state for the reactant and detonation products, pathological detonations are prevented, thereby maintaining a globally exothermic reaction consistent with the Zeldovich–von Neumann–Döring theory.
- Open Access
- 1 November 2023
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 35 (11)
Relaxation method for Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state
Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state (EOS) are widely used to describe the thermodynamics of solids, liquids, and gases in a variety of physics problems, including shock wave dynamics in condensed materials and the thermodynamic behavior of dense gases generated by detonation waves. The Jones–Wilkins–Lee (JWL), Cochran–Chan, and original Mie–Grüneisen EOSs are relevant examples. However, these EOSs present several major difficulties. First, their range of validity is limited because these EOSs are fitted to a reference curve and tolerate only small deviations from that curve. The second difficulty lies in the complexity of the mathematical formulations, affecting the efficiency of pressure relaxation solvers. These two difficulties give rise to a third. Under extreme flow conditions, computational failures are quite common. Methods for “extending” the equations of state are often used to continue the computations. For example, below a certain arbitrary density, the JWL EOS is sometimes extended to the ideal-gas EOS. A fundamentally new method is presented in this work. It consists of using the much simpler Noble–Abel-stiffened-gas EOS as a predictor, to close the corresponding flow model. A thermodynamic relaxation step follows the prediction step. The solution is projected onto the target EOS, in this case the Mie–Grüneisen EOS, with the help of additional transport equations. Therefore, the flow model is an extended version, much more efficient for numerical resolution. This method solves the three problems above by extending the validity domain of the thermodynamic formulation, making the relaxation solvers much faster, and dramatically increasing the robustness of computations.
- 1 November 2023
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 35 (11)
Open AccessRelaxation method for Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state
Mie–Grüneisen type equations of state (EOS) are widely used to describe the thermodynamics of solids, liquids, and gases in a variety of physics problems, including shock wave dynamics in condensed materials and the thermodynamic behavior of dense gases generated by detonation waves. The Jones–Wilkins–Lee (JWL), Cochran–Chan, and original Mie–Grüneisen EOSs are relevant examples. However, these EOSs present several major difficulties. First, their range of validity is limited because these EOSs are fitted to a reference curve and tolerate only small deviations from that curve. The second difficulty lies in the complexity of the mathematical formulations, affecting the efficiency of pressure relaxation solvers. These two difficulties give rise to a third. Under extreme flow conditions, computational failures are quite common. Methods for “extending” the equations of state are often used to continue the computations. For example, below a certain arbitrary density, the JWL EOS is sometimes extended to the ideal-gas EOS. A fundamentally new method is presented in this work. It consists of using the much simpler Noble–Abel-stiffened-gas EOS as a predictor, to close the corresponding flow model. A thermodynamic relaxation step follows the prediction step. The solution is projected onto the target EOS, in this case the Mie–Grüneisen EOS, with the help of additional transport equations. Therefore, the flow model is an extended version, much more efficient for numerical resolution. This method solves the three problems above by extending the validity domain of the thermodynamic formulation, making the relaxation solvers much faster, and dramatically increasing the robustness of computations.
- Open Access
Simplified Interfacial Area Modeling in Polydisperse Two-Phase Flows under Explosion Situations
The aim of the present work is to account for polydisperse effects in a two-phase flow with a simple and fast method. Polydisperse two-phase flows arise in numerous applications. Fire sprinkler systems are relevant examples as they release clouds of polydisperse droplets. Another relevant example is the polydisperse two-phase flow created by the detonation of an explosive charge surrounded by a liquid layer. In such a situation, material interfaces are initially present and the created two-phase flow consists of a carrier gas phase and a liquid phase involving many droplets of various sizes. Spherical particles or droplets are usually assumed in two-phase flow computations. When dealing with explosion situations involving both dense and dilute flow regimes, multiple particle diameters can be addressed but at the price of introducing as many additional equations that describe mass, momentum and energy balance of the various particle classes. Consequently, the computation time needed to address numerical resolution increases tremendously. Under explosion situations involving many particle diameters, the method becomes intractable and is usually reduced to a single diameter, which is often insufficient. A simplified approach is developed in the present work to account for a substantial number of particles of different sizes with few extra computational cost. The approach is said to be simplified as a single velocity and a single temperature are considered for all the spherical particles, regardless of their diameters. This type of modeling seems apt for the target explosion situations. The focus is placed on the interfacial area, which is the main parameter involved in the coupling of the two phases. In the present work, Gamma-like continuous probability distributions are considered to address the various sizes of particles. The effects of the size distribution are only summarized in the specific interfacial area, yielding consequently few code modifications while taking into account the polydisperse aspect of the two-phase flow.
Open AccessSimplified Interfacial Area Modeling in Polydisperse Two-Phase Flows under Explosion Situations
The aim of the present work is to account for polydisperse effects in a two-phase flow with a simple and fast method. Polydisperse two-phase flows arise in numerous applications. Fire sprinkler systems are relevant examples as they release clouds of polydisperse droplets. Another relevant example is the polydisperse two-phase flow created by the detonation of an explosive charge surrounded by a liquid layer. In such a situation, material interfaces are initially present and the created two-phase flow consists of a carrier gas phase and a liquid phase involving many droplets of various sizes. Spherical particles or droplets are usually assumed in two-phase flow computations. When dealing with explosion situations involving both dense and dilute flow regimes, multiple particle diameters can be addressed but at the price of introducing as many additional equations that describe mass, momentum and energy balance of the various particle classes. Consequently, the computation time needed to address numerical resolution increases tremendously. Under explosion situations involving many particle diameters, the method becomes intractable and is usually reduced to a single diameter, which is often insufficient. A simplified approach is developed in the present work to account for a substantial number of particles of different sizes with few extra computational cost. The approach is said to be simplified as a single velocity and a single temperature are considered for all the spherical particles, regardless of their diameters. This type of modeling seems apt for the target explosion situations. The focus is placed on the interfacial area, which is the main parameter involved in the coupling of the two phases. In the present work, Gamma-like continuous probability distributions are considered to address the various sizes of particles. The effects of the size distribution are only summarized in the specific interfacial area, yielding consequently few code modifications while taking into account the polydisperse aspect of the two-phase flow.
- 24 November 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Computational Physics
- Vol. 474
Fast 3D computations of compressible flow discharge in buildings and complex networks
- 24 November 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Computational Physics
- Vol. 474
Fast 3D computations of compressible flow discharge in buildings and complex networks
- Open Access
Fast 3D computations of compressible flow discharge in buildings and complex networks
Flow computation in complex geometries, such as buildings for example, is challenging at several levels including for instance mesh generation and presence of small elements (doors, windows) that need spatial resolution. When compressible effects are present, such as those resulting from explosions, choking conditions may appear in geometric restrictions. Pressure relaxation to atmospheric condition with existing CFD solvers consequently requires resolved 3D computations, that may be tremendously expensive. In the present work under-resolved computations are addressed, meaning that large computational cells and large time steps are used. Typically, cells’ size is of the order of rooms’ size. Consequently, special care must be taken at geometric discontinuities. This issue is reminiscent of flow computation with discontinuous area change (Le Floch and Thanh, 2003, Andrianov and Warnecke, 2004, Kroner and Thanh, 2005, Thanh, 2009, Han et al., 2012, to cite a few). However, in the present context, both simplifications and complexities appear. On one hand, full Riemann problem solution is not needed, only flux computation is required resulting in significant simplifications. On the other hand, the flow is 3D, meaning that related complexities must be considered, in the frame of unstructured grids. A fast, efficient, and accurate method is developed for such flows. It consists of two steps. The first step deals with a simple and fast mesh generation where no geometric detail, such as a door for example, is needed. Only “footprints” of the 3D geometry are required. The second step deals with a simple, fast and specific Riemann solver that addresses the previously omitted geometric restrictions directly in the solution states and through the flux distribution as well. The proposed method then appears very convenient when hazardous and pressing situations are involved and require knowledge of the pressure fields. It is validated against resolved computations. Examples are shown with 3D computations of a realistic building.
Open AccessFast 3D computations of compressible flow discharge in buildings and complex networks
Flow computation in complex geometries, such as buildings for example, is challenging at several levels including for instance mesh generation and presence of small elements (doors, windows) that need spatial resolution. When compressible effects are present, such as those resulting from explosions, choking conditions may appear in geometric restrictions. Pressure relaxation to atmospheric condition with existing CFD solvers consequently requires resolved 3D computations, that may be tremendously expensive. In the present work under-resolved computations are addressed, meaning that large computational cells and large time steps are used. Typically, cells’ size is of the order of rooms’ size. Consequently, special care must be taken at geometric discontinuities. This issue is reminiscent of flow computation with discontinuous area change (Le Floch and Thanh, 2003, Andrianov and Warnecke, 2004, Kroner and Thanh, 2005, Thanh, 2009, Han et al., 2012, to cite a few). However, in the present context, both simplifications and complexities appear. On one hand, full Riemann problem solution is not needed, only flux computation is required resulting in significant simplifications. On the other hand, the flow is 3D, meaning that related complexities must be considered, in the frame of unstructured grids. A fast, efficient, and accurate method is developed for such flows. It consists of two steps. The first step deals with a simple and fast mesh generation where no geometric detail, such as a door for example, is needed. Only “footprints” of the 3D geometry are required. The second step deals with a simple, fast and specific Riemann solver that addresses the previously omitted geometric restrictions directly in the solution states and through the flux distribution as well. The proposed method then appears very convenient when hazardous and pressing situations are involved and require knowledge of the pressure fields. It is validated against resolved computations. Examples are shown with 3D computations of a realistic building.
- 23 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Scientific Computing
- Vol. 88 (1) , 1-43
A Method to Solve Hamilton–Jacobi Type Equation on Unstructured Meshes
- 23 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Scientific Computing
- Vol. 88 (1) , 1-43
A Method to Solve Hamilton–Jacobi Type Equation on Unstructured Meshes
- Open Access
Modeling Heavy-Gas Dispersion in Air with Two-Layer Shallow Water Equations
Computation of gas dispersal in urban places or hilly grounds requires a large amount of computer time when addressed with conventional multidimensional models. Those are usually based on two-phase flow or Navier-Stokes equations. Different classes of simplified models exist. Among them, two-layer shallow water models are interesting to address large-scale dispersion. Indeed, compared to conventional multidimensional approaches, 2D simulations are carried out to mimic 3D effects. The computational gain in CPU time is consequently expected to be tremendous. However, such models involve at least three fundamental difficulties. The first one is related to the lack of hyperbolicity of most existing formulations, yielding serious consequences regarding wave propagation. The second is related to the non-conservative terms in the momentum equations. Those terms account for interactions between fluid layers. Recently, these two difficulties have been addressed in Chiapolino and Saurel (2018) and an unconditional hyperbolic model has been proposed along with a Harten-Lax-van Leer (HLL) type Riemann solver dealing with the non-conservative terms. In the same reference, numerical experiments showed robustness and accuracy of the formulation. In the present paper, a third difficulty is addressed. It consists of the determination of appropriate drag effect formulation. Such effects also account for interactions between fluid layers and become of particular importance when dealing with heavy-gas dispersion. With this aim, the model is compared to laboratory experiments in the context of heavy gas dispersal in quiescent air. It is shown that the model accurately reproduces experimental results thanks to an appropriate drag force correlation. This function expresses drag effects between the heavy and light gas layers. It is determined thanks to various experimental configurations of dam-break test problems.
Open AccessModeling Heavy-Gas Dispersion in Air with Two-Layer Shallow Water Equations
Computation of gas dispersal in urban places or hilly grounds requires a large amount of computer time when addressed with conventional multidimensional models. Those are usually based on two-phase flow or Navier-Stokes equations. Different classes of simplified models exist. Among them, two-layer shallow water models are interesting to address large-scale dispersion. Indeed, compared to conventional multidimensional approaches, 2D simulations are carried out to mimic 3D effects. The computational gain in CPU time is consequently expected to be tremendous. However, such models involve at least three fundamental difficulties. The first one is related to the lack of hyperbolicity of most existing formulations, yielding serious consequences regarding wave propagation. The second is related to the non-conservative terms in the momentum equations. Those terms account for interactions between fluid layers. Recently, these two difficulties have been addressed in Chiapolino and Saurel (2018) and an unconditional hyperbolic model has been proposed along with a Harten-Lax-van Leer (HLL) type Riemann solver dealing with the non-conservative terms. In the same reference, numerical experiments showed robustness and accuracy of the formulation. In the present paper, a third difficulty is addressed. It consists of the determination of appropriate drag effect formulation. Such effects also account for interactions between fluid layers and become of particular importance when dealing with heavy-gas dispersion. With this aim, the model is compared to laboratory experiments in the context of heavy gas dispersal in quiescent air. It is shown that the model accurately reproduces experimental results thanks to an appropriate drag force correlation. This function expresses drag effects between the heavy and light gas layers. It is determined thanks to various experimental configurations of dam-break test problems.
- Open Access
Extended Noble–Abel Stiffened-Gas Equation of State for Sub-and-Supercritical Liquid-Gas Systems Far from the Critical Point
The Noble–Abel Stiffened-Gas (NASG) equation of state (Le Métayer, O. and Saurel, R. proposed in 2016) is extended to variable attractive and repulsive effects to improve the liquid phase accuracy when large temperature and pressure variation ranges are under consideration. The transition from pure phase to supercritical state is of interest as well. The gas phase is considered through the ideal gas assumption with variable specific heat rendering the formulation valid for high temperatures. The liquid equation-of-state constants are determined through the saturation curves making the formulation suitable for two-phase mixtures at thermodynamic equilibrium. The overall formulation is compared to experimental characteristic curves of the phase diagram showing good agreement for various fluids (water, oxygen). Compared to existing cubic equations of state, the present one is convex, a key feature for computations with hyperbolic flow models.
Open AccessExtended Noble–Abel Stiffened-Gas Equation of State for Sub-and-Supercritical Liquid-Gas Systems Far from the Critical Point
The Noble–Abel Stiffened-Gas (NASG) equation of state (Le Métayer, O. and Saurel, R. proposed in 2016) is extended to variable attractive and repulsive effects to improve the liquid phase accuracy when large temperature and pressure variation ranges are under consideration. The transition from pure phase to supercritical state is of interest as well. The gas phase is considered through the ideal gas assumption with variable specific heat rendering the formulation valid for high temperatures. The liquid equation-of-state constants are determined through the saturation curves making the formulation suitable for two-phase mixtures at thermodynamic equilibrium. The overall formulation is compared to experimental characteristic curves of the phase diagram showing good agreement for various fluids (water, oxygen). Compared to existing cubic equations of state, the present one is convex, a key feature for computations with hyperbolic flow models.