PWPhillip Wool

Phillip Wool

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Phillip Wool has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Kicking the Elephant Out of the Room: The Case for EMs ex-China

    by Lu He, Jason Hsu, Phillip Wool

    Rapid growth in the ETF market over the past two decades has made it easier for investors to add emerging markets (EM) to their portfolios—but also has made investors more aware of the complexities and risks associated with such an allocation. Along those lines, China has recently been the “elephant in the room,” leading some to question whether a global EM allocation is worth the trouble. In this article, we assess various arguments for a modern approach that calls for carving China out of one’s EM allocation and treating it differently from a traditional cap-weighted global emerging markets portfolio. Those considerations range from China’s size within the EM basket to more technical aspects of portfolio construction, and even sentiment toward China and value-based reasons for casting it aside. Our conclusions will help frame the discussion of whether investors should separate China and EM ex-China, and how they might go about investing among and within those two allocations.

  • What Matters More for Emerging Markets Investors: Economic Growth or EPS Growth?

    by Jason Hsu, Jay Ritter, Phillip Wool, Yanxiang Zhao

    Investors often allocate to emerging markets equities with the expectation that higher rates of gross domestic product (GDP) growth typical of developing economies will translate to better stock market returns. Adherents to this conventional wisdom have historically been disappointed, as numerous studies of emerging and developed markets have shown GDP growth to be unreliable in predicting country-level stock returns. Using data from 15 emerging and 21 developed equity markets over samples ranging from 32 to 120 years, we confirm the failure of GDP growth as a cross-sectional predictor. What truly matters to investors is not an overall increase in economic output but rather the growth in listed companies’ earnings per share (EPS) and dividends per share (DPS), which ultimately flows to shareholders. We confirm that, unlike changes in GDP, growth in EPS and DPS exhibit a strong positive correlation with country-level equity returns, offering emerging markets investors a more effective tool for thinking about allocation decisions. Surprisingly, we also find that most emerging economies, despite their high GDP growth rate, have low EPS and DPS growth rates, suggesting that listed companies are not representative of the underlying economy.


  • Market Timing Skill and Trading Activity in Taiwan’s Retail-Dominated Futures Market

    by Shean-Bii Chiu, Jason Hsu, Hsing-Kuo Lai, Phillip Wool

    There has been substantial research on performance persistence among professional and retail investors. These studies typically employ infrequently sampled data on portfolio holdings and returns, making it difficult to distinguish skill from luck, let alone differentiate between superior security selection and market timing ability. Based on 10 years of comprehensive account-level data comprising 61 million trades made by investors in Taiwan’s retail-dominated futures market, the authors confirm that institutions consistently earn alpha at the expense of behaviorally biased individual traders. The authors introduce an approach for separating overconfident traders from skilled market timers. This novel skill measure interacts prior performance with past trading volume. Investors identified as highly skilled subsequently earn a net-of-cost average annual return of 115%. The authors’ results contribute in two ways: (1) introducing a new measure for assessing high-frequency trading skill and (2) validating the intuition that significant alpha can be harvested by active investors in retail-dominated markets. TOPICS:Derivatives, futures and forward contracts, emerging markets, manager selection, performance measurement Key Findings ▪ The authors employ comprehensive data on 61 million individual trades made by investors in Taiwan’s financial futures market over a 10-year period to confirm that behaviorally biased retail investors consistently lose to institutional investors. ▪ They demonstrate weak performance persistence and a nonlinear relationship between past trading volume and future performance, characterized by overconfidence on the part of a vast majority of traders and rational learning about skill by the most active traders. ▪ The authors describe a method for inferring true market timing ability from a combination of data on prior performance and past trading volume and identify a small subset of skilled traders who subsequently earn extraordinary profits after accounting for transactions costs.


  • Should You Have More China in Your Portfolio? Putting Common Arguments for Increased China Exposure to the Test

    by Jason Hsu, Xiang Liu, Phillip Wool

    Currently, China onshore and offshore equities represent benchmark weights of roughly 0.4% and 4%, respectively, in global portfolios. These small weights are largely a result of complex index inclusion rules focused on access, regulation, governance, and liquidity considerations; index providers do not specifically consider the investment thesis for including Chinese stocks in global benchmarks. In this article, we critically examine the most popular investment arguments in favor of a greater allocation to China onshore and offshore equities, as well as skeptical counterarguments to these claims. China is large in terms of GDP and market capitalization—so what? China’s GDP growth is projected to be 5% higher than developed markets—but there is no empirical relationship between GDP growth and equity market returns. Chinese equities have lower correlation with global markets—but they also have much higher volatility, calling into question the diversification benefits investors seek. The Chinese stock market is filled with non-professional retail investors—but does that lead to greater alpha, and can investors capture that through long exposure to a market with questionable accounting and large differences in regulatory practices? We settle these debates through hard data and straightforward empirical tests. TOPICS: Emerging markets, global markets, private equity, portfolio theory, portfolio construction, equity portfolio management, mutual fund performance Key Findings • A number of popular arguments for including more Chinese equities in investors’ equity portfolios are based on the size of China’s GDP, the size of China’s equity market capitalization, or the growth in China’s GDP. These considerations do not appear to be correlated with portfolio returns or risks. • However, other arguments based on low correlation, faster corporate earnings growth, and high potential for alpha can be empirically verified and do provide meaningful return-risk improvement to investor portfolios. • China is one of the very few economies in the EM basket that has delivered high earnings growth and high equity return against the backdrop of strong GDP growth. This is generally not observed in other EM economies. • China onshore equities have a surprisingly low correlation with its own offshore listed equities and with global equities. The onshore equities historically also have provided faster earnings growth and higher returns than the offshores shares. The heterogeneity between onshore and offshore shares makes the current 90%/10% split between offshore/onshore shares dictated by mainstream indexes suboptimal.


  • Assessing Mutual Fund Performance in China

    by Bradford Cornell, Jason Hsu, Patrick Kiefer, Phillip Wool

    Chinese fund manager performance is interesting because, in a market dominated by speculative retail trading, we expect professional fund managers to have persistent edge. Using data on the Chinese mutual fund industry, the authors compute a new skill measure to identify exceptional funds with persistent performance. When an equity mutual fund is in the top 1% of their ranking in a particular six-month period, the probability the fund will be among the top 10% in return in the following period is 22%. By comparison, for funds that rank in the top 1% by past six-month return, the probability of being a top 10% fund in the next six months is only modestly better than noise at 12%. The authors also find declining skill and performance persistence at the industry level, likely driven by the exodus of mutual fund managers to hedge funds. They provide evidence that most of the outperforming funds in China deliver excess performance, relative to peers, through market timing. Funds that reliably pick winning stocks often do not have evidence of performance. This may be related to a mutual fund management culture that emphasizes market timing for managing downside risk over a focus on relative performance. TOPICS:Mutual fund performance, emerging markets, manager selection Key Findings • The authors develop a new mutual fund skill measure that identifies exceptional funds with persistent performance and assesses stock selection and market timing ability. They then apply this measure to Chinese mutual funds. • They demonstrate that some Chinese mutual funds exhibit persistent skill but that industry-wide skill is declining over time—likely because of a migration of the most talented managers from mutual funds to hedge funds. • The authors show that most exceptional Chinese mutual funds deliver excess performance relative to peers through market timing as opposed to stock selection, a finding consistent with management culture emphasizing downside risk management over relative returns.


  • Anomalies in Chinese A-Shares

    by Jason Hsu, Vivek Viswanathan, Michael Wang, Phillip Wool

    In this article, the authors apply well-studied factor strategies from the U.S. equity anomalies literature to Chinese A-shares, demonstrating which factors have worked and which have not over the last two decades since the opening of China’s stock markets. They find that although a number of traditional factors such as value and size appear to work well in China, other factors are less effective—including A-shares momentum, which works in the opposite direction. Their analysis reconciles conflicting results from the prior A-shares anomalies literature and explains differences in U.S. and Chinese factor investing experiences on the basis of unique features of China’s evolving investing landscape, including issues related to regulation, financial reporting standards, differences in market microstructure, and investor behavior. Their findings will be of interest to researchers of equity anomalies and those developing quantitative strategies for Chinese equities.